4@>AE6D C6?5FD $ 3@6

4@>AE6D C6?5FD $ 3@6<36DAC6<:?86?3@@< C6G:6H

4U]$ C[NQ^`[# 3<KBMMB LNEE: K>LIHGLB;BEBMT BGM>KG:SBHG:E> =>@EB 3M:MB AaNXUOM$fU[ZU PiXUM 7MO[X`h PU 8UaÛ_\âPQZfM PQXXvFZUbQ^_U`h PU 4MYQÛZ[#CU_`MY\Q# ;[bQZQ 6PU`[^Q# b[X% :# (0.0# b[X% ::# (# (0/-# b[X% ::# )# (0/-#(+/- \MSQ_ \[a^ XQ_ `^[U_ b[XaYQ_%

B\ \S ^Scb _cS aS ToZWQWbS` RS ZÑW\WbWObWdS ^`WaS Ô` ZO 9OQcZbo RS R`]Wb RS6O[S`W\] RS ^cPZWS` ZÑS\aS[PZS RS Z ÑÇcd`S RS E]PS`b] 4U] Q]\aOQòS l ZO`Sa^]\aOPWZWbo W\bS`\ObW]\OZS& ?S ùZS o[W\S\b Rc ^`]TSaaSc` 4U] RO\a ZO Q]RWTWQO%bW]\ Rc R`]Wb RS ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWbo W\bS`\ObW]\OZS Sab Q]\\c$ ZÑO[^ZSc` Rc ^`]^]a$ZO `WUcSc` RS ZO ^S\aoS$ ZO TW\SaaS RSa O\OZgaSa& 6ÑSab c\S Çcd`S [OUWabÒZS _cWS[^]`bS ZÑOR[WÒbW]\ [q[S aW QS`bOW\a ^]W\ba a]\b Q`WbW_coa Ô` ZSa c\a ]c Ô`ZSa Ocb`Sa&?Sa d]Zc[Sa <<$ ( Sb <<$ ) Q][^]`bS\b ZSa QoZpP`Sa VcWb Ò^^]`ba RS Z ÑW\bo`Saao

l ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ& ?Sa òc\W` b]ca S\aS[PZS TOQWZWbS ZSc`Q]\acZbObW]\& @OWa Q ÑSab ac`b]cb ZS d]Zc[S < _cÑWZ Q]\dWS\b RS aOZcS` QO` WZ`S^`S\R RSa bSfbSa ^Zca O\QWS\a Sb RWaao[W\oa 1

É ?O `Sa^]\aOPWZWbl W\RW`SbbO \SZ RW`Wbb] W\bS`\OhW]\OZS$ )OAFGSGL BG BGOGQQLMR@@IGAL" (0*-&

É ?O `SU]ZO RSZ ^`SdW] SaOc`W[S\b] RSW `WQ]àW W\bS`\W W\ bS[O RW `Sa^]\aOPWZWblW\bS`\OhW]\OZS$ )OAFGSGL BG BGOGQQL MR@@IGAL" (0*/&

É <ZZSQWb] Q][[WaaWd] S WZZSQWb] ][WaaWd] \SZ RW`Wbb] W\bS`\OhW]\OZS$ ,GOGQQLGKQCOK?WGLK?IC" (0*/&

É ?S RoZWb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ 8CARCGI BCP ALROP BC <)A?BYJGC BC BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?IBC 3? 0?VC" (0*0$ d]Z& -/&

É ?O Q]ZÔ \SZZÑWZZSQWb] W\bS`\OhW]\OZS$ 9AOGQQG EGROGBGAG GK LKLOC BG 9?KQG 8LJ?KL"(0+'&

6Sb S\aS[PZS RS bSfbSa WZZcab`S Q][PWS\ ZO ^`]PZo[ObW_cS Rc acXSb Sab ZS^`]RcWb R Ñc\S òTZSfW]\ _cW aÑSab obS\RcS ac` _cOÒ\bS O\a&? Ñ]cdÒUS Sab Q][^Zobo Ô` c\S bOPZS RS Q]\Q]`RO\QS S\b`S ZSa bSfbSa ^`]^]aoa

Ô` E]PS`b] 4U] Sb QScf OR]^boa S\ ^`S[Wp`S ZSQbc`S Ô` ZO 6][[WaaW]\ RcR`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&? Ñ]cdÒUS aS QZub ac` RWdSà W\RSf _cW TOQWZWbS\b ZSa `SQVS`QVSa RO\a ZÑS\aS[PZS

RS Z ÑÇcd`S 1 RSa OcbScà$ RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS$ RS ZO ^ÒbW_cS$ RSa OQbSa W\bS`%\ObW]\Ocf Sb O\OZgbW_cS&H\S b`pa PSZZS òOZWaObW]\ Sb c\ ]cdÒUS W\RWa^S\aOPZS ^]c` QScf _cS VO\bS

QS QVO^Wb`S SaaS\bWSZ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&=SO\ F4?@BA&

4 bbO `R $ 5MbUP# 4A> >Q<ENLBO> ><HGHFB< SHG> BG BGM>KG:MBHG:E E:P 4XM^QZP[ZA^Q__# @dR[^P# (0/.# *,' \MSQ_%

?O ^òaS\bS obcRS Sab S\bWp`S[S\b Q]\aOQòS l ZÑSfO[S\ RS ZO h]\S oQ]\][W_cSSfQZcaWdS "M&8&8&# S\ R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ& ? ÑOcbSc` Sf^ZW_cS Sb WZZcab`S ZS RodS%Z]^^S[S\b ^`]U`SaaWT RS QSbbS \]bW]\ RS^cWa ZO TW\ RS ZO aSQ]\RS UcS``S []\RWOZS&

)+) 6B@8G8F E8A 7H F

dOW\Qc b]cb ZS []\RS& ?S ^`]XSb R ÑO`bWQZSa RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`%\ObW]\OZ S\ bo[]WU\S&

=SO\ F4?@BA&

5 4 5 5 8 E <F $ ;aXU[ 2%# .HL %><NKLHL G:MNK:E>L <HFI:KMB=HL >GMK> (LM:=HL R >E

'>K><AH ,GM>KG:MBHG:E 6P% EQOZ[_ u 4[X% PQ 4UQZ[UM_ D[OUMXQ_# >MPÛP#(0.0# (/( \MSQ_%

6SbbS Çcd`S Sab RWdWaoS S\ RScf Ô`bWSa&7O\a ZO ^`S[Wp`S$ Z ÑOcbSc` OP]`RS ZÑO\OZgaS Xc`WRW_cS RSa \]`[Sa W\bS`%

\ObW]\OZSa `SZObWdSa l QVO_cS `Saa]c`QS Ô`bOUoS$ ^]c` ]TT`W` RO\a ZO RScfWp[SÔ`bWS c\S bVo]`WS Uo\oÒZS RSa `Saa]c`QSa Ô`bOUoSa$ l Ô`bW` RSa `SaaS[PZO\QSa`SbS\cSa RO\a QVO_cS aSQbSc`&6Sb ]cdÒUS Sab `S[O`_cOPZS Ô`bWQcZWp`S[S\b Ô` Z ÑobcRS SfVOcabWdS Rc R`]Wb

RSa US\a _cS ZÑOcbSc` \]ca ]TT`S RO\a ZO ^`S[Wp`S Ô`bWS 2 ZSa `Saa]c`QSa Q]\%aWRoòSa a]\b QSZZSa `SZObWdSa Ocf POaaW\a VgR`]UÒ^VW_cSa$ Ocf [W\oÒcf$ l ZOTOc\S Sb l Z ÑOb[]a^Vp`S&? ÑOcbSc`$ Q][[S \]ca Z ÑOd]\a RWb$ O bS\bo RS agabo[ObWaS` ZS R`]Wb W\bS`%

\ObW]\OZ ^]aWbWT Sb O``WdS l ZO Q]\QZcaW]\ _cÑWZ SfWabS b`]Wa `pUZSa Xc`WRW_cSa%QZoa^]c` QVOQc\S RSa `Saa]c`QSa Ô`bOUoSa 1

(# ZÑ]PZWUObW]\ RS \S Ôa QOcaS` c\ ^òXcRWQS aS\aWPZS 2)# ZS R`]Wb R ÑcaOUS o_cWbOPZS Sb ÒWa]\\OPZS 2*# ZÑ]PZWUObW]\ RS Z ÑoQVO\US RÑW\T]`[ObW]\a Sb ZS RSd]W` RS \oU]QWS`&

BcdÒUS Ô`c S\ (0.0$ RO\a ZS_cSZ 4& 5O`PS`Wa O\bWQW^S ZS RodSZ]^^S[S\bR]Qb`W\OZ _cW aS ^`]RcWÒ cZbo`WSc`S[S\bBcdÒUS RS ZSQbc`S OWaoS$ TOQWZS l Q]\acZbS`$ OdSQ RS \][P`ScaSa QWbObW]\a

RS bSfbSa Q]\dS\bW]\\SZa$ _cW bo[]WU\S RS ZÑW[^]`bO\QS OQQ`cS RSa a]ZcbW]\aÒbW]\\SZZSa l O^^]`bS` l QSbbS ^`]PZo[ObW_cS&

:Z]`WO 4?5<B?&

5 45A ; B B EA $ =% 2% ?% >%# 2>I>KMHKBNF HI => 0>=>KE:G=L> OHED>GK><AM>EBCD>

K><AMLIK::D (/+'$(0/*# E% >% 4% 2__Q^ :Z_Ùàa`# v_ 8^MbQZTMSQ# (0/-#/'. \MSQ_%

?S ò^S`b]W`S RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS \oS`ZO\ROWaS S\ [ObWp`S RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZQ]cdÒ\b ZO ô`W]RS (/+'%(0/* Sab c\ ]cdÒUS Sfb`q[S[S\b ^òQWScf Sb b`paXcRWQWScaS[S\b OUS\Qo&7Wa]\a W[[oRWObS[S\b _cS ZÑ]cdÒUS Q][^]`bS RSa W\RWQObW]\a ac` ))0- RoQW%

aW]\a& ?O Q]\acZbObW]\ Rc ò^S`b]W`S Sab b`pa OWaoS&? Ñ]cdÒUS Q][^]`bS b]cb R ÑOP]`R c\ agabp[S RS QZOaaWTWQObW]\ agabo[ObW_cS

]w QVO_cS _cSabW]\ Xc`WRW_cS Sab ò^S`b]`WoS Ô` c\ U`]c^S RS QVWTT`Sa& CO`SfS[^ZS$ OaWZS RW^Z][ObW_cS 1 ,&)/$ W[[c\Wboa RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]%\OZSa 1 /&)*)$ _cSabW]\a R ÑS\dW`]\\S[S\b 1 (-&,, SbQ&8\acWbS QVO_cS RoQWaW]\ O\OZgaoS O `Snc c\ \c[o`] RÑ]`R`S OR[W\WabÒbWT

_cW \S ò^]\R l OcQc\S Z]UW_cS Ô`bWQcZWp`S aW QS \ÑSab aO\a R]cbS Z Ñ]`R`S RO\aZS_cSZ ZSa RoQWaW]\a ]\b obo [O\cSZZS[S\b SfO[W\oSa$ obcRWoSa Sb [WaSa ac`]`RW\ObSc`&?Sa /' ÔUSa acWdO\bSa `S^`S\\S\b ZS QZOaaS[S\b agabo[ObW_cS S\ R]\\O\b

a]ca QVO_cS `cP`W_cS ZO RObS RS ZO RoQWaW]\$ ZO Xc`WRWQbW]\ _cW Z ÑO `S\RcS Sb a]\\c[o`] R Ñ]`R`S OR[W\WabÒbWT& CO` SfS[^ZS 1 *&((+& 8UOZWbo RSa 8bOba

'/&'-&(0/- >bU Ña :ÒdS\VOUS$ E (0),&FcWdO\b _cSZ_cS -'' ÔUSa Q][^`S\O\b ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS Ô` ]`R`S QV`]\]Z]%

UW_cS& C]c` QVO_cS RoQWaW]\ ]\ b`]cdS 1 aO RObS$ ZO Xc`WRWQbW]\ _cW Z ÑO `S\RcS$ ZS\c[o`] R Ñ]`R`S OR[W\WabÒbWT$ ZS \][ RSa Ô`bWSa$ c\ P`ST òac[o RSa ^]W\baRS R`]Wb bÒWboa$ ZSa `cP`W_cSa Rc QZOaaS[S\b agabo[ObW_cS W\bo`SaaoSa$ ZSa

6B@CG8F E8A7H F )+*

a]c`QSa Rc bSfbS W\boUÒZ RS ZO RoQWaW]\ ]c RÑc\ òac[o OW\aW _cS ZSa \]bSaR ÑO``qb odS\bcSZZSa&4^`pa QSZO$ /' ÔUSa RO\a ZSa_cSZZSa ZSa RoQWaW]\a a]\b W\RSfoSa aSZ]\ Z Ñ]`R`S

QV`]\]Z]UW_cS RSa bÒWboa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf TOWaO\b ZÑ]PXSb RSa RoQWaW]\a&? Ñ]cdÒUS aS QZub S\TW\ Ô` c\ W\RSf RSa [ObWp`Sa `S\d]gO\b Oc \c[o`] RS

ZO QZOaaWTWQObW]\ agabo[ObW_cS&8\ P`ST$ c\ ]cdÒUS QZOW`$ b`pa PWS\ ^òaS\bo$ W\RWa^S\aOPZS QZo RS ZO Xc`Wa%

^`cRS\QS \oS`ZO\ROWaS&=SO\ F4?@BA&

5 j ? 4 áÜ: 8 E $ >UOTQX# .>L &HFFNG:NMUL >NKHIU>GG>L >M E: L:GMU \aNXUi \M^ XQ_A^Q__Q_ aZUbQ^_U`MU^Q_ PQ 3[^PQMad MbQO XQ O[ZO[a^_ PQ XM 4[YYU__U[ZPQ_ 4[YYaZMaì_ Qa^[\iQZZQ_# (0/,# (*+ \MSQ_%

@OZUò ZS aWZS\QS RSa bÒWboa$ ZSa ]ÙO\Sa Q][[c\OcbOW`Sa ]\b OR]^bo c\\][P`S Q]\aWRoÒPZS RS bSfbSa Sb obOPZW ^`]U`SaaWdS[S\b c\S ^]ZWbW_cS Q][%[c\OcbOW`S RS ZO aO\bo&? ÑOcbSc`$ _cW S\aSWU\S ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ oQ]\][W_cS Sb OdOWb RoXl ^cPZWo

S\ (0/* ZS ^`S[WS` ]cdÒUS W\bWbcZo Ä 7`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RS ZO aO\bo Å$ []\b`SZS QVS[W\S[S\b RS Ä ZÑ8c`]^S PZO\QVS Å _cW ô\pb`S ZSa ZoUWaZObW]\a \ObW]\OZSaSb Q]\QS`\S OcbO\b ZSa ^`]TSaaW]\a [oRWQOZSa Sb ZSa UÒ\RSa ZWPS`boa Q][[c\Oc%bOW`Sa _cS ZSa ^]^cZObW]\a SZZSa%[q[Sa$ Oc bÒdSà RS ZO [oRSQW\S Rc bÒdOWZ$RSa \]`[Sa `SZObWdSa Ocf [oRWQO[S\ba$ ]c RSa STT]`ba RS ^`]^VgZOfWS$ S\ Q]]ô%ÒbW]\ OdSQ Z ÑB&@&F& Sb ZS 6]\aSWZ RS ZÑ8c`]^S&

64 FF8 $F8 $ 2Z`[ZU[# .> =KHBM BGM>KG:MBHG:E =:GL NG FHG=> =BOBLU >[ZPQ_ QZPQbQZU^ I :I # >MZaQX_ 3%=% Zp .# 3Q^SQ^$=Qb^MaX`# (0/-# UZ$(-p# *., \%

64FF8 F8 $ 2Z`[ZU[# ,GM>KG:MBHG:E .:P BG : 'BOB=>= 7HKE= 4XM^QZP[Z A^Q__#@dR[^P# (0/-# +)0 \%# UZPQd%

6Sa RScf ]cdÒUSa ^ScdS\b qb`S ^òaS\boa S\aS[PZS ^cWa_cS ZS ^`S[WS` SabZO bÒRcQbW]\ Rc aSQ]\R OZZoUoS RS _cSZ_cSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba [W\Scà Sb RS[O\Wp`S ^Zca `SU`SbbOPZS$ R Ñc\ W\RSf&7O\a ZSa RScf QOa$ obO\b R]\\o ZS \][P`S RS ÔUSa ZW[Wbo$ WZ O^ÔÒsb W[[o%

RWObS[S\b _cS ZS a]cQW RS ZÑOcbSc` \ÑSab Ôa RS TOW`S c\ [O\cSZ& ? ÑOPaS\QS RSbSQV\WQWbo Rc ^`]^]a Sb Z ÑO^Ô`SWZ RS òTo`S\QS òRcWb l c\ ab`WQb [W\W[c[ S\bo[]WU\S\b& <Z aÑOUWb l dÒW RW`S R Ñc\ ]cdÒUS RS òTZSfW]\ RSabW\o l ]TT`W` RSaQZSTa ^]c` Q][^`S\R`S ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Q]\bS[^]ÒW\$ ]TTS`bSa l c\ ^cPZWQb`pa dOabS& 4 \]b`S aS\a$ QSa QZSTa ]cd`S\b ZSa P]\\Sa ^]`bSa&<Z TOcb$ \]ca ^S\a]\a$ O^^`]cdS` S\bWp`S[S\b ZS TOWb _cÑ4\b]\W] 6OaaSaS OWb

d]cZc ^òaS\bS` ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RO\a aO ^Sà^SQbWdS VWab]`W_cS& 6SbbS[obV]RS$ \]ca a][[Sa \][P`Scf l Z ÑOd]W` Sfô`W[S\boS$ Sab ZO aScZS _cW`SabWbcS ZS R`]Wb RO\a c\S ^Sà^SQbWdS ToQ]\RS$ QSZcW RSa Ò^^]`ba RS T]`QS$ RcQ]\bSfbS oQ]\][W_cS Sb a]QWOZ Sb RSa WRo]Z]UWSa _cW ZcW a]\b Q]\bS[^]ÒW\a&6][[S ZÑOcbSc` ZÑoQ`Wb "^& 0/ Rc bSfbS TÒ\nOWa$ ^& (', Rc bSfbS O\UZOWa#$

Ä C]c` aS TOW`S c\S WRoS Rc Q][^]`bS[S\b RSa 8bOba RO\a Z ÑO`p\S W\bS`\ObW]\OZS$WZ Sab R]\Q \oQSaaOW`S RS ZSa Q]\aWRo`S` \]\ Ôa Q][[S RSa []\ORSa Wa]ZoSaRO\a c\ []\RS [obO%VWab]`W_cS$ [OWa ^Zcbub RO\a ZSc` aWbcObW]\ òSZZS Sb RO\aZS Q]\bSfbS RSa U`]c^Sa Ocf_cSZa WZa O^Ô`bWS\\S\b BC D?AQL Å&7O\a QSb ]cdÒUS$ Q ÑSab l XcabS bWb`S _cS ZÑOcbSc` dO W\aWabS` ac` ZS ùZS SaaS\bWSZ

RS Z ÑSTTSQbWdWbo "^& )0 b&T&$ ^& )- b&O&#$ Rc òOZWa[S "^& *+ b&T&$ ^& *' b&O&#$ Rc ùZSRS Z ÑoQ]\][WS& I& Ô` SfS[^ZS ZO Zc[W\ScaS Sf^ZWQObW]\ oQ]\][W_cS RS ZO RWa%Ô`WbW]\ RS Z ÑSaQZOdOUS "^& ,)%,+ b&T&$ ^& ,)%,+ b&O&#&6S ^]W\b RS dcS VWab]`W_cS O[p\S ZÑOcbSc` l RWabW\UcS` RScf UÒ\RSa obO^Sa$

RScf UÒ\Ra []RpZSa 1 ZS bÒRWbW]\\SZ$ QSZcW Rc bg^S R Ñ]`R`S Qòo Ô` ZS bÒWbo RS

)++ 6B@8G8F E8A7H F

JSab^VOZWS 1 R Ñ8bOba R]\b ZO a]cdSÒW\Sbo \ÑobOWb Ucp`S ZW[WboS$ Sb ]w òU\OWbc\S QS`bOW\S c\Wbo RS dcS Sc`]ôS\\S Sb Z Ñ]`R`S []RS`\S QOÒQbo`Wao Ô` RWdSàbÒWba RWabW\QbWTa 1 b]cb R ÑOP]`R c\S RWdWaW]\ RS ZO Q][[c\Ocbo RSa 8bOba S\b`]Wa U`]c^Sa 1 ZSa 8bOba ]QQWRS\bOcf$ ZSa 8bOba a]QWOZWabSa Sb ZSa 8bOba Rc bWSà%[]\RS& @q[S aW ZÑO\OZgaS R]Wb qb`S \cO\QoS$ Sb ZÑOcbSc` l ^ZcaWScà S\R`]Wba^òdWS\b ZO Q`WbW_cS$ QSbbS dWaW]\ \]ca aS[PZS T]\RO[S\bOZS[S\b XcabS$ bO\bWZ Sab dÒW _cS ZS R`]Wb `S^]aS ac` RSa dOZScà Sb RSa W\bo`qba _cW$ ac` PWS\ RSa^]W\ba$ \S a]\b Ôa Q][[c\a l QSa b`]Wa U`]c^Sa R Ñ8bOba&6SQW \ ÑW\bS`RWb Ôa c\S Q]]ôÒbW]\ W\bS`\ObW]\OZS RodSZ]^ôS OcX]c`RÑVcW Oc

aSW\ R Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa$ ZÑo[SÙS\QS RSa R`]Wba RSa W\RWdWRca SbRSa ^Sc^ZSa$ \W RSa ^`W\QW^Sa T]\RO[S\bOcf Q][[c\a RS Q]SfWabS\QS 1 ZSa^`W\QW^Sa RSa `SZObW]\a O[WQOZSa _cW ]\b W\b`]RcWb R ÑW[^]`bO\bSa ZW[WbSa Oc`SQ]cà l ZO T]`QS [WZWbOW`S d]W`S oQ]\][W_cS& A]ca Ô`bOUS]\a QSa dcSa Sb ZSaS\aSWU\]\a oUOZS[S\b&4 XcabS bWb`S S\Q]`S RO\a ZO RSaQ`W^bW]\ RSa ^`W\QWÔcf OQbScà$ 6OaaSaS[]\b`S

ZO ^ZOQS o[W\S\bS RS ZÑ8bOb&B\ O^^òQWSÒ ZO XcabSaaS RSa dcSa ac` ZSa ObbWbcRSa Sb ZSa abÒboUWSa RSa b`]Wa

U`]c^Sa R Ñ8bOba "d& ^& Sf& ZO RSaQ`W^bW]\ Rc ^]W\b RS dcS ]QQWRS\bOZ RoTS\RO\bZS R`]Wb CK PLG É b&T& ^& 00%(''$ b&O& ^& ('-%('.#&A]ca Ô`bOUS]\a S\Q]`S ZS ^]W\b RS dcS RS Z ÑOcbSc` ac` ZS ùZS RSa ^`W\QW^Sa

T]\RO[S\bOcf& G]cb Oc ^Zca \cO\QS`W]\a%\]ca ZS ^]W\b RS dcS ]QQWRS\bOZ$ _cW$QSa bS[â RS`\WSà$ bS\R l RoQ]cd`W` ZSa QVO`[Sa RS Z ÑW\RWdWRcOZWa[S a]cdSÒW\Z]à_cÑWZ aS b`]cdS RO\a c\ S\dW`]\\S[S\b V]abWZS& ?Sa PSOcf X]cà OQbcSZa RcALKPCKPRP "RoQ`Wb OR[WÒPZS[S\b b&T& ^& (./ Sb aa&$ b&O& ^& (0, Sb aa&# S\ bo[]WU\S\b&7O\a ZS QVO^Wb`S ac` ZS `pUZS[S\b RSa RWTTo`S\Ra$ ]\ \]bSÒ RSa ÔUSa W\bo`Sa%

aO\bSa É _c]W_cS ^Scb%qb`S W\ObbS\RcS RO\a QS QVO^Wb`S É ac` ZS Q]\bùZSW\bS`\ObW]\OZ "^& (/0 Sb aa& b&T& Sb ^& )'/ Sb aa& b&O&#&

4^`pa ZÑSfO[S\ Rc ùZS RS ZO Q]\bÒW\bS RO\a ZS R`]Wb Q]\bS[^]ÒW\$ ]\ ZWÒZSa PSOcf QVO^Wb`Sa ac` ZO ^`]bSQbW]\ RS ZO RWU\Wbo Vc[OW\S "]w ZSa RWdSàSa dcSaSb abÒboUWSa RSa b`]Wa U`]c^Sa R Ñ8bOba a]\b O\OZgaoSa OdSQ Sa^`Wb Q`WbW_cS#$ZO òUZS[S\bObW]\ RSa Ò^^]`ba oQ]\][W_cSa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf Sb ZO ^`][]bW]\ RcRodSZ]^^S[S\b&?S []RpZS []RS`\S \ ÑO Ôa QS^S\RO\b STTOQo S\bWp`S[S\b ZS []RpZS eSaTQ^VO%

ZWS\ _cW acPaWabS S\ Ô`bWQcZWS` RO\a ZS R][OW\S Rc `SQ]cà l ZO T]`QS& ? ÑOPaS\QSRS a]ZWRO`Wbo òSZZS Sf^ZW_cS ZOÙS[S\b QS ^Vo\][p\S "^& *,) b&T&$ ^& +'* b&O&#&6ÑSab S\Q]`S OdSQ PSOcQ]c^ RS P]\ aS\a _cS Z ÑOcbSc` aWbcS ZS ùZS Rc R`]Wb

RO\a ZO Q][[c\Ocbo []\RWOZS$ ^Zca W[^]`bO\b _cÑ]\ \S ZS RWb S\ RÒ[ObWaO\bZSa OQQ`]Qa a][[S b]cbS `SZObWdS[S\b ZW[Wboa Sb ZS ùZS RSa W\RWdWRca Sb RSZ Ñ]^W\W]\ ^cPZW_cS RO\a ZS TOn]\\S[S\b Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&

4^`pa QS Q]\QS`b R ÑoZ]USa$ [S\bW]\\]\a$ aO\a d]cZ]W` qb`S SfVOcabWT$ _cSZ_cSa^]W\ba ]w RSa \cO\QSa OcÒWS\b ^c qb`S W\b`]RcWbSa&C& )* b&T&$ ^& (, b&O&$ aÑWZ Sab dÒW _cS a]cdS\b ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ZOWaaS l

QVO_cS Ôga c\S S\bWp`S ZWPS`bo ^]c` aObWaTOW`S l aSa RSd]Wà W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf$ QS\ ÑSab Ôa b]cX]cà ZS QOa& <Z O``WdS _cS ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RobS`[W\S ZSa []gS\a_cW RSd`]\b qb`S cbWZWaoa RO\a ZÑ]`R`S W\bS`\S Sb Q]\Tp`S l QS`bOW\Sa RWa^]aWbW]\ac\ Ä STTSb RW`SQb Å&C& .0 b&T&$ ^& ./ b&O& 1 WZ Sab aO\a R]cbS SfQSaaWT RS RW`S _cS Z ÑOQbS RS `SQ]\\OWa%

aO\QS \ÑO Ôa R ÑSTTSb Xc`WRW_cS&C& /( b&T&$ ^& /* b&O& 1 ZÑOcbSc` ^òaS\bS Q][[S OQ_cWa _cÑS\ QOa RS Q]\TZWb

W\bS`\S ZSa U]cdS`\S[S\ba ^ScdS\b TOW`S O^^SZ l Z ÑOWRS Sfbo`WSc`S$ QS _cW SabQ]\bSabo "Ô` ZÑW\abWbcb RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Ô` Sf&#& <Z Sab dÒW _cÑWZ Sab ^Zca\cO\Qo ^& )(+ Sb aa& b&T&$ ^& )*0 Sb aa& b&O&C& /+ 1 WZ Sab TOWb OZZcaW]\ Oc TOWb _cS ZSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a OcÒWS\b RSa R`]Wba l

Z ÑoUO`R RSa 8bOba \]\%[S[P`Sa$ S\ aS T]\RO\b ac` ZÑOdWa RS ZO 6&<&=& ac` ZO8YM?O?QGLK MLRO ICP BLJJ?ECP PR@GP$ =S \ÑOW XO[OWa obo Q]\dOW\Qc Ô` ZS ÔaaOUSS\ _cSabW]\ RS ZÑOdWa& FW <aÒrZ O `SQ]\\c OZ]à ZÑB&A&H&$ Q ÑSab _cÑWZ g OdOWbW\bo`qb& <Z \ ÑobOWb S\ `WS\ bS\c RS ZO `SQ]\\Osb`S& ?Sa Ro[qZoa 6&8&8&%6B@86BA

6B@CG8F 58A7GGF )+,

Ro[]\b`S\b _cS RO\a QSa R][OW\Sa WZ \ Ñg O Ôa dÒW[S\b RS ^Sà]\\OZWbo ]PXSQ%bWdS _cW ^Scb W[^]aS` RSa ]PZWUObW]\a Ocf bWSà$ [OWa RS aW[^ZSa Ò^^]`ba RSd]Z]\bo Sb RS T]`QS& 6ÑSab R]\Q []W\a RS BOLGQP l ZÑoUO`R RS bWSà _cS RS SGOQR?IGQYPR]\b WZ aÑOUWb&C& // 1 ZÑWRoS _cS ZSa ^Sc^ZSa R]WdS\b RWa^]aS` RÑc\S ab`cQbc`S _cW ZSa `S^ò%

aS\bS Sab XcabS [OWa ^]c`_c]W SfWUS` _cS QSbbS ab`cQbc`S a]Wb Ä `S^òaS\bObWdS Å$QS _cW \S aS TOWb Ôa S\ ^ÒbW_cS$ QO` ZSa Q]\RWbW]\a RS ZcbbS RSa ^Sc^ZSa \S ZS^S`[SbbS\b Ôa& 6S Q]\QS^b acPXSQbWT \ ÑSab a]cdS\b cbWZWao _cS Ô` QScf _cWdScZS\b RWa_cOZWTWS` c\ []cdS[S\b RobS`[W\o&C& ))* b&T&$ ^& )+0 b&O& 1 A]ca `SU`Sbb]\a ZO dOZaS VoaWbObW]\ R Ñ4\b]\W] 6OaaSaS

ac` ZO ZoUWbW[S RoTS\aS Sb ZSa S\b]àSa Ô` ZSa ac^S`%UÒ\Ra Oc ^`W\QW^S RS \]\%`SQ]cà l ZO T]`QS& F]\ a]cQW RS òOZWa[S [Sb S\ ô`WZ ZO \]`[S Sb dWS\b Q]\T]`bS`ZO [OfW[S ÄaSZ]\ _cS d]ca aS`Sh ^cWaaO\b ]c [WaoÒPZS&&& Å&

6Sa _cSZ_cSa `S[O`_cSa Q`WbW_cSa ^]c` [WScf TOW`S `Saa]`bW` Z ÑO[^ZSc` RS\]b`S ORVoaW]\ l QS PSZ ]cdÒUS RS ag\bVpaS ac` ZSa ^`]PZp[Sa T]\RO[S\bOcfRc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Q]\bS[^]ÒW\&

=SO\ F4?@BA&

4QZ`Q^ R[^ CQ_QMÔT [Z :Z`Q^ZMÙ[ZMX :Z_ÙàÙ[Z_# ,GM>KG:MBHG:E *>G>O:

(0/,# AMe[`# =Ma_MZZQ# **) \MSQ_%

C]c` ZSa RW^Z][ObSa$ X]c`\OZWabSa$ T]\QbW]\\OW`Sa$ V][[Sa R ÑOTTOW`Sa$ QVS`%QVScà Sb obcRWO\ba$ QSb ]cdÒUS ÒaaS[PZS RSa W\T]`[ObW]\a Q][^ZpbSa SbW\RWa^S\aOPZSa ac` ZSa Q]\To`S\QSa bS\cSa l :S\pdS Sb ac` ZSa *' ]ÙO\Wa[Sa Sb(* OUS\QSa aôQWOZWaoSa RSa AObW]\a H\WSa$ ZS 6&<&6&E&$ ZO ?WUcS RSa F]QWoboa RSZO 6`]Wf E]cUS Sb Rc 6`]WaaO\b E]cUS$ ZSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a òUW]\OZSa Q][[SZ Ñ4&8&?&8& Sb ZS 6&8&E&A&$ ZSa /. ]ÙO\WaObW]\a \]\ U]cdS`\S[S\bOZSa$ ZSa)/ W\abWbcba RS `SQVS`QVS Sb R ÑS\aSWU\S[S\b$ ZSa [WaaW]\a ^S`[O\S\bSa Sb ZSaa]QWoboa [cZbW\ObW]\OZSa W\abOZZoa RO\a QS QS\b`S RS ZO dWS W\bS`\ObW]\OZS&7SabW\o l RSdS\W` c\ O\\cOW`S$ WZ `SbÒQS ZSa ]`WUW\Sa Sb RoQ`Wb ZSa ]PXSQbWTa$

ZO ab`cQbc`S$ ZSa OQbWdWboa ^]ZWbW_cSa$ oQ]\][W_cSa Sb aQWS\bWTW_cSa$ ÔaaoSa Sb^òaS\bSa RS QSa W\abWbcbW]\a& <Z S\ [S\bW]\\S Z ÑOR`SaaS Sb ZS \][ RSa RW`WUSO\ba&

=&%C& ?8:E4A7&

&HFF>GM:BK> =>L 1KHMH<HE>L :==BMBHGG>EL =N / CNBG (0.. :NQ &HGO>GMBHGL =>

*>GVO> =N () :HXM (0+0# iP% \M^ J % DMZP[f# 4T %̂ DcUZM^_WU Q`3% KUYYQ^$YMZZ# 8QZjbQ# 4%:%4%C%# Q` >% ?UVT[Rm # (0/-# I I I G Q` (-+. \%

?Sa aôQWOZWabSa Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Vc[O\WbOW`S Z ÑObbS\ROWS\b RS^cWa Z]\U%bS[â 1 ZS Q][[S\bOW`S RSa Sf^S`ba Rc 6&<&6&E& ac` ZSa C`]b]Q]ZSa ORRWbW]\\SZaRS (0.. Sab S\TW\ O``Wdo$ Sb ZS òacZbOb$ ]\ aÑS\ R]cbS$ Sab l ZO [Sac`S RS aO Z]\UcSUSabObW]\$ l aOd]W`$ c\S òTZSfW]\ O^^`]T]\RWS$ \]c``WS Sb [x`WS ac` ZO aWU\WTWQO%bW]\ Sb ZO ^]`boS RSa bSfbSa OR]^boa$ WZ g O [OW\bS\O\b RWf O\a&5WS\ _cS ZO ^òaS\bObW]\ RS QS 6][[S\bOW`S a]Wb T]`[SZZS[S\b RWTTo`S\bS RS

QSZZS RSa 6][[S\bOW`Sa RSa 6]\dS\bW]\a RS :S\pdS RS (0+0$ Z ÑSa^`Wb `SabSRO\a ZO ZWU\oS RS a]\ WZZcab`S ^òRoQSaaSc`& FW OcX]c`RÑVcW$ ZÑ]\ aS òTp`S PSOcQ]c^^Zca _cÑVWS` l ZO ^ÒbW_cS$ ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS Sb ZO R]Qb`W\S$ WZ `SabS _cS RO\a c\QOa Q][[S RO\a Z ÑOcb`S$ Z Ñ]cdÒUS \ ÑS\bS\R `S^òaS\bS` _cS Z Ñ]^W\W]\ RS aSaOcbScà Sb \]\ QSZZS Rc 6&<&6&E& "^& K K L 2 d]g& OcaaW ZÑOdS`bWaaS[S\b _cW^òQpRS ZS Q][[S\bOW`S RSa 6]\dS\bW]\a RS :S\pdS RS (0+0#&?Sa OcbScà É =& 8PS`ZW\$ ;& C& :OaaS`$ F& =c\]R$ =& CWQbSb$ 6Z& CWZW]cR$

=& RS C`Scf$ L & FO\R]h$ 6V`& FeW\OàYW$ 6Z& 9& JS\US`$ 5& MW[[S`[O\\ É|\ ÑS\ a]\b Ôa []W\a RSa Sf^S`ba Rc 6&<&6&E& Sb Q ÑSab PWS\ RO\a ZÑSa^`Wb RS ZO[OWa]\ _cS Z ÑO\OZgaS RSa C`]b]Q]ZSa O obo Q]\ncS Sb òOZWaoS& 6SZO aS bÒRcWbÔ` RScf QOÒQbo`WabW_cSa SaaS\bWSZZSa 1 R Ñc\S Ô`b$ aW ZSa OcbScà od]_cS\bagabo[ObW_cS[S\b ZSa bÒdOcf ^òÔÒb]W`Sa RS ZO 6]\To`S\QS RW^Z][ObW_cS _cWO OR]^bo ZSa C`]b]Q]ZSa$ WZa \S RWaS\b QS^S\RO\b _cOaW[S\b `WS\ RSa ]`WUW\Sa

)+- 6B@CG8F 85;7k F

^]ZWbW_cSa ]c Uo]^]ZWbW_cSa a]Wb RSa ^`]^]aWbW]\a TOWbSa S\ Q]\To`S\QS$ a]Wb RSaa]ZcbW]\a Xc`WRW_cSa TW\OZS[S\b O``qboSa É ZS ZSQbSc` W\bo`Saao Ô` QS ^`]PZp[SR]Wb R]\Q `Sb]c`\S` RW`SQbS[S\b Ocf OQbSa RS ZO 6]\To`S\QS RW^Z][ObW_cS ]cl RSa O\OZgaSa R]Qb`W\OZSa "d]g& Ô` Sf& 5]bVS$ CO`baQV O\R F]WT$ 5CT 8RICP DLO<GAQGJP LD )OJCB +LKDIGAQP" GVS ;OUcS$ AWXV]TT$ (0/)$ .+- ^&$ QSbbS 8CSRC"(0/*$ ^& 0+0# 2 R ÑOcb`S Ô`b$ ZS 6][[S\bOW`S$ Z]W\ RS aS QO\b]\\S` l c\S SfoUpaSOaS^bWaoS$ aS dScb òa]Zc[S\b Ä ^]aWbWT Å Sb Vc[O\WbOW`S S\ QS _cÑWZ bS\R Uo\oÒZS%[S\b l W\bS`^òbS` ZSa RWa^]aWbW]\a Ä aS\aWPZSa Å ]c OgO\b TOWb ZÑ]PXSb RS RWdS`%US\QSa$ Z]à RS ZO 6]\To`S\QS RW^Z][ObW_cS$ RO\a c\ aS\a TOd]ÒPZS Ocf dWQbW[Sa$aO\a ^]c` OcbO\b bÒVW` ]c QOQVS` RSa ]^W\W]\a ^Zca `Sab`WQbWdSa& ?Sa W\bS`%^òbObW]\a R]\\oSa Ocf \]bW]\a RS Ä Ro^Z]WS[S\b [WZWbOW`S Å RO\a ZÑO`bWQZS ++${ *$ P "^^& ,+(%,+*#$ ]c RS Ä R][[OUSa SfQSaaWTa ] RO\a ZÑO`bWQZS ,($ { ,$ P$ Rc^`S[WS` C`]b]Q]ZS "^^& -+'%-+(# S\ a]\b RSa SfS[^ZSa oQZOWÒ\ba&GS\RO\QS Uo\oÒZS l c\S W\bS`^òbObW]\ Uo\o`ScaS Rc R`]Wb Vc[O\WbOW`S$ R]\Q$

[OWa \]\ ^]W\b bS\RO\QS Q]\abO\bS 1 ZSa OcbScà \S aS`]\b aO\a R]cbS Ôa ac`^`WaRS aOd]W` _cS \]ca `SU`Sbb]\a ZScà VoaWbObW]\a ac` Z ÑWZZWQoWbo RS Z ÑS[^Z]W RSa O`[Sa\cQZoOW`Sa Oc `SUO`R RSa `pUZSa Rc C`]b]Q]ZS _cW a]\b OcaaW RSa `pUZSa Q]cbc%[Wp`Sa 1 ZW[WbObW]\ RSa []gS\a RS \cW`S l Z ÑS\\S[W "O`b& *,$ { (#$ W\bS`RWQbW]\RSa O`[Sa RS \Obc`S l QOcaS` RSa [Ocf ac^S`TZca "O`b& *,$ { )#$ `Sa^SQb RS ZORWabW\QbW]\ S\b`S ]PXSQbWTa QWdWZa Sb [WZWbOW`Sa "O`b& +/# "^^& -'+%-',#&&&6SZO obO\b$ ZÑ]cdÒUS O^^]`bS c\S [W\S RS `S\aSWU\S[S\ba _cW RoÔaaS\b

ZOÙS[S\b ZO ^]`boS R Ñc\S Q]RWTWQObW]\ O\\]boS Sb S\ T]\b c\ do`WbOPZS bÒWboRS R`]Wb Vc[O\WbOW`S OdO\b ZO ZSbb`S& ? ÑS\b`S^`WaS Sab `S[O`_cOPZS[S\b aS`dWSÔ` c\ bÒdOWZ R ÑoRWbW]\ R]\b ZO [W\cbWS Sb ZO QZO`bo \S a]\b Ôa aO\a Ò^^SZS`QSZcW RSa 4YI?KECP 7GAQCQ "QSbbS 8CSRC" (0/+%(0/,$ ^& ,.(#&FÑWZ aSÒ R]\Q SfQZc Roa]`[OWa R ÑOP]`RS` c\ ^`]PZp[S RS R`]Wb Vc[O\WbOW`S

aO\a aS òTo`S` l QSb ]cdÒUS$ WZ \S TOcRÒWb QS^S\RO\b Ôa Q]\TW\S` a]\ ùZS lQSZcW R Ñ Ä Ocb]`Wbo Å OQORo[W_cS& FO d]QObW]\ Sab OdO\b b]cb Vc[OW\S Sb Q]\%Q`pbS$ QO` Q][[S ZS a]cZWU\S ZS CòaWRS\b Rc 6&<&6&E&$ 4 & ;Og RO\a a]\ 4dO\b%^`]^]a$ QS _cW W[^]`bS$ Q ÑSab ZO Ä ^`]bSQbW]\ RSa dWQbW[Sa RSa Q]\TZWba O`[oa Å$ SbÄ 8\ QS aS\a$ Z ÑoRWbW]\ RS QS 6][[S\bOW`S Sab SaaS\bWSZZS[S\b Q]\aWRoòS$ Ô`ZS 6&<&6&E&$ Q][[S c\ STT]`b S\ TOdSc` RS QSa dWQbW[Sa Å "^& K <<<#&

8& 74I<7&

.>L =BF>GLBHGL BGM>KG:MBHG:E>L =N =KHBM ANF:GBM:BK> FZQ_O[# :Z_Ùà` 9QZê5aZMZ`# AQP[ZQ# AMÛ_# (0/.# *-' \MSQ_%

7`]Wb RSa V][[Sa Sb RSa TS[[Sa _cW a]cTT`S\b S\ b]cb ^`S[WS` ZWSc Sb dWQbW[SaRSa Q]\TZWba O`[oa Sb RS ZScà Q]\ao_cS\QSa RW`SQbSa ]c W\RW`SQbSa$ R`]Wb RSZO ^`]bSQbW]\$ R`]Wb RS ZO Q]\QWZWObW]\$ R`]Wb RS ZO XcabWQS&<Z Sab RSdS\c W\RWa^S\aOPZS R ÑSf^]aS` ZS aS\a Rc R`]Wb Vc[O\WbOW`S Sb ZSa

]PZWUObW]\a _cW S\ RoQ]cZS\b ^]c` b]ca QScf _cW R]WdS\b ZSa ]PaS`dS`$ bO\b WZSab dÒW _cÑc\S `pUZS Xc`WRW_cS \S RSdWS\b c\S \]`[S RS Q]\RcWbS _cÑl Ô`bW`Rc [][S\b ]w SZZS aÑW[^]aS l ZO Q]\aQWS\QS Q]ZZSQbWdS RS Z ÑVc[O\Wbo b]cb S\bWp`S&

I]WQW ZO bOPZS RSa [ObWp`Sa RS QS d]Zc[S 1

A C 6 > :w C 6 A 2 C E :6

3? K?QROC BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I FRJ?KGQ?GOCCQ P? MI?AC CK BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I

<\b`]RcQbW]\& É 3CP GBYCP FRJ?KGQ?GOCP X QO?SCOP ICP BGSCOP ALRO?KQP BC I? MCKPYCCQ BCP QO?BGQGLKP ARIQROCIICP" Ô` =SO\ CWQbSb&

6VO^Wb`S <& É 3? ALKACMQGLK ?DOGA?GKC" Ô` 4RO[]c ARO[ AX]gO&6VO^Wb`S <<& É 3? ALKACMQGLK ?PG?QGNRC" Ô` Fc[W] 4ROQVW&6VO^Wb`S <<<& É 3? ALKACMQGLK BCP -Q?QP PLAG?IGPQCP" Ô` :ohO ;S`ShSUV&

6B@CG8F E8A7H F )+.

6VO^Wb`S <I &2É 3? ALKACMQGLK GPI?JGNRC" Ô` ;O[SR FcZbO\&6VO^Wb`S L& É 3? ALKACMQGLK I?QGKL#?JYOGA?GKC" Ô` =]ao%@O`WO EcRO&6VO^Wb`S I<& É 3? ALKACMQGLK LAAGBCKQ?IC" Ô` >O`Z =]aS^V CO`baQV

5 6 F I :w > 6 A 2 C E :6

3C BYSCILMMCJCKQ BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I FRJ?KGQ?GOC

6VO^Wb`S I <<& É 3C BYSCILMMCJCKQ BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I FRJ?KGQ?GOC" Ô`:& <& 4& 7& 7Ò^S`

E C @ :D :w > 6 A 2 C E :6

3C BOLGQ BCP ALKDIGQP ?OJYP

FSQbW]\ ( 1 ?Sa Q]\TZWba RS QOÒQbp`S W\bS`\ObW]\OZ

6VO^Wb`S I <<<& É +LJMLOQCJCKQ BCP ALJ@?QQ?KQP CQ ALKBRGQC BCP FLPQGIGQYP "7`]WbRS ?O ;OgS#$ Ô` EWQVO`R E& 5OfbS`&

6VO^Wb`SZK& É 4LVCKP CQ JYQFLBCP BC ALJ@?Q" Ô` ;O\a 5ZWf&6VO^Wb`S K & É|7OLQCAQGLK BCP SGAQGJCP BCP ALKDIGQP ?OJYP$

<& É *ICPPYP" J?I?BCP CQ K?RDO?EYP" Ô` =]ao 9Ò\QWaQ] EShSY&6VO^Wb`S K <& É|7OLQCAQGLK BCP SGAQGJCP BCP ALKDIGQP ?OJYP$

<<& É 7OGPLKKGCOP BC ERCOOC" Ô` 6ZOcRS CWZW]cR&6VO^Wb`S K <<& É 7OLQCAQGLK BCP SGAQGJCP BCP ALKDIGQP ?GJYP$

<<<& |É 7LMRI?QGLK AGSGIC" Ô` BXW H[]hc`WYS&6VO^Wb`S K <<<& É 7OLQCAQGLK BCP @GCKP ARIQROCIP" Ô` FbO\WaZOa%8ReO`R AOVZWY&

FSQbW]\ ) 1 ?Sa Q]\TZWba RS QOÒQbp`S \]\ W\bS`\ObW]\OZ

6VO^Wb`S K <I & É +LKDIGQP ?OJYP KLK GKQCOK?QGLK?RU" Ô` :S]ÙSa 4PW%FOOP&6VO^Wb`S KI & É :OLR@ICP CQ QCKPGLKP GKQYOGCROP" Ô` 4aPXv[ 8WRS&

BF 2 E C :w > 6 A 2 C E :6

3 _?MMIGA?QGLK BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I FRJ?KGQ?GOC

6VO^Wb`S KI <& É 4GPC CK ^RSOC BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I" Ô` LdSa FO\R]h6VO^Wb`S KI <<& É|8CPMLKP?@GIGQY CK A?P BC SGLI?QGLKP BR BOLGQ GKQCOK?QGLK?I"

FRJ?KGQ?GOC" Ô` <U]` C& 5ZWaVQVS\Y]&6]\QZcaW]\a$ Ô` >O`SZ IOaOY&5WPZW]UÒ^VWS acQQW\QbS&

6__Me_ [Z `TQ ZQc =Mc [R `TQ DQM# ^M__QYNXiQ \M^ 3aPU_XMb GaWM_# &HGMKB

;NMBHGL :NQ UMN=>L => =KHBM <HFI:KU >M => =KHBM BGM>KG:MBHG:E Zp )(# 7MOaXìPQ P^[U` PQ XvFZUbQ^_Uì PQ KMS^QN%

6S _cÑO d]cZc Z ÑoRWbSc`$ 5cRWaZOd IcYOa$ Q ÑSab ÒaaS[PZS` RSa obcRSa ac` ZS\]cdSOc R`]Wb RS ZO [S` òRWUoSa Ô` RSa Xc`WabSa \]\ aScZS[S\b g]cU]aZOdSa[OWa OcaaW RS RWdSà 8bOba& 6S QV]Wf ^S`[Sb RS ^òaS\bS` RSa dcSa bO\bub Q]\%Q]`RO\bSa$ [OWa bO\bub Q]\bÒW`Sa ac` ZÑc\ ]c Z ÑOcb`S Oa^SQb Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZRS ZO [S`&6Sb S\aS[PZS aS dScb OcaaW ORO^bo Ocf ^Zca òQS\ba RodSZ]^^S[S\ba Rc R`]Wb

RS ZO [S` O^`pa ZO Q]\dS\bW]\ RS @]\bSU] 5Og&

?O bOPZS QW%RSaa]ca `S\R Q][^bS RS ZO `WQVSaaS RS Z Ñ]cdÒUS 1

6BAG8AGF

?Wab ] T 4PP`SdWObW]\a9]`]e]`R

A 2 C E < 1 ;56369 1 1 1 ' ) 3?KBJ?OH GK 1KQCOK?QGLK?I 3YEGPI?QGLK

@& FOV]dWQ$ ?O Q]RWTWQObW]\ Sb ZS RodSZ]^^S[S\b ^`]U`SaaWT Rc R`]Wb W\bS`%\ObW]\OZ 1 6]\dS\bW]\ RSa AObW]\a H\WSa ac` ZS R`]Wb RS ZO [S`&

4& LÒbcaO$ 6]\dS\bW]\ ]\ bVS ?Oe ] T bVS FSO W\ bVS ?WUVb ] T bVS Fb`cUUZS T]`bVS ASe <\bS`\ObW]\OZ 8Q]\][WS B`RS`&

A 2 C E << 1 369 +LKSCKQGLK 1 /CKCO?I )PMCAQP

4& J & >]Sà$ F][S BPaS`dObW]\a ]\ bVS (0/) H\WbSR AObW]\a 6]\dS\bW]\ ]\bVS ?Oe ] T bVS FSO O\R Wba <[^ZS[S\bObW]\&

=&%C& Dco\ScRSQ$ ?Sa W\QS`bWbcRSa RS ZO \]cdSZZS 6]\dS\bW]\ ac` ZS R`]Wb RSZO [S`&

;& GcS`Y$ :& ;OT\S`$ GVS ?O\R%?]QVSR 6]c\b`WSa O\R bVS H\WbSR AObW]\a6]\dS\bW]\ ]\ bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&

7& IWU\Sa$ ?O Ô`bWQWÔbW]\ RS ZO 6][[c\Ocbo 8Q]\][W_cS 8c`]ôS\\S l ZO6]\dS\bW]\ RSa AObW]\a H\WSa ac` ZS R`]Wb RS ZO [S`&

A 2 C E <<< 1 4?OGQGJC =LKCP RKBCO 5?QGLK?I 2ROGPBGAQGLK

8& :]c[O`Wa$ GVS 8fbS\aW]\ O\R 7oZW[WbObW]\ ] T FSO 4`SOa H\RS` bVS F]dS`%`SWU\bg$ F]dS`SWU\ EWUVba O\R =c`WaRWQbW]\ ] T 6]OabOZ FbObSa&

5& >eWObY]eaYO$ 8fQZcaWdS 8Q]\][WS M]\S É :S\SÒZ 8dOZcObW]\&I & <PWS`$ GVS <[^]`bO\QS ] T bVS 8fQZcaWdS 8Q]\][WS M]\S Oa O A]\%ESa]c`QS

M]\S&7& EcR]ZT$ F][S ES[O`Ya OP]cb bVS C`]dWaW]\a Q]\QS`\W\U bVS 6]\bW\S\bOZ

FVSZT GK QFC ;5 6]\dS\bW]\ ]\ bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&5& IcYOa$ GVS ?BF 6]\dS\bW]\ O\R FSO 5]c\RO`g 7oZW[WbObW]\&

A 2 C E <I 1 5?SGE?QGLK

C& 7& 5OÒP]ZgO$ 6VO\USa W\ bVS ?oUOZ ESUW[S ] T bVS FSO O\R bVSW` <\TZcS\QS]\ AOdWUObW]\&

G& G`SdSa$ ?S \]cdSOc òUW[S RSa SaÔQSa [O`W\a Sb ZO QW`QcZObW]\ RSa \OdW`Sa&7& 7cU]aSdWQ$ ?Sa 8bOba O`QVW^SZa Sb ZS R`]Wb RS ÔaaOUS RSa \OdW`Sa Sb Oo`]\STa&7& @][bOh$ ?Sa T]`QSa \OdOZSa Sb ZÑW[ôÒbWT RS aoQc`Wbo RO\a ZO 6]\dS\bW]\

RSa AObW]\a H\WSa ac` ZS R`]Wb RS ZO [S`&?& @WUZW]`W\]$ GVS ESQ]dS`g ] T Fc\YS\ JOàVWâ W\ <\bS`\ObW]\OZ ?Oe&

A 2 C E I 1 3GSGKE 8CPLROACP LD QFC 9C?

C& @S\U]hhW$ 9WaVW\U O\R <\bS`\ObW]\OZ 6]%]^SÒbW]\ W\ bVS ?WUVb ] T ASe7SdSZ]^[S\ba W\ bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&

G& FQ]dOhhW$ ?Sa Sa^pQSa VOcbS[S\b [WUÒb`WQSa Sb ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RS ZO[S`&

A 2 C E I < 1 1KQCOK?QGLK?I 9C?#*CB )OC?

M& CS`WaWQ$ 6][[]\ ;o`WbOUS ] T @O\YW\R W\ bVS H\WbSR AObW]\a 6]\dS\bW]\]\ bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&

F& A]dOY]dWQ$ 6]cZR JS VOdS C`]dWRSR T]` O 5SbbS` H\WbSR AObW]\a 6]\dS\bW]\]\ bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSOs

9& ;& COQZWZZ]$ GVS C`SÔÒb]`g 6][[WaaW]\ T]` bVS <\bS`\ObW]\OZ FSO%5SR4cbV]`Wbg O\R T]` bVS <\bS`\ObW]\OZ G`WPc\OZ T]` bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&

)+/ 6B@CG8F ` S \ R c a

6B@CG8F 58A7G=F )+0

A 2 3 E I << 1 7OLQCAQGLK ?KB 7OYPCOS?QGLK LD QFC 4?OGKC -KSGOLKJCKQ

H& ?SO\hO$ <\bS`\ObW]\OZ ?Oe O\R 7][SabWQ ?Oe ]\ bVS C`]bSQbW]\ ]T bVS@O`W\S 8\dW`]\[S\b OUOW\ab C]ZZcbW]\&

4& C& CO\hSÒ$ GVS @]\bSU] 5Og 6]\dS\bW]\ O\R bVS C`]QoRcÒZ @SO\a T]`8\T]`QW\U <\bS`\ObW]\OZ EcZSa ]\ bVS C`]bSQbW]\ ] T bVS @O`W\S 8\dW`]\[S\b&

:& 6]\SbbW$ G=A6?BF O\R 886 8fbS`\OZ 6][ôbS\QS ]\ @O`W\S 8\dW`]\[S\bC`]bSQbW]\&

A 2 3 E I <<< 1 8YEGLK?I )MMOL?CFCP QL QFC 3?T LD QFC 9C?

@& <& :ZOOa\S`$ EoUW]\OZWaOW O\R bVS ASe ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&7& @OhWZc$ CSOQS O\R FSQc`Wbg O\R a][S C`]PZS[a `SUO`RW\U bVS 8\QZ]aSR ]`

FS[W%8\QZ]aSR FSOa&4 & >& 4PPORW$ FSQc`Wbg O\R 6]%]^SÒbW]\ W\ bVS @SRWbS`Ò\SO\ 5OaW\&4& @O\]a$ GVS 6]\dS\bW]\ O\R EoUW]\OZ 6]%]^SÒbW]\ T]` bVS C`]bSQbW]\ ]T

bVS @SRWbS`Ò\SO\ FSO OUOW\ab&

A 2 3 E <K 1 :FC 5CT 3?T LD QFC 9C? ?KB 6QFCO .GCIBPLD 1KQCOK?QGLK?I 3?T

H& =S\WaQV$ GVS 4`QbWS BQoO\ O\R bVS ASe ?Oe ]T bVS FSO&7& IWROa$ GVS ?oUOZ FbObca ] T 4\bO`QbWQO eWbV F^SQWOZ ESTS`S\QS b] bVS 4\bO`QbWQ

FSO%5SR O\R Wba FcPa]WZ&A& IOXWQ$ GVS ?Oe ]T BcbS` FÔQS O\R bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO 1 4 =]W\b 6]\b`WPcbW]\

b] bVS 8[SÙS\QS ] T bVS 6][[]\ ;o`WbOUS ] T @O\YW\R 6]\QS^b&

9 8 E E 8 á < $ CMeY[ZP# .: <HHK=BG:MBHG => E[<M<MBHG =>L HK@:GBL:MBHGL BGM>KG:

MBHG:E>L :N GBO>:N >NKHIU>G \îRMOQ PQ 8% 4[TQZ$;[ZM`TMZ# MbMZ`$\^[\[_PQ 9% 8[X_[ZS# 3âeXMZ`# 3âdQXXQ_# (0/+# I :G Q` *), \MSQ_%

? ÑOcbSc`$ _cW Sab [Osb`S%OaaWabO\b l ZO TOQcZbo RS R`]Wb RS @Sbh$ Q]\abObS _cSZSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa$ QòoSa aO\a Q]\QS`bObW]\$ OUWaaS\b aO\a Q] %Vo`S\QS$ <Z obcRWS ZSa b`]Wa abÒboUWSa dWaO\b l g `S[oRWS`&?Sa RScf ^`S[Wp`Sa$ aÑObbOQVO\b Ocf `SZObW]\a S\b`S ]ÙO\WaObW]\a$ Q]\aWabS\b

l ZSa ZWS` Ô` RSa OQQ]`Ra ]c l ZSa acP]`R]\\S` l c\S ]ÙO\WaObW]\ ^`W\QWÔZSQ][[S Z ÑB&A&H& ]c ZS 6]\aSWZ RS Z Ñ8c`]^S&H\S b`]WaWp[S [obV]RS aS Ò^^]`bS Ocf ^`]QSaaca RoQWaW]\\SZa RSa ]ÙO\Sa

Sb RSa 8bOba [S[P`Sa R]\b ZSa OQbWdWboa aSÒWS\b OW\aW ^`]UÒ[[oSa&

I]WQW$ S\ òac[o$ ZO bOPZS RSa [ObWp`Sa 1

CE8@<ÖE8 C4EG<8

= 6 D D E C 2 E g 8 :6 D 5 6 = 2 4 @ @ C 5 :? 2 E :@ ?

<\b`]RcQbW]\&

E :E 3 6 A 3 6 > :6 3 % É 3CP PQO?QYEGCP OCI?QGLKKCIICP$

6VO^Wb`S ^`S[WS`& É 3? PQO?QYEGC ALKAROOCKQGCIIC LR I? ALKAIRPGLK B_?AALOB BCALLOBGK?QGLK$

9CAQGLK 1 IC$ É ?O QOÔQWbo RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa RS Q]\QZc`SRSa OQQ]`Ra RS Q]]`RW\ObW]\&

9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ?O T]`[S RSa OQQ]`Ra RS Q]]`RW\ObW]\&9CAQGLK 1 1 1 $ É ?O Q]\QZcaW]\ RSa OQQ]`Ra&

6VO^Wb`S <<& ãÉ 3? PQO?QYEGC JLKLMLIGPQGNRC LR I GKPQ?RO?QGLK BC OCI?QGLKPÄ FGYO?OAFGP?KQCP Å CKQOC LOE?KGP?QGLKP$

9CAQGLK 1 IC$ É ?S []RpZS RS òTo`S\QS 1 ?S agabp[S RSa AObW]\a H\WSa&

),' 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ?Sa SaaOWa RS bÒ\a^]aWbW]\ Rc []RpZS RS òTo`S\QS Oc ^ZO\Sc`]ôS\&

E :E 3 6 <<& É 3? PQO?QYEGC BYAGPGLKKCIIC$

6VO^Wb`S ^`S[WS`& É| ;KC OCJGPC CK A?RPC BCP PQO?QYEGCP OCI?QGLKKCIICP$9CAQGLK < `S& É ES[WaS S\ QOcaS RS Z ÑSTTWQOQWbo RSa abÒboUWSa `SZObW]\\SZZSa&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ES[WaS S\ QOcaS Rc T]\RS[S\b RSa abÒboUWSa `SZObW]\\SZZSa

]c Q`WbW_cS RS ZO \]bW]\ R Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\$ OcbSc` RS ZO Q]]`RW\ObW]\&

6VO^Wb`S <<& É ;KC KLRSCIIC ?MMOLAFC BR MOL@IZJC BC I? ALLOBGK?QGLK$9CAQGLK 1 :C$ É 6]]`RW\ObW]\ Sb ^`]QSaaca RS RoQWaW]\ RS Z Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É 6]]`RW\ObW]\ Sb ^`]QSaaca RS RoQWaW]\ RSa 8bOba [S[P`Sa&

4@ ? 4 = F D :@ ? 5 6 = 2 A C 6 > :w C 6 A 2 C E :6 %

78HK<Ö@8 C4EG<8

= 6 D E 6 4 9 ? :B F 6 D 5 6 = 2 4 @ @ C 5 :? 2 E :@ ?

E :E C 6 A C 6 > :6 C % É 3CP QCAFKGNRCP OCI?QGLKKCIICP$

6VO^Wb`S ^`S[WS`& É 3? BGSGPGLK BR QO?S?GI$9CAQGLK 1 :C$ É ? ÑOcb]ZW[WbObW]\ RSa Q][ôbS\QSa&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ?O ZW[WbObW]\ Q]\dS\bW]\\SZZS RSa Q][ôbS\QSa&9CAQGLK 1 1 1 $ É ?O ZW[WbObW]\ RSa Q][ôbS\QSa Ô` c\ Ä O`PWb`S Å&

6VO^Wb`S <<& É 3? ALII?@LO?QGLK$9CAQGLK 1 1C$ É ? ÑW\T]`[ObW]\ òQW^`]_cS&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ? ÑOaaWabO\QS&9CAQGLK 1 1 1 $ É|?ÑOQbW]\ Q][[c\S&

6VO^Wb`S <<<& É 3 GKQCOMYKYQO?QGLK$9CAQGLK 1 IC$ É ? ÑW\bS`ô\obÒbW]\ RW`SQbS&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ? ÑW\bS`ô\obÒbW]\ W\RW`SQbS&

E :E C 6 <<& ãÉ|3CP QCAFKGNRCP BYAGPGLKKCIICP$

6VO^Wb`S ^`S[WS`& É 3CP QCAFKGNRCP B ?JYIGLO?QGLK BC I? MOGPC BC BYAGPGLK BCPLOE?KGP?QGLKP GKQCOK?QGLK?ICP 1 I? MOLEO?JJ?QGLK$

9CAQGLK 1 1*$ É ? ÑO^^]`b ObbS\Rc RSa bSQV\W_cSa RS ^`]UÒ[[ObW]\&9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ?S acQQpa `SZObWT RSa bSQV\W_cSa RS ^`]UÒ[[ObW]\&

6VO^Wb`S <<& É 3CP QCAFKGNRCP B_?JYIGLO?QGLK BC I? MOGPC BC BYAGPGLK BCP -Q?QPJCJ@OCP$

9CAQGLK 1 :C$ É ? ÑO[oZW]ÒbW]\ RS ZO ^`WaS RS RoQWaW]\ Oc \WdSOc W\bS`%[W\Wabo`WSZ&

9CAQGLK 1 1 $ É ? ÑO[oZW]ÒbW]\ RS ZO ^`WaS RS RoQWaW]\ Oc \WdSOc [W\Wabo`WSZ&

4@ ? 4 = F D :@ ? 8 g ? g C 2 = 6 %

3 :3 = :@ 8 C 2 A 9 :6 %

:4 F G 8 E $ ;QZ_$=UQZTM^P# '>K />>K>L;H=>G;>K@;HN NGM>K =>K +HA>G 3>>#

4MÛ 9QeYMZ_ GQ^XMS <8# <nXZ# (0/.# *., \MSQ_%

? ÑOcbSc` SfO[W\S ZSa ^Sà^SQbWdSa RÑSf^Z]WbObW]\ RSa \]RcZSa [obOZZWTp`Sa _cW$^]c` ZSa Ôga W\Rcab`WOZWaoa$ aÑOdo`SÒWS\b []W\a Q]xbScaSa Sb ^Zca ax`Sa _cSZÑW[^]`bObW]\ RS [W\SÒWa S\ ^`]dS\O\QS Rc GWSà @]\RS& ?O h]\S ZO ^Zca `WQVSP]`RSÒWb Z ÑsZS TÒ\nOWaS RS 6ZW^^S`b]\$ RO\a Z Ñ]QoO\ COQWTW_cS Oc ZOÙS Rc@SfW_cS&

6B@CG8F E8A7H F ),(

7O\a QS R][OW\S$ ZSa W\bo`qba Rc :`]c^S RSa .. Sb RSa BQQWRS\bOcf aÑ]^^]aS\b&?Sa ^`S[WSà W\d]_cS\b ZO 6]\dS\bW]\ RS @]\bSU] 5Og R]\b ZO [WaS S\ dWUcSc`Sab `SbO`RoS$ Sb ^]c` QOcaS$ OW\aW _cS ZO Eoa]ZcbW]\ @]Òb]W`S Rc (, RoQS[P`S(0-0$ ZO 7oQZOÒbW]\ RS ^`W\QW^Sa Rc (. Tod`WS` (0.' Sb Z ÑSfWabS\QS R Ñc\ òUW[S]PXSQbWT Ocf_cSZa ZSa aSQ]\Ra Ro\WS\b b]cb STTSb ]PZWUOb]W`S&?Sa RWa^]aWbW]\a bÒ\aWb]W`Sa ^òOZOPZSa l Z ÑS\bòS S\ dWUcSc` RS ZO 6]\dS\bW]\

^]c`ÒWS\b aÑO^^ZW_cS` Ocf S\b`S^`WaSa ]QQWRS\bOZSa$ [OWa SZZSa ZSa Q]\aWRp`S\bQ][[S b`pa RoaOdO\bOUScaSa& 8ZZSa Çcd`S\b ^Zcbub RO\a ZS QOR`S RS `pUZSaOR]^boSa c\WZOboÒZS[S\b ]c R ÑOQQ]`Ra PWZOboÒcf _cS Q]\bSabS\b ZSa Ôga S\d]WS RS RodSZ]^^S[S\b&?Sa SfS[^ZSa abObWabW_cSa Sb QO`bSa ^cPZWoa Ô` @]\aWSc` :OabS` WZZcab`S\b

l [S`dSWZZS QSa Q]\b`]dSàSa&=&%C& ?8:E4A7&

*KHMBNL >M E[HK=K> CNKB=BJN> BGM>KG:MBHG:E E^MbMad Pa O[XX[]aQ 8^[Ùa_%8QZjbQ# ('$(( Z[bQYN^Q (0/*# =Ma_MZZQ# (0/,# (,, \MSQ_%

?Sa Ô`bWQWÔ\ba l QS Q]ZZ]_cS ]\b aWbco ZÑO^^]`b Xc`WRW_cS RS :`]bWca RO\aZO bÒRWbW]\ Sb ZSa ZcbbSa RS a]\ bS[â& ?Sa oQ`Wba RS QSb Vc[O\WabS a]\b W[^òU\oaRS ZSQbc`Sa PWPZW_cSa$ R ÑOcbScà O\QWS\a Sb QVòbWS\a& 7oaW`Scf RS òQ]\QWZWS`6ObV]ZW_cSa Sb C`]bSabO\ba$ l c\S o^]_cS RS dW]ZS\bSa [cbObW]\a$ WZ Tcb RW^Z]%[ObS Sb V][[S ^]ZWbW_cS Ocf COga%5Oa$ ^cWa SfWZo S\ 9Ò\QS&A]ca aOd]\a _cS ZS /LJJCKQ?OGRP BC 2ROC 7O?CB?C Sb ZS 4?OC 3G@CORJ RoTS\%

ROWS\b R ÑW[^]`bO\ba W\bo`qba Q][[S`QWOcf& ;cU] RS :`]]b ]^^]aOWb Oc C]`bcUOZSb l ZÑ4\UZSbS``S ZS R`]Wb `][OW\ aSZ]\ ZS_cSZ ZO [S` obOWb WZZW[WboS$ \S ^]cdOWbqb`S O^^`]^`WoS Sb RSdOWb qb`S OTTSQboS l ZO ZWP`S Q][[c\WQObW]\& 4cX]c`RÑVcW$Q][[S Z ÑoQ`WdS\b ZSa ^`]TSaaScà @]\\WS` Sb 6OTZWaQV$ WZ \ ÑSab ^Zca b`pa cbWZSR ÑW\d]_cS` :`]bWca l QS ^`]^]a$ S\ ÒWa]\ RSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba bSQV\W_cSa SbRSa ]PXSQbWTa Q]\dSÙS\ba RSa UÒ\RSa ^cWaaO\QSa&?S ,C 2ROC *CIIG ?A 7?AGP òc\Wb RSa \]`[Sa RSabW\oSa Ocf ^`]TSaaW]\\SZa

RS ZO UcS``S 1 ZO ÔWf W\bS`\ObW]\OZS \ Ñg Sab _cÑc\S b`qdS& G]cbST]Wa$ Ô` ZÑSfO[S\RSa QOcaSa R ÑV]abWZWbo$ :`]bWca Q]\ab`cWb c\ agabp[S RS R`]Wb [Obo`WSZ ZOtQ$T]\Ro ac` ZSa Q]cbc[Sa$ ZSa bÒWboa Sb ZO ÒWa]\ Vc[OW\S& 6SbbS Çcd`S$ Q]\bS[%^]ÒW\S RS ZO :cS``S RS G`S\bS 4\a$ S\bS\R ZW[WbS` ZSa a]cTTÒ\QSa RSa QWdWZaOcf \oQSaaWboa RSa Q]\TZWba&G]cb S\ òaS`dO\b Z ÑSfS`QWQS Ô` ZSa Ô`bWQcZWSà RS `S^òaOWZZSa l ZÑobÒ\US`$

:`]bWca OTTW`[S Z ÑOcb]`Wbo RSa ^`W\QSa ac` ZScà bS``Wb]W`Sa& CZca _cS ZS ^p`SZoUS\ROW`S Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ WZ O^ÔÒsb Q][[S c\ ^òQcàSc` RS ZO \]bW]\Q]\bS[^]ÒW\S RS Z Ñ8bOb& 6Sb S\aSWU\S[S\b$ [Wa S\ Zc[Wp`S Ô` @& CSbS` ;OUUS\%[OQVS`$ \ ÑSab Ôa ZS []W\a W\bo`SaaO\b RSa OQbSa Rc Q]ZZ]_cS& 8\ d]WQW ZO bOPZSRSa [ObWp`Sa 1

: ? E C @ 5 F 4 E :@ ? 8 g ? g C 2 = 6

4ZT`SR 7cT]c`$ :`]bWca É V][[S RS Z]W$ V][[S RS T]W$ V][[S RS ZSbb`Sa&

A C 6 > :w C 6 A 2 C E :6

:EBG<HF 8G ?8 7EB<G 78 ?4 @8E

FW` E]PS`b L & =S\\W\Ua$ <\b`]RcQbW]\&

E]PS`b 9S]\abÒ$ 4?OC IG@CORJ # Q]\bSfbS VWab]`W_cS Sb QS\QS^ba T]\RO[S\bOcf&

>S\\SbV E & FW[[]\Ra$ :`]bWca O\R bVS ?Oe ]T bVS FSO % 4 ESOaaSaa[S\b&

=SO\ @]\\WS`$ ? ÑVo`WbOUS U`]bWS\ RO\a ZS R`]Wb RS ZO [S` []RS`\S S\ QS _cWQ]\QS`\S ^Zca Ô`bWQcZWp`S[S\b ZO ZWPS`bo RS \OdWUObW]\&

?cQWca 6OTZWaQV$ ? ÑVo`WbOUS U`]bWS\ Sb ZS òUW[S Xc`WRW_cS RSa `Saa]c`QSa \Obc`SZZSaRS ZO [S`&

),) 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

5 6 F I :w > 6 A 2 C E :6

:EBG<HF 8G ?8 7EB<G 78F 6BA9?<GF 4E@jF

7WSb`WQV FQVW\RZS`$ <\b`]RcQbW]\&<d] ES\a$ :`]bWca Sb ZO R]Qb`W\S bÒRWbW]\\SZZS RS ZO Ä UcS``S XcabS Å&:S]ÙSa 4PW%FOOP$ :`]bWca Oa O FgabS[%5cWZRS` % GVS 8fO[^ZS ] T bVS 2RP ?B

*CIIRJ$9`Wba >OZaV]dS\$ :`]bWcaÑ 2RP GK *CIIL eWbV F^SQWOZ ESTS`S\QS b] EcaSa ] T JO`

O\R CS`TWRg&:S]TT`]g 5Sab$ GVS CZOQS ] T :`]bWca W\ bVS 7SdSZ]^[S\b ]T <\bS`\ObW]\OZ

;c[O\WbO`WO\ ?Oe&7S\WaS 5W\RaQVSRZS`%E]PS`b$ ? ÑW\RWdWRc Sb aSa R`]Wba RO\a ZS agabp[S U`]bWS\&

4@ ? 4 = F D :@ ? 8 g ? g C 2 = 6

CSbS` ;OUUS\[OQVS`$ :`]bWca Sb ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ % ZS bSfbS Sb ZO ZoUS\RS&

=SO\%CWS``S ?8:E4A7&

:H G <8 E E 8 M 8 F C 4 7 4 $ 4Q_M^Q[ Q` 64?IB 64 E 4 I 4B 4 $ 2XR[Z_[$=aU_# 4>QMHL

=> =>K><AH BGM>KG:MBHG:E IN;;EB<H 6PU`[ÛMX EQOZ[_# >MPÛP# (0/-#0)(\%

I]WQW c\ `SQcSWZ RS bSfbSa _cW [o`WbS ZÑObbS\bW]\ l ^Zca RÑc\ oUO`R&FO\a R]cbS$ l ZÑodWRS\QS$ QO` WZ ]TT`S S\ ZO\UcS SaÔU\]ZS$ RSa bSfbSa _cÑ]\

\ÑO ZÑVOPWbcRS RS ZW`S _cÑS\ TÒ\nOWa ]c S\ O\UZOWa&@OWa Z ÑW\bo`qb RS QS `SQcSWZ dO Oc%RSZl&FO Q]\QS^bW]\ [q[S Sab W\bo`SaaO\bS& 8ZZS aS Ò^^`]QVS ^Zca RSa +?PCP ?KB

4?QCOG?IP O[o`WQOW\a _cS RSa `SQcSWZa RS bSfbSa l ZO TÒ\nOWaS& ?O [ObWp`SRWdWaoS RS [O\Wp`S agabo[ObW_cS aSZ]\ ZSa UÒ\Ra QVO^Wb`Sa Rc R`]Wb W\bS`%\ObW]\OZ Sab WZZcabòS \]\ aScZS[S\b Ô` RSa bSfbSa Q]\dS\bW]\\SZa [OWa OcaaWÔ` RSa SfbÒWba RS XcUS[S\ba RSa Q]cà W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa$ aS\bS\QSa O`PWbÒZSaSb bSfbSa RS R`]Wb W\bS`\S SaÔU\]Z&6S RS`\WS` ^]W\b [o`WbS R Ñqb`S a]cZWU\o& 6S ESQcSWZ W\bo`SaaSÒ ZSa \]\%

SaÔU\]Za Ô` ZO `WQVS R]Qc[S\bObW]\ W\bS`\S `SZObWdS Ocf bSfbSa Q]\abWbcbW]\%\SZa ]c ZoUWaZObWTa SaÔU\]Za ]c Ocf _cSabW]\a _cW W\bo`SaaS\b aôQWTW_cS[S\bZ Ñ8aÔU\S "OTTOW`S RS :WPÒZbO` RSa Q]\dS\bW]\a RS R]cPZS \ObW]\OZWbo OdSQRWdSàSa ò^cPZW_cSa R Ñ4[o`W_cS ZObW\S$ OQQ]`Ra RS RoTS\aS OdSQ ZSa 8bOba%H\Wa$ RWdSà OQQ]`Ra `SZObWTa l RSa _cSabW]\a [O`WbW[Sa$ OQQ]`R RÑW\RS[\WaObW]\RS PWS\a \ObW]\OZWaoa Oc @O`]Q$ SbQ&#&8\ c\ []b$ c\ b`pa P]\ []RpZS Rc US\`S&

=SO\ F4?@BA&

; 8E6 M8 : ; $ 8ifM# '>O>EHIF>GM H? ,GM>KG:MBHG:E +NF:GBM:KB:G .:P 2WMPi$YUMU <UMPn# 3aPM\Q_`# (0/+# )+' \MSQ_%

4^`pa c\ P`ST VWab]`W_cS$ Z ÑOcbSc` aWbcS ZSa Q]\dS\bW]\a RS :S\pdS ^`]boUSO\bZSa dWQbW[Sa RS UcS``S RO\a ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Q]\bS[^]ÒW\& <Z Q][[S\bSZScà `SZObW]\a OdSQ ZS R`]Wb RS ZO UcS``S Sb ZSa R`]Wba RS ZÑV][[S&?O Ô`bWS ^`W\QWÔZS Sab Q]\aOQòS Ocf ^`]PZp[Sa ^]aoa Z]à RSa Q]\TZWba RS

Z ÑO^`pa%UcS``S Sb Ocf ò^]\aSa T]`[cZoSa RO\a ZSa ^`]b]Q]ZSa ORRWbW]\\SZa S\[ObWp`S RS ^`]bSQbW]\ RSa QWdWZa$ RS abObcb RSa Q][PObbO\ba RS Uco`WZZO$ RSdWQbW[Sa RS Q]\TZWba \]\ W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf ]c RS `S^òaOWZZSa&6Sb ]cdÒUS Sab RSabW\o Ocf Xc`WabSa$ Ocf d]Z]\bOW`Sa RS ZO 6`]Wf E]cUS Sb

l b]cbSa ZSa ^Sà]\\Sa ^ò]QQcôSa RS QSa UÒdSa _cSabW]\a&

6B@CG8F E8A7H F ),*

+HFF:@> T 1:NE '> 6BLL<A>K! (OHENMBHG <HGLMBMNMBHGG>EE> >G %>E@BJN> >M

K>E:MBHGL BGM>KG:MBHG:E>L# AMÛ_# AiP[ZQ# (0/+# )(- \%

FÑOUWaaO\b R ÑV]\]`S` c\ Xc`WabS _cW Qc[cZS ZO R]cPZS _cOZWbo RS ^cPZWQWabSSb R ÑW\bS`\ObW]\OZWabS RS `S\][$ ]\ \S ^]cdOWb [WScf TOW`S _cS RS Q]\QSd]W`c\ bVp[S Oc Q]\TZcS\b Rc R`]Wb Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZ Sb Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&6ÑSab Z Ñ]PXSb Rc ^òaS\b d]Zc[S Oc_cSZ ]\b Q]\b`WPco RSa OcbScà PSZUSa Sb

obÒ\USà PWS\ Q]\\ca RSa ^cPZWQWabSa Sb W\bS`\ObW]\OZWabSa&4^`pa c\ OdO\b%^`]^]a ]w ZS ^`]TSaaSc` =& IS`V]SdS\ Sf^]aS ZÑOQbWdWbo

aQWS\bWTW_cS RS\aS Sb dO`WoS Rc ^`]TSaaSc` 7S IWaaQVS`$ @& E &%=& 7c^cg aWbcSQSbbS OQbWdWbo RO\a ZS QOR`S RS Z Ñ4QORo[WS RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RS ?O ;OgS&@& IOZbWQ]a Q]\aOQ`S c\S obcRS T]`b W\bo`SaaO\bS l ZÑO`bWQZS %&@GP RS ZO 6]\abWbc%

bW]\ PSZUS _cW `pUZS ZS bÒ\aTS`b RS ^]cd]Wà l RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa&F]ca ZS bWb`S Ä F]c`QSa Sb ^`W\QW^Sa Rc R`]Wb RSa US\a Sb ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS PSZUS 1

QS`bWbcRSa Sb dÒWaS[PZO\QSa Å$ ZS ^`]TSaaSc` IS`V]SdS\ P`]aaS c\ bOPZSOcQ]\QWa [OWa SfVOcabWT RS ZO ^ÒbW_cS PSZUS OfoS SaaS\bWSZZS[S\b ac` ZO Xc`Wa%^`cRS\QS& FW Z ÑW\bS`\ObW]\OZWa[S R]\b QSZZS%QW bo[]WU\S \S TOWb Ôa RS R]cbS$ZSa W\QS`bWbcRSa _cW ^paS\b ac` ZS a]`b RS ZO Q]cbc[S Sb RSa Ocb`Sa `pUZSa \]\oQ`WbSa W\a^W`S\b$ S\ `SdO\QVS$ QS`bOW\a `SU`Sba l Z ÑOcbSc`&4c bWb`S od]QObSc` Ä ?S E]W TOWb ZSa bÒWboa Å$ Z ÑobcRS Rc ^`]TSaaSc` 9& 7SZôòS

OX]cbS c\S d]Wf R ÑOcb]`Wbo l ZO [OX]`Wbo RS ZO R]Qb`W\S _cW Ro\WS Ocf Q][%[c\Ocboa Sb òUW]\a PSZUSa ZS R`]Wb RS Q]\QZc`S RSa bÒWboa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf&? ÑobcRS RS @& dO\ 6][^S`\]ZZS$ _cW Q]\abWbcS c\S O\OZgaS T]cWZZoS RSa W\QW%

RS\QSa [cZbW^ZSa RSa bÒWboa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf ac` Z ÑO[o\OUS[S\b RS ZO T]\QbW]\XcRWQWOW`S$ Sab acWdWS R Ñc\S Q]\b`WPcbW]\ RS @& C& GO^WS$ O^^òQWO\b l aO XcabS[Sac`S ZÑO^^]`b Sfb`q[S[S\b `WQVS RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS RS ZO 6]c` Sc`]ôS\\SRSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S l ZO aOcdSUO`RS RSa ZWPS`boa ^cPZW_cSa RO\a ZSa 8bObaSc`]ôS\a&B\ b`]cdS a]ca ZO ^Zc[S RS 6V& ;cPS`ZO\b R ÑW\bo`SaaO\bSa ]PaS`dObW]\a ac`

ZS abObcb OR[W\WabÒbWT RSa obÒ\USà Sb Z Ñ]`R`S ^cPZWQ \ObW]\OZ& ?O ^ÒbW_cSPSZUS aÑSab SfQZcaWdS[S\b T]\RoS ac` ZÑ]`R`S ^cPZWQ \ObW]\OZ ^]c` XcabWTWS` ZSaZW[WbObW]\a Ocf R`]Wba RSa obÒ\USà& 6S Q]\QS^b TZ]c O `Snc RSa Q]\b]cà ^Zca^òQWa RO\a ZO Z]W Rc (, RoQS[P`S (0/'$ Ô` ZO_cSZZS ZS ZoUWaZObSc` O ^òQWaoZSa QOa ]w ZÑOcb]`Wbo OR[W\WabÒbWdS ^Scb ^`S\R`S RSa [Sac`Sa RS ax`Sbo l Z ÑoUO`RRSa obÒ\USà&?O RS`\Wp`S obcRS$ QSZZS Rc ^`]TSaaSc` 9& EWUOcf$ ^]`bS ac` ZÑod]ZcbW]\ Q]\a%

bWbcbW]\\SZZS RS ZO 5SZUW_cS Sb ZSa `SZObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa& B\ `SbWS\RÒ Ô`%bWQcZWp`S[S\b ZSa òTZSfW]\a RS Z ÑOcbSc` ac` ZO Q]\b`]dSàS acaQWboS Ô` ZÑOcb]`WboS\ R`]Wb W\bS`\S RSa O``qba RS ZO 6]c` Sc`]ôS\\S RSa R`]Wba RS ZÑV][[S$ ac`Z Ñ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS ac^Ò\ObW]\OZ$ OW\aW _cS ac` ZS Ä Roô`WaaS[S\b Rc Q]\QS^bR ÑW\Ro^S\RO\QS \ObW]\OZS Å WZZcabò$ aSZ]\ ZÑOcbSc`$ Ô` ZÑW[^ZO\bObW]\ RSa [Wa%aWZSa \cQZoOW`Sa S\ 5SZUW_cS&

EcaS\ 8E:86&

; BB> 8 $ 2% H% !iP%"# 4A> )NG= :G= &ABG: BG MA> ,GM>KG:MBHG:E /HG>M:KR

3RLM>F :Z`Q^ZMÙ[ZMX >[ZQ`Mê 7aZP# (0/*# (/. \MSQ_%

6S d]Zc[S òc\Wb ZSa OQbSa R Ñc\ Q]ZZ]_cS bS\c l CoYW\$ a]ca ZSa Oca^WQSa RSZO 5O\_cS C]^cZOW`S RS 6VW\S Sb Rc 9&@&<&$ Rc )' Oc )/ ]Qb]P`S (0/)& 8\ d]WQWZS Q]\bS\c 1

4hWhOZW @]VO[[SR$ GVS 8d]ZcbW]\ ] T bVS <\bS`\ObW]\OZ @]\SbO`g FgabS[ O\RbVS 6VO\UW\U EuZS ] T bVS 9c\R&

?o] IO\ ;]cbdS\$ GVS 9Ò[Se]`Y T]` C]ZWQg[OYW\U W\ bVS 9c\R&J[& 6& ;]]R$ GVS 6c``S\b J]`ZR 8Q]\][WS FWbcObW]\ O\R bVS C`]PZS[ ]T

:Z]POZ COg[S\ba <[POZO\QSa&;]\U =c\gO\$ F][S 6][[S\bO ]\ bVS 6c``S\b 8Q]\][WS FWbcObW]\ W\ bVS JSab&

),+ 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

?c] LcO\hVS\U$ GVS 6VW\SaS 8Q]\][g O\R& <ba EuZS W\ bVS J]`ZR&@O\cSZ :cWbWm\$ 9c\R C`]UÒ[a T]` 8Q]\][WS 4RXcab[S\b&C& E & AO`dSYO`$ 6]ZZOP]ÒbW]\ 5SbeSS\ bVS 9c\R O\R bVS J]`ZR 5O\Y&J[& 6& ;]]R$ GVS F7E É 4\ <\b`]RcQbW]\&E & =& 9O[WZb]\$ GVS F7E É <ba 8d]ZcbW]\ O\R C`]a^SQba&4& J & ;]]ZQS$ GVS EuZS ] T bVS 9c\R W\ 7SdSZ]^W\U 6]c\b`WSa&

?Sa bVp[Sa$ SfO[W\oa Ô` RSa oQ]\][WabSa QVW\]Wa Sb RSa T]\QbW]\\OW`Sa Rc9&@&<&$ bo[]WU\S\b RS Z ÑW\bo`qb RSa Ocb]`Wboa QVW\]WaSa ^]c` ZSa [oQO\Wa[SaoQ]\][W_cSa Sb []\obOW`Sa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf Sb RSa `Sa^]\aOPZSa Rc 9]\Ra ^]c`Z Ñod]ZcbW]\ R Ñc\ Ôga R]\b ZS C&ÜFG&5& obOWb$ S\ Od`WZ (0/*$ ZS aS^bWp[S Oc ÔZ[O`paRSa [S[P`Sa Rc 9&@&<&

,M:EB:G 8>:K;HHD H? ,GM>KG:MBHG:E .:P b[XaYQ G:# (0/,# 8âRRî# >UXMZ#(0/-# +-. \MSQ_%

?Sa obcRSa RS QS d]Zc[S a]\b Q]\aOQòSa l RSa _cSabW]\a RS P`xZO\bS OQbcOZWbo$aW\UcZWp`S[S\b RO\a ZS R][OW\S Rc RoaO`[S[S\b& 4W\aW$ ZS C`]TSaaSc` 6]\R]`SZZWSb @& @o`WP]cQVS Ro\]\QS\b Z!W\acTTWaO\QS Rc R`]Wb ZWdÒ\b Z ÑSaÔQS SfbÒ%Ob[]a^Vo`W_cS l ZO Q]càS Ocf O`[S[S\ba RSa ac^SÙÒ\Ra& @& E]\hWbbW aÑSab^S\QVo ac` ZSa abObcba Sb ^`]XSba$ Ô`T]Wa Z]W\bOW\a$ RS Ro[WZWbO`WaObW]\ Sb RS\ScbÒZWaObW]\ Rc POaaW\ [oRWbS`Ò\oS\$ `SZObWTa Oc Rob`]Wb RS :WPÒZbO`$ l ZO[S` 8UoS$ l @OZbS$ l 6Vg^`S Sb [q[S Oc ?WPO\& @& 6O\OhO\\] \]ca ZWd`S RSaQ]\aWRoÒbW]\a ac` ZO R]cPZS RoQWaW]\ RS ZÑB&G&4&A& S\ (0.0 Sb ZÑW\abOZZObW]\RS POaSa RS [WaaWZSa S\ 8c`]^S& ?S C`]TSaaSc` C]ZWbW `S\R Q][^bS RS ZO Q]\To`S\QSR ÑSfO[S\ RS ZO \]\%^`]ZWToÒbW]\ RSa O`[Sa \cQZoOW`Sa& @& 4& 9& CO\hS`ÒQ][[S\bS ZO Q]\dS\bW]\ RS (0.. ac` ZO []RWTWQObW]\ RS ZÑS\dW`]\\S[S\b l RSaTW\a V]abWZSa&@& @W^ZW]\W\] O\OZgaS ZSa RoQZOÒbW]\a Sb òaS`dSa Oc bÒWbo RS (0.( `SZObWT

l ZO Ro\cQZoO`WaObW]\ Rc T]\R RSa [Sà&ESZSd]\a OcaaW c\ Q][[S\bOW`S RS @& 8& G`WUUWO\W l ^`]^]a Rc bÒWbS[S\b

RS ZO \ObW]\ ZO ^Zca TOd]`WaoS&?O aSQ]\RS Ô`bWS Rc d]Zc[S ò^S`b]`WS Sb SfO[W\S ZO ^ÒbW_cS XcRWQWOW`S$

U]cdS`\S[S\bOZS Sb ZoUWaZObWdS WbOZWS\\S S\ [ObWp`S W\bS`\ObW]\OZS&?Sa Xc`WabSa obÒ\USà Q]\acZbS`]\b QSbbS ZWdÒWa]\ RS ZÑO\\cOW`S WbOZWS\ OdSQ

R ÑOcbO\b ^Zca R ÑW\bo`qb Sb RS TOQWZWbo _cÑWZa ^]c``]\b aS `S^]`bS` l RSa W\RSfa]WU\oa&


= B H I 8 $ 6PY[ZP# .> MB>KL FHG=> =:GL E: OB> BGM>KG:MBHG:E> AMÛ_# 3Q^SQ^$=Qb^MaX`# PQadUjYQ iPUÙ[Z# (0/-# *'. \%

FWU\OZ]\a ZO òoRWbW]\ RS QSb ]cdÒUS _cW \S RWTTp`S RS ZÑ]`WUW\OZ _cS Ô` RSa[]RWTWQObW]\a RS RobOWZ$ RSa [WaSa l X]c` OW\aW _cS Z ÑORX]\QbW]\ R Ñc\ W\RSf RSa\][a Ôb`]\g[W_cSa&EO^^SZ]\a b]cb Z ÑW\bo`qb RS ZÑobcRS ^]c` c\S O^^`]QVS RSa aWbcObW]\a W\bS`%

\ObW]\OZSa `S\Q]\bòSa Ô` ÄZS bWSà []\RSÅ "^Sc^ZSa Sb 8bOba#& ?Sa PWPZW]%UÒ^VWSa obOPZWSa S\ TW\ RS QVO^Wb`S a]\b OP]\RO\bSa Sb SZZSa OWRS`]\b QScf _cSZO _cSabW]\ W\bo`SaaS&

7S\WaS @4G;L&

-:GL:BGHBD>NL u ENL *>GMBNF ($)&(0/.# 9QX_UZWU# )*- \MSQ_%

? ÑOaa]QWObW]\ TW\ZO\ROWaS Zca :S\bWc[ ^cPZWS RS^cWa (0/+ c\S `SdcS Q]\aOQòSOc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^cPZWQ Sb ^`Wdo$ Oc R`]Wb Q][Ôò Sb l ZO bVo]`WS Rc R`]Wb&

6B@CG8F 58A7H F ),,

CZca RS ZO []WbWo RSa O`bWQZSa Rc _cOb`Wp[S d]Zc[S$ Ô`c S\ [OW (0/.$ ]\bobo òRWUoa S\ O\UZOWa& 8\ d]WQW ZS a][[OW`S 1

@Oc`WQS A& 4\RS[$ F][S ESTZSQbW]\a ]\ bVS (0/- <?4 7oQZOÒbW]\ ]\ bVSC`]U`SaaWdS 7SdSZ]^[S\b ] T C`W\QW^ZSa ]T CcPZWQ <\bS`\ObW]\OZ ?Oe ESZObW\Ub] O ASe <\bS`\ObW]\OZ 8Q]\][WS B`RS`&

>m`]Zg 5m`R$ GVS 6]\QS^b ] T bVS 6`W[W\OZ BTTS\QS W\ bVS F]QWOZWab 6]c\b`WSa&ISWX] ;SWaYO\S\$ BWYScadOZbW]\ bS]``SbbWaSabO X]VbO[WaSabO <<< 1 J & A& ;]VTSZR

XO 9c\RO[S\bOZ ?oUOZ 6]\QS^bW]\a& "B\ bVS GVS]`SbWQOZ 7o`WdObW]\ ] TÄ ESQVbaabOOb Å <<< 1 J & A& ;]VTSZR O\R 9c\RO[ScbOW ?oUOZ 6]\QS^bW]\a#&

@O`bbW >]aYS\\WS[W$ F]dS`SWU\bg& C`]ZSU][S\O b] O FbcRg ] T bVS Fb`cQbc`S ] T<\bS`\ObW]\OZ ?Oe Oa 7WaQ]càS&

4`b] >]a]\S\$ >ZOaaW\S\ Vc[O\WbOO`W\S\ W\bS`dS\bW] <<< "6ZOaaWQOZ ;c[O\WbO%`WO\ <\bS`dS\bW]\ <<<#&

EOW[] ?OVbW$ FQO\RW\OdWO\ 6`W[W\OZ C]ZWQg 1 G`S\Ra O\R <\bSÒQbW]\a&LO\RO ?O[[$ GVS B^bW]\OZ 6ZOcaS W\ GVS]`g O\R W\ CÒQbWQS&

?86GHE8F B9 G;8 <<< <AG8EA4G<BA4? C8468 HA<I8EF<GL";SZaW\YW ))%)- BQb]PS` (0/-#

JOZbS` C]SUUSZ$ ;c[O\ EWUVba O\R CSOQS&;O\a =]Ù FO\RYyVZS`$ GVS EWUVb ]T @S\ b] G`cbV$ FQ]^S ] T 4QbW]\$ ;]^S$

O\R CSOQS É B\ bVS 8bVWQa ] T FQWS\bWTWQ 6]\RcQb&:S`VO`R FbcPg$ ;c[O\ EWUVb b] O ?WTS W\ CSOQS&

ABG8F 6B@@8AGF

8`YYW >]c`cZO$ ESdWSe ]T bVS J]`Y ]T bVS FWfbV 6][[WbbSS ] T bVS +(ab :S\SÒZ4aaS[PZg ]T bVS H\WbSR AObW]\a&

@ObbW GcÔ[mYW$ <?41\ +'%dc]bWaXcVZOaS[W\OO`W "GVS +'bV 4\\WdSàO`g FS[W\O`]T bVS <?4#&

? 4G=I4HK $ ATUXU\\Q# .> I:KE>F>GM:KBLF> AMÛ_# A%F%7%# 4[XX% s BaQ _MU_$VQ1 t#(). ^&

9]`[S RS U]cdS`\S[S\b ZO ^ZWOa òÔ\RcS RO\a ZSa Ro[]QÒbWSa ]QQWRS\bOZSaiZS Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S `SQpZS RSa Q][^ZSfWboa l ZO [Sac`S RS a]\ W[^]`bO\QS& FOagabo[ObWaObW]\ Sab RWTTWQWZS$ bO\b a]\ O[o\OUS[S\b dO`WS Oc Uò RSa aôQWTWQWboa^]ZWbW_cSa& F]\ T]\QbW]\\S[S\b aS aWbcS RO\a c\S ^Sà^SQbWdS Rg\O[W_cS$ OcTWZ RSa Sfô`WS\QSa OQ_cWaSa _cW OZW[S\bS\b c\S od]ZcbW]\ Q]\bW\cS& ? ÑobcRS RcÔ`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S Sab R]\Q O`RcS& 8ZZS ZÑSab R ÑOcbO\b ^Zca Z]à_cS Z ÑOcbSc`RWa^]aS R Ñc\ SaÔQS ZW[Wbo& 6ÑSab ZS [o`WbS RS @& ?OcdOcf RÑOd]W` ^ZSW\S[S\b[Osb`Wao QSa RWTTWQcZboa RO\a c\ ZWd`S _cW ]TT`S c\S ag\bVpaS Q][^ZpbS RSa Oa^SQba^]ZWbW_cSa Sb Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZa Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S&7O\a c\S ^`S[Wp`S Ô`bWS$ Z ÑOcbSc` obcRWS ZSa T]\RS[S\ba VWab]`W_cSa Sb

Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZa Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S& ?O US\paS Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S QZOaaW_cSS\ 4\UZSbS``S$ aS QOÒQbo`WaO\b Ô` ZS RcOZWa[S$ Sb aO òQS^bW]\ ac` ZS Q]\bW\S\b$a]\b acWdWSa RS RodSZ]^^S[S\ba ac` ZO bVo]`WS Rc òUW[S Ô`ZS[S\bOW`S Sb aSabS\RO\QSa Q]\bS[^]ÒW\Sa& B\ \]bSÒ OdSQ W\bo`qb _cS$ Q]\bÒW`S[S\b l ZOR]Qb`W\S QZOaaW_cS$ @& ?OcdOcf \S `SbWS\b _cÑc\ aScZ Q`Wbp`S Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S 1ÄZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWbo U]cdS`\S[S\bOZS RSdO\b c\S OaaS[PZoS oZcSÅ "^& *'#& 7O\aZ ÑO[o\OUS[S\b Q]\bS[^]ÒW\ Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S$ WZ RWaQS`\S c\S ^òR][W\O\QS[]\WabS "`Sa^]\aOPWZWbo Rc U]cdS`\S[S\b RSdO\b ZÑOaaS[PZoS aScZS# aS QOÒQ%bo`WaO\b$ [q[S ac` ZS ^ZO\ T]`[SZ$ Ô` Z Ño`]aW]\ RSa ^ò`]UObWdSa RS QVST RSZÑ8bOb& DcO\b Oc RcOZWa[S "`Sa^]\aOPWZWbo Rc U]cdS`\S[S\b RSdO\b ÒaaS[PZoSSb ZS QVST RS Z Ñ8bOb l ZO T]Wa#$ WZ O b`]cdo c\ `S\]cdSOc aWU\WTWQObWT RO\a ZO 9Ò\QSRS ZO I S Eo^cPZW_cS _cS ZÑOcbSc` `STcaS$ Q]\bÒW`S[S\b l Z Ñ]^W\W]\ R][W\O\bS

),- 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

"QT& 7cdSÙS`#$ RS _cOZWTWS` RS òUW[S aS[W%^òaWRS\bWSZ 1 Ä ?S Q]\abWbcO\b RS(0,/ O Qòo c\ òUW[S Ô`ZS[S\bOW`S Ô`QS _cÑWZ O [OW\bS\c ZS ^`W\QW^S RS ZO`Sa^]\aOPWZWbo ^]ZWbW_cS Rc U]cdS`\S[S\b RSdO\b Z ÑOaaS[PZoSÅ "^& +'#&?O aSQ]\RS Ô`bWS bÒWbS Rc QOR`S W\abWbcbW]\\SZ& ?Sa ]ÙO\Sa$ ZS CO`ZS[S\b$

ZS QVST RS Z Ñ8bOb Sb ZS U]cdS`\S[S\b$ T]\b Z Ñ]PXSb RÑO\OZgaSa ObbS\bWdSa& B\`SbWS\RÒ Ô`bWQcZWp`S[S\b ZSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba ac` ZS PWQO[oÒZWa[S Sb a]\RoQZW\$ ac` ZÑSTTOQS[S\b ^`]U`SaaWT Rc ùZS Rc QVST RS ZÑ8bOb "Ä ZS QOR`S \Obc`SZRc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S Sab ZO []\O`QVWS Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZZS Å# l ZÑSfQS^bW]\ RSaòUW[Sa TÒ\nOWa$ ^]`bcUOWa Sb TW\ZO\ROWa& DcO\b Ocf [oQO\Wa[Sa Rc òUW[SÔ`ZS[S\bOW`S$ WZa R]\\S\b ZWSc l RÑW\bo`SaaO\bSa òTZSfW]\a ac` ZS Ô`ZS[S\bO%`Wa[S ÒbW]\OZWao RO\a aSa dSàW]\a R ÑOdO\b Sb O^`pa ZO aSQ]\RS UcS``S []\RWOZS$OW\aW _cS ac` ZO RWaa]ZcbW]\ RSa OaaS[PZoSa Ô`ZS[S\bOW`Sa$ ZO_cSZZS O PSOcQ]c^^S`Rc RS aO aWU\WTWQObW]\ ]`WUW\SZZS&7O\a ZO b`]WaWp[S Ô`bWS$ @& ?OcdOcf aÑObbOQVS l [Sbb`S S\ `SZWST ZSa R][W%

\O\bSa RO\a ZS T]\QbW]\\S[S\b RSa W\abWbcbW]\a Ô`ZS[S\bOW`Sa& <Z W\aWabS Ô`%bWQcZWp`S[S\b ac` Z ÑW\QWRS\QS Rc agabp[S oZSQb]ÒZ Sb ac` ZS ùZS RSa Ô`bWa^]ZWbW_cSa& ?O abOPWZWbo [W\Wabo`WSZZS$ c\ RSa ^`]PZp[Sa [OXScà Rc Ô`ZS[S\%bO`Wa[S$ O W\a^Wò ZSa STT]`ba RS ÒbW]\OZWaObW]\ O^`pa (0+,$ S\ [O\Wp`S bSZZS_cS Ä ZS Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S P`WbO\\W_cS Sb aSa bSQV\W_cSa ^ÒU[ObW_cSa ]\b QSaaoR Ñqb`S ZS []RpZS T]\RO[S\bOZ R ÑORO^bObW]\ RSa W\abWbcbW]\a Ô`ZS[S\bOW`Sa Å"^&((+#& 6S a]\b Roa]`[OWa ZSa agabp[Sa TÒ\nOWa Sb OZZS[O\R _cW aS`dS\b RS[]RpZS Oc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S []RS`\S Q][[S ZS Ro[]\b`S ZÑSfS[^ZS Rc C]`bcUOZSb RS Z Ñ8aÔU\S&8\ UcWaS RS Q]\QZcaW]\$ @& ?OcdOcf \ ÑVoaWbS Ôa l Ô`ZS` RÑ Ä c\ do`WbOPZS

`S\]cdSOc Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S Å& ?S QVO[^ RS Òg]\\S[S\b ^]bS\bWSZ RcÔ`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S$ Ä Sf^`SaaW]\ ZO ^Zca T]\QbW]\\SZZS RS ZO Ro[]QÒbWS `S^òaS\%bObWdS Å$ RoÔaaS ZS Q]\bSfbS ^c`S[S\b ]QQWRS\bOZ&

EcaS\ 8E:86&

?`WT4tT A ]UcSÒa $ 5UQS[# (E '>M>GB=H >G (E &HGO>GBH (NKHI>H => EHL'>K><AHL

+NF:"GHL 6P% FZUbQ^_UPMP PQ 8^MZMPM# (0/'# (*+ \MSQ_%

8bcRS O^^`]T]\RWS R Ñc\ acXSb R ÑOQbcOZWbo bSZ _cS ZSa R`]Wba Obb`WPcoa l ZO^Sà]\\S _cW aS b`]cdS S\ RobS\bW]\ ^òdS\bWdS l ZO Zc[Wp`S RS ZO 6]\dS\bW]\Sc`]ôS\\S "O`bWQZS ,$ Sb Ô`bWS -# Sb RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS RS aSa W\abWbcbW]\a Ô`[ S O\OZgaS Q][ÔÒbWdS OdSQ ZO 6]\abWbcbW]\ SaÔU\]ZS&? ÑOcbSc` OP]`RS OdSQ Q]cÒUS Z ÑobcRS Rc R`]Wb l Z ÑW\T]`[ObW]\ RSa ÒWa]\a RS ZO

RobS\bW]\$ ZS R`]Wb l qb`S Q]\RcWb aO\a RoZOW S\ ^òaS\QS R Ñc\ XcUS$ ZS R`]WbR Ñqb`S XcUo RO\a c\ RoZOW ÒWa]\\OPZS Sb ZO ZWPS`bo ^`]dWa]W`S$ ZS R`]Wb R ÑW\%b`]RcW`S c\ `SQ]cà RSdO\b c\ b`WPc\OZ$ ZS R`]Wb l ZO òÔÒbW]\$ ZÑOaaWabO\QSRÑc\ RoTS\aSc` Sb ZO ax`Sbo RS ZO ^Sà]\\S RobS\cS$ Sb QS l ZO Zc[Wp`S RS ZO^òa][^bW]\ R ÑW\\]QS\QS RO\a c\S a]QWobo Ro[]QÒbW_cS&? ÑO\OZgaS Q`WbW_cS RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS Sab b]cb OcaaW `S[O`_cOPZS& ? ÑOcbSc`

^]aS ^ZcaWScà _cSabW]\a& 7 ÑOP]`R WZ ]PaS`dS _cS QS`bOW\a Q`Wbp`Sa S[^Z]goa Ô` ZSb`WPc\OZ a]\b acaQS^bWPZSa R Ñqb`S cbWZWaoa Q][[S OÙc[S\bObW]\a ^]ZWbW_cSaÄ _cW `Wa_cS\b R ÑO\\cZS` ZS [W\W[c[ RS aoQc`Wbo Xc`WRW_cS `S_cWaS Å ]c RÑqb`ST]\QWp`S[S\b W[^òQWa2 OcaaW$ WZ Q]\abObS _cSZ_cSa W\bS`^òbObW]\a RS ZO 6][%[WaaW]\$ do`WbOPZS[S\b ac`^`S\O\bSa& 6S`bSa$ ZÑOcbSc` XcUS ZS RodSZ]^^S[S\bXc`Wa^`cRS\bWSZ ^Sc aObWaTOWaO\b&8\ QS _cW Q]\QS`\S ZS R][OW\S W\bS`\S$ ZO RobS\bW]\ ^òdS\bWdS Sab S\b]còS

RS ^Zca RS UOÒ\bWSa RO\a ZO 6]\abWbcbW]\ SaÔU\]ZS& 6ÑSab ^]c`_c]W ZO ÒbWTWQObW]\Ô` Z Ñ8aÔU\S RS ZO 6]\dS\bW]\ Sc`]ôS\\S \ÑO Ôa O^^]`bo R ÑO[oZW]ÒbW]\ RO\aQS R][OW\S&8\ Q]\QZcaW]\$ ZÑOcbSc` bS`[W\S S\ TOWaO\b c\ O^^SZ Oc 6]\aSWZ RS ZÑ8c`]^S 1

Ä c\S SfbS\aW]\ RSa R`]Wba Rc RobS\c Sb Z ÑOR]^bW]\ RS \]`[Sa _cW ^S`[SbbÒWS\bc\S [SWZZSc`S ^òQWaW]\ Xc`WRW_cS RO\a ZSc` O^^ZWQObW]\ Sb ZSc` Q]``Sa^]\RO\QSOdSQ Z ÑOQbcOZWbo Sb ZS ^`]U`pa RSa aQWS\QSa Xc`WRW_cSa RO\a QS R][OW\S Å&

:Z]`WO 4?5<B?&

6B@CG8F E8A 7H F ),.

@ 456; <F <B $ DQ^SU[# ,E ?BG:GSB:F>GMH FNEMB;BE:M>K:E> u .: M>KSB: OB: =UEB:

<HHI>K:SBHG> :EEH LOWENIIH >UZU_`j^Q U`MXUQZ PQ_ 2RRMU^Q_ i`^MZSj^Q_#7^MZO[ 2ZSQXU iP%# >UXMZ# (0/-# (,0 \MSQ_%

?O Q`WaS oQ]\][W_cS Sb ZO [oTWO\QS RS QS`bOW\a 8bOba ]QQWRS\bOcf l ZÑoUO`RR Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa ^]`bS\b ObbSW\bS l ZO Q]]ôÒbW]\ [cZbWZOboÒZSOc RodSZ]^^S[S\b& 4caaW$ RO\a ZS QOR`S Rc C&A&H&7&$ RS ZO 9&4&B& Sb RS ZO5O\_cS []\RWOZS$ ZSa 8bOba RWba R]\ObScà \oU]QWS\b%WZa Z Ñ]Qb`]W R ÑOWRSa l RSa8bOba RobS`[W\oa Sb l RSa Q]\RWbW]\a _cW ZSc` ^`]TWbS\b ^]ZWbW_cS[S\b Sb Q][%[S`QWOZS[S\b&? ÑOcbSc` SfO[W\S QSbbS ^ÒbW_cS _cS acWb \]bO[[S\b ZS U]cdS`\S[S\b

WbOZWS\&

@ SY ` WZa $ ;[TZ# $G:MHFR H? ,GM>KG:MBHG:E .:P DcQQ` MZP >MdcQXX# =[ZP[Z#(0/(# (+- \MSQ_%

6SbbS aSQ]\RS oRWbW]\ OQbcOZWaoS R Ñc\ ]cdÒUS Ô`c ^]c` ZO ^`S[Wp`S T]WaS\ (0.- Sab RSabW\oS l W\WbWS` ZSa obcRWO\ba Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ agabo[ObW_cS%[S\b Q]\T`]\bo Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\S Sb Oc Q]\bSfbS ^]ZWbW_cS&? ÑOcbSc`$ _cW S\aSWU\S l Z ÑH\WdSàWbo RS FVSTTWSZR$ RoQ`Wb ZO ab`cQbc`S RoQS\%

bÒZWaoS$ ZO T]`[ObW]\$ ZO bÒ\aT]`[ObW]\$ Z ÑW\bS`^òbObW]\ Sb Z ÑO^^ZWQObW]\ RcR`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ& <Z a]cZWU\S _cS ZSa 8bOba O\QWS\a Sb \]cdSOcf$ [ca Ô` RSaW\bo`qba dO`Woa aW\]\ ]^^]aoa$ RWdSÙS\b \oQSaaOW`S[S\b ac` Z ÑSfWabS\QS RSQ]cbc[Sa$ ZO acQQSaaW]\ Ocf bÒWboa ]c ZS `pUZS[S\b XcRWQWOW`S RSa RWTTo`S\Ra&7 ÑOcb`Sa acXSba RS bS\aW]\ É R`]Wb RS ZO [S`$ abObcb RSa obÒ\USà$ \]cdSZ ]`R`S

oQ]\][W_cS É O^ÔÒWaaS\b RO\a ZO RScfWp[S Ô`bWS _cW bÒWbS$ S\ `SbÒnO\bZSc` od]ZcbW]\ RS^cWa (0+,$ RSa T]\QbW]\a Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ 1 ZO òÔ`bWbW]\RSa Q][ôbS\QSa S\b`S ZSa 8bOba$ ZO ^`][]bW]\ RS ZScà W\bo`qba Q][[c\a$ ZS[OW\bWS\ RS ZO ÔWf Sb ZS Q]\bùZS RS Z ÑcaOUS RS ZO T]`QS&?O b`]WaWp[S Ô`bWS agabo[ObWaS ZSa ZSn]\a RSa RScf ^`S[Wp`Sa S\ QS _cW

Q]\QS`\S Z ÑObbWbcRS RSa 8bOba TOQS Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Sb ZS ùZS _cÑWZa ZcWOaaWU\S\b RO\a ZO ^òdS\bW]\ Sb ZO òa]ZcbW]\ RSa Q`WaSa& ?S RS`\WS` QVO^Wb`SSab Q]\aOQò Ocf `SZObW]\a 8ab%BcSab&@& @S``WZa$ S\ ]PaS`dObSc` ZcQWRS$ o[OWZZS a]\ S\aSWU\S[S\b RS òTo`S\QSa

QZOW`S[S\b Sf^]aoSa l ZO ^ÒbW_cS Sb l ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS òQS\bSa& F]\ [O\cSZS\ Sab R ÑOcbO\b ^Zca cbWZS Sb ÔaaW]\\O\b&


>UOTMlX# >UOTQX# . [:IIEB<:;BEBMU =N MK:BMU BGLMBMN:GM E: *!(!(! >M =N =KHBM

=UKBOU :N IE:M>:N <HGMBG>GM:E =>L (M:ML F>F;K>L AMÛ_# =%8%5%;%# (0/+#*'( \MSQ_%

8fO[W\O\b acQQSaaWdS[S\b ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ ZSa RWa^]aWbW]\a Q][[c\Oc%bOW`Sa Sb ZSa ZoUWaZObW]\a$ Z ÑOcbSc` Q]\QZcb _cS ZSa W\abWbcbW]\a RS ZO 6&8&8& ^ScdS\bòUZS[S\bS` ZSa OQbWdWboa RSa 8bOba [S[P`Sa ac` ZSc` ^ZObSOc Q]\bW\S\bOZ&4 ZÑO^^cW RS aO bVpaS$ WZ QWbS ZSa O`bWQZSa )). Sb )*, Rc GÒWbo RS E][S$ ZS [o[]%Ò\Rc[ RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ S\ RObS Rc (/ aS^bS[P`S (0.'$ ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS RSZO 6&=&6&8&$ S\ Ô`bWQcZWS` ZSa O``qba 4&8 &G&E & Sb >Ò[S`$ ZSa ^òQoRS\ba S\[ObWp`S RS ^qQVS$ R ÑOWRSa obObW_cSa$ RS R`]Wba RS R]cO\S \]bO[[S\b$ ZÑSfS[^ZSRSa 8bOba ToRoÒcf Sb$ S\TW\$ Z ÑW[ô`WScaS \oQSaaWbo RS RodSZ]^^S` c\S ^]ZWbW_cSo\SÙobW_cS Q][[c\S&6][[S Z ÑW\RW_cS\b @@& 6]ZZWO`R Sb IWU\Sa RO\a ZO ^òTOQS Sb ZÑOdO\b%^`]^]a$

WZ aÑOUWb R Ñc\S Çcd`S BC GCEC DCOCKB?" òa]Zc[S\b ]^bW[WabS RO\a ZÑOdS\W` RS ZO6][[c\Ocbo&


),/ 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

/BL<>EE:G>: *>HK@>L O:G +><D>! 3>E><M>=PKBMBG@L 2Z`cQ^\QZ# <XacQ^ ^QOT`_$cQ`QZ_OTM\\QZ# (0/,# **+ \%

6S ZWd`S O ZS UÒ\R [o`WbS RS ÒaaS[PZS` c\S Ô`bWS RSa O`bWQZSa _cS ZS C`]TSa%aSc` dO\ ;SQYS OdOWb ^cPZWoa RO\a RWdSàSa `SdcSa Sb [oZO\USa& ?S `SQcSWZ`STZpbS l a]cVOWb ZSa _cOZWboa c\O\W[S[S\b `SQ]\\cSa RS @& dO\ ;SQYS _cS ZSC`]TSaaSc` 5ObWTT]Z Ò^^SZZS RO\a a]\ W\b`]RcQbW]\ 1 c\S QcZbc`S Xc`WRW_cSo[W\S[[S\b ^]ZgdOZS\bS$ \]c``WS Ô` c\S Z]\UcS ^ÒbW_cS$ RSa Q]\\OWaaO\QSaZW\UcWabW_cSa obS\RcSa _cW ^S`[SbbS\b RS \][P`Scf Sb cbWZSa `SQ]cà Oc R`]WbQ][Ôò$ c\S Ro[O`QVS W\bSZZSQbcSZZS _cW ò^cU\S b]cX]cà Ocf Sfb`q[Sa Sb$S\TW\$ c\ abgZS Q]\QWa$ a]P`S Sb ^òQWa&?O Ô`bWS Uo\oÒZS Q][^`S\R RSa obcRSa _cW b]cQVS\b Ocf RWTTo`S\ba Oa^SQba

Rc R`]Wb& F]ca ZS bWb`S Ä 7S ^ZOOba dO\ VSb `SQVb W\ RS aO[S\ZSdW\U Å$ ZS ^`]TSaaSc`dO\ ;SQYS aÑW\bS``]US ac` ZÑSTTSQbWdWbo RS Z Ñ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS ^]c` `SQ]\\Osb`S _cSQS`bOW\Sa a^Vp`Sa RS ZO dWS a]QWOZS oQVO^^S\b Oc R`]Wb& ? ÑS[^`WaS Rc R`]Wb dO`WSOcaaW acWdO\b ZSa Ôga& 4Z]à _cS RO\a ZSa agabp[Sa O\UZ]%aOf]\a$ SZZS Sab W[^]`%bO\bS$ ZSa bÒRWbW]\a OT`WQOW\Sa Sb Sfb`q[S%]`WS\bOZSa ^`qQVS\b ^Zcbub ZS `pUZS[S\bO[WOPZS& 9Ocb%WZ$ Rpa Z]à$ aÑob]\\S` _cS RO\a Z ÑOQbW]\ RSa AObW]\a H\WSa$ ZORW^Z][ObWS Sb ZO \oU]QWObW]\ Z ÑS[^]`bS\b ac` Z ÑOÙc[S\bObW]\ Xc`WRW_cS3 "^& .#@& dO\ ;SQYS aS ^`]\]\QS ^]c` c\S d]WS []gS\\S S\b`S ZSa Q]\QS^bW]\a ]`WS\%bOZSa Sb ]QQWRS\bOZSa 1 Ä OTTW`[S` aSa ^`]^`Sa R`]Wba \ ÑSab Ôa b]cX]cà ZS Q][^]`bS%[S\b obVW_cS ZSa ^Zca RWU\SÅ "^& 0#&Ä AOO` Q]RWTWQObWS dO\ VSb 8\USZaS `SQVb 3 Å Q]\abObS ZSa ^`]U`pa RS ZO Q]RWTWQO%

bW]\ S\ R`]Wb O\UZOWa ^]c` a]cZWU\S` ZO Q]\dSÙS\QS OdSQ ZSa agabp[Sa Q]\bW\S\%bOcf _cW$ l Z ÑW\dSàS$ Q]\\OWaaS\b c\S SfbS\aW]\ Rc R`]Wb Xc`Wa^`cRS\bWSZ l[Sac`S _cS ZSa bSfbSa ZoUWaZObWTa dWSWZZWaaS\b& 4caaW$ ZO RWTTo`S\QS T]\RO[S\bOZSS\b`S ZSa RScf agabp[Sa òaWRS []W\a RO\a ZO ab`c]bc`S RSa a]c`QSa _cS RO\aZ ÑOàS\OZ RSa Q]\QS^ba&Ä 4 QWdWZWO\ Z]]Ya Ob bVS Q][[]\%ZOe ZOegS` Å [Sb S\ `SZWST ZSa bÒWba T]\RO%

[S\bOcf _cW aW\UcZO`WaS\b ZS R`]Wb O[o`WQOW\ Ô` Ò^^]`b Ocf agbp[Sa Q]\bW\S\%bOcf& ?O QOacWabW_cS$ ZO Ro[O`QVS S[^W`W_cS Sb ^ÒU[ObW_cS Rc Xc`WabS O[o`W%QOW\$ Q]\T`]\bo Ocf UÒ\RSa Q][^ZSfWboa Rc R`]Wb O[o`WQOW\$ Q]\bÒabS OdSQ ZOQS`bWbcRS Sb ZO aW[^ZWQWbo RSa a]ZcbW]\a _cÑ]TT`S\b ZSa R`]Wba Sc`]ôS\a$ ]PaS`dSZS C`]TSaaSc` dO\ ;SQYS&DcO\b Ocf Ä EoTZSfW]\a ac` Z ÑobOb ^òaS\b RS Z Ñc\WTWQObW]\ Rc R`]Wb Å$ SZZSa

OP]cbWaaS\b Oc dÇc R Ñc\S ÒbW]\OZWaObW]\ RSa STT]`ba RÑc\WTWQObW]\ Sb R Ñc\S[SWZZSc`S Q]]`RW\ObW]\ S\b`S ZSa RWTTo`S\ba ]ÙO\Wa[Sa RÑc\WTWQObW]\&?O aSQ]\RS Ô`bWS `S\TS`[S RSa obcRSa RS R`]Wb ^`Wdo& ? ÑO`bWQZS ac` Ä ?SF

ò^S`QcaaW]\a RSa `pUZSa Rc Q]\bùZS RSa QVO\USa ac` ZO dOZWRWbo Sb Z ÑSfoQcbW]\RSa ]PZWUObW]\a Q][[S`QWOZSa Å$ TOWb ]PaS`dS` _cS ZSa ZoUWaZObW]\a ac` ZS Q]\bùZSRSa QVO\USa Q]\bWS\\S\b Ò`S[S\b RSa RWa^]aWbW]\a RS R`]Wb ^`Wdo òUZS[S\bO\bZSc` W\QWRS\QS ac` Z ÑSfoQcbW]\ RSa ]PZWUObW]\a Q][[S`QWOZSa& ?S R`]Wb Q][[c\RSa ]PZWUObW]\a UO`RS R]\Q b]cb a]\ S[^W`S 1 Z ÑS\UOUS[S\b Rc RoPWbSc` ^Scb qb`SQ]\aWRoò Q][[S OTTSQbo R Ñc\S Q]\RWbW]\ aca^S\aWdS bOQWbS$ l aOd]W`$ Z ÑOcb]`WaO%bW]\ RSa Ocb]`Wboa []\obOW`Sa& Ä ?O `Sa^]\aOPWZWbo RSa a]QWoboa ^]c` TOWba RS ZScàOR[W\WabÒbScà S\ R`]Wb PSZUS Å TOWb ZÑ]PXSb RÑc\ SfO[S\ Q`WbW_cS$ ]w @& dO\;SQYS [Sb S\ QOcaS Z ÑW\bS`^òbObW]\ W\Rx[S\b SfbS\aWdS RS ZO \]bW]\ RÑ]ÙO\SOc bWb`S RS ZÑO`bWQZS (*/) Rc 6]RS QWdWZ& Ä I`WXVSWR ]T ReO\U W\ VSb OO\P]R dO\U]SRS`S\ S\ RWS\abS\ Å [O`_cS ZSa ^òTo`S\QSa RS ZÑOcbSc` ^]c` ZSa a]ZcbW]\a\cO\QoSa Rc R`]Wb OZZS[O\R Ô` Ò^^]`b Ocf RWa^]aWbW]\a PSZUSa ]c O[o`WQOW\Sa_cW aO\QbW]\\S\b ZS `STca RS dS\R`S& 8\TW\$ a]ca ZS bWb`S Ä ?]QObW] ]^S`Wa TOQWS\RW&8W\ 5SWbÒU hc` FgabS[ObWY RS` IS`bÒUabg^S\ Å$ @& dO\ ;SQYS obcRWS ZS Z]cOUSR ÑW\Rcab`WS bSZ _cÑWZ Tcb Q]\nc Ô` ZSa E][OW\a Sb bSZ _cÑWZ O obo O[o\OUo Sb `SncRO\a ZSa UÒ\Ra agabp[Sa Xc`WRW_cSa Q]\bS[^]ÒW\a$ ZSa RWTTo`S\ba bg^Sa RSQ]\bÒba Ocf_cSZa WZ O R]\\o ZWSc "[O\ROb$ Q]\bÒb R ÑS\b`S^`WaS$ Q]\bÒb RSbÒdOWZ$ RÑOUS\QS$ RS Q][[WaaW]\$ SbQ&#$ OW\aW _cS ZSa Q`Wbp`Sa _cW ^òaWRS\b l QSaRWabW\QbW]\a&?S R`]Wb O\bW%b`cab O W\a^Wò l @& dO\ ;SQYS RSa òTZSfW]\a W[^]`bO\bSa ac`

ZSa Ä EpUZSa O\bW%b`cab Sb Q]\QS\bÒbW]\ RÑS\b`S^`WaSa l Z ÑoQVSZ]\ W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Å&

6B@CG8F E8A7H F ),0

?l òUZS[S\bObW]\ W\bS`\ObW]\OZS c\WT]`[S RSa ^ÒbW_cSa `Sab`WQbWdSa aS VSc`bSOcf ]^^]aWbW]\a R ÑW\bo`qba S\b`S 8bOba& H\S do`WbOPZS c\WT]`[WaObW]\ \S ^ScbaS Q]\QSd]W` _cS RO\a ZS QOR`S RÑc\S W\boUÒbW]\ Q][[S ZS Ro[]\b`S ZÑSfS[^ZSRSa 6][[c\Ocboa Sc`]ôS\\Sa& 4 ZÑoQVSZ]\ c\WdSàSZ$ ]\ ^Scb b]cb Oc ^ZcaW\abOc`S` RSa QS\b`Sa RS \oU]QWObW]\&?S R`]Wb ^cPZWQ \ ÑoQVO^^S Ôa ROdO\bOUS Ocf W\dSabWUObW]\a Rc C`]TSaaSc`

dO\ ;SQYS& Ä ?Sa S\aSWU\S[S\ba Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\S Å aÑW\bS``]US\b ac` Z ÑOZoO RS^cWaaO\QS ^cPZW_cS "^]aaWPWZWbo ^]c` ZÑOR[W\WabÒbW]\ R ÑW[^]aS` ZO []RWTWQObW]\c\WZOboÒZS Rc Q]\bÒb# Sb ZÑOZoO RS ZoUWaZObW]\ "RWa^]aWbW]\a Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZZSa]c ZoUOZSa ^]`bO\b ObbSW\bS Ocf R`]Wba OQ_cWa# S\ Ò^^]`b OdSQ ZSa R`]Wba RSaW\dSabWaaScà obÒ\USà S\UOUoa RO\a c\ ZWS\ Q]\bÒQbcSZ OdSQ ZÑ8bOb RÑOQScSWZ&H\S obcRS RS R`]Wb TWaQOZ$ Ä G`cab S\ acQQSaaWS`SQVbS\ Å$ ^S`[Sb RS Ro[]\b`S`

Q][PWS\ ZSa a]ZcbW]\a Rc R`]Wb TWaQOZ ^ScdS\b qb`S b`WPcbOW`Sa RSa _cOZWTWQObW]\aSb OaaW[WZObW]\a ^]abcZoSa Ô` ZS R`]Wb ^`Wdo&Ä ? ÑO`PWbÒUS Sb `Sab`WQbW]\a RS ZO Q]\Qc``S\QS Å O\OZgaS ZO Q][ÔbWPWZWbo RS

Z ÑO`PWbÒUS OdSQ ZS QOÒQbp`S W[ôÒbWT RSa `pUZSa aOcdSUO`RO\b ZO Q]\Qc``S\QS$\]bO[[S\b ZSa O`bWQZSa /, Sb /- Rc bÒWbo 6&8&8& 7O\a aSa Ä EoTZSfW]\a ac`ZÑO`PWbÒUS Oc ^]W\b RS dcS RS a]\ W\boUÒbW]\ RO\a ZSa RWdSà ]`R`Sa Xc`WRW_cSa Å$@& dO\ ;SQYS òQcaS ZÑWRoS RS ZÑO`PWbÒUS Ä O\ObW]\OZ Å& G]cb O`P`WbOUS aS Òb%bOQVS l c\ ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS$ \ObW]\OZ ]c W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&C]c` QS _cW Sab RSa R`]Wba W\bSZZSQbcSZa$ ]\ [S\bW]\\SÒ Z ÑO`bWQZS ac` Ä? S

`SbO`R bSQV\]Z]UW_cS Sb R`]Wba W\bSZZSQbcSZa Å _cW SfO[W\S ZS òUW[S RSa P`SdSbaSb a]\ od]ZcbW]\ a]ca ZÑO\UZS Rc \]cdSZ ]`R`S oQ]\][W_cS W\bS`\ObW]\OZ& 4^`paOd]W` `SXSbo ZS Q]\QS^b RS Ä Ôb`W[]W\S Q][[cO RS ZÑVc[O\Wbo Å$ ZÑOcbSc` O^^cWSZO a]ZcbW]\ _cW Q]\aWabS l \ ÑOQQ]`RS` RSa P`SdSba _cS []gS\\O\b c\S Sf^Z]WbObW]\W\Rcab`WSZZS ac` ^ZOQS&?S R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^cPZWQ TOWb ZÑ]PXSb RS RScf obcRSa RWabW\QbSa& 7O\a

Ä AObW]\OZWbg ] T Q][Ô\WSa O\OZgaSR Å$ ZS C`]TSaaSc` dO\ ;SQYS RWaap_cS ZO\ObW]\OZWbo RSa a]QWoboa l RWdSàSa TW\a$ OdO\b R Ño^]caS` ZS Q`Wbp`S Uo\oÒZ RcZWSc R ÑW\Q]`^]ÒbW]\& ? ÑO`bWQZS ac` Z ÑO^^ZWQObW]\ SfbÒbS``Wb]`WOZS Rc R`]Wb O\bW%b`cab [Sb ZÑOQQS\b ac` ZSa W\QS`bWbcRSa OQbcSZZSa RS ZO ^ÒbW_cS obObW_cS Sb aS QZubÔ` RSa ^`]^]aWbW]\a RS a]ZcbW]\ l ZO Zc[Wp`S RSa bÒdOcf RS <1KQCOK?QGLK?I 3?T)PPLAG?QGLK$B\ aÑS\ aSÒ R]cbo$ ZO Ô`bWS ZO ^Zca W[^]`bO\bS$ Sb ZO RS`\Wp`S$ Sab òaS`doS

Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^`Wdo& 8ZZS Sab W\OcUcòS Ô` (Ñ Ä H\WdSàOZWa[S Sb Ô`bW%QcZO`Wa[S RSa `pUZSa RS Q]\TZWb Oc K K S aWpQZS Å ]w Z ÑOcbSc` ^ù\S ZS Ò^^`]QVS[S\bRSa `pUZSa RS Q]\TZWb Oc ^ZO\ W\bS`\ObW]\OZ a]ca ZO òaS`dS RS Z Ñ]`R`S ^cPZWQ^`]^`S l QVO_cS Ôga& 4 ZO _cSabW]\ Ä ;SSTb S` W\bS`\ObW]\OOZ ^`WdOOb`SQVbPSabOO\ d]]` RS abObcbWabS\3 Å$ @& dO\ ;SQYS ò^]\R Ô` Z ÑOTTW`[ObWdS 1 ZSa^`S[WSà ^`W\QW^Sa RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^`Wdo ]\b obo ^]aoa Ô` ZS CO`ZS[S\bRS CO`Wa$ RS a]`bS _cS$ Q][[S RO\a ZSa Ocb`Sa PÒ\QVSa Rc R`]Wb$ ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QSO ^òQoRo ZO R]Qb`W\S& H\S obcRS ac` ZSa Q]\TZWba RS Z]Wa RO\a ZSa a]QWoboa OT`WQOW\SaO\OZgaS RScf bg^Sa RS Q]\TZWba W\bS`\Sa 1 ZS Q]\TZWb S\b`S ZS R`]Wb Q]cbc[WS` "RSa]c`QS SaaS\bWSZZS[S\b b`WPOZS# Sb ZS R`]Wb oQ`Wb$ R Ñc\S Ô`b$ Sb ZS Q]\TZWb S\b`SQ]cbc[Sa W\RWUp\Sa$ R ÑOcb`S Ô`b& 4dSQ Ä ?Sa WRoSa R Ñ8cUS\W] COQSZZW ac` ZO^Sà]\\OZWbo Sb ZO bS``Wb]`WOZWbo Rc R`]Wb Å$ ZS C`]TSaaSc` dO\ ;SQYS `S\R c\dWPÒ\b V][[OUS l QS a]cdSÒW\ ^]\bWTS$ Q]\\c a]ca ZS \][ RS CWS K << $ l _cWWZ Obb`WPcS ZS [o`WbS R ÑOd]W` RoTW\WbWdS[S\b PObbc S\ P`pQVS ZS [gbVS RS ZObS``Wb]`WOZWbo OPa]ZcS RSa Z]Wa$ [O`_cO\b Ô` Zl Ä c\S obO^S RoQWaWdS RO\a ZÑVWab]W`SRSa R]Qb`W\Sa Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^`WdoÅ& Ä6]\TWaQObW]\$ Sf^`]^`WObW]\ O\RbVS Q]\TZWQb ] T ZOea Å Ro\WS$ S\ aÑO^^cgO\b ac` ZSa Xc`Wa^`cRS\QSa \ObW]\OZSa$ZÑSTTWQOQWbo SfbÒbS``Wb]`WOZS Ocf [Sac`Sa Q]\TZaQOb]W`Sa& ?O ^`]bSQbW]\ ZO ^ZcaORo_cObS RSa ^Sà]\\Sa a^]ZWoSa òaWRS QS^S\RO\b RO\a ZO ^`]bSQbW]\ XcRWQWOW`SW\bS`\ObW]\OZS RSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S& Ä LS`bÒUaOcb]\][WS c\R JW`baQVOTbaUSaSbhUSPc\U W[ W\bS`\ObW]\OZS\ C`WdOb`SQVb Å `SQVS`QVS ZO Z]W Q][ôbS\bS ^]c`RoaWU\S` ZSa `pUZSa R Ñ]`R`S ^cPZWQ oQ]\][W_cS R Ñ]`WUW\S obÒ\Up`S _cW R]WdS\b`SQSd]W` O^^ZWQObW]\ RSdO\b ZS XcUS Rc T]` 1 ^]c` RSa ÒWa]\a RS aoQc`Wbo Xc`WRW_cSSaaS\bWSZZS[S\b$ ZSa ^òTo`S\QSa RS ZÑOcbSc` d]\b l ZO ICU ALKQO?AQRP$ B\ aWU\OZSÒ$S\TW\$ Z ÑobcRS ac` Ä ?Sa OQQ]`Ra S\b`S c\ 8bOb Sb c\S ^Sà]\\S ^`WdoS obÒ\Up`S Å

)-' 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

_cW O\OZgaS ZSa Q]\TZWba RS Z]Wa acaQWboa Ô` QSa Q]\bÒba$ ZSa QZOcaSa R ÑW\bO\UWPWZWboSb ZSa Ocb`Sa [obV]RSa O^bSa l a]cabÒW`S QSa Q]\bÒba Ocf Ä OZoOa Å RS ZO a]cdS%ÒW\Sbo obObW_cS&

EcaS\ 8E:86&

>[ÛZ# ;%$J%# CUSMXPUQ_# 7^% Q` Ea^\# 5%# 'KHBM BGM>KG:MBHG:E IN;EB<

0HM>L >M 'H<NF>GML E[YQ (# 5[OaYQZ`_ PvUZì^k` UZ`Q^ZMÙ[ZMX# >[Z`$îMX# 7MOaXì PQ P^[U` Q` iP% ETiYU_ :ZO%# (0/.# I :I Q` (''- \%

6Sb ]cdÒUS Q]\bWS\b ZSa ^`W\QWÔcf bSfbSa Q]\dS\bW]\\SZa$ W\abWbcbW]\\SZa SbXc`Wa^`cRS\bWSZa _cW a]\b l ZO POaS Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^cPZWQ Q]\bS[^]ÒW\&6ÑSab RW`S ZÑW\bo`qb Sb ZÑcbWZWbo _cS ^òaS\bS c\ bSZ `SQcSWZ ^]c` ZÑW\bS`\ObW]\OZWabS^`]TSaaW]\\SZ "ZÑS\aSWU\O\b$ ZS QVS`QVSc`$ ZS ^ÒbWQWS\# ]c ]QQOaW]\\SZ "ZÑobcRWO\b#&?O ^`S[Wp`S Ô`bWS É Ä GÒWboa Sb ^`]XSba R ÑO`bWQZSa RS bÒWboa Å É `S^`]RcWb$

GK CUQCKPL ]c Ô` SfbÒWba$ dW\Ub%\ScT bSfbSa _cW$ ]cb`S ZSa bSfbSa W\Q]\b]c`\OPZSa"QVO`bS RSa AObW]\a H\WSa$ abObcb RS ZO 6&<&=&$ :4GG$ 6&8&8&$ R`]Wb RSa bÒWboa$R`]Wb RS ZO [S`$ `SZObW]\a RW^Z][ObW_cSa Sb Q]\acZOW`Sa$ O`[Sa \cQZoOW`Sa$ R`]WbaRS Z ÑV][[S$ SbQ&# Q][^`S\R RSa R]Qc[S\ba ^Zca Ò`Sa$ [OWa R]\b Z ÑW\bo`qbUo\oÒZ ]c aôQWTW_cS XcabWTWS ZOÙS[S\b ZSc` ^òaS\QS 1 Q]\dS\bW]\ 6<E7<$^`]XSba RÑO`bWQZSa RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ac` ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWboW\bS`\ObW]\OZS RS Z Ñ8bOb Sb ac` ZSa W[[c\Wboa Xc`WRWQbW]\\SZZSa RSa 8bOba$ Q]\%dS\bW]\ `SZObWdS l Z ÑB&6&7&8&$ Sb S\TW\ É Sb Z Ñ]\ S\ ObbS\ROWb Ôa []W\a R Ñc\]cdÒUS òOZWao Ô` RSa TÒ\Q]^V]\Sa Rc A]cdSOc @]\RS É $ ZO Q]\dS\bW]\`SZObWdS l Z Ñ4US\QS RS Q]]ôÒbW]\ QcZbc`SZZS Sb bSQV\W_cS&?O RScfWp[S Ô`bWS É|Ä 4QbSa RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a Sb Q]\To`S\QSa W\bS`\ObW]%

\OZSa Å É `S^`S\R ZSa ^`W\QWÔZSa òa]ZcbW]\a Sb RoQZOÒbW]\a RSa AObW]\a H\WSa"R`]Wb RS Z ÑV][[S$ òa]ZcbW]\ 4QVSa]\$ RoQ]Z]\WaObW]\$ `SZObW]\a O[WQOZSa$`SZObW]\a oQ]\][W_cSa$ OU`SaaW]\$ `pUZS[S\b RSa RWTTo`S\Ra$ S\dW`]\\S[S\b$ SbQ&#OW\aW _cS RSa SfbÒWba RS Z ÑOQbS TW\OZ R Ñ;SZaW\ZR&?l b`]WaWp[S Ô`bWS É (G4QbSa Xc`WRWQbW]\\SZa Sb _cOaW Xc`WRWQbW]\\SZa W\bS`%

\ObW]\Ocf Å É Q]\bWS\b ZSa ^`W\QWÔcf ÔaaOUSa \]\ aScZS[S\b RS aSWhS UÒ\RaO``qba Sb OdWa RS ZO 6]c` RS ?O ;OgS 3LQRP" /OLCKI?KB LOGCKQ?I" ,YQOLGQ BC 6LODLR"OYM?O?QGLKP" BOLGQ B_?PGIC" SbQ&# [OWa OcaaW RS aS\bS\QSa O`PWbÒZSa "[IC BC 7?IJ?P":CU?AL /?I?PG?QGA!" RÑO``qba `S\Rca l ?cfS[P]cÙ "+LPQ? A$ -$5$-$3$! Sb lFbÒaP]cÙ "9RKB?V :GJCP! Sb É QS _cW Sab Ò`S ÉãRS Ò^^]`ba Rc 6][Wbo RSaR`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S Qòo Ô` ZS COQbS RS (0-- "OTT& )RJCCORBBV#/WGDDO?! Sb Rc6][Wbo RS ZO ZWPS`bo ag\RWQOZS RS Z ÑB&<&G& "OTTOW`S RS ZO ILG J?OQG?IC CK 7LILEKC!$<Z TOcb O^^ZOcRW` c\ Ô`SWZ oQZSQbWa[S Sb a]cZWU\S` S\ [q[S bS[â ZO ^òaS\%

bObW]\ a]WU\oS Sb RWROQbW_cS Rc `SQcSWZ 1 QVO_cS bSfbS Sab ^òQoRo R Ñc\S \]bSW\b`]RcQbWdS Ò^^SZO\b P`WpdS[S\b Z Ñ]PXSb Rc R]Qc[S\b$ ZO RObS RS a]\ OR]^bW]\$aO a]c`QS ]TTWQWSZZS$ Sb aSZ]\ ZSa QOa$ aO RObS R ÑS\bòS S\ dWUcSc`$ aSa Q]\RWbW]\aR ÑOR]^bW]\$ SbQ&6S`bSa$ ZS ZSQbSc` ^Scb b]cX]cà `SU`SbbS`$ Oc Uò RS aSa ^òTo`S\QSa ]c RS aSa

QS\b`Sa R ÑW\bo`qb$ ZÑOPaS\QS RS bSZ bSfbS ]c RS bSZ SfbÒWb$ [OWa QS a]\b RSaZW[WbSa W\Vo`S\bSa Ocf Q]\bÒW\bSa RS QS US\`S R Ñ]cdÒUS& <Z aSÒWb b]cbST]Wa^]aaWPZS RS UOU\S` c\ ^Sc RS ^ZOQS$ Sb R]\Q R ÑOcU[S\bS`$ ^]c` ZS [q[S \][P`SRS ÔUSa$ ZO Ä ac`TOQS cbWZS Å S\ OR]^bO\b c\S ^òaS\bObW]\ RS bg^S Ä Q]RS ÅOdSQ ac^^`SaaW]\ RSa SaÔQSa W\bS`QOZOW`Sa òaS`doa Ocf W\bWbcZoa R ÑO`bWQZSa&8\ ]cb`S$ ]\ ^]c`ÒWb ac^^`W[S` Z ÑOQbS c\W_cS Sc`]ôS\ Sb ZÑOQbS R ÑORVoaW]\RS ZÑ8aÔU\S Sb Rc C]`bcUOZ l ZO 6&8&8& S\ \S Q]\aS`dO\b _cS ZSa RWa^]aWbW]\aZSa ^Zca SaaS\bWSZZSa$ Q ÑSab%l%RW`S$ ZSa RWa^]aWbW]\a []RWTWQObWdSa Rc bÒWbo 6&8&8&$Sb S\ ZSa `S^]`bO\b RW`SQbS[S\b RO\a ZS bÒWbo ZcW%[q[S&6Sa acUUSabW]\a \ ÑOTTSQbS\b QS^S\RO\b Ôa ZSa _cOZWboa RÑc\ `SQcSWZ _cW bO\b

Ô` Z ÑOWaO\QS RS a]\ [O\WS[S\b Sb a]\ ^Sc R ÑS\Q][P`S[S\b _cS Ô` ZÑobS\RcSRSa [ObWp`Sa OP]`RoSa Sab O^^SZo l RSdS\W` ZS Q][ÔU\]\ TWRpZS RS b]cb _cWaÑW\bo`SaaS Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&

8`WQ 74I<7&

6B@CG8F E8A7H F )-(

/NEMBE:MUK:E 4K>:MB>L :ZPQd MZP 4a^^QZ` _`Mà_# ETU^P OaYaXMÙbQ _a\$\XQYQZ`# =[ZP[Z# 3a``Q^c[^`T_# (0/-# ('( \%# Q` 7[a^`T 4aYaXMÙbQDa\\XQYQZ`# ?[`ÙZSTMY# E^QMè 4QZ`Q #̂ (0/.# ()' \%

6Sa b`]WaWp[S Sb _cOb`Wp[S ac^^Zo[S\ba Rc ^òQWScf bÒdOWZ RS òTo`S\QS S\[ObWp`S RS bÒWboa W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf obOPZWa Ô` 5]e[O\ Sb ;O``Wa ZS [Sb l X]c`Xca_cÑOc (S̀ XO\dWS` (0/.& ?Sa ^`S[Wp`Sa Ô`bWSa RS QSa ac^^Zo[S\ba W\b`]%RcWaS\b ZSa \]cdSOcf bÒWboa "Xca_cÑOc \z /0*# bO\RWa _cS ZSa aSQ]\RSa Ô`bWSaW\T]`[S\b ac` ZSa QVO\US[S\ba W\bS`dS\ca Ocf bÒWboa RoXl ò^S`b]`Woa&B\ \S ^]c`ÒWb b`]^ W\aWabS` ac` ZÑW\bo`qb odWRS\b RS QSa W\RSf$ RS Q]\acZbObW]\

b`pa OWaoS Sb _cW ^S`[SbbS\b R Ñ]PbS\W` Ò^WRS[S\b RSa W\T]`[ObW]\a a]ZWRSa Sb`SZObWdS[S\b l X]c` ac` ^`pa RS 0'' bÒWboa [cZbWZOboÒcf&

7S\WaS @4G;L&

C 4 H $ 8U[bMZZU# .> =KHBM BGM>KG> =:GL E[HK=K> BGM>KG:MBHG:E# ;[bQZQ# ?M\XQ_#(0/,# .' \MSQ_%

6Sb ]^caQcZS ZWd`S RSa òTZSfW]\a ac` ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\S$ R ÑOP]`R Q]\aWRoò Q][[ST]\RS[S\b Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ S\ Ô`bWQcZWS` _cO\b Ocf acXSba RS ZO Q][%[c\Ocbo W\bS`\ObW]\OZS&?S RScfWp[S QVO^Wb`S obcRWS Z ÑW\TZcS\QS Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\S RO\a ZÑod]ZcbW]\

Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ ZSa ^`W\QW^Sa Uo\oÒcf Sb Z ÑOaaW[WZObW]\ RS `pUZSa RS R`]Wb^`Wdo Ô` ZO Q]cbc[S Sb ZSa bÒWboa&8\TW\$ Z ÑOcbSc` aÑObbOQVS l Z ÑVO`[]\WaObW]\ RSa ZoUWaZObW]\a W\bS`\Sa S\ [ObWp`S

RS \ObW]\OZWbo$ RS `SQ]\\OWaaO\QS Sb R ÑSfoQcbW]\ RSa XcUS[S\ba$ RS ZWPS`boaT]\RO[S\bOZSa Sb RS abObcb RSa obÒ\USà&

6 :2F49# 6XYM^# 4A> 1KHMH<HE $==BMBHG:E MH MA> *>G>K:E &HGO>GMBHGL ?HK MA>

1KHM><MBHG H? 6B<MBFL H? ,GM>KG:MBHG:E &HG?EB<ML :G= MA> 5GBM>= 0:MBHGL

&HGO>GMBHGL HG MA> .:P H? MA> 3>: # 2>I>KFBLLBHGL HG MA> .:P H? 0:O:E

7:K?:K> 5aZOWQ^ 9aYN[X`# 3Q^XUZ$>oZOTQZ# (0/+# (-, \MSQ_%

?Sa RoQZOÒbW]\a RS CO`Wa "(/-,# Sb RS ?]\R`Sa "(0'0#$ ZSa Q]\dS\bW]\a RS?O ;OgS "(0'.# ]\b Q]RWTWo ZS R`]Wb RS ZO UcS``S \OdOZS l c\S o^]_cS ]w ZSaO`[Sa Sb ZO \OdWUObW]\ obOWS\b oZ]WU\oSa RS ZSc` abORS OQbcSZ R Ñod]ZcbW]\& ?S^`]b]Q]ZS RS (0*- `SZObWT l ZO UcS``S a]ca%[O`W\S O obo Tò_cS[[S\b dW]Zo^S\RO\b ZS aSQ]\R Q]\TZWb []\RWOZ&? ÑOcbSc` RS QS Ò^^]`b$ aSQòbOW`S Uo\oÒZ ORX]W\b RS ZO F]QWobo W\bS`\ObW]\OZS

^]c` ZS R`]Wb [WZWbOW`S Sb ZS R`]Wb RS ZO UcS``S$ Q]\abObS QS QVO]a Sb aWbcS ZS R`]WbRS ZO UcS``S \OdOZS l ZO Q`]WaoS Rc R`]Wb Vc[O\WbOW`S$ ^òQWaO\b \]bO[[S\bZS abObcb RSa []cdS[S\ba RS ZWPoÒbW]\$ RSa `S^òaOWZZSa&&&$ Sb Rc R`]Wb RS ZO [S`_cW aS Ò^^]`bS ^Zcbub Ocf RWTTo`S\bSa h]\Sa R Ñ]ôÒbW]\&

2><N>BE =>L <HNKL => 6$<:=UFB> => =KHBM BGM>KG:MBHG:E (0/-#( h :G# `[YQ_ (0-h (00# ?UVT[RR# 5[^P^QOT`# +''# +(0# +'' Q` ,)' \MSQ_%

7O\a a]\ Q]cà Uo\oÒZ RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^`Wdo$ ZS C`]TSaaSc` COcZ?OUO`RS O\OZgaS ZS ^`W\QW^S RS Q]\\SfWbo ÒbbOQVO\b c\S aWbcObW]\ l ZÑ]`R`SXc`WRW_cS Sb l ZÑOcb]`Wbo OdSQ ZSa_cSZa SZZS ^òaS\bS ZSa ZWS\a ZSa ^Zca ob`]Wba&6SbbS a]ZcbW]\ a]c^ZS$ [OWa [S\O\b Ô`T]Wa l RSa a]ZcbW]\a ^Sc ^òdWaWPZSa$aÑO^^ZW_cS RS ^Zca S\ ^Zca$ ^`W\QWÔZS[S\b Ocf Q]\bÒba Sb Ocf òUW[Sa [Ob`W%[]\WOcf$ acPaWRWOW`S[S\b Ocf _cOaW%RoZWba$ S\ bO\b _cÑoZo[S\b Q]``SQbSc` OcabObcb ^Sà]\\SZ& <Z Q]\QZcb l ZO [cZbW^ZWQWbo RSa T]\RS[S\ba Rc R`]Wb W\bS`%\ObW]\OZ ^`Wdo Sb [S\bW]\\S l QS bWb`S ZO a]cdSÒW\Sbo$ ZO Q]c`b]WaWS W\bS`\ObW]\OZSSb ZS a]cQW RS RobS`[W\S` ZSa W\abO\QSa ZSa ^Zca ^`]QVSa ]c ZSa ^Zca ORo_cObSa"b][S (0-$ ^^& 0 l )*/#&

)-) 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

?S ^`]TSaaSc` CO]Z] CWQ]\S _cW S\aSWU\S ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ Ocf H\WdSàWboaRS AO^ZSa Sb 5O`W aÑObbOQVS oUOZS[S\b l c\S OZbS`\ObWdS T]\RO[S\bOZS 1 S\b`SZSa [obV]RSa Vo`WboSa RS FOdWU\g É Q]\TZWba RS Xc`WRWQbW]\$ RS Z]Wa RO\a Z Ñ]^bW_cSPWZOboÒZS$ `SQ]\\OWaaO\QS É Sb c\S bVo]`WS W\a^WòS RS IO\ 5O`$ aS òToÒ\b lZ Ñ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS Q][ôbS\b& <Z aÑOUWb RS RobS`[W\S` S\ PZ]Q ZS agabp[S RO\aZS_cSZ c\ TOWb a]QWOZ ^Scb qb`S dOZOPZS[S\b Qòo ]c `SQ]\\c& ? ÑOcbSc` _cW SfO[W\SZSa _cSabW]\a ^òOZOPZSa RO\a QSbbS ^Sà^SQbWdS QWbS RSa SfS[^ZSa bWòa RSaZoUWaZObW]\a US`[O\W_cSa Sb RS FcpRS "b][S (0.$ ^^& ))0 l *+'#&@& 4& ?& 7WO[]\R$ RW`SQbSc` RS Z Ñ<\abWbcbS ] T 4RdO\QSR ?oUOZ FbcRWSa RS

?]\R`Sa$ ÔaaS S\ `SdcS ZSa STT]`ba R ÑVO`[]\WaObW]\ RSa R`]Wba [Obo`WSZa Sb RcR`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^`Wdo RO\a ZS R][OW\S RSa Q]\bÒba& <Z `SZpdS ZSa a]ZcbW]\a Q]c%Ò\bSa 1 Ocb]\][WS RS ZO d]Z]\bo$ a]ca òaS`dS RSa Z]Wa RS ^]ZWQS$ RS ZO ^`]bSQbW]\RSa Q]\a][[ObScà Sb RSa bÒdOWZZScà$ Z]W RS ZO ^`SabObW]\ QOÒQbo`WabW_cS S\^`W\QW^S S\ QOa RS aWZS\QS RSa Ô`bWSa "b][S (00$ ^^& )** l *()#&@& F]ZbgaW\aYW$ C`]TSaaSc` l Z ÑH\WdSàWbo @WQYWSeWQh RS C]h\O\$ ^òQ]\WaS$

S\ ÒWa]\ RS Z ÑObbWbcRS RSa Sf^]`bObScà RS bSQV\]Z]UWS$ ZS `SQ]cà Ocf W\abO\QSaO`PWbÒZSa RS Z ÑH&A&6&G&4&7& Sb Z ÑO^^ZWQObW]\ RS ZO Z]W RoaWU\oS Ô` ZSa Ô`bWSaaOcT aW QS QV]Wf ^]`bS ObbSW\bS l Z Ñ]`R`S ^cPZWQ W\bS`\ObW]\OZ "b][S (0-$ ^^& )*0%*/+#&?S C`]TSaaSc` COZa]\\$ RS Z ÑH\WdSàWbo RS ?c\R$ ^òaS\bS ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ

^`Wdo RS ZO TO[WZZS$ S\ Ô`bWQcZWS` ZO ÔbS`\Wbo$ ZSa ]PZWUObW]\a OZW[S\bOW`Sa Sb ZSaòUW[Sa [Ob`W[]\WOcf "b][S (00$ ^^& *(* l +(+#&8[W\S\b Xc`WabS PòaWZWS\$ @& C& 9& EShSY ]TT`S c\ O^S`nc b`pa Q][^ZSb RSa

_cSabW]\a `SZObWdSa l ZO \ObW]\OZWbo 1 \]bW]\$ ^`W\QW^S R ÑSTTSQbWdWbo$ Q]\dS\bW]\aSb acPabÒb ^]ZWbW_cS& H Q]\QZcb S\ Q]\abObO\b _cS ZO \ObW]\OZWbo$ RW[S\aW]\^Sà]\\SZZS RSa 8bOba$ Sab c\S W\abWbcbW]\ OcaaW a]ZWRS _cS ZSc` a]cdSÒW\Sbo"b][S (0/$ ^^& *** l +''#&?S C`]TSaaSc` FSWRZ%;]VS\dSZRS[$ bWbcZOW`S Rc Q]cà RS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ

^cPZWQ$ Sf^]aS [obV]RW_cS[S\b ZS R`]Wb oQ]\][W_cS W\bS`\ObW]\OZ& ?S ^ZO\acWdW Sab bÒRWbW]\\SZ 1 RoTW\WbW]\$ acXSb$ ZSa a]c`QSa$ ZSa 8bOba$ ZSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a$ZSa R`]Wba Sb ZSa ]PZWUObW]\a RSa 8bOba$ ZO aWbcObW]\ RSa Ô`bWQcZWSà$ ZSa RWTTo`S\Ra&ESZSd]\a _cSZ_cSa ^`WaSa RS ^]aWbW]\ RO\a RSa Q]\b`]dSàSa OQbcSZZSa 1 \Obc`SXc`WRW_cS RSa òa]ZcbW]\a RS Z Ñ4aaS[PZoS Uo\oÒZS "^^& -( Sb a&#$ RSa OQQ]`RaS\b`S 8bOba Sb W\dSabWaaScà obÒ\USà "^^& .( Sb a&#$ ZSa \ObW]\OZWaObW]\a "^^& (.(Sb a&#$ ZO UcS``S oQ]\][W_cS "^^& )'' Sb a&# "b][S (0/$ ^^& 0 l )-+#&?S C`]TSaaSc` 4\O\R$ RS Z ÑH\WdSàWbo =OeOVO`VOZ RS 7SZVW$ O Ô`Zo RS Z ÑoUOZWbo

a]cdSÒW\S RSa 8bOba RO\a ZÑVWab]W`S Sb ZÑOQbcOZWbo$ aÑO``qbO\b \]bO[[S\b Ocf^`]PZp[Sa RS [WQ`]%8bOba$ RS ZSc` dcZ\oÒPWZWbo Sb RS ZSc` Ô`bWQWÔbW]\ lZ ÑB&A&H& ? ÑOcbSc` SabW[S _cS Z ÑoUOZWbo a]cdSÒW\S Sab c\ WRoOZ W`òOZWaOPZS 1S\b`S ZSa 8bOba W\bS`Ro^S\RO\ba S\ TOWb `pU\S ZO Z]W Rc ^Zca T]`b "b][S (0.$ ^^& 0l ))/#&@& FOV]dWQ$ RW`SQbSc` RS Z ÑW\abWbcb RS ^]ZWbW_cS Sb R ÑoQ]\][WS W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa

RS 5SZUÒRS$ W\b`]RcWb Oc ùZS RSa TOQbScà [Obo`WSZa$ Q][[S ZSa ^`]U`pa bSQV%\W_cSa$ Sb T]`[SZa É ZSa ab`cQbc`Sa RS QòObW]\ Sb R ÑO^^ZWQObW]\ RSa \]`[Sa ÉRO\a ZO T]`[ObW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ "b][S (00$ ^^& (.( l )*)#&@[S :OZS\aYOXO$ C`]TSaaSc` l ?S\W\UÒR$ bÒWbS RS ZO Q]]ôÒbW]\ QcZbc`SZZS

W\bSòbObW_cS Ô` Q]\dS\bW]\a ]c Oc bÒdSà R Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\a$ S\ ô`W]RS RS ÔWfSb RS UcS``S& F]\b OP]`RoSa 1 ZO \]bW]\ RS Ôb`W[]W\S Q][[c\ RS ZÑVc[O\Wbo$ZSa `pUZSa W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa Sb ZSa ZoUWaZObW]\a$ \]bO[[S\b S\ [ObWp`S RS T]cWZZSaO`QVo]Z]UW_cSa ]c RS ^òdS\bW]\ Rc ^WZZOUS RSa `WQVSaaSa QcZbc`SZZSa "b][S (0.$^^& )-, l **(#&?Sa aôQWOZWabSa Rc R`]Wb RS ZO [S` ZW`]\b OdSQ W\bo`qb ZSa Q]cà Rc =cUS 8dS\aS\

`SbÒnO\b ZO b`]WaWp[S 6]\To`S\QS ac` ZS R`]Wb RS ZO [S` "b][S (0,$ ^^& +(, l ,)'#Sb Rc ^`]TSaaSc` QVWZWS\ B``SU]%IWQc\O ac` ZO \Obc`S Xc`WRW_cS Sb ZS òUW[S RSaOQbWdWboa RO\a ZO h]\S oQ]\][W_cS SfQZcaWdS "b][S (00$ ^^& 0 l (.'#&C]c` bS`[W\S` QS P`ST Q][^bS `S\Rc RS ZO aSaaW]\ (0/-$ Ocf W\bo`qba dO`Woa

Sb Ocf Ô`bWQWÔ\ba dS\ca RÑV]`Wh]\a RWdSà$ [S\bW]\\]\a ZO Q]\To`S\QS R]\\oSÔ` @& 6OZRSÒ$ O\QWS\ CòaWRS\b Rc IS\ShcSZO Sb ^]`bO\b ac` ZSa T]\RS[S\baXc`WRW_cSa Rc A]cdSZ B`R`S 8Q]\][W_cS <\bS`\ObW]\OZ "b][S (0-$ ^^& */,%+''#&


6B@CG8F E8A7H F )-*

E B 7 ? 8 L $ 0B@>E 4A> 4K>:MF>GM H? 1KBLHG>KL NG=>K ,GM>KG:MBHG:E .:P @dR[^P#4XM^QZP[Z A^Q__ Q` AMÛ_# F?6D4@# (0/.# I I :: Q` *.+ \%

6Sb ]cdÒUS Sab c\ do`WbOPZS Sf^]ao RSa R`]Wba RSa ^Sà]\\Sa O``qboSa SbRobS\cSa Q]\b`S b]cbSa ZSa T]`[Sa R ÑOPca Ocf_cSZZSa SZZSa `Wa_cS\b R Ñqb`S a]c%[WaSa& F]\b OW\aW Ôaaoa S\ `SdcS ZSa ^`]PZp[Sa `SZObWTa l ZO ZoUOZWbo "]c l ZÑWZZo%UOZWbo$ Q][[S ]\ d]cRÒ&&&#$ RS ZO b]`bc`S$ RSa SfoQcbW]\a SfbÒXcRWQWOW`Sa$ RSZO ^SW\S RS []`b$ RSa RWaÔ`WbW]\a$ RSa Q]\RWbW]\a RS RobS\bW]\$ RSa ^c\WbW]\aQ]`^]`SZZSa Sb RSa O``SabObW]\a O`PWbÒW`Sa&C]c` QVOQc\ RS QSa ^]W\ba$ Z ÑOcbSc` SfO[W\S Z ÑS\aS[PZS RSa W\ab`c[S\ba W\bS`%

\ObW]\Ocf òUWaaO\b ZO [ObWp`S$ _cÑWZa a]WS\b c\WdSàSZa ]c òUW]\Ocf$ Q]\dS\%bW]\\SZa ]c W\abWbcbW]\\SZa$ SfWabO\ba ]c S\ ^`]XSb$ O^^ZWQOPZSa S\ bS[â RSUcS``S ]c S\ bS[â RS ÔWf$ Sb WZ O^^]`bS RSa Q]\QZcaW]\a TS`[Sa$ [OWa \cO\QoSa$Sb aS`dWSa Ô` c\S UÒ\RS o`cRWbW]\ "@& E]RZSg Sab ZS Q]\aSWZZS` Xc`WRW_cS RÑ4[%\Sabg <\bS`\ObW]\OZ # ac` Z ÑobOb OQbcSZ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ&CO`[W ZSa _cSabW]\a O\OZgaoSa$ \]ca Od]\a `SZSdo ZS ^`]PZp[S RS ZO Xc`WRWQWbo

R ÑW\ab`c[S\ba bSZa _cS ZO 7oQZOÒbW]\ c\WdSàSZZS RSa R`]Wba RS ZÑV][[S ]cZ Ñ8\aS[PZS RSa `pUZSa [W\W[O ^]c` ZS bÒWbS[S\b RSa RobS\ca$ _cS Z ÑOcbSc`\ ÑOaaW[WZS Ôa l RS aW[^ZSa dÇcf ^WScf$ [OWa Q]\aWRp`S Q][[S ^]`bScà RS\]`[Sa R]\b QS`bOW\Sa a]\b acaQS^bWPZSa RS IGCO Z ÑS\aS[PZS RSa 8bOba l bWb`S RS`pUZSa Q]cbc[Wp`Sa ]c W\bS`^òbObWdSa "^^& -* aa&$ ^^& ))( aa&#& A]ca Ô`bOUS]\aQSbbS ]^W\W]\ b]cb Q][[S ZÑWRoS _cS ZS R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^]aWbWT MCOJCQ l b]cb8bOb R ÑSfS`QS` c\S Q][ôbS\QS c\WdSàSZZS ac` ZSa OcbScà R ÑOQbSa RS b]`bc`S"^^& ('. Sb (,-#$ Sb _cS RS bSZa OQbSa `SabS\b W\XcabWTWOPZSa "^^& .+%./#&A]ca Od]\a oUOZS[S\b O^^òQWo ZO RWaQcaaW]\ RSa OTTOW`Sa )PQGW Sb .GI?OQGE?

"^^& (') aa&# b]cb S\ `SU`SbbO\b _cS Z ÑOcbSc` \ ÑOWb Ôa OP]`Ro RS T`]\b ZO _cSabW]\RS aOd]W` aW ZSa `pUZSa `SZObWdSa Ocf R`]Wba RS ZÑV][[S Sb l Z ÑW\Q`W[W\ObW]\ RSQS`bOW\Sa RS ZScà dW]ZObW]\a L@IGEC?GCKQ BGOCAQCJCKQ ZSa ^Sà]\\Sa MOGSYCP$7][[OUS OcaaW ^]c` ZÑOPaS\QS RS PWPZW]UÒ^VWS$ [OWa$ PÒd] ^]c` ZO `S^`]%

RcQbW]\$ ac` _cSZ_cS a]WfO\bS ÔUSa R ÑO\\SfSa$ RSa ^`W\QWÔZSa RWa^]aWbW]\aZoUOZSa W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa O^^ZWQOPZSa l ZO [ObWp`S&8\ òac[o$ ]\ ]PaS`dSÒ _cÑS\ TOWaO\b ZS ^]W\b RSa `pUZSa O^^ZWQOPZSa Ocf

dW]ZObW]\a RSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S ZSa ^Zca \][P`ScaSa Sb ZSa ^Zca oV]\boSa _cW aS^`]RcWaS\b _c]bWRWS\\S[S\b RO\a ZS []\RS$ QSb ]cdÒUS [o`WbS RS TWUc`S` RO\aZO PWPZW]bVp_cS RS b]cb Xc`WabS$ Sb [q[S RS b]cb W\RWdWRc Q]\aQWS\b ]c aS ^ò%bS\RO\b bSZ&&& <Z ZS ^Scb R ÑOcbO\b ^Zca _cÑWZ òcaaWb ZO UOUSc`S R Ñqb`S aOdO\b b]cbS\ `SabO\b QZOW` Sb RWROQbW_cS&

8`WQ 74I<7&

F<A 6 ? 4 <E $ :MZ !DU^"# 4A> ,GM>KG:MBHG:E .:P &HFFBLLBHG 4MYNÛPSQ# 8^[Ùa_AaNXUOMÙ[Z_# (0/.# (.. \%

H\S \]cdSZZS obcRS ac` ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ QSb ]ÙO\S RSaAObW]\a H\WSa _cW Q]\b`WPcS Oc RodSZ]^^S[S\b ^`]U`SaaWT Sb l ZO Q]RWTWQObW]\Rc R`]Wb \S ^Scb ZOWaaS` W\RWTTo`S\b ZS []\RS OQORo[W_cS Sb obcRWO\b RS R`]WbW\bS`\ObW]\OZ&? Ñ]cdÒUS ^òaS\bo WQW Sab Z ÑÇcd`S R Ñc\ O\QWS\ [S[P`S RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc

R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ _cW Qc[cZS OcaaW ZSa Q]\\OWaaO\QSa R Ñc\ ^ÒbWQWS\ Rc R`]WbW\bS`\ObW]\OZ Sb R Ñc\ OcbSc`&4^`pa Od]W` Ò^^SZo P`WpdS[S\b ZÑVWab]`W_cS RSa Q]RWTWQObW]\a Rc R`]Wb W\bS`%

\ObW]\OZ Sb RS ZO Q]\abWbcbW]\ RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ$ Z ÑOcbScòbcRWS ZSa [obV]RSa RS bÒdOWZ RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\$ aSa []RSa RS `SQ`cbS[S\b$ZSa QV]Wf RS acXSb& <Z Q]\aOQ`S S\acWbS aSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba l ZÑobcRS RS ZÑS\aS[PZSRSa bÒdOcf òOZWaoa Xca_cÑS\ (0/- _cÑWZa OWS\b ]c \]\ OP]cbW l c\S Q]\dS\bW]\RS Q]RWTWQObW]\&?O ZSQbc`S RS QS bÒdOWZ RS ag\bVpaS ^S`[Sb c\S SfQSZZS\bS dcS R ÑS\aS[PZS RS

ZÑÇcd`S OQQ][^ZWS Ô` ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RS^cWa (0+0& FW RSa^`]PZp[Sa RS T]\QbW]\\S[S\b a]\b [Wa S\ `SZWST$ WZ \ ÑS\ `SabS Ôa []W\a _cS ZSùZS RS ZO 6][[WaaW]\ Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^]c` ZS RodSZ]^^S[S\b Rc R`]WbW\bS`\ObW]\OZ `SabS [OXSc` Sb \ ÑSab Ôa ^`pa RS aÑobSW\R`S&

)-+ 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

G]cb ZS []\RS OQORo[W_cS Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ aSÒ Ô`TOWbS[S\b `SQgQZoÔ` ZO ZSQbc`S RS QS ZWd`S&

7S\WaS @4G;L&

F B@ 88F $ 6PPe# ,GE>B=BG@ MHM A>M BGM>KG:MBHG::E S>>K><AM <XacQ^ ^QOT`_$cQ`QZ_OTM\\QZ# 2Z`cQ^\QZ# (0/+# ++) \MSQ_%

I]WQW c\S W\b`]RcQbW]\ Oc R`]Wb RS ZO [S` QZOW`S Sb PWS\ R]Qc[S\boS$ acTTWaO[%[S\b ^òQWaS ^]c` aÑOR`SaaS` \]\ aScZS[S\b l b]ca QScf _cW aÑW\bo`SaaS\b OcòUW[S Xc`WRW_cS RS ZO [S` [OWa OcaaW Oc ^ÒbWQWS\&HbWZS OcaaW ^]c` QScf _cW a]cVOWbS\b cbWZWaS` c\ ]cdÒUS S\ \oS`ZO\ROWa&@OZUò ZS QOÒQbp`S Ô`T]Wa O`Rc RS ZO [ObWp`S$ ZO ^òaS\bObW]\ Rc bSfbS ZS

`S\R OUòOPZS l ZW`S& ?O US\paS RS QVO_cS \]bW]\ Rc R`]Wb RS ZO [S` Sab Sf^ZW_coSS\ []\bÒ\b ZSa RWTTWQcZboa `S\Q]\bòSa l QVO_cS obO^S RS a]\ RodSZ]^^S[S\b&? ÑOcbSc` OR]^bS ZS aQVo[O bÒRWbW]\\SZ RS Z ÑSfO[S\$ QVO^Wb`S Ô` QVO^Wb`S$

RSa RWdSàSa h]\Sa [O`WbW[Sa 1 SOcf W\bo`WSc`Sa$ [S` bS``Wb]`WOZS$ h]\Sa [O`WbW[SaÄ T]\QbW]\\SZZSa Å "h]\S oQ]\][W_cS SfQZcaWdS$ h]\S RS ^qQVS$ h]\S Q]\bWUcr#$^ZObSOc Q]\bW\S\bOZ$ T]\Ra [O`W\a$ VOcbS [S`$ d]WSa [O`WbW[Sa W\bS`\ObW]\OZSaSb QO\Ocf W\bS`\ObW]\Ocf&?Sa RScf RS`\WSà QVO^Wb`Sa a]\b Q]\aOQòa `Sa^SQbWdS[S\b l Zl ^]ZZcbW]\ S\

[S` Sb l ZO `SQVS`QVS aQWS\bWTW_cS Sb Oc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZ RSa ^qQVS`WSa& 6SaR][OW\Sa$ a]\b S\ ^ZSW\ RodSZ]^^S[S\b Sb ZSc` W[^]`bO\QS aÑOQQ`]sb& 4 bWb`SR ÑSfS[^ZS$ ZS òUW[S Xc`WRW_cS RS ZO ^qQVS aÑSab Q]\aWRoÒPZS[S\b RodSZ]^ôacWbS l ZO Uo\oÒZWaObW]\ RSa h]\Sa RS ^qQVS \ObW]\OZSa Xca_cÑl )'' [WZZSa "a]cdS\bRO\a ZS QOR`S RSa h]\Sa oQ]\][W_cSa SfQZcaWdSa#$ l Z ÑoZOP]ÒbW]\ RS \][P`ScaSa[Sac`Sa RS Q]\aS`dObW]\ Sb RS USabW]\ RSa `Saa]c`QSa VOZWScbW_cSa S\bÒs\O\bZO \oQSaaWbo RS [Sbb`S ac` ^WSR RSa agabp[Sa RS Q]\bùZS& 6S RodSZ]^^S[S\baS aWbcS bO\b ac` ZS ^ZO\ \ObW]\OZ "ZoUWaZObW]\a W\bS`\Sa# _cÑW\bS`\ObW]\OZ "OQQ]`RaRS ^qQVS$ òUZS[S\bObW]\ RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a òUW]\OZSa RS ^qQVS#&

CVWZW^^S J<??48EG&

I 8 ? H $ ;MO]aQ_# 'KHBM IN;EB< 3âdQXXQ_# 3âeXMZ`# `% :Q̂ # //+ \%# MbQO XM\îRMOQ PQ H%$;% 8MZ_T[R bMZ PQ^ >QQ^_OT%

? Ñ]cdÒUS _cS ZS ^`]TSaaSc` ISZc dWS\b RS ^cPZWS` a]ca ZS bWb`S RS Ä 7`]Wb^cPZWQ Å Q]\abWbcS aO\a Q]\bSabS Ä c\ odo\S[S\b RO\a ZO dWS ^cPZW_cS PSZUS Å^]c` `S^`S\R`S ZSa ^`]^]a Rc ^`]TSaaSc` :O\aV]T dO\ RS` @SSàQV& ?O []RSabWSRS Z ÑOcbSc` aSÒ ^S`ncS R ÑS[PZoS S\ TScWZZSbO\b QSbbS dOabS T`Sa_cS _cW Sxb Rx[o`WbS` ZS ZWPSZZo RS Ä bÒWbo Å&CS\RO\b RS Z]\UcSa O\\oSa$ ZS ^`]TSaaSc` ISZc O [O`_co Z ÑS\aSWU\S[S\b Rc

R`]Wb ^cPZWQ l Z ÑH\WdSàWbo RS 5`cfSZZSa& FO _cOZWbo R ÑOd]QOb Uo\oÒZ l ZO 6]c`RS QOaaObW]\ Sf^ZW_cS Z ÑO^^]`b Sfb`q[S[S\b `WQVS RS ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS l QSbS\aSWU\S[S\b& B\ aOWb _cS ZSa Q]\QZcaW]\a RS Z ÑOcbSc` ]\b W\a^Wò [OW\ba O``qba$\]bO[[S\b RO\a ZS R][OW\S RSa R`]Wba RS ZÑV][[S$ RS ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWbo QWdWZSRS ZO ^cWaaO\QS ^cPZW_cS$ RS ZO òT]`[S RS Z Ñ8bOb$ O``qba _cW Q]\abWbcS\b RSaXOZ]\a W[^]`bO\ba RO\a Z Ñod]ZcbW]\ Rc R`]Wb ^cPZWQ PSZUS& ?Sa W\bS`\ObW]\OZWabSaQ]\\OWaaS\b Z ÑOcbSc` ac`b]cb Ô` aSa obcRSa OcaaW \][P`ScaSa _cS ^òQWScaSaac` ZO 6]\dS\bW]\ Sc`]ôS\\S RSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S&6][[S ZS ^`]TSaaSc` ISZc Z ÑoQ`Wb ZcW%[q[S RO\a a]\ OdO\b%^`]^]a$ Ä ZO ^ò%

QWScaS Q]ZZOP]ÒbW]\ Å RS RScf RS aSa Q]ZZpUcSa$ @@& DcS`bOW\[]\b Sb ?S`]g$ZcW O ^S`[Wa RS [S\S` l bS`[S ZS b][S ^`S[WS` RS ZÑ]cdÒUS _cW aSÒ PWS\bubacWdW RS RScf Ocb`Sa b][Sa OcaaW d]Zc[W\Scf$ b]cX]cà OdSQ ZO Q]ZZOP]ÒbW]\RS aSa Q]ZZpUcSa& 6Scf%QW$ ]cb`S _cÑWZa a]WS\b RSa ^ÒbWQWS\a OdS`bWa Oc^`pa RSVOcbSa Xc`WRWQbW]\a$ a]\b bWbcZOW`Sa RS QVOW`Sa RS R`]Wb ^cPZWQ Sb RS R`]Wb OR[W\Wa%bÒbWT&(6ÑSab RW`S aW Z Ñ]cdÒUS `S^]aS ac` c\S Ro[O`QVS Ocabp`S$ ]w ZO ^òQWaW]\ Sb ZO`WUcSc` d]\b RS ÔW` OdSQ ZO \cO\QS Sb ZO ^`cRS\QS RO\a ZSa òTZSfW]\a& ?O

6B@CG8F E8A7H F )-,

RWaQòbW]\ RO\a ZSa ^`]^]a \S ^`]QpRS Ôa R Ñc\S O^^`]QVS bW[]òS Q][[SRÑOcQc\a aSÒWS\b bS\boa RS ZS Q`]W`S& 8ZZS Sab RWQboS Ô` ZÑObbOQVS[S\b RS Z ÑOcbScÒcf Q]\bÒW\bSa _cS ZcW W[^]aS a]\ abObcb RS VOcb [OUWabÒb acaQS^bWPZS RÑqb`SO^^SZo l aS ^`]\]\QS` ac` RSa _cSabW]\a RS R`]Wb ^cPZWQ _cW b]cQVS\b Ocf Oa^SQbaT]\RO[S\bOcf RS ZO dWS obObW_cS& @OZUò QS PCID#OCPQO?GKQ" c\S ZSQbc`S ObbS\bWdSRS ZÑ]cdÒUS ^S`[Sb RS RoQ]cd`W` S\ TWZWUÒ\S$ l bÒdSà Z ÑSf^]ao Q][^ZSb RSaRWdSàSa bVpaSa S\ ^òaS\QS$ ZSa ]^bW]\a aQWS\bWTW_cSa RS ZÑOcbSc`$ OW\aW _cÑS\ObbSabS ZO Ô`bWS ac` ZS Q]\bùZS RS ZO Q]\abWbcbW]\\OZWbo RSa Z]Wa& 7 ÑOcb`Sa Ô`bWSaRS ZÑ]cdÒUS Q]\bWS\\S\b RSa ^`WaSa RS ^]aWbW]\ Sf^ZWQWbSa ac` RSa _cSabW]\aSaaS\bWSZZSa$ Q][[S ]\ ZS []\b`SÒ QW%RSaa]ca&?O [obV]RS `WU]c`ScaS[S\b aQWS\bWTW_cS RS Z ÑOcbSc` Sab obOgoS Ô` c\S

PWPZW]UÒ^VWS R Ñc\S OP]\RO\QS W[^`SaaW]\\O\bS$ Ô` RSa òTo`S\QSa \][P`ScaSal ZO R]Qb`W\S$ Sb l ZO ^ÒbW_cS Xc`WRWQbW]\\SZZS$ ZoUWaZObWdS Sb OR[W\WabÒbWdS&DcO\b l Z Ñ]PXSb Rc bÒWbo$ WZ `SQ]cd`S$ ]cb`S ZS R`]Wb Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZ$ ZÑobcRS

RSa ^`W\QW^Sa RS POaS Rc R`]Wb OR[W\WabÒbWT OW\aW _cS RSa ZWPS`boa ^cPZW_cSa&4 Qubo RSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba Q]\aOQòa Ocf W\abWbcbW]\a ^]ZWbW_cSa$ ]\ b`]cdSOW\aW RSa Sf^]aoa ac` ZS aS`dWQS ^cPZWQ "b][S < S #̀$ ac` ZSa W\abWbcbW]\a XcRWQWOW`SaSb ZS 6]\aSWZ R Ñ8bOb$ ac` ZSa ^`W\QWÔZSa W\abWbcbW]\a OR[W\WabÒbWdSa$ bSZZSa ZSaQ][[c\Sa Sb ZSa ^`]dW\QSa "b][S <<#& ?S b][S <<< Q]\bWS\RÒ Z ÑobcRS RSa R`]WbaSb ZWPS`boa T]\RO[S\bOcf ]w Z ÑO\OZgaS RSa RWa^]aWbW]\a Rc R`]Wb \ObW]\OZ aÑOQ%Q][ÔU\SÒ Rc Q][[S\bOW`S RSa RWa^]aWbW]\a Q]``Sa^]\RO\bSa RSa W\ab`c[S\baW\bS`\ObW]\Ocf ac` ZSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S OdSQ c\S ^ZOQS ^`WdWZoUWoS òaS`doS lZO 6]\dS\bW]\ Sc`]ôS\\S RSa R`]Wba RS Z ÑV][[S&?Sa W\bS`\ObW]\OZWabSa aS òX]cW`]\b RS Q]\abObS` _cS ZS ^`]TSaaSc` ISZc \o

\oUZWUS \cZZS[S\b ZS R`]Wb Q][Ôò QVO_cS T]Wa _cS ZS PSa]W\ aÑS\ TOWb aS\bW`Sb _cÑWZ O^^òQWS l aO XcabS dOZSc` ZO ô\obÒbW]\ Q`]WaaO\bS Rc R`]Wb W\bS`\ObW]\OZRO\a ZÑ]`R`S Xc`WRW_cS W\bS`\S$ aW\UcZWp`S[S\b RO\a ZS R][OW\S RSa ZWPS`boa&6SZO obO\b$ ZS bÒWbo RS @& ISZc Sab$ OdO\b b]cb$ Q]\aOQò Oc R`]Wb ^cPZWQ RS

ZO 5SZUW_cS& ?O 6]\abWbcbW]\ PSZUS RS (/*( OdOWb oRWTWo c\ 8bOb c\WbOW`S OdSQc\ òUW[S RS []\O`QVWS Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZZS Sb Ô`ZS[S\bOW`S& B\ ZS aOWb$ QSbbSQ]\abWbcbW]\$ `S\TS`[O\b c\S RoQZOÒbW]\ Q]\Q`pbS RS R`]Wba$ W\a^WÒ [OW\baQ]\abWbcO\ba Rc K <K S aWpQZS& 7S^cWa Z]à$ SZZS O TOWb ZÑ]PXSb R Ñc\S ao`WS RÑO[S\RS%[S\ba _cW ]\b ^`]T]\Ro[S\b []RWTWo ZS ÔgaOUS W\abWbcbW]\\SZ& 4 Z Ñ8bOb c\WbOW`SaS a]\b acQQoRo RSa ab`cQbc`Sa RSabW\oSa l TOd]`WaS` ZÑoÔ\]cWaaS[S\b W\abWbcbW]\%\SZ RSa Q][[c\Ocboa& ?O `SRWab`WPcbW]\ RSa ^]cd]Wà O ]PoW l c\ aQVo[OVgP`WRS l [W%QVS[W\ S\b`S ZS []RpZS òUW]\OZ Sb ZS agabp[S ToRoÒZ& 7Sa bSQV%\W_cSa a]^VWabW_coSa RS ^`]bSQbW]\ RSa [W\]`Wboa ]\b dc ZS X]c`& B\ O ^c RW`SRS QS \]cdSOc agabp[S _cÑWZ obOWb Ä ZÑc\ RSa []RSa RS U]cdS`\S[S\b ZSa ^ZcaQ][^ZW_coa Rc []\RS Å !B E;6C> @??6 # =&%?&$ 3CP OYEGJCP MLIGQGNRCP LAAGBCKQ?RU"CO`Wa$ (0/-$ ^& )-0#& @OWa c\ Ocb`S OcbSc` \ ÑO%b%WZ Ôa RWb _cS ZO 5SZUW_cS obOWbZS Ä ZOP]Òb]W`S ^]ZWbW_cS RS Z Ñ8c`]^S Ås !6 D> 6 :? # -IYJCKQP BC BOLGQ ALKPQGQRQGLKKCI"CO`Wa$ (0).$ b& <$ ^& *0)#&6ÑSab _cS ZSa T]`[cZSa RS U]cdS`\S[S\b OcaaW acPbWZSa _cS Q][^ZSfSa$ T]ÙoSa

Ô` c\ W\bO`WaaOPZS aS\a Rc Q][^`][Wa$ \S ^ScdS\b ZOWaaS` W\RWTTo`S\ba ZSa^cPZWQWabSa obÒ\USà$ aW\UcZWp`S[S\b QScf R ÑS\b`S Scf _cW aÑW\bo`SaaS\b OcToRoÒZWa[S& ? ÑW\bS`\ObW]\OZWabS$ _cO\b l ZcW$ O^^òQWSÒ Z ÑW\bo`qb RS QSa T]`[cZSa_cO\R WZ ZWÒ RO\a ZS b][S << ZÑSf^]ao ac` ZSa Q][ôbS\QSa W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa RSaQ][[c\Ocboa Sb RSa òUW]\a&6S b][S ^`S[WS` bÒWbS RSa \]bW]\a Uo\oÒZSa Rc R`]Wb ^cPZWQ Sb R Ñc\S Ô`bWS

Rc abObcb RSa U]cdS`\O\ba$ ZO acWbS obO\b O\\]\QoS ^]c` ZS b][S <<& 7O\aZ ÑW\b`]RcQbW]\$ ]\ `SZpdSÒ ZSa RodSZ]^^S[S\ba Q]\aOQòa l Z Ñ8bOb$ Sb ZO ^òTo`S\QSRS @& ISZc ^]c` ZO bVpaS RS 7cUcWb _cW d]Wb RO\a ZO T]`[ObW]\ RS ZÑ8bOb c\^Vo\][p\S SfbÒ%Xc`WRW_cS aS [O\WTSabO\b Ô` Z ÑO^Ô`WbW]\ RS ZO RWabW\QbW]\a]QW]Z]UW_cS S\b`S U]cdS`\O\ba Sb U]cdS`\oa "^& +-#& B\ \]bSÒ OcaaW _cS RO\aZÑSfO[S\ Rc ^`]PZp[S RS ZO a]cdSÒW\Sbo B?KP ZÑ8bOb$ @& ISZc Sf^]aS OdSQ a]W\ZO bVo]`WS RS ZO a]cdSÒW\Sbo \ObW]\OZS$ Ä SZo RS d]xbS Å RS ZÑoRWTWQS Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZPSZUS Sb aO QR\QWZWObW]\ OdSQ ZS bÒ\aTS`b RS ^]cd]Wà l RSa W\abWbcbW]\a RS R`]WbW\bS`\ObW]\OZ ^cPZWQ U`mQS l ZÑW\b`]RcSbW]\$ S\ (0.'$ R Ñc\ O`bWQZS %&@GP RO\aZO 6]\abWbcbW]\&

)-- 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

?S ^]cd]W` Q]\abWbcO\b `Sn]Wb c\S ^ZOQS RS QV]Wf OdSQ Ôa []W\a RS ()' ÔUSa&4^`pa _cSZ_cSa oQZOW`QWaaS[S\ba R Ñ]`R`S bS`[W\]Z]UW_cS$ Ocf_cSZa ZÑOcbSc` aS[]\b`S ObbOQVo b]cb Oc Z]\U RS Z Ñ]cdÒUS$ @& ISZc RWaap_cS ZO ^`]QoRc`S Q][%^ZSfS _cW ^òaWRS l ZO òdWaW]\ RS ZO 6]\abWbcbW]\ PSZUS& ?Sa Ä RgaT]\QbW]\a ÅRS QS agabp[S ]\b obo [WaSa S\ odWRS\QS Ô` ZSa òQS\bSa ô`WôbWSa _cW ]\b ^S`[Wal c\ Ô`bW RS ZO Q]OZWbW]\ U]cdS`\S[S\bOZS RS PZ]_cS` b]cbS òdWaW]\$ \]\]PabO\bZ ÑSfWabS\QS R Ñc\S [OX]`Wbo RSa RScf bWSà Oc CO`ZS[S\b S\ TOdSc` RS ZO òdWaW]\&4caaW$ RSa ^`]^]aWbW]\a ^]c` OZZoUS` ZO ^`]QoRc`S RS òdWaW]\ ]\b%SZZSa obo T]`%[cZoSa& 6S`bOW\a acUUp`S\b RS ac^^`W[S` ZS Q]\Q]cà ]PZWUOb]W`S Rc ^]cd]W`SfoQcbWT l Z ÑÇcd`S òdWaW]\\SZZS& 8ab%QS W\RW_co3 @& ISZc \S aS ^`]\]\QS Ôaac` QSa RoPOba Q]\b`]dSàoa$ [OWa ]\ ^Scb ^òac[S` _cÑWZ \S aSÒWb Ôa V]abWZS lc\S aW[^ZWTWQObW]\ RSa [oQO\Wa[Sa&?O 5SZUW_cS \S Q]\\Osb _cÑc\ Q]\bùZS Ô`bWSZ RS ZO Q]\abWbcbW]\\OZWbo RSa

Z]Wa$ ZW[Wbo Ocf \]`[Sa _cW òÔ`bWaaS\b ZSa Q][ôbS\QSa S\b`S ZÑ8bOb QS\bÒZ SbZSa Q]ZZSQbWdWboa WaacSa RSa òT]`[Sa W\abWbcbW]\\SZZSa$ Q]\bùZS Oaacò Ô` c\SXc`WRWQbW]\ aôQWOZWaoS$ ZO 6]c` R ÑO`PWbÒUS&8\ (0.+$ c\ O``qb `S\Rc ac` ZSa Q]\QZcaW]\a RS @& ZS ^`]Qc`Sc` Uo\oÒZ :O\aV]T

dO\ RS` @SSàQV O acaQWbo RS dWdSa Q]\b`]dSàSa R]Qb`W\OZSa Sb Ô`ZS[S\bOW`Sa_cO\b l ZO _cSabW]\ RS aOd]W` aW ZO 6]c` OdOWb o^]cao ]c \]\ ZO R]Qb`W\S RSZ Ño[W\S\b [OUWabÒb S\ TOdSc` Rc Q]\bùZS RS ZO Q]\abWbcbW]\\OZWbo& @& ISZcSf^]aS OdSQ [W\cbWS ZSa RWTTo`S\bSa bVpaSa S\ ^òaS\QS$ OW\aW _cS ZSa \][P`ScaSaRoQWaW]\a Xc`WRWQbW]\\SZZSa _cW$ RO\a ZÑS\aS[PZS$ `STcaS\b ZS Q]\bùZS& ?Sa Xc`WabSaRSa Ôga _cW \S Q]\\OWaaS\b Ôa ROdO\bOUS ZS Q]\bùZS RS ZO Q]\abWbcbW]\\OZWboRSa Z]Wa ZW`]\b OdSQ W\bo`qb QSa ÔUSa ]w WZa ^ScdS\b ^cWaS` l d]Z]\bo RSa OÙc[S\ba^]c` ]c Q]\b`S ZS Q]\bùZS&? ÑSf^]ao ac` ZSa Ä ^]cd]Wà RS Z Ñ8bOb QS\bÒZ Å Sab W\OcUcò Ô` Z ÑO\OZgaS RSa

\]bW]\a Uo\oÒZSa$ bSZa ZSa RWTTo`S\bSa T]`[Sa RS Ro[]QÒbWS Sb ZSa agabp[Sa^]ZWbW_cSa T]\Roa ac` ZO aoÔÒbW]\ RSa ^]cd]Wà& ?S Q]\abWbcO\b PSZUS O W\abOcòGW\ òUW[S `S^òaS\bObWT _cW O acPW ZSa RoT]`[ObW]\a _cS @& ISZc WZZcab`S a]caZ ÑO\UZS RS ZO aQWS\QS ^]ZWbW_cS& H\ dSabWUS W[^]`bO\b acPaWabS QS^S\RO\b RO\aZ ÑW[^]aaWPWZWbo RS ^`W\QW^S R ÑW\b`]RcW`S ZS òTo`S\Rc[ ^]abcZoS Ô` ZO 6]\abWbc%bW]\$ Z ÑO^^SZ Oc ^Sc^ZS Txb%WZ RS \Obc`S ^c`S[S\b Q]\acZbObWdS& ?Sa OdWa RS ZOaSQbW]\ RS ZoUWaZObW]\ Rc 6]\aSWZ R Ñ8bOb a]\b T]`[SZa l QSb oUO`R& @& ISZc OR]^bSc\S ^]aWbW]\ ^Zca \cO\QoS$ S\ oQ`WdO\b _cS ÄZS C]cd]W` ZoUWaZObWT ^Scb RoQWRS`Z Ñ]ÙO\WaObW]\ RS òTo`S\Rc[a ^c`S[S\b Q]\acZbObWTa ^]`bO\b ac` RSa [ObWp`SaR ÑW\bo`qb \ObW]\OZ Rpa Z]à _cÑWZ O ZS ^]cd]W` RS TOW`S QS _cW \ÑSab Ôa Sf^`Saao[S\b]c W[^ZWQWbS[S\b W\bS`RWb Ô` ZO 6]\abWbcbW]\Å "^& )/-#&FW[^ZS `SQSbbS R ÑO`b ^]ZWbW_cS ]c ^`W\QW^S RS R`]Wb Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZ ^]aWbWT3

6SbbS _cSabW]\ _cW a]ca%bS\R ZO ^`]PZo[ObW_cS RS ZO aoÔÒbW]\ RSa ^]cd]Wà`Sn]Wb c\S ò^]\aS _cW ]^bS ^]c` ZO aSQ]\RS a]ZcbW]\$ Rc []W\a RO\a ZS agabp[SPSZUS$ Oc bS`[S R Ñc\S O\OZgaS T]cWZZoS ]w a]\b [WaSa S\ `SZWST ZSa [cZbW^ZSa O`bWQc%ZObW]\a RS QS ^`W\QW^S W\Vo`S\b l ZÑ8bOb RS R`]Wb& @& ISZc Ro[]\b`S QS^S\RO\bQ][PWS\ ZO aoÔÒbW]\ RSa ^]cd]Wà Sab `SZObWT RO\a c\ òUW[S Ô`ZS[S\bOW`SQ][[S QSZcW RS ZO 5SZUW_cS&?O aQWS\QS ^]ZWbW_cS$ OcfWZWOW`S W\aoÔÒPZS Rc R`]Wb Q]\abWbcbW]\\SZ$ `Sn]Wb

aSa ZSbb`Sa RS \]PZSaaS QVO_cS T]Wa _cÑWZ aÑOUWb RS [Sbb`S S\ SfSÙcS ZS RWd]`QSS\b`S ZSa `pUZSa T]`[SZZSa Sb ZS T]\QbW]\\S[S\b òSZ RSa W\abWbcbW]\a& 8\ Ô`bWQc%ZWS`$ @& ISZc SfO[W\S ZSa STTSba RS Z ÑOQbW]\ RSa ^]cd]Wà RS TOWb ac` ZS T]\QbW]\\S%[S\b RSa ^]cd]Wà W\abWbcoa& 6][[S\b WU\]`S` OW\aW _cS Ä ZS QV]Wf RSa U]cdS`%\O\ba aÑ]^p`S Ô` c\ [oZO\US R ÑoZSQbW]\ Sb RS Q]]^bObW]\ Å Sb _cS Ä QS \ÑSab ^ZcaaScZS[S\b RS ZO \ObW]\ _cS Z ÑoZc `Sn]Wb c\ [O\ROb$ WZ `Sn]Wb c\ [O\ROb l ZO T]WaRS ZO \ObW]\ Sb RS a]\ Ô`bW Å "^^& *,0 Sb a&#& B\ ^Scb ^Scb%qb`S OX]cbS` _cS ZOÄ Ô`bWQÒbWS Å É QS \o]Z]UWa[S PSZUS É Sab S\ `SQcZ 1 a]ca ZS U]cdS`\S[S\b@O`bS\a I<$ ZS QS\b`S RS RoQWaW]\ ^]ZWbW_cS bS\R l aS Ro^ZOQS` RSa Pc`SOcf RSÔ`bWa dSà ZSa W\abO\QSa U]cdS`\S[S\bOZSa&4dSQ ZÑobcRS Rc CO`ZS[S\b$ Q ÑSab c\S Ô`bWS W[^]`bO\bS RS Z Ñ]cdÒUS _cW

aÑ]cd`S& ?S CO`ZS[S\b bÒdSàS c\S Q`WaS UÒdS& FSa ^ò`]UObWdSa ZoUWaZObWdSa ]\b$QSa RS`\Wp`Sa O\\oSa$ acPW c\S o`]aW]\ ^ò]QQcÔ\bS l ZO TOdSc` RSa ^]cd]WàaôQWOcf OQQ]`Roa Oc U]cdS`\S[S\b a]ca ZO ^`SaaW]\ RS ZO Q`WaS oQ]\][W_cS Sba]QWOZS& ?Sa ZS\bScà ZoUWaZObWdSa S\US\RòSa Ô` c\ PWQO[oÒZWa[S oUOZWbOW`S ]\b

6B@CG8F E8A7H F )-.

OW\aW Q]\b`WPco Oc `S\T]`QS[S\b Rc ^]cd]W` SfoQcbWT$ ^Vo\][p\S acTTWaO[[S\bQ]cÒ\b RO\a ZSa Ro[]QÒbWSa ]QQWRS\bOZSa ^]c` _cS ZO 5SZUW_cS \S TOaaS Ôa TWUc`SR ÑSfQS^bW]\& G]cbST]Wa$ QSbbS od]ZcbW]\ O ObbSW\b RSa RW[S\aW]\a bSZZSa _cÑSZZSOZbp`S RO\US`ScaS[S\b ZS [W\W[c[ RÑo_cWZWP`S _cW R]Wb ^òaWRS` Ocf Ò^^]`baòQW^`]_cSa Rc U]cdS`\S[S\b Sb Rc CO`ZS[S\b 1 Ä ?S QòRWb Rc CO`ZS[S\b Sab^`]U`SaaWdS[S\b ObbSW\b RO\a Z Ñ]^W\W]\ ^cPZW_cS$ RoXl b`]^ RWa^]aoS$ RO\a QSÔga$ l ZO Q`WbW_cS RSa W\abWbcbW]\a Å$ oQ`Wb ^S`bW\S[[S\b ZS ^`]TSaaSc` :O\aV]TdO\ RS` @rSàQV RO\a aO ^òTOQS&7Sa òT]`[Sa a]\b S\dWaOUoSa& B\ aS ^`]^]aS RS []RWTWS` ZSa Obb`WPcbW]\a Sb

ZO Q][^]aWbW]\ Rc Fo\Ob& @& LSZc Sf^]aS ZSa RWTTo`S\bSa a]ZcbW]\a ^`]^]aoSab]cb S\ W\aWabO\b ac` ZS ZWS\ W\bW[S S\b`S ZSa RScf Oa^SQba RS ZO òT]`[S& DcO\bOc Q]\bùZS RS Z ÑOQbW]\ U]cdS`\S[S\bOZS$ @& ISZc W\aWabS ac` ZSa ^`]T]\RSa[cbObW]\a _cÑWZ O Q]\\cSa l ZÑW[OUS Rc Ô`ZS[S\bO`Wa[S Q]\bS[^]ÒW\ 1 Ä& & & ZSU]cdS`\S[S\b Sab Z Ño[O\ObW]\ RS ZO [OX]`Wbo Ô`ZS[S\bOW`S$ S\ [O\Wp`S bSZZS_cÑWZ g O c\Wbo R ÑOQbW]\ S\b`S Z ÑSfoQcbWT Sb ZS ZoUWaZObWT& ?O Q]ZZOP]ÒbW]\ S\b`SQSa RScf ^]cd]Wà aS bÒ\aT]`[S ^`]U`SaaWdS[S\b S\ c\S Q]\TcaW]\ RS ^]cd]Wà Å"^^& .(+ Sb a&#& ?Sa 6VO[P`Sa Q]\aS`dS\b QS^S\RO\b c\ ùZS W[^]`bO\b$ SabW[S@& ISZc$ ^cWa_cS ZS U]cdS`\S[S\b Sab O[S\o l aÑSf^ZW_cS` ^cPZW_cS[S\b acàO ^]ZWbW_cS&?S 6]\abWbcO\b PSZUS RS (/*( O obOPZW c\ do`WbOPZS `pU\S RS ZO Ä Z]W Å 1 RS

\][P`ScaSa [ObWp`Sa \S ^ScdS\b qb`S òUZoSa Ä _cS Ô` ZO Z]W Å ]c Ä S\ dS`bc RSZO Z]W Å& ? ÑOcbSc` `SU`SbbS$ l XcabS bWb`S$ ZO bVpaS _cW Q]\T]\R QSa RScf Sf^`SaaW]\a 1ZO ^`S[Wp`S ^]abcZS ZO Q][ôbS\QS SfQZcaWdS Rc ZoUWaZObSc`$ bO\RWa _cS ZO aSQ]\RSOcb]`WaS RSa VOPWZWbObW]\a a]ca T]`[S RS Z]Wa%QOR`S \]bO[[S\b& @& ISZc aS^`]\]\QS ac` c\S Ocb`S _cSabW]\$ ^Zca Q]\b`]dSàoS$ S\ SabW[O\b _cS ZSa Q][%[c\Ocboa Sb òUW]\a \S ^ScdS\b$ Txb%QS Ô` ZS PWOWa RSa ^]cd]Wà W[^ZWQWbSa$cbWZWaS` ZSc` ^]cd]W` RoQòbOW ^]c` S[^WobS` ac` ZSa [ObWp`Sa òaS`doSa Oc ZoUWa%ZObSc` \ObW]\OZ& H\ O``qb RS ZO 6]c` RS QOaaObW]\$ ^cPZWo O^`pa Z ÑW[^`SaaW]\ RSZÑ]cdÒUS Sb `S\Rc ac` aSa Q]\QZcaW]\a Q]\T]`[Sa$ ÔÒsb Od]W` R]\\o ÒWa]\ lZÑOcbSc`& G]cbST]Wa$ QSbbS _cSabW]\%QZo RSa òT]`[Sa W\abWbcbW]\\SZZSa Sab Z]W\R ÑOd]W` TOWb Z Ñc\O\W[Wbo 1 ZO Xc`Wa^`cRS\QS RS ZO 6]c` R ÑO`PWbÒUS OP]\RS S\ aS\aQ]\bÒW`S& 6ÑSab Oc ^`]QVOW\ Q]\abWbcO\b _cÑWZ W\Q][PS RS bÒ\QVS` RoTW\WbWdS[S\bZS RoPOb&Bcb`S ZSa [ObWp`Sa òaS`doSa$ ZO 6]\abWbcbW]\ Obb`WPcS W[^ZWQWbS[S\b Oc

CO`ZS[S\b ZSa Q][ôbS\QSa RWbSa òaWRcSZZSa$ QS _cW$ a]cdS\b$ R]\\S ZWSc l RSa[OZS\bS\Rca [OZS\Q]\b`Scf RO\a ZSa OaaS[PZoSa Ô`ZS[S\bOW`Sa& 7 Ñ]w QSbbSaodp`S [WaS S\ UO`RS RS @& ISZc 1 Ä ?O ^Zo\WbcRS R ÑObb`WPcbW]\a Rc C]cd]W`ZoUWaZObWT \ObW]\OZ \Ño_cWdOcb Ôa Oc RSa^]bWa[S Ô`ZS[S\bOW`S& 8ZZS \S aWU\WTWSÔa _cS ZS ZoUWaZObSc` \ObW]\OZ ]c ZS CO`ZS[S\b ^Scb b]cb TOW`S Å "^& -+.#&? ÑSaÔQS ZW[Wbo R]\b \]ca RWa^]a]\a \S \]ca ^S`[Sb [OZVSc`ScaS[S\b Ôa

RS ^]càcWd`S ZS Q][^bS `S\Rc RS ZÑ]cdÒUS _cW$ Ô` aO `WQVSaaS$ RoQ]\QS`bS_cSZ_cS ^Sc Ä ZS `S\RO\b Q][^bS Å& 7Sa QV]Wf$ T]`Qo[S\b O`PWbÒW`Sa$ ]\b oboTOWba& B\ aWU\OZSÒ QS^S\RO\b ZO Ô`bWS ac` ZSa TW\O\QSa ^cPZW_cSa ]w ZÑOcb]c`P`]aaS c\ bOPZSOc SfVOcabWT RS QSbbS PÒ\QVS T]`b bSQV\W_cS [OWa T]\RO[S\bOZSRc R`]Wb ^cPZWQ$ aO\a ]cPZWS` ZSa Ô`bWSa ac` ZS abObcb Sb ZSa W[[c\Wboa RSa Ô`ZS%[S\bOW`Sa OW\aW _cS ac` ZO bSQV\W_cS ZoUWaZObWdS& ?Sa ZSQbScà PSZUSa Q][[SobÒ\USà g b`]cdS`]\b c\S [W\S RS `S\aSWU\S[S\ba ^òQWScf& B\ T]`[cZSÒOcaaW c\ a]cVOWb 1 QSZcW RS d]W` ZS ^`]TSaaSc` ISZc Sb aSa Q]ZZpUcSa RS ^òÔ`S`c\ W\RSf Uo\oÒZ _cW a]cZOUSÒWb PWS\ RSa QVS`QVScà Sb ^ÒbWQWS\a O^^SZoa lQ]\acZbS` Tò_cS[[S\b QSb W[^]`bO\b bÒWbo$ [q[S aW c\S bOPZS RSa [ObWp`SaT]cWZZoS ZSc` ]TT`S RoXl RSa `S^p`Sa cbWZSa&

EcaS\ 8E:86&

J <? ? 8 @ <A $ 8Q[^SQ_ Q` ; 846BB> $ C[SQ^# 4A> ,GM>KG:MBHG:E &HFFBMM>> H? MA>

2>= &KHLL ?UVT[RR# ETQ 9MSaQ# (0/+# )'0 \MSQ_%

6SbbS []\]UÒ^VWS Sab ZO aSQ]\RS RÑc\S ao`WS RcS l Z ÑW\WbWObWdS Rc C`]TSaaScÈ]PS`b] 4U] Sb bS\RO\b l []\b`S` Z ÑW\TZcS\QS RSa ]ÙO\WaObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSaac` ZO bÒ\aT]`[ObW]\ RSa `SZObW]\a W\bS`\ObW]\OZSa RS^cWa (0+,&

)-/ 6B@CG8F E8A7H F

<QW$ Q][Ôò l Z ÑB&<&G&$ l Z ÑB&@&F& Sb l ZO 9&4&B&$ ZS 6&<&6&E& O^ÔÒsb RO\ab]cbS aO aW\UcZO`Wbo R ÑOaa]QWObW]\ ^`WdoS acWaaS&<ZZcabÒ\b ZScà ^`]^]a RS \][P`Scf bOPZSOcf$ ZSa OcbScà ]\b obcRWo ZÑOQ%

Q`]WaaS[S\b S\ d]Zc[S$ ZO RWdSàWTWQObW]\ Uo]UÒ^VW_cS Sb _cOZWbObWdS RSaOQbWdWboa Rc 6&<&6&E& 7O\a ZO aSQ]\RS Ô`bWS RS ZÑ]cdÒUS$ WZa ]\b ^òQWao ZSa[Sac`Sa W\abWbcbW]\\SZZSa$ ^]ZWbW_cSa Sb TW\O\QWp`Sa _cS ZS 6][Wbo O Rx ^`S\R`SS\ Q]\ao_cS\QS$ OW\aW _cS Z Ñod]ZcbW]\ RS aSa Ò^^]`ba OdSQ ZSa 8bOba$ Sb ZO ?WUcSRSa F]QWoboa RS ZO 6`]Wf E]cUS Sb Rc 6`]WaaO\b E]cUS&


4@>AE6D C6?5FD $ 3@6

Documents

Transcript of 4@>AE6D C6?5FD $ 3@6