7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 1/6

Problema 8.15

Método I: Destilación Ordinaria

Subgr

upo

F acolumn

a

Separac

ión!a"o

!a"o con

separaciones

subsecuent

es

m#nimo

de

separaci

ón

$% 600 A/B 40000 40000 40000

%& 800 B/C 64000 64000 64000

&D 400 C/D 76923.07

69

76923.07692 76923.07

69$%& 900 A/BC 60000 124000

AB/C 72000 112000 112000

%&D 900 B/CD 72000 148923.0769 148923.077  BC/D 173076.9

23

237076.9231

$%&D 1000 A/BCD 66666.66

67

215589.7436

AB/CD 80000 196923.0769 196923.0

769  ABC/D 192307.6

92

304307.6923

Método II: Destilación '(tracti)a

Subgr

upo

F a

column

a

Separa

ción

!a"o !a"o con

separacion

es

subsecuent

es

m#nimo

de

separac

ión$% 600 A/B 75000 75000 75000

%& 800 B/C 80000 80000 80000

&D 400 C/D 66666.6

667

66666.6666

7

66666.6

667

$%& 900 A/BC 112500 192500AB/C 90000 165000 165000

%&D 900 B/CD 90000 156666.666

7

156666.

667  BC/D 150000 230000

$%&D 1000 A/BCD 125000 281666.666

7

 

AB/CD 100000 241666.666

7

241666.

667  ABC/D 166666. 331666.666

7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 2/6

667 7

Problema 8.1*

Balances para las Columnas a Evaluar

&olumna F D %A/B 250 200 50B/C 250 50 200C/D 400 200 200D/E 250 200 50E/F 350 50 300

A/BC 450 200 250AB/C 450 250 200B/CD 450 50 400BC/D 450 250 200C/DE 450 200 250CD/E 450 400 50D/EF 550 200 350DE/F 550 250 300

A/BCD 650 200 450AB/CD 650 250 400ABC/D 650 450 200B/CDE 500 50 450BC/DE 500 250 250BCD/E 500 450 50C/DEF 750 200 550CD/EF 750 400 350CDE/F 750 450 300

A/BCDE 700 200 500AB/CDE 700 250 450ABC/DE 700 450 250ABCD/E 700 650 50B/CDEF 800 50 750BC/DEF 800 250 550BCD/EF 800 450 350BCDE/F 800 500 300

A/BCDEF 1000 200 800AB/CDEF 1000 250 750

7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 3/6

ABC/DEF 1000 450 550ABCD/EF 1000 650 350ABCDE/F 1000 700 300

Evaluac!n Econ!mca con "ro#ramac!n Dn$mca

Subgrupo

&orte S!a"o

S!a"om+s

separaciones

subsecuentes

&ostom#nimo

AB A/B%21&740.

26%21&740.2

6%21&740.

26

BCB/C

%21&338.49

%21&338.49

%21&338.49

CDC/D

%29&140.68

%29&140.68

%29&140.68

DED/E

%12&798.41

%12&798.41

%12&798.41

EFE/F %33&863.

28%33&863.2

8%33&863.

28

ABCA/BC

%46&488.47

%67&826.96

AB/C%28&442.

25%50&182.5

0%50&182.

50

BCDB/CD

%40&442.25

%69&582.93

BC/D%31&148.

63%52&487.1

2%52&487.

12

CDEC/DE

%34&148.63

%46&947.04

%46&947.04

CD/E %20&178.28

%49&318.97

DEFD/EF

%41&818.82

%75&682.11

DE/F%42&199.

57%42&199.5

7%42&199.

57

ABCDA/BCD

%70&640.98

%123&128.10

AB/CD%47&448.

57%98&329.5

1ABC/D %39&080. %89&263.1 %89&263.

7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 4/6

60 0 10

BCDEB/CDE

%45&201.00

%92&148.03

BC/DE%36&145.

38%57&483.8

7%57&483.

87

 BCD/E

%22&001.76

%74&488.88

CDEF

C/DEF%64&000.

06

%106&199.

63CD/EF

%49&035.09

%112&039.05

CDE/F%50&367.

91%97&314.9

5%97&314.

95

ABCDEA/BCDE

%76&615.49

%134&099.36

AB/CDE%52&189.

74%120&877.

04

ABC/DE%44&043.

62%94&226.1

2%94&226.

12

 

ABCD/E%29&237.

86

%118&500.

96

BCDEFB/CDEF

%73&662.09

%170&977.04

BC/DEF%65&950.

45%129&488.

51

BCD/EF%50&828.

37%137&178.

77

BCDE/F%52&390.

78%109&874.

65%109&874

.65

ABCDEFA/BCDEF

%112&074.09

%221&948.74

AB/CDEF%80&573.

26

%199&628.

46ABC/DEF

%73&699.73

%166&081.80

ABCD/EF%57&967.

47%181&093.

86

ABCDE/F%60&421.

56%154&647.

68%154&647

.68

Problema 8.,-

Método I: Destilación Ordinaria

Subgrupo

&olumna

F i/ !a"o!a"o m+s

separacionessubsecuentes

&ostom#nimo deseparación

ABA/B 600 2

 %150&000.00

%150&000.00

%150&000.00

BCB/C 500 1.7

 %147&058.82

%147&058.82

%147&058.82

7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 5/6

CDC/D 200 1.5

 %66&666.67

%66&666.67

%66&666.67

DED/E 300

1.04

 %144&230.77

%144&230.77

%144&230.77

ABCA/BC 700 2

 %175&000.00

%322&058.82

%322&058.82

AB/C 700 1.7 %

205&882.35%

355&882.35

BCD B/CD 600 1.7 %

176&470.59%

243&137.25%

243&137.25

BC/D 600 1.5 %

200&000.00%

347&058.82

CDEC/DE 400 1.5

 %133&333.33

%277&564.10

CD/E 400 1.4 %

142&857.14%

209&523.81%

209&523.81

ABCDA/BCD 800 2

 %200&000.00

%443&137.25

%443&137.25

AB/CD 800 1.7 %

235&294.12%

451&960.78

ABC/D 800 1.5 %

266&666.67%

588&725.49

BCDEB/CDE 800 1.7

 %235&294.12

%444&817.93

%444&817.93

BC/DE 800 1.5 %

266&666.67%

557&956.26

BCD/E 8001.04

 %384&615.38

%627&752.64

ABCDEA/BCDE

1000

2 %

250&000.00%

694&817.93

AB/CDE100

01.7

 %294&117.65

%653&641.46

%653&641.46

ABC/DE100

0 1.5 %

333&333.33%

799&622.93

ABCD/E100

01.04

 %480&769.23

%923&906.49

Método II: Destilación '(tracti)a con Fenol

Subgrupo

&olumna

F i/ !a"o!a"o m+s

separacionessubsecuentes

&ostom#nimo deseparación

ABA/B 600

2.5

 % 144&000.00%

144&000.00%

144&000.00

BC

B/C 500 2 % 150&000.00%

150&000.00

%

150&000.00

CDC/D 200 2 % 60&000.00

%60&000.00

%60&000.00

DED/E 300

1.7

 % 105&882.35%

105&882.35%

105&882.35

ABCA/BC 700

2.5

 % 168&000.00%

318&000.00%

318&000.00

AB/C 700 2 % 210&000.00%

354&000.00

BCDB/CD 600 2 % 180&000.00

%240&000.00

%240&000.00

BC/D 600 2 % 180&000.00 %

7/21/2019 8.15 kirk

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/815-kirk 6/6

330&000.00

CDEC/DE 400 2 % 120&000.00

%225&882.35

CD/E 4001.7

 % 141&176.47%

201&176.47%

201&176.47

ABCDA/BCD 800

2.5

 % 192&000.00%

432&000.00%

432&000.00

AB/CD 800 2 % 240&000.00%

444&000.00

ABC/D 800 2 % 240&000.00%

558&000.00

BCDEB/CDE 800 2 % 240&000.00

%441&176.47

%441&176.47

BC/DE 800 2 % 240&000.00%

495&882.35

BCD/E 8001.7

 % 282&352.94%

522&352.94

ABCDEA/BCDE

1000

2.5

 % 240&000.00%

681&176.47

AB/CDE1000

2 % 300&000.00%

645&176.47%

645&176.47

ABC/DE1000

2 % 300&000.00%

723&882.35

ABCD/E1000

1.7

 % 352&941.18%

784&941.18