· Ha ocnoBaHue r{r. 58 or 3arcoHa 3a cr1e6uara BJracr r4 r-oAr4rrrHara ilporpaMa Ha I4BCC za 2019...

$: · Ha ocnoBaHue r{r. 58 or 3arcoHa 3a cr1e6uara BJracr r4 r-oAr4rrrHara ilporpaMa Ha I4BCC za 2019 r., ilpr4era c perxeHue or 20.03.2019 r., r. II, 1.3.2, Ha 3auoeeA J\lb TII-01-2$
PETIYEJII4KA EbJIf API,Ifl

TilHCIIEKTOPAT KbM BIICIIIUS CbAEEEH CbBET

z,*.:vnTn -fl;* /Jq

;;;;; 5o,qY; Ln^-o'

AKT3A PE3YJITATII OT II3BbPIIIEHA TEMATIIIIHA IIPOBEPKA'

Bb3JIOI(EHA CbC 3AIIOBEA Nb Tfl-01-21 11.04.2019 r.

HA IJIABIilTIfl. IIHCTIEKTO P

rp. Co4us 1000, yl. ,,feopr BaurunrroH" J\io 17, re*'. 02 9057502, Sarc: 02 9057503

Ha ocnoBaHue r{r. 58 or 3arcoHa 3a cr1e6uara BJracr r4 r-oAr4rrrHarailporpaMa Ha I4BCC za 2019 r., ilpr4era c perxeHue or 20.03.2019 r., r. II,1.3.2, Ha 3auoeeA J\lb TII-01-2 or 11.04.2019 r. ua rraenufl r.rHcrreKrop rr3auone4 l\b TII-01-21 02.12.2019 r., c Korro cpoKbr 3a rrpeAcraBrHe Ha aKra cpe3ynTaTLITe oT npoBepKaTa e y.qbJDKeH,

CE I'I3BbPIilI4 IPOBEPKA na reMa ,,flpnuzHr4 3a Bb3o6nosssaHe HaHaKa3areJIHI4Te Aena or arleJrarr4BHr4Te cbAr4nurrla B cnyqar4Te rro utt. 424, an. 1

or HilK" B Anerarznen cbA flnon4un, AnerarrrBeH cBA BapHa,AneraruseH cbA - Byprac u Anelau4BeH cbA - Beruxo TtpHono.

cbcTAB HA TIPOBEPflBAUVIfl EKI4tr :

I4HCIEKTOP : IIutus, CroqHonaEKCIIEPTZ: T K ra B E |IEPI4OA: Peureszrra, rrocraHoBeHI4 rrpe3 2017 r. u 2018 r., c Kot4ro

HcKaHLItra 3a Bb3o6nosssaHe, pa3rneAaHkr no peAa Ha rJr.33 HilK, ca npuerlr3€t OCHOBATCJIHI4.

IEJI: la ce ycraHoBqr rpI4r{I4HVre za srso6noaqBaHe Ha HaKa3areJrHr{re/Iena.

METOI: AHarus Ha nocraHoBeHrlTe peureHr4fl, c Korrro ca nrso6HoBeHrrAenara.

I. Ocnonanvfl sa nrro6HoBqBaHe:Cruacso u1.424, an.l HIIK, rr3MeHeH crc 3I4AH[IK, o6n. lp 6p.42 or

09.06.2015 r. racraHero sa erso6noB-f,BaHe Ha HaKa3areJrHo Aeno Ha ocHoBaHr4e

ust.422, N.l, r.5 HIIK ce pa3rnexAa or cborBerHns, a\enarvBeH cbA, KoraroaKTbr no qn.419 HnK e [ocraHoBeH or pafioHeH ubqunv or oKpbxeH cbA KaroBb33r{BHa r,rHCTaHrIkrq, c [,I3KJIIOqeHI,re Ha HOBr,rTe npprCbAl,r.

OcnonasvflTa sa sr:o6HoBrBaHe Ha HaKa3areJrHr{ Aena ilo \r.422, aJr.l,r.5 HIIK ca AorycHarlr cbrrlecrBeHn HapyrueHufl. no un.348, anI, r. I - 3 HIIK.

flpanovroulr4rra Ha ailerarurBHnfl. cbA ca Ia orMeHr4 npucr4ara,perxeHr4eTo, olpeAeJreHlreTo vnu pa3nopexAaHeTo v Aa BbpHe AenoTo 3a HoBopa3rnexAaHe Karo rrocorrr4 cra4nfl, or rofiro rpr6na Aa 3arroqHe HoBoropa3fnexAaHe Ha AenoTo; Aa oTMeHr,r [plrcbAaTa, perueHHeTo ,lJrvI

onpeAeneHr4eTo r4 Aa npeKparfi unv Ia cllpe HaKa3aTeJrHoTo npor43BoAcTBo, a Bcny'rar Ha qr.24, ar.l, r.1 HIIK - Aa orrpaBAae noAcbAr4Murfl. B paMKrlTe Ha

QarrravecKrlTe rroJro)KeHvrfl tro BJrr3Jrara B cr4rra ilpr4crAa; Aa orMeHV npuc'b4mat4[rv pe[reHr4eTo, Aa rrpr43Hae rroAcbAr4Mr4r 3a HeBvHeH v Aa My Hzuro)KI4

aillMLtHI"{CTpaTI4BHO HAKA3aHLte. KOfaTO AetHI4eTO Ce HaKa3Ba IIO

aAMr4Hr4crparr4BeH pel s [peABraAeHr,rre e oco6eHata qacr na Haxa:ateJrHvrs.KOAeKC Cnyq.av l.d'rrr4 C'bCTABrflBa AAMVTHI4ATpaTUBHO HapyIXeHHe, npeABUAeHO B

3aKOH r4nr4 yKa3; Aa r43MeHr4 rrprrcb4ura vrrr4 BT33r4BHoTo pe[reHkre B cJlyrlauTe,KOTATO OCHOBAHVflTA 34 TOBA CA B TIOJI3A HA OCb,IIEHIdfl.

flprn u:nlpruBaHe Ha rrpoBepKara 6sxa ananrr3trpaHr4 npeAocraBeHl{Te orcbAunr..ruaTa peueHr4q, rrocraHoBeHlr rro AeJra, p€BfneAaHr4 rro peAa na rn. 33

H|IK ..Brgo6uoB.sBaHe Ha HaKa3areJIHI4 gera" B nepuoAa 01.01.2017 r.

31.12.2018 r., c Kor{To vaKaHlaflTa 3a Bb3o6HoBqeaHe ca npnerv 3a ocHoBareJlHrr

r43u.rno vrIvr qacrtrqHo. llo-rorsuara rracr or rtx ca onucaHr v fpy[LlpaHu no

c"6Ae6gn paitouvt, Karo ca cr4creMarv3vpaur{ c[opeA ocHoBaHkIero, Ha Koero eet:o6HoeeHo Aenoro. [enara, nr:o6HoBeHu Ha eAHo u cbulo ocHoBaHI{e, ca

rrocoqeHlt caMo c HoMepara 14 roAl4Hara na o6pa:yBaHe.

1. AnerarnseH cbA - fllon4Iae.1.1. [ena, elso6uoBeHr{ Ha ocHoBaHlre HenpaBl{nHo rlpunoxeHl,Ie Ha

MarepzzrrrHl4.fl 3aKoH (vn.348, il.1, r.l HIIK).HAB Ns l29l 20ll r., o6pa3yBaHo ro peAa na \n.420, M.2 np. ut-422,

il.1, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrfl. C perueune or 03.05.2017 r. crAlr e

Bb3o6HoBzl HOX! Ns 5l7l 2017 r. rro orruca na PC - Benunrpal\vr e LI3MeHI{JI

orrpeAeneHr{ero, c Koero e oAo6peHo clopa3yMeHl,Iero. llpuel e, qe pafioHHu{rcbA HerrpaBlrnHo B HapyureHrae Ha rIJI. 51 3I4H3C e orpeAenlan crporlbpBonaqarreH pexr4M BMecro o6ut ga r43T:bpntBaHe Ha HaKa3aHLIero u B

HapyrueHr4e :na.rr.58 3I{H3C ce e upo}r3HecbJl 3a rl4[a Ha 3arBopHLIqecKoro

3aBeAeHLIe.

HAB Ns 2391 2017 r., o6pa3yBaHo ilo peAa :na'rr.424, M.l np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK no ucKaHe Ha ocbAeHure. C pemenlre or 24.07.2017 r. ctArr e

Bb3o6HoBun HOXA J\b 1090/ 20L5 r. rro orrl4ca na PC - lIa:ap4xI,IK 14 BHOXANs 2991 2016 r. ro onuca Ha OC - lIa":ap4)KLrK, oTMeHLIJI e npLlcbAara vperrreHl,IeTo B rracTTa, B KO'TO e onpeAeneHo HaKa3aHLIe Ha eAvIHI4fl. oT

noAcbAlrMfiTe, ocBo6o4utt ro e or HaKa3arenHa orfoBopHocr vr Ha ocu. .rr. 78a

or HK My e H€LJroxr,rJr aAMlrHr.rcrparr.rBHo HaK€BaHLIe rno6a. llpuen e) qe

cbAI4JrLrqaTA CA AOnyCHanLr HapylueHHe Ha 3aKOHa, KaTO He ca ocno6oAuJll4 To3I4

rroAcbAtrM oT HaKA3aTeJrHa OT|OBOpHOCT C HaJIafaHe Ha aAMI{HI4CTpaTI4BHO

HaKa3aHHe tlpu H€rrrr{rrlreTo Ha BcHqKr4 KyMynaTLrBHo rIpeABI4AeHI,I

rrpeArIocTaBKvr.HAB J\b 7ll 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa ya wr.424, M.l

"p. utr.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJIaBHI4t rpoKypop Ha PB. C peureHlle or26.06.2017 r. cbAbr e nrso6HoBrrrr HOXA Ns 709/ 2015 r. rlo onuca Ha PC -Xacxono, orMeHuJr e [pucbAara 14 e BbpH€In Aenoro Ha cbIrII{s, cr4 3a HoBo

pa3rnexqaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craArlrr na crAe6Horo 3aceAaHI,Ie. llpraen e, qe

pafiouuurr cbA e orJrolxLrJr rd3rrbJrHeHr4ero Ha Hzl[oxeHoro HaKa3aHHe, 6e: Aa ca

H€L[vqe upeAnocraBKr,rre uo ur.66, ar.1 HK.HAB l\b 488/ 2017 r., o6pa":yBaHo rlo peAa ya wr.424, il.l np. wr.422,

N.l, r.5 HIIK ro rlcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{rr npoKypop na PE. C peureHlle or03.11.2017 r. cbAbr e nr:o6uoBurr HOXA Ns3921 20ll r. rro orrr{ca Ha PC -Crapa 3aropa, Karo e orMeHr4n rrprlcb.{ara caMo rro orHorueHue Ha eALrHr{r ornoAcbAI{MLrre B rracT"ra 3a HaKa3aHr4ero I,r e BbpH€ur Aenoro Ha csqur cbA 3a

HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe PC e rpr4Jro)Kr{n HenpaBr,rJrHo

'il. JBa FIK no orHorrreHr4e Ha HaKa3aHr{ero, olpeAeJreHo Ha ocH. un. 63, il. 1,

T. 3 HK Ha HenbJIHoJIerHLrfl loAcbAr4M, Koero ecMeKrIaBaHe Ha HaKa3aTeJrHaTa oTfoBopHocT, Ho He VHarraf aHe Ha aAMI,I Ht4cTpaTr4BHO HaKa3aHr{e.

npeABlrAeHo caMo 3a

3a ocBo6ox.rlaBaHe c

HAB llb 71ll 2017 r., o6pa:ynaHo rro peAa :e'a'ar.420, an.2 np. wr.422,an.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha rrraBHr{r rrpoKypop Ha PE. C peueHr4e or09.03.2017 r. c'ssbr e Bb3o6Honur HOXI j\b 53141 2017 r. uo oruca ua pC -llloe4un, orMeHI4Jr e onpeAeneHl4ero, c Koero e o4o6peuo cnopa3yMeHr4ero, r,r eBbpHa-II Aenoro Ha cbrIIHq cbA 3a HoBo pzrrne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuel e,

're PC e AonycHan HapymeHl4e Ha qJr. 67, at.3 HK, He e rrpeAJroxr4Jr npoMrHacbrJracHo ,il. 382, al. 5 HIIK r.r B HapyueHr4e Ha rrJr. 382 ax 7 HIIK e o4o6puncrropa3yMeHr4e, Koero nporr4Boperrlr Ha 3aKoHa orrpeAeJreHr4 aa ABenpo6aquouuu MepKI{ [pe3 I{3rrrrrarerrnufl cpoK, BMecro caMo eAHa ornpeABr4AeHr{Te B qJr. 42a, at.2, r. 1 - 4 HK.

HAB J\e 1751 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa uaw.420, M.2 np. wt.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha rraBHr4q rpoKypop Ha PB. C perxeHr,re or26.04.2018 r. cr4rr e nrso6HoBLIrI BHOXA i\b 6571 2017 r. rro ornca na OC -fla:apAxzrc, LI3MeHuJr e pe[reHl,Iero B qacrra, B Kotro I{3rIbJIHeHrdero HaH€tloxeHr,rre Ha [oAcbALIMLrre HaKa3aHVfl, Jrr{[raBaHe or cso6o.{a e orJIo)KeHo,Karo e HaM€LIILIJT I43rlurarelrnvrr^ cpoK. llpraen e, qe e olpeAeneH B HapyrueHr.re Haut.66, an.2 HK, rrfi raro HaAMI4HaBa cpoKa Ha HaKa3aHLrero JrurrraBaHe orcno6o4a c rtoBeqe or 3 ro4unu.

HAB }lb 25l 2018 r., o6pa-:yBaHo no peAa ua'aL420, at.2 n;p. tt.422,anl, r.5 HIIK rro r.rcKaHe Ha rJraBHrdr npoKypop Ha PE. C perreHrre or08.03.2018 r. crArr e srso6HoBr{Jr HOXA J\b 28I51 20L7 r. rro onrzca na PC -flnon4un, orMeHLIn e rrpucr4ara B rracr-Ta, B Kosro e rrpnc[aAHaro BpeMero,rlpe3 Koero rIoAcbALIMr4frT e 6ul zaArp)KaH rIoA crpa>Ka, v. B rracrra, B Korro e

o[peAeneH TLIIa Ha 3aTBopHI{rIecKoTo 3aBeAeHze. llpueJr e, qe PC e AonycH€rJrHapylreHue Ha 3aKoHa - na .rn.59 , N.2 Bp. an.1, r.1 HK u vn.65, an.1 FIK, r:sfiKaTO IIOACbALIMI,IST e HensJrHOJIeTeH U AO HaBbprUBaHe Ha frbJrHoJrerlreLl3Tbpn.f,Ba HaKa3aHuIeTo Jrl4ruaBaHe or cno6oAa B norlpaBLrreJreH AoM, a He B3aTBOp.

HAB i\b 54l 2018 r., o6pa-:yBaHo rro peAa :rra'ril.424, N.l ep. wr.422,il.I, r.5 HnK ro r{cKaHe Ha rJraBHLrs rpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHlre or09.03.2018 r. crArr e nrso6HoBLIrI HOXA J\b 1306/ 2017 r. rro orrr4ca Ha PC -KasaHrlr, orMeHrrn e rrpl4c'b4ara r{ e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrrlvr cbA 3a HoBop€Brnex(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAn.rr na cr4e6Horo 3aceAaHrre. llpuen e, qe

PC e AorIycH€Ln HapyrreHr4e Ha 3aKoHa c rrprluo)KeHr{ero Ha .rr.78a, al.l HK,3arrloro He e B3eJr rrpeABraA za6payara Aa ce nplrnara al. l-6 B cn)rqar4Te cneAynotpe6a Ha HapKornrlu cbrrracHo r3MeHeHr,rero Ha at7 |ffi,6p.5412017 r.l.

HAB J\b 2151 2018 r., o6pa:ynaHo rro peAa :naw.420, M.2 np. un.422,an.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha ocbAe:nvr. C perueHr{e or 06.07.2018 r. crArr e

srso6Hoeran BHOXA J\b llT l 2018 r. uo orrnca na OC - llnosAus ra HOXI Ns

40471 2017 r. ro ouuca na PC-lInoBAr{B, Lr3MeHr{Jr e perreHr{ero lr npucbAara B

r{acrra 3a KBaJll4$ur<aqraxra Ha AeflHuflT4 orMeHI4JI fI4 e B ocb.4I4TeJIHara I{Mqacr 14 B r{acrra 3a rrpr4noxeHr4ero ua'aL23) aJr.l HK. flo ornoureHr4e Ha

e[LrHvrfl, or noAcbAr4MHTe e npunoxvlt ut.78a, a-rr.l HK. Pafionnu-sr cbA e

AonycHan HapyrxeHvre Ha 3aKoHa KaTo e rrprreJr, qe c AeqHI{eTo ca r43B:bprrreHl{

ABe rrpecrbrrrrenutfl, BMecro eAHo rro rrJr.l3l,at.I,r.4,rry.3 ut.l2, np.1 HK.HAB }lb 4l ll 2018 r., o6pa:ynaHo rro pe,aa Ha \r.420, N.2 np. wt.422,

N.l, r.5 HIIK ro rrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHnfl. C perueul{e or 11.10.2018 r. cr.qrr e

nrso6Honran HOX! Ns 16321 2018 r. rro oruca na PC - Crapa 3aropa, orMeHr{rr

e onpeAeJreHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHr{ero, v a rr3nparr4Jr Aenororo KoMrrereHrHocr Ha Pfl-Crapa 3aropa. llpuen e, qe pafioHnuar cbA e

Hapyrxun rrpr4Hrlr{fla ua wr.2, N.2 HK, raro He e npr{Jroxc{Jr 3aKoHbr, xofiro e

uafi-6naro[prlrreH 3a AeeIIa.HAB }lb 456/ 2018 r., o6pa^:yBaHo rro peAa :rra'rn.424, il.l yp. utr.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr{f, rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHr.re or01.10.2018 r. cbAbr e smo6uoBl4rr fftIXA J\e 25l 2018 r. no orrr4ca Ha PC -Ilanarropl4lrlg, rr3MeHLrJr e rrprlcbAara B rracrra, B Ko{To e Hilrro}KeHo HaK€I3aHI{e

Jrlr[raBaHe or cno6o.qa, ocBo6oAur ro e or HaKa3areJrHa orroBopHocr Lr My e

H€Lrro)KLtJr aAMI4HI{crparI4BHo HaKa3aHr.re ruo6a. llpr,ren e, qe pafioHHnrr cbA e.{olycHalr HapyrueHvre Ha 3aKoHa, KaTo He e B3eJI npeABLrA H€t[urIXeTo Ha

KyMynarkrBHo [peABr{AeHr.rTe s qr.78a HK upe4rocraBKr4.HAB Ns 653/ 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa ua qr.424, il.I np. wr.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK uo r{cKaHe Ha nraBHr{q rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHne or13.02.2019 r. crAtt e srso6HoBlrJr HOXA Ng 4731 20ll r. ro orrr{ca Ha PC -Kaprono, I43MeHL{JI e olpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clop€ByMeHr4ero 3aperxaBaHe Ha Aenoro B qacrra, B Kosro Ha o6euH-flel{ur e o[peAeneHoHaKa3aHLIe JILIUIaBaHe or rlpaBo Aa yrrpaBrrflBa MnC. llpuen e, qe e AonycHaroHapyrxeHr{e Ha 3aKoHa, Karo e HaJro)KeHo rrpeABrrAeHoro B .rr.343r HKJrr.rlraBaHe or rlpaBo rro rrJr. 37, an I, r.7 FIK na o6suHrel,rw, rcoitto He e

rrpaBocuoco6en BoAaq ua MIIC.Apyrer AeIra, slgo6HoneHr,r Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHHe: H{B Ns3241 2018 r.;

HIB Ns22412018 r.; HAB Ns 355/ 2017 r.; HIB i\b 63ll 2018 r.; HAB Ns577l2018 r.; HAB J\b 1431 2018 r.; HIB J\b 45l 2018 r.; HIB Ns2821 2017 r.; HruNs2751 2017 r.; HF Ns47512018 r.; HIB J\b 33ll 2018 r.; Hp J\b 103/2018r.; HAB J\b 4591 2017 r.

1.2. fieta, elso6HoseHu Ha ocHoBaHue AorrycHaro cbulecrBeHoHapyrxeHue Ha rrpoqecyanHLrre rrpaBr4na (un.348, M.I, r.2 HIIK).

HAB .l\b 330/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua \rr.424, N.I np. tn.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK rlo HcKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrfl. C peureuLTe or 23.10.2017 r. crArr e

srso6Hosran BHOXA Ns ll9l 2017 r. rro oru{ca Ha OC - llasappKr.rK r{ HOXAJ\b 2011 2016 r. rlo orrr4ca na PC - llanarroplrrle, orMeHr4Jr e perreHr.rero r.r

rlpvcbAara u e BbpHzt[ Aenoro na PC 3a HoBo pa3rnex(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB orcra4prfl. na ctAe6Horo 3aceAaHI,Ie. llpnen e, qe PC e AorrycH€rn ABe cbrrlecrBeHz

HapyrxeH[fl]Ha rrpoqecyanHhTe ilpaB]i1'na - Ha rrJr. 94 HnK, npaBoro Ha 3axlr4Ta

Ha rroAcbA]li.Mkrfl, r(aTo My e Ha3Haqr4n cnyxe6eH 3arqurHnK rropahr HeflBflBaHe

Ha ylbnHoMouleHl4q ilo yBax{r4TenHr4 nppr.l'krHr4, 6es HeroBo cbfJracue, vr Ha

vn.305, an4 HnK, Karo B Ar4crro3r,rrrrBa Ha ilpprcr4ara He e nocorruJrCaMOJIHTIHOATTa Ha TIOACb \LrMr4fl .

HAB J\b 43l 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha 'ar.424, il.l n,p. urr.422,il.l, r.5, HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha ocbAenr4fl. C perueur4e or 13.06.2017 r. cl4rr e

srso6Hosran BHOXA }lb 1198/ 2016 r. no oruca na OC * Crapa 3aropa,OTMeHUJT e perxeHr4eTo r{ e BbpHirn AenoTo Ha cbIIIr{q cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHeor Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe oKpb)KHr,rf,T cbA e AonycHurn HapyueHr4e na vr.l3,an.2 HIIK, KaKro v Ha .rn. 339, u. 2 HIIK - perueHr.rero He orroBapfl, Ha

I,I3I{CKBaHVflTA 3a CbAbp)I(aHLIe [peABr4A JII{rICaTa Ha OT|OBOpU Ha BCr4IIKI4

AoBoArr, r43nox{eHrl s xart6ara Ha rroAcr4nv'us.HAB Ns l44l 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa ua wr.424, anI np. wt.422,

il.l, r.5, HIIK no r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHLrs rpoKypop na PE. C peureHr4e or12.04.2017 r. cr.qbr e Bb3o6nonur HOXA Ns 12411 2016 r. rro onr4ca na PC -Krpqxaru, orMeHr4n e rrpucr4ara r.r e BbpHaJr Aenoro Ha cbrrrr4s cbA 3a HoBo

puBrnex(AaHe or Apyf cbcraB or craAlrr ua crAe6Horo 3ace1aHtre. llpuen e, qe

paitotntuxr cbA HelpaBr{nHo e orKa3arr Aa AorrycHe LrcKaHero Ha [poKypopa,HarrpaBeHo cbfJracHo rrJr. 287, an 1 HIIK 3a LI3MeHeHr4e Ha o6BLrHeHlIero, rIpI4

ycraHoBeHr{ Ha crge6noro cneAcrBlle ocHoBaHr4fl 3a cbulecrBeHo Lr3MeHeHLIe Ha

o6crosreJrcrBeHara rracr Ha o6suHeHl,Iero.HAB J\lb 309/ 2017 r., o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Ha'aL424, il.l rrp. w.422,

il.l, r.5, HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJIaBHI4r{ rlpoKypop na PB. C perreHlle or28.07.2017 r. csgrr e ergo6HoBnJr HOXA J\b 11551 2015 r. uo oruca Ha PC -Krp4xanrr, H3MeHr4n e o[peAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e oqo6peHo cnopa3yMeHprero B

qacrra, B Korro o6nuHseNaurflT e rrppr3Har 3a BrrHoBeH no eAHo or o6BLIHeHkrflTa,

rrpeAMer Ha clop€ByMeHrrero, vt Ha ocHoBaHI{e wt.24, il.l, r.6 HIIK ro e

rrpeKparlrJr B Ta3r,r qacr. flpnen e, tre pafioHHlrsr cbA e AorrycHzul cblrlecrBeHoHapy[reHr4e Ha rrpoqecyanHr{Te npaBr4Jla, KaTo He e cbop€lJl AoKa3aTeJIcTBa 3a

[peAXoAHr4 ocbx{AaHr{{ u e o4o6pzr cilopa3yMeHLlero B r{acrra 3a

rrpecrbrrneHnero rro ut.343y, an2 Bp. an.l Bp. ut.2, al.2 HK, 3a Koeroo6suHxelarrtrT Beqe e 6ur octAeH c BJLx3na B cr4ila npulcbAa no Apyro Aeno.

HAB J\b 384/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa wa w.424, anl np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrs. C peurenue or 11.10.201J r. cr4rr e

snso6Hoeun BHOXA Ib 1691 2017 r. rro orrrlca na OC - Xacrcono, orMeHIaJI e

peIIIeHLIeTo LI e BbpHzuI AenoTo Ha cbIIIH{ cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne}KAaHe oT ApyrcbcraB. Ilpnen e, qe Bb33trBHLrflT cr4 e AorrycHan cblrlecrBeHo HapylxeHne Ha

npoqecy€rJrHlrre npaBHna [opaAI,I rocraHoBf,BaHe Ha clAe6uux aKT orHe3aKoHeH cbcraB - HaJrvr.tvre Ha ocHoBaHue 3a orBoA rro wt.29, a:l.l,6. ,,B"H|IK no orHorueHlle Ha rrneH na cr,ue6nvs. ercraB.

HAB Ng 261 2018 r., o6pa3yBaHo ro peAa na \r.424, at.l "p.

wr.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HilK [o r{cKaHe Ha 3auIr.ITHI{Ka Ha oclAenprs. C pe[reHl,Ie or

22.02.2018 r. crlrr e elso6HoBlrn BHOXA J\b 1073/ 2017 r. no orrr4ca Ha OC -flrosAue ra HOXA }lb 464L1 2015 r. rro orrr4ca sa PC-ilJIoBAI4B, orMeHI4JI eperxeHr4ero kr rrpl4cbAara v e BbpHan Aenoro Ha paitouuux cbA 3a HoBo

pa3rnex(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpraen e, qe rrpr4cbAara e r]ocraHoBeHa nptlAorrycHaTrr cT,uIecTBeHr4 HapylreHafl Ha npoqecyanHr'rTe rrpaBvna ilo cMlrcbJra

Ha qr. 1 3 u qn. 14 HIIK, KaKro u Ha \r.29, an2, up. 1 HIIK - He3aKoHeH cbcraBrro cMr.rcbrralaa vn.348, il.3, r.3, up.l HnK, [opaAl4 HiLrrHqI4e Ha ocHoBaHr4e 3a

0TBOA - ,,,I/.3flBJIeHIdg, HA IIbpBOHHCTaHIII'IOHHLIfl. CbA, C KOI'ITO e AeMOHCTpI,IpanrrpeABapureJrHo SoprrazpaHo craHoBr4ule (npegy6ex4enne) 3a racruHHocrra Ha

Sarrnre ro r{rl.102 HIIK".HAB l\b 486/ 2011 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa Ha'aL424, il.l np. tx.422,

N.I, r.5 HIIK no rrcKaHe Ha ocbAe*prfl. C peurenr{e or 07.11.2017 r. cbAbr esr:o6Honran BHOXA J\b Ill4l 2017 r. rro oruca na OC - Crapa 3aropa uHOXA J\b 37411 2016 r. rro orruca Ha PC Crapa 3aropa, orMeHr4Jr e

perrreHr{ero vr [prrcbAara H e BbpH€rJr Aenoro ua pafroHnur cr4 3a HoBopa3fne)KAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB 3a oTcTpaH{BaHe Ha AorrycHaTnTe HapyueHr4_{.flpuen e, qe cnaeiuusr aKT Ha oKpb)KHvrfl c'b1 He orroBapq rro cbAbpxaHr.re Ha

Lr3r.rcKBaHUfrTa no .Ir.339, N.2 HfIK, a pafionnuflT cr1 e Hapyrur4n rrplrHrllrrrareformatio in pejus, rsir Karo AeJroro e o6pa:yBaHo cneA orMrHa Ha rrpucbplmd,rrocraHoBeHa rlpu nbpBoro pa3rne)KAaHe Ha AeJroro, rro xraJr6a Ha noAcb4r4v'krrr{ He Moxte Aa 6t4e onpeAeneHo no-TexrKo HaKa3aHr4e.

HAB Ns 4731 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha'an.424, M.7 np. ut.422,M.l, r.5 HilK ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHr,r{ rpoKypop Ha PB. C perueHr{e or16.10.2017 r. crtrr e srso6HoBrrJr BHOXA Ns 12931 2016 r. rro onnca Ha OC -Crapa 3aropa n HOX! Ilb 2668i 2016 r. rro orrr4ca na PC-Crapa 3aropa,oTMeHr4Jr e pe[reHr,reTo vr [ptrcbAaTa u e BbpHan AeJroTo Ha

TIbpBoI4HCTaHIILIOHHVfl Cb.A 3a HOBO pa3rnexAaHe OT Apyf CbCTaB OT CTaAr{f, Ha

cr4e6uoro 3aceAaHLIe. fIpueJI e, qe Bb33r4BHrl.rrr cbA e rrorBbpArrn npr{c'b1ara,rlocraHoBeHa B rIpoLI3BoAcrBo rlo rn.27 HIIK 14 rrpv ycnoBrlrrra no qn.37l, r.2HIIK, rpu AotlycHaro or PC cbrrlecrBeHo HapyrreHr{e Ha rpoqecyurnHurerlpaBl{na - He e npno6quJl no HaAnexHr4fr peI- AoKa3aTeJrcrBaTa, cr6paHra uaAOCbAeOHOTO IpOUI3BOACTBO, A Bb33ZBHI{'T CbA He Ce e [por.r3Hecbn rIO

LI3JIOXeHI{Te AOBOAII B IIpOTeCTa.

HAB Ns 639/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo uo pe.qa Ha'rn.424, ffi.| rlp. un.422,N.l, r.5, HIIK uo rlcKaHe Ha uraBHr{r npoKypop na PB. C perueHr4e or20.02.2018 r. crArr e srso6HoBl{rl HOXA J\b 11681 2015 r. uo orrr4ca na PC -KtpAxanu, orMeHI,In e rpltcbl;ura Lr e BbpH€rrr Aenoro Ha Pn - KlpAxanu saHoBo pa3rnexAaHe BbB Sasara Ha ',{il or craAr4{ ,,fieircrB;ut Ha rrpoKypopa cneA3aBbpluBaHe Ha pa3cneABaHero". flpuen e, qe [pplcbAara e rrocraHoBeHa rroorHorrreHne Ha rIoAcbAlIM c pa3nr4qHo Sauunno LrMe or roBa Ha nr4rlero, cpeqyKoero e BoAeHo HaKa3aTeJrHoro npor43BoAcTBo.

HAB Ns 4341 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa :na'ar.424, il.I up. ut.422,il.l, r.5 HnK ro r{cKaHe Ha rJraBHrrr npoKypop Ha PE. C peureHr{e or

19.11.2018 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBr4rr HrIXI J\b 5285/ 2017 r. rro onr4ca Ha PC -flnoeAlae, I,I3MeHHJI e onpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHa crroro q6ara MexAyIIOACbAIIMaTa V nOCTpaA€LnATa) VI fO e OTMeHIIJI B rIaCTTa, B KOqTO nOACT,Ar4MaTa

ce e ilpl43Hara 3a BI{HoBHa B r{3BbprrrBaHe Ha rrpecrbrrJreHr,re rro qJr. I32, an 1, t.4, r;p..uI. 130, an. 2 HK u fi e HaJroxeHo HaKa3aHr{e. llpHen e, qe pafiouHraxrc:sA e AorrycHan cbrrlecrBeHo HapyueHr,re ua ut.24, wr.4, r.3 HIIK (clornerHowr.24, il.5, r.3 HIIK, B cuJra or 05.11.2017 r.), Aeficrsaq KbM MoMeHra Ha

IIocraHoB{BaHe Ha perxeHl4ero, rrfi Karo nocneAr4rlr{Te or cuoro46araI43KJI}OqBaT Bb3MO)KHOCTTa AeeUbT Aa Ce [pr43HaBa 3a Br{HOBeH r4 Aa Ce HaKZBBa.

HAB J\b 128/ 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha.m.424, an.l np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro HcKaHe Ha rJraBHZ-r npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or29.05.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr4Jr HOXA Jt|s 890/ 2016 r. rro orrr,rca Ha PC -Kaprono, orMeHr,rJr e pa3rropex{AaHero, c Koero Ha ocHoBaHne.rr.250 HIIK e

rrpeKpaTeHo HaKa3aTeJrHoTo npopr3BoAcTBo r,r MaTepr4anprTe ca r,r3npaTeHr4 Ha

MLrHLlCTbpa Ha LTKOHOMHKaTa 3a npnnafaHe Ha aAMr4HrrCTpUrr4BHUra nporleAypano'ar.424, aJr.Z,6. ,,8" IIP sa HK, u e BbpHaJr Aenoro Ha cbrrlr4q cbA 3a HoBopa3rnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAlrr ,,llpe4anaHe Ha ar1 u rroAForBr4TeJrHr4

4eficrnnr 3a pa3rJrexAaHe Ha AeJroro s crAe6Ho 3aceAaHr{e". llpuen e, qe PC eAOrrycH€Ln cbulecTBeHo Hapy[reHr4e Ha rrpoqecyanHr{Te frpaBHJra, KaTo B

nporleAypara no qr.248 rr cJr. H[IK, BMecro clc crAe6eH aKr rro cbrrlecrBoro Ha

AeJroro, ce e [pora3HecbJr c pa3rropexAaHe 3a rrpaBHara KBzlrrraQuraqufl. Ha

Ae.rrHr,rero, Karo ro e rrpeKB€lJrr$nqzpan B rro-ireKo rrpecrbrrneHr4e vr e

rrpeKparuJr HaKa3arerrHoro rrpoLr3BoAcrBo. (P Ne 28ll 2011 uo n.A. 15191 20Ilr., II n.o. BKC)

HAB Ng 2341 2018 r., o6pa^:yBaHo rro peAa Haqn.420, M.2 up. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK rro HcKaHe Ha ocbAela:zn. C peureru{e or 26.06.2018 r. ctArr e

Bb3o6HoBun HOXA Ns 3261 2017 r. ro orll4ca Ha PC - ftnt6oeo z BHOXA J\b

12791 2017 r. rro oruca na OC - Crapa 3aropa. Oruenur e rpLlcbAara Lr

perrreHr{ero r{ e BbpH€rn Aenoro na PII - frnt6oBo 3a HoBo pa3rnex(AaHe orSa:ara Ha AoctAe6Horo npoLI3BoAcrBo. llpraen e, qe ca HapyureHl4

lpoqecyanHlrre rrpaBa Ha ocbAe:aprfl B KaqecrBoro Ha o6suHser\,r rr Ha rIoAcbApIM

BbB Bpb3Ka C rrocotrBaHe Ha r{HAt4Bu4yanvBvrpaq}rTe cbcraBoMepHr{ nprI3HaII[Ha rrpecrtrlJleHvero rlo rrJI. 3436, a-rr. 3 HK.

[ena, srso6HoseHr{ Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHLIe: HIB J\b 631 2017 r.; HAB J\b

1461 2017 r.

1.3. .{era, nrso6HoneHlr Ha ocHoBaHl{ero rlo vn.348, il.l, r.3 HIIK -HaKa3aHHeTO e .rrBHO HeCrrpaBeAnI4BO.

HAB }lb 383/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa na'il.424, il.l rlp. ut.422,il.l, r.5 H|IK uo ucKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrs. C peurenne or 23.10.2017 r. csgrr e

srgo6Hosran BHOXA Ns 5761 2017 r. no orruca na OC - flnon4IaB, I43MeHarI e

pelrreHr4eTo B qacTTa, B Kof,To e IroTBbPAeg pa3Mepa Ha HaIIo)KeHI,ITe HaKa3aHut

Jrr{rrraBaHe or cno6o,4a 14 B qacrra 3a lrpl4no)KeHuero :na'il.23 HK, rato e

HaMa.rreH pa3Mepa uM. lIpHeJr e, qe ca Hanr{qe H Apyfv rlHilr4Bklilyanv3vparJr4

rlrr{Hocrra *r LeflHprrra o6crorreJrcrBa. Br: ocHoBa Ha HoB utJiocreH anaJrv3 vorIeHKa e HanpaBzn rr3BoA, rre HaKa3aHr4.rITa B onpeAeneHr{Te pa3Mepn H

orrpeAeneHoro Ha ocHoBaHrle \r.23 HK ca npeKoMepHo 3aBlIrueHH, H€

orroBapqr Ha rlenr4Te rro .{r.36 HK, uopa4r4 Koero ca qBHo HecrlpaBernvBklHAB J\b 6341 20L7 r., o6pasyBaHo rlo peAa Ha'il.424, an.I up. ut.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha ocbAeHr{r. C peurenr4e or 09.02.2018 r. cbAbr enrso6Honran BHOXA Jrlb 4241 2016 r. no orrr4ca na OC - llnon4raB, u3MeHHrI e

Bb33HBHara \pI,{CbAa B qacrra, B Kotro e [orBbpAeHa rlpl{cbAara Ha

IIbpBOITHCTaHTI?IOHHr4{ CbA IIO OTHOrrreHr4e Ha pa3Mepa HA HaIOXeHOTO

HaKa3aHI,Ie JII,I[IaBaHe or cno6o4a, orMeH]IJI f, e B qacrra, B Kotro e ttpnnoxeHut.23, an. 1 HK, ra B qacrra 3a pexr{Ma 3a lr3TbprrtBaHe Ha HaKa3aHlrero. llpraene, qe ABere cr4e6uu HHcraHrIHr4 He ca B3eJrr{ [peABIaA rlpeKoMepHara

rrpoAbDKr4TeJrHOcr Ha HaKa3areJIHOTO IpOr43BOACTBO, O6CTOSTeJICTBO OT

3HaqeHr{e 3a crrpaBeAnuBocrra Ha HaKa3aHrlero cbrnacHo rIpaKTI4Kara Ha ECITtIro rpunoxeHrdero Ha rrap.l K3ITqOC, v He ca rrpnnox{LrJlll KoMrleHcaropHl{tMexaHr43bM rlo vr.55, il.1, r.1 HK (P Ns 2991 12.06.2013 r. no HA J\b 9061 2013r., BKC, III H.o.)

Apyrn Aerra, srgo6HoseHr4 Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHr{e: H.{B Ns 312l 2017 r.;Hltr Np4691 2017 r.; HAB Ns5741 2017 r.; HAB l\b 155/ 2018 r.; HAB J\e 15i2018 r.; HAB J\b 638i 2018 r.; HIB ]',lb 568/ 2018 r.; HAB J\b 5671 2018 r.;HIF J\b 486/ 2018 r.; HAB J\e 112l 2018 r.; Hre Ns 41212018 r.

1.4. [em, m:o6uoBeHr4 Ha ocHoBaHue He[paB[nHo rrpr,rJro]r(eHr,re Ha

MaTepr{€rJrHr,rr 3aKoH Lr AonycHaTo cbrrlecTBeHo HapyrueHLre Ha rrpoqecy€urHr4Te

rrpaBuna (un.348, an.1 r.1 ur.2 HIIK).HAB }lb 120/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha'm.424, il.l sp. utr.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr.rr upoKypop na PE. C perxeHlre or30.03.2017 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBlrrr HOXA J,{b 338/ 2016 r. rro onvca na PC -Xapvrannr{, orMeHLrJr e olpeAeJreHnero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHrrero B

rIacTTa 3a HaKa3aTeJrHaTa oTfoBopHocT Ha ooBHHgeMvrTe) u e BbpHzIJr AenoTo Ha

cbulux cr4 3a HoBo pa3rnex(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAr{rr na cr4e6Horo3aceAaHr{e. llpnen e, qe pafioHnurr cbA e AorrycHirn HapyueHlre Ha 3aKoHa,

Karo HerrpaBunHo e npunolKr,rJr vr.55, il.1, r.2,6. ,,6" vr ar.3 FIK BMecro vr.55,il.1, r.1 HK 3a rrpecrbrlJleHl{e, 3a Koero e rrpeABLrAeH cfieqn€ureH Mr{Hr{MyM Ha

HaKa3aHr.rero JIIarrIaBaHe or cno6oAa, He e ylpaxHr4n rrpaBoMorrlr{rra cu rrowl382, an.5 HIIK u e o4o6pvn cropzByMeHvero B HapyrueHLre Ha 382, an.7HIIK.

HAB }lb 145/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa naw.424, il.l rlp. un.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHHr rrpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHrae or18.04.2017 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBlrJr HOXA Ng 26541 2016 r. ro oruca Ha PC -Crapa 3aropa, orMeHr4n e olpeAeneHrlero, c Koero e ogo6peHocnopa3yMeHplero, u e BbpH€LII Aenoro Ha cbulHr cbA 3a HoBo pa3fne)I(AaHe oT

Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe pairouuurrr cbA e o4o6pnJr BHeceHoro cnopa3yMeHr4eB HapyueHl4e Ha 'tt.382, an.7 HnK, rlft xaro pr3rrbJrHeHrrero Ha HaKa3aHr.rero e

orJlox{eHo npl4 ycnoBnflTauaun.66, an.1 HK,6es Aa ca Harrr4rle npeAnocraBKnTe3a roBa - o6nuuqeMr4rr ue e 6ul pea6urrurvpaH 3a npeAXoAHo ocbxAaHe.

HAB Ng 4931 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa na w.424, a:l..l vp. u.l..422,il.I, r.5 HnK rro r,rcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{r npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or17.L0.20I7 r. crabr e Bb3o6Honzr HOXA Ng 44711 2017 r. no oruca na PC -llrosAzs, orMeHI,IJr e onpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHr4ero 3a

pelxaBaHe Ha AeJIoTo, vI e BbpH€Lrr AenoTo Ha cbrrlr4r cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHeor Apyr cbcraB. IIpHen e, qe HenpaBr,rnHo e rrpr{Jro)r{eH Marepr4anHr{-fl 3aKoH -xnanuQurca\prflTa Ha AerHr4ero e Brrr4caHa Karo npecrbnJreHr4e rro wt.l97, r.3HK, nuecro rro .ur.l96 HK, ue e [peAnoxeHa npoMqHa vr crp.:.T e o4o6pr,rnclopa3yMeHHe, KoeTo lrpoTr4Bopeqpr Ha 3aKoHa, rrpH cbulecTBeHo Hapy[reHue HanpoqecyaJrHzTe rrpaBr{na ro cMLrcbra.{r.382, M.7 HnK.

HAB J\b 630/ 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa sa s1.424, il.l vp. wt.422,ar'.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHr,rr npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or29.01.20L9 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBl4n HOXA J\b 25 171 2018 r. no orrLrca na PC -Crapa 3aropa, orMeHr,rJr e o[peAeneHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6penocIIOpa3yMeHLIeTO, 14 e BbpH€rJr AenOTO Ha CbrrIXr CbA 3a HOBO pa3fne)rqaHe OT

Apyr cbcraB. llpnen e, qe cbAbr e AorrycHaJr HapyneHne Ha MarepvrarlF.r4fl3aKoH, Karo e ogo6pun c[opzr3yMeHr{ero, 6es Aa o6clAu Bbrrpoca 3a

HaKa3aHrrero JrLruraBaHe or rrpaBo, rrpeABLrAeHo B .rr.343r HK, [peABLrAo6nusenuero 3a r.r3BbprxeHo [pecrbrrneHr{e no qr.3436, an.3 HK, He e

rrpeAno)Klln IIpoMr}Ia v e AorrycH€rJr cbrrlecTBeHo HapyueHr{e Ha rrpoqecyarrHr{TerrpaBr{Jra rro cMracbtawr.38Z, an5 u anJ HnK.

HAB J\b 301/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa :aa'il.420, il.l up. w.422,M.I, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr{.f, npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHLre or28.06.2017 r. crgbr e Bb3o6Hoslrr HOXA l\b 1487i 2017 r. uo onr4ca na PC -llnosAzs, orMeHlrJI e onpeAeneHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHr,rero, r.r e

BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrrllrr cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnex(AaHe oT Apyf cbcraB oT cTaAlr,rna crAe6Horo cneAcrBr.re. flpuen e, qe ca AoflycHarlr ABe HapyrueHur Ha

Marepr4€rJrHr.rq 3aKoH - Ha wt.49, an.z lil<, 3arrloro cpoKbr Ha HaKa3aHr{ero

JrLrruaBaHe or rrpaBa no qn.343r HK e [o-Kpar6K or cpoKa Ha HaKa3aHvero

Jrlr[raBaHe or cBo6oAa, vr ua .u.28, an.1 HK - AerHrrero e KB€rluSu[upaHo KarorroBropHo rrpu nnrrca Ha npeArrocraBKr4 3a roBa. (ltrI l\b ll 1983 r. u TP J\b 6ll1980 OCHK, sa BC Ha PE). Karo e o4o6pzn cnopa3yMeHr.rero rrprr H€Lnr4qr4ero

Ha HapyueHLre Ha MaTepuurHufl,3aKoH, 6es Aa npeAnolKr{ npoMfHa, cbAbr e

AOnycH€rJr cbrrlecTBeHo HapyueHr,re Ha rrpoqecyanHr{Te rrpaBlrna IIo cMr{cbJla

wr.382, an. 5 u anJ HIIK.HAB Ns 2861 20Il r., o6pasyBaHo no pe.4a ua wr.420, M.2 rlp. wr.422,

M.1, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha 3arrlrrrHr4K. C perueHr,re or 1I.07.2017 r. cr4rr e

Bb3o6HoBur HOXA Ns 79441 2016 r. rro orrr4ca na PC - flnosAlan u BHFI{ Nl4561 2017 r. uo orruca Ha OC - llnosAzB, orMeHHn e orpeAeJreHr{ero, c Koero e

10

oAo6peHo c[opa3yMeHHeTo 3a pe[raBaHe Ha AenoTo 14 onpeAeneHl{eTo rlo.rn.306, an.l HnK 14 e BbpHan Aenoro 3a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe or cra\Vfl

,,feitcrnufl Ha rlpoKypopa cnetr 3aBbpuBaHe Ha pa3cneABaHero". llpuen e, qe

pafrouuurr cbA e AonycHan HapyrueHne Ha Marepr4aJrlavrfl 3aKoH, rlil xaro e

ogo6pun c[opa3yMeHrre c [porrrBopeqrlBo o6nuueuue, ofpaHl4r{uno

cbrrrecrBeHo npaBoro Ha noAcb rvM:afl ra ro paa6epe v [a ce 3aIIII4TI,I. C

o4o6prnane Ha cnopa3yMeHuero, Koero [porl4Bopequ Ha 3aKoHa, cbAbr eAorrycH€ur cburecrBeHo HapyueHl,Ie Ha npoqecyanHl{Te npaBl,Ina - wt.382, an7HIIK.

HAB J\b 3751 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa ua'aL424, il.I r;p.wt.422,M.l, r.5 HIIK rro ucKaHe Ha rJIaBHI4f, npoKypop Ha PE. C perreHl4e or23.10.20L'l r. cr[rr e Bb3o6HoBr{Jr HOXA Np 21941 2011 r. ro oruca na PC -llnon.{us, orMeHr.rJr e olpeAeJreHuero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHl4ero 3a

perxaBaHe Ha AenoTo B qacTTa 3a HaKa3aHI{eTo nHrIIaBaHe oT rlpaBo. llpuen e, qe

HerrpaBr4nHo e rpunolxeH .rr.343r HK Bp. wt.37, il.l, 'r.J HK, r'sir Karoo6suHsernrnqr He e npaBocroco6eu BoAaq Ha MIIC. Karo e o4o6pnncrropa3yMeHl4eTo, KOerO [poTl{Bopequ Ha 3aKOHa, CbAbT e AOlyCHancbrrlecrBeHo HapyueHLre Ha rrpoqecyaJrHr{Te npaBr{na IIo cMr,rcbna wr.382, M.7HIIK.

HAB }lb 595i 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa Ha \il.424, il.l np. wt.422,N.I, r.5 HIIK ro t4cKaHe HarJraBHu.r rpoKypop.C peruenkre or 22.11.2017 r.cbAbr e srso6HoBlrJr HOXA J\b 13671 2017 r. tro oruca Ha PC - Crapa 3aropa,H3MeHLrJr e olpeAeJreHuero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHllero B rlacrra, B

Korro e o[peAeJreH cTpof pexr{M 3a H3Tbprr{BaHe Ha HaKa3aHI{eTo JI}IlIaBaHe oT

cno6o4a, r4 e orrpeAeJrlrJr o6u na ocHoBaHHe ut57, M.I, r.3 3I,IH3C. llpner e,qe Karo e o4o6pun c[opa3yMeHr.rero rtpu Hurlurrlrero Ha HapyrxeHr{e Ha

}''{ATepI/AJTIJIJS. 3aKOH, CbAbT e AOrryCH€il CbITIeCTBeHO HapyIXeHI{e Ha

rpoqecyiilHr4re rrpaBllna no cMlrcbra\r.382, N.7 HnK.HAB }lb 156/ 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha qr.420, an.2 r;p. wl42\

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr4rr rpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHl{e or11.05.2018 r. cr4rr e erso6HoBrrJr HOXA Ns32ll 2017 r. ro onkrca Ha PC -flnr6ono, orMeHr{n e olpeAeneHuero, c Koero e oAo6peHo clopa3yMeHr{ero,c[opeA KoeTo B HapyueHlre Ha 3aKoHa e onpeAeneHo HaKa3aHr,re Jrr4rrraBaHe oT

ceo6o4a, BMecro H-flKoe or KyMynarr{BHo npeABr{AeHlrre B qr.197, r.2 lil(HaK€BaHLrx - upo6ar\vrfl vrJrvr uo6a, pr e BbpHaJr Aenoro Ha cbrrln.rr cbA 3a HoBopa3rnexAaHe. llpzen e, qe PC e AorrycHaJr cbrrlecrBeHo HapyrxeHrle Ha

rpoqecyarHure rrpaBI4na rlo cMrlcbrra Ha.{r.382, ar-..5 u an.7 HIIK Karo He errpeAnoxzn [poMrHa Ir e oAoopun clopzr3yMeHr.re, KoeTo [poTlrBopeqr4 Ha

3aKOHa.

HAB }lb 57l 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa ua wr.420, M.2 np. wr.422,an.l, r.5 HnK no ucKaHe Ha uraBHr,r.rr upoKypop na PE. C perreHr4e or09.03.2018 r. cr4br e Bb3o6Honur HOXA JS 6682/ 2017 r. ro oruca na PC -llnonAus, oTMeHHJI e onpeAeneHlrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHr{ero, u e

1l

BbpHan Aenoro Ha cb[Izq cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe or Apyf cr,craB. llpuel e,r{e e Ao[ycHaro HapytrreHne Ha 3aKoHa - ut.67, an.3 HK, 3au]oro e o4o6peuoclopa3yMeHne, cnopeA Koero ca nocraHoBeHr{ 4ne upo6arlr4oHHr4 MepKr4 nowr.42a, an2, r.l-4 HK npes r43rrr{rarerr:a:afl cpoK BMecro eAHa (P-528-2013,BKC, III H.o., P-312-20I1, BKC, I H.o.) 14 cbqecrBeHo HapyrueHr{e HailpoqecyanHrrre rrpaBrana no cMr{cbra:aawt.382, at.5 u ar.7 HIIK.

Apyru Aerra, nrso6Hoeenr Ha cbqoro ocHoBaHne: HIB Ns 20l 2018 r.;HAB llb 6/ 2018 r.; HIB J'.lb 4951 2018 r.; HIB Ns2991 2018 r.; HAB J\b 115/2018 r.; Hre J\b 355/ 2017 r.

2. AuerarzneH cbA - Bapna.2.1.,{era, nrso6HoseHra Ha ocHoBaHHe HelpaBunHo nptrno}KeHue Ha

Marepr4anHn.rr 3aKoH (un.348, il.1, r.1 HIIK).HAB J\b 410/ 2016 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ula'aL420, an.Z n,p. un.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK rro LIcKaHe Ha ocbAeHuq, qpe3 3arrlraTHr.rK. C pelreHne or25.0I.2017 r. cbAbr e erso6HoBIaJI BHOXA J\b 1461 2016 r. rro orrr4ca na OC -L[yueu, orMeHr{n e perreHrrero r{ rpr{cbAara uo HOXA Ns 14001 2014 r. na PC

LL[yueH, Karo e [plr3Harr ocbAeHrar 3a HeBr,rHeH 14 ro e olpaBAan frorloBAplrHaroro My o6euHeHze. llpuen e, qe ABere crAe6upr r,rHcraHrluu ca

AOnycHanLI HapyueHze Ha 3aKoHa c ocb)nAaHeTo Ha IIoAcbAIdMIdfl 3a AeflHLre)Koero He e rrpecrbrrneHlre - qn.24, M.l, r. 1 HIIK (TP Is3/ 2013 r. OCfTK,BKC).

HAB J\b 661 2017 r., o6pa^:yBaHo ro peAa Ha'il.424, M.l "p.

wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro rrcKaHe Ha rJraBHurr rpoKypop Ha PB. C perxeHue or1I.04.201'l r. csry'sr e nrso6HoBlrJr HOXA }tb 3653/ 2016 r. ro oruca sa PC -BapHa, orMeHr{Jr e olpeAeneHr4ero, c Koero e oAo6peHo c[opa3yMeHueroropaAr{ AorlycHaro HapyueHr{e Ha 3aKoHa B qacrra 3a rrpuno}KeHuero naw. 66,an.l HK rro orHolueHrre Ha HuliroxeHoro HaK€BaHr4e JrurrraBaHe or cso6ona u eBbpHan AenoTo Ha cslIllr_f, cbA 3a HoBo pa3fne)KAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB oT cTaAHrr

na crAe6Horo 3aceAaHLre. flpuen e, qe PC He e B3eJr rpeABLrA crrpaBKara 3a

cbAlrMocr na o6eraHflewurfl' or Korro ce ycraHoBflBa, qe He e 6ral peaiulurlrpaHrro npaBo 3a [peAr'truHo ocb)r(AaHe c BJu3Jra B cr,{na fiplrcbAa. ,{ouycnaro e

cbrrlecrBeHo HapymeHlre no .rr.382, M.J HIIK.HAB }lb 21l 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa ua \r.424, a*l

"p. wr.422,

il.l, r.5 HilK ro r{cKaHe Ha rJraBHLrr rpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHlre or11.05.2017 r. crg'sr e srso6HoBr{Jr qHA Ns22I3l 2016 r. uo oruca na PC -Bapua, orMeHr{Jr e olpeAeJreHLrero, nocraHoBeHo rro peAa sa qn.306, ar.1, r.1H[IK, u e BbpHiur Aenoro Ha cbrrlr{r cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne)r(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB.llpuen e, qe PC e AolycH€rJr HapyureHr4e Ha 3aKoHa rrpn olpeAenf,He Ha o6uloroHaKa3aHr.re no .rr.25

"p. 'il.23 HK, raro e B3en npeABr4A caMo HaKa3aHlrf,Ta IIorreTr,rpu oT freTTe BJre3Jrr..r B avJla flpvcb4ll, BsrrpeKr{ HarruqpreTo Ha ocHoBaHr4{ IIoOTHOIIIEHI4E HA B CLI IIKLI.

t2

HAB i\b 63i 2017 r., o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Ha qn.420, ar.z Bp. qn.422,

a1.1, r.5 HnK rro LrcKaHe Ha oc:bAeHr4r, r{pe3 3aIIIHTHI4K. C pelxeHrre or11.05.2017 r. cr,g'sr e erso6HoBr4rr BHOXA Ns 430/ 2016 r. no onr4ca na OC -!o6puv, r43MeHr4Jr e Bb33r.rBHoro peueHlre, rpeKnanr,r$nqvpan e AerHuero KarorrpecrbrrneHne no .rr.3436, al.l HK 14 ro e orMeHI4JI B rlacrra, B Kofro e

onpeAeneH Tnrra Ha 3arBopHr{qecKoro 3aBeAeHIle B HapyureHl4e Ha .Ir.58

3I4H3C, cbrJracHo H3MeHeHr4ero, BJrr3Jro B cuJra na 07.02.2017 r. llprEerr e, qe

rrpaBHara rcnanv$uxarJurfl, Ha Aefl:aprero e He3aKoHocro6pasua, rl'.it. Karo He ca

B3err{ rrpeABr{A AaHHr{Te 3a Hacrbnvrarapea6uxura\vrfl no npaBo rro [peAr4rrrHo

ocbx{AaHe.

HAB l\b l15l 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa lr'aw.420, il.l n,p. wt.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHuq rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHlre or17.05.201J r. c'sxsr e nuo6HoBr{n HOXA }lb 1641/ 2016 r. rro ourrca na PC -[o6pnv, orMeHr4Jr e olpeAeJreHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHuero, r4 e

BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrrlur cbA 3a HoBo puBrne)K4aHe or Apyf cbcraB. llpuer e,.{e PC e AorrycHan HapyueHr.re Ha Marepvreurnurs.3aKoH rro cMlrcbJra Ha wt.49,a*Zlil{ - cpoKbr Ha olpeAeJreHoro B crropa3yMeHr,rero HaKa3aHHe nkrrxaBaHe orrrpaBa e rro-KparbK or cpoKa Ha Hul[or(eHoro HaKa3aHve Jrr{rxaBaHe or cso6oAa.(f[I Ne Il 1983 r. z TP ]lb 61/ 1980 OCHK, na BC Ha PE).

HAB Ns 2331 2016 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha w.420, M.I yp. utr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro I4cKaHe Ha DraBHLrq npoKypop Ha PE. C perueHue or25.05.201J r. crilrr e nrso6HoBlrrr rIHA Np 23021 2013 r. rro onr{ca na PC -Bapna, orMeHI{JI e olpeAeJleHlrero r4 e BbpH€rJr Aenoro Ha cbrrlr4rr cbA 3a HoBopa3fnel(AaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB 3a oTcTpaH.flBaHe Ha AorrycHaToTo HapyrxeHr,re IIorpvno)KeHlrero na 3I,IH3C. llpuen e, qe e rocraHoBeHo or PC B HapyueHr{e Ha

Marepu€rnHrrr 3aKoH, Karo He e [pLrJro)KeH wt.57, il.l, T.2,6.,,,8" 3p{H3C rI He eonpeAeneH cTpof pex{LIM 3a rr3TbprrrBaHe Ha HaKa3aHLreTo, [pLrBeAeHo B

Lr3rrbJrHeHVe Ha ocHoBaHlre .rr.68 HK.HAB Ns 2821 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa na \r.420, M.2 n,p. un.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha ocbAelr'vrs. C perueuue or 26.10.2017 r. crAm e

erso6Honur HOXA }lb I4Il 2016 r. ro orvca na PC - Ky6par, r{3MeHr,rJr e

rrplrcbAara B qacrra 3a pexr{Ma, Karo Ha ocHoBaHlze wt.57, il.l, r.3 3I4H3C e

orrpeAenun rIbpBoHatI€uIeH o6q pexLrM 3a r43TbprrrBaHe Ha HaK€BaHLrero Lr eorMeHr,rJr B r{acrra 3a oflpeAereHr{s rnrr 3arBopHkrqecKo 3aBeAeHHe. llpzen e, qe

PC e AorlycHzrn HapylxeHvre Ha Marepr{€ilHr{s 3aKoH, Karo e onpeAenr/u pe)Kr.rMa

rrprd ycnoBvrflTa ua w.57, M.2 Bp. il.l, r.3 3['IH3C, Ho He e MorrrBrrpanseo6xoAlaMocrra or H€IJIaraHero Ha rro-Te)r{bK pexr,rM, vr laa.rr.58 3['IH3C Karoce e [por43HecbJl rro Bbupoc, rcofiro e or KoMrrereHTHocr Ha 3arBopHr.rqecKaraaAMLrHr{CTpAr\Us..

HAB J\b 1211 2017 r. rro peAa :na'm.424, il.l sp.wr.422,M.l, r.5 HilKrro r{cKaHe Ha rJIaBHzr trpoKypop na PE. C peureHlre or 19.06.2017 r. crArr e

nrso6Honnl BHHI J\b 58/ 2017 r. rro orrrica Ha OC - Bapna, orMeHr{rr e

peueHl4eTo I{ e BbpHuLn AenoTo Ha cbrur{fl a'b4 3a HoBo pa3fne)KAaHe oT Apyf

t-l

cr'craB or craAaq Ha cbAe6Horo 3aceAaHr4e. llpraen e, qe oKpr,xrHr4rr cr,AHeIIpaBI{nHO e [pI4nOX{rrJr MaTepnairHr4r 3aKoH, KaTo e r.r3MeHun o[peAeireHr4eToHa pafiouHH.a cbA B qacrra 3a Mecrorr3rrbJrHeHr4ero Ha [pr4HyAuTenHaraMeArrrII4HcKa M{pKa no .{r.89,6. ,,8" HK n e oilpeAeJrr4Jr ocBr{AerencrBaHzrfrT [a6rle HacraHeH B MeAr4rIr4HcKo 3aBeAeHr4e, Koero He e crrerlr4ann3vrpaHalcuxrrarpvqna 6orHIaqa, a o6ur<uoBeHo rrcuxo-HeBponorplrlHo 3aBeAeHrre, B

KOeTO H.{Ma pa3KpI4TO Cnerlr4arrHo OTAeneHr4e.

HAB l\b 25ll 2017 r., o6pa:ynaHo ro peAa Ha'm.424, N.I n,p. wr.422,an.l, r.5 HIIK no rzcKaHe Ha rJraBHu{ npoKypop Ha PB. C perxeHrle or21.01.2017 r. crarr e erso6HoBr.rrr HOXA J\le 6210/ 2016 r. no orrr4ca ua PC -BapHa, orMeHr,rJr e peureHr4ero r,r e BbpHarr Aenoro Ha cbrrlus, cr1 3a HoBo

pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe PC e AonycHan HapyrreHue Ha

3aKoHa Karo e ocBo6oAun noAcbAvrvrvrfl or HaKa3areJrHa orroBopHocr r4 My eH€Lrroxr.rJr aAMLrHLrcTpaTr4BHo HaK€BaHr{e IIpu rvlIca Ha rrpeAnocTaBKr.r oT

rrpe.{Br4AeHr4Te n qn.78a HK.HAB }lb 2091 2017 r., o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Ha ,rr.424, M.l n,p. wt.422,

arI, r.5 HIIK rro LrcKaHe Ha r.lraBHv.a rpoKypop Ha PE. C perreHrre or2I.08.2017 r. crlrr e Bb3o6HoBLrJr HOXA J\b 50/ 2017 r. no orrdca Ha PC -Pa:rpa4, orMeHlrJr e onpeAeJreHlrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHlrero, r,r e

BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrrlr{{ cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpner e,

ue pafiourrnflT cbA He[paBrrJrHo e [puno)Kr,{n MarepvraJr:nr4fl 3aKoH - wt.42a, at.4r;p. at.2, r.2 HK, Karo He e H&rrox.prrvr ABere [peABr{AeHrr Karo 3aAbJD{rkrreJIHI{

upo6aqraoHHr,r MepKvr 3a r43BTprueHoro rlpecrbrlneHl{e. Hapyurun e un.382, ar.5u a*J HIIK Karo He e npeAnoxvn npoMfllaa, v e o4o6pun clopa3yMeHue, KoerorrpoTr4Boperrr4 Ha 3aKoHa.

HAB Ns 2671 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa :r'a'aL420, an.2 rlp. wr.422,ffi.|, r.5 HilK ro HcKaHe Ha rJraBHLrf, ilpoKypop Ha PB. C perxeHne or19.09.2017 r. crtrr e srgo6HoBzrr BHOXA J\b 133/ 2016 r. rro orruca na OC -Trproauqe, LI3MeHuJI e Bb33LIBHoro pelueHl{e, Karo e [punox(LIJI 3aKoH 3a rro-IreKo HaKa3yeMo upecrbrrneHue IrpeKB€L[Ll$vqupan e AetHnero orrrpecrbrrneHue uo .rr.3436, at.2 HK xaro rpecrbrneHl4e no qn.3436, N.l Iff.flpuen e 3a rrpaBr4rrna KoHcrara\r4fl'ra Ha OC, qe uo orHorrreHr4e Ha ocbAeHklt e

HacTbrrI{JIa IIbJrHa peaounLrTar\Lrg., 3aToBa To3rI c5.4 e ol4n AnbxeH Aa I43MeHI{

rrplrcbAara B rracrra 3a KBarrraQzraqu-ara Ha AesHr4ero, BMecro Aa { norBbpApl.HAB J\b 339/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa :aa'il.424, il.l np. wt.422,

wr.l, r.5 HIIK ro rrcKaHe Ha rJIaBHI4t rpoKypop Ha PE. C peIueHI,Ie or28.09.2011 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBr.rJr BHOXA Ns 9/ 2011 r. ro orrca na PC -Cutmcrp4 r43MeHLrJr e perueHr{ero B rracrra, B Ko.rrro e oupeAeneH pexc{Ma 3a

I43TbprItBaHe Ha HaKZBaHI'IeTO, I{ fO e OTMeHT4JI B tIaCTTa, B KOTTO e OlpeAeneHTr4rra Ha 3arBopHr{qecKoro 3aBe,qeHue. llpraeJr e, qe oKpb)KHI4f,T cbA e AonycH€LnHapylleHus, HA MaTepI,Ia[HI{t 3aKOH, KaTO e onpeAenlln nbpBoHar{aJlHt4.fl pe}KIIM

3a r{3TbpnsBaHe Ha HaKa3aHr4ero B HapyueHr4e Ha un.57, M.l, r.2 3W13C pr e

t4

onpeAenHJr Tara Ha 3aTBopHr4qecKoTo 3aBeAeHHe, KoeTo e oT KoMrreTeHTHocT Ha

3arBopH llrlecKara aAMHHI4OT pa\v\fl , B HapyueH ue Ha .In. 5 8 3I,1H3 C.HAB J\b 350/ 20ll r., o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Ha qn.424, arr.7 Bp. qn.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HIIK ro t4cKaHe Ha rJraBHHr rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or02.10.2017 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBr4Jr HOXA J\b 17l 2017 r. rro orrr4ca na PC -VIctepux, r{3MeHI4n e onpeAeneHraero, c Koero e oAo6peHo c[opa3yMeHlrero B

r{acTTa, B KotTo e o[peAeneH pe)KrrMa 3a r43TbplqBaHe Ha HaK€BaHI4eTo

JII4IrIaBaHe Or CnO6OIIA] 14 fO e OTMeHT{Jr B rraCTTa, B KOTTO e O[peAeJIeH TI4IIa Ha

3arBopHr4r{ecKoro 3aBeAeHHe. llpnen e, qe cbAbr e Ao[ycHzln HapymeHr4e Ha

MaTepI,I€LnHI'Iq 3aKOH, KaTO e OlpeAenr4n rrbpBoHaqullrHr4{ pexHM 3a z3TbprrrBaHeHa HaKa3aHr4ero Ha ocHoBanr4e wt.57, ar'I, r.2 u r.3 3IrIH3C v rLrna Ha

3aTBOpHI{TIeCKOTO 3aBeAeHI4e, KOeTO e OT KOMIIeTeHTHOCT Ha 3aTBOpHLrqeCKaTa

aAMrr Hr,rcrp ar1Lrfl, B HapyueHr{e Ha .rn. 5 8 HIIK.HAB }lb 44ll 2017 r. o6pasyBaHo no peAa na w.424, M.I np. un.422,

M.l, r.5 HnK no HcKaHe Ha ruraBHr4r rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHlre or15.02.2018 r. cbAbr e stso6HoBLrrr .{HA Ns 24491 20ll r. rro orrnca na PC -Bapna, orMeHzJr e o[peAeJreHrrero, nocraHoBeHo rro peAa lr'a.rn.25 up. wt.23HK, z e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrrlzr cbA 3a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB.llpzen e, qe e Ao[ycHaro HapyrxeHr4e Ha Marepr4€LrrHlrr 3aKoH, Karo e

orrpeAeneHo o6IIIo HaKa3aHr,re oT Hirlox(eHLrTe rro Tpr{ oT BJre3JrlrTe B cuJranpvcT4vr, KoI{To ca B oTHolueHr{e Ha peql{AuB) a He B peaJrHa cbBKyrrHocT.

H[n Ns 25ll 2018 r. o6pasyBaHo rro peAa :na'il.424, an\ vp. wl42\M.l, r.5 HIIK no ucKaHe Ha ocbAenvrfl. C peureurre or 19.01.2018 r. cr4rr e

etso6Hoszn HOXA J\b 65121 2016 r. ro orrr{ca na PC - Bapna, r{3MeHr4Jr erlpLIcbAara, Karo e flpeKB€uluouqupan AerHr4ero, HarroxuJr e HaKa3a]FIue rno6a ue orlpaBAarl noAcbAI{MIlt rro nbpBoHaqarrHoro o6snHeHne. OrnaeHral e

npucbAara B rlacrra, B Kof,To e [p[no)KeH qn.68 HK sa HaKa3aHl{ero, HaJIox(eHoc BJrs3Jra B cura [pr4cbAa rro Apyro Aeno. llpraen e, qe paitounuxr cbA e

AOTIyCHaJI HapyIUeHLIe Ha 3aKOHa, KaTO He e B3eJr [peABr{A HULnUqLTeTO Hao6cro-areJlcrBa or npeABuAeHLITe B vn.93, r.9 HK Lr He e rnalHsraqvrpaJrAerHprero Karo M€uroBDKeu clyrafi.

HAB Ns 168/ 2018 r. o6pasyBaHo rro peAa Ha'il.424, M.l np. ut.422,M.I, r.5 Hltr( ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHLrr npoKypop Ha PE. C peureHr.re or07.08.2018 r. crAtr e sBo6HoBI,IrI BHOXA Ns 3521 2017 r. ro orrrlca na OC -Cu:nucrpa n HOXI ]lb 358/ 2017 r. uo oruca na PC - Cranzcrpa, orMeHLrJr eperreHl4ero I{ upucbAara u e BbpH€rn Aenoro Ha PC 3a HoBo pa3rnex(AaHe orApyr cbcraB or cral.r4ri Ha pa3rropeArrreJrHoro 3aceAaHkre. llpzel e, qepafioHHurr cbA HenpaBunHo e rrpnnoxr4n qn.54 HK, raro e HaJroxr{Jr HaK€BaHr.re

rroA MLrHr{MyMa, rrpeABr.rAen e.rr.343n, an.2 HK.Apyru AeJIa, srso6HoeeHu Ha cbuloro ocHoBaHr4e: HIB ]le 53/ 2018 r.;

HAB J\b 361 2018 r.; HIB ]''{b 110/ 2018 r.; HAB J\b 7/ 2018 r.; HIB Ns 53/2018 r.; HAB }lb 99l 2017 r.; HIB Ns23612018 r.; (lIlIBC Ns 4/ 1965 r.,r.9,vrperueHr4e J\|l 11/ 1987 r. OCHK na BC).

l-s

2.2. {era, nrso6HoseHi{ Ha ocHoBaHrre AonycHaro cr,ii{ecrBeHoHapyrueHvre Ha rrpoqecy€uHr4re rtpaBlrna (.rn.348, an.l, r.2 HIIK).

HBA Jrlb 4821 2016 r. o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua'ar.424, an.l vp. url422,an.I, r.5 HIIK ilo rrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHara, qpe3 3arqr4THr4K. C peureHne or24.03.2017 r. cbAbr e nrso6HoBurr HOXA J\s 959/ 2016 r. rro onraca na PC -Cutmcrpa, orMeHrlJr e o[peAeneHr{ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHr4ero 3a

perxaBaHe Ha AenoTo, 14 fo e BbpHan Ha cbrr{H{ cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe oT

Apyr cbcraB or cra.{ufl, Ha cr4e6uoro 3aceAaHrae. llpraeJr e, tre ca Hapy[IeHI4

ilpoqecyanHuTe rrpaBr4na no qn.382, N.6 u 7 HIIK, rrit Karo crpaHrlTe ca ce

IIOAIIUCaIU CneA BrrLrCBaHe Lr OAOOp-fBaHe Ha C[Opa3yMeHI{eTO, a KaTO rIaCT OT

cbAbpx{aHl{eTo My e BIILICaHO I4 olpeAeneHI,IeTO, IIocTaHoBeHo IIO peAa Ha.rr.306, M.I, r.3 H[IK, c Koero c6Abr ce e [pov3HecbJl no qn.68 HK, euecto corAenHo orrpeAeJreHr,re, B HapyrxeHHe Ha .rr.381, an.5 u an.S H[IK,,,.qoflbJlBafiru, ue B Ta3u rracr noAnex{LI Ha o6xalteaHe".

HAB }lb 106/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa :na'rr.420, an.2 rlp. wl42\il.1, r.5 HIIK rro HcKaHe Ha ocbAeHara. C peureur{e or 04.05.2017 r. clAlr e

erso6Hosun BHOXA Ns 1661 2016 r. no orr{ca Ha OC - Cr.rnncrpa, orMeHLIJr e

perrreHlrero, c Koero e rrorBspAeHa rrpllcbAara uo HOXA Ns 1651 2015 r. na PC

- r{ynono, u e BbpHan Aenoro Ha oKpbxr^prs. cr4 3a HoBo pa3rnex(.{aHe or ApyrcbcraB. llpuen e, rre PC e AouycHan cblrlecrBeHo HapyueHlle Ha lpaBoro Ha

3arrlr,rTa Ha rroAcbAr.rMaTa, Karo ne fi e [peAocTaBLIJI Bb3Mo)ItHocr Aa ynpaxGurrpaBoro cv Aa AaAe odr'clr'euut, BKJI. vr cneA pa3nI,ITa Ha Beurl4 nHIIa ucBr4AereJrpr, 3a Koero 3auIr{THLrKbr e HanpaBun LIcKaHe. B [poroKonllTe orcrAe6uure 3aceAaHvt He e orpa3eHo A€lJrr4 e p€t:tcHeHo rlpaBoro Aa AaBa vrnv Aa

orKa)r{e ra AaBa o6scsenus no o6suHeHuero.HAB l,{b 39/ 20ll r. o6pa":yBaHo rlo peAa nast.420, anZ np. tt.422, at.l,

r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha ocbAuavrs, qpe3 3auIurHLrK. C perueHue or 19.05.2011 r.c6A:nr e srso6HoBrtJr BHOXA J\b 110/ 2016 r. no onnca na OC - Pa:rpa,4,

oTMeHr4Jr e perxeHlreTo r{ e BbpHan Aenoro Ha CbIIIV.'I cbA 3a HoBo pa3fne)KAaHe

or Apyr cbcraB 3a orcrpaHsBaHe Ha HapymenvrflTa rlo trJl.l3, un.14 u.rr.107H|IK BbB Bpb3Ka cbc cr6npaue, [poBepKa u orIeHKa Ha AoKa3areJlcrBara.flpzel e) rre Bb33r.rBHLr-f,T cbA He e o6ctAur cr6panure ilo AeJIoro

AOKa3aTeJrCTBa r.r He e Cl6pan AoITbIHI4TeJIHI'I 3a pa3KpI{BaHe sa O6erU{BHaTa

wetr4Ha, ueo6xo,quMu npu SopunpaHe Ha BbrpelxHoro y6exAeHLIe.

Hrc J\b 356/ 2017 r. o6pasyBaHo rlo peAa na'an.420, an2 np. wr.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HIIK uo HcKaHe Ha ocbAeHlrr, qpe3 3aITILITHLIK. C perreHl{e or06.11 .2017 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr,rJr BHOXA Ns 2391 2016 r. no orll{ca na OC -Ttpronraule, orMeHr{n e peneHrrero r4 e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cblIlvrfl, ub4 3a HoBo

pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craplvrfl na ctAe6Horo 3aceAantre.llpueu e, qe e

AorrycHaro cbxlecrBeHo npoqecy€rJrHo HapyueHlre no cMLIcbIra:na vn. 348, an.

3,r.2, np. 1, Bp. il. 1,r.2 HIIK - perreHl4ero HtMa MorI,IBI4.

l6

HAB J\b 363/ 2017 r. o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Ha qn.424, ar.I Bp. sn.422,an.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHH{ npoKypop Ha PB. C pemeHr4e or06.11.2011 r. cr,Abr e er:o6uoBrrJr Br{Htr J{s 671 2Al7 r. rro oilIzca ua OC -TlpronHqe, orMeHlrn e oilpeAeneHprero 14 e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrt1r4r cbA 3a

HoBo pa3rne)r(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe oupeAeneHr4ero e [ocraHoBeHooT He3aKOHeH CbCTaB nopa.qu HaJIrIrII4e Ha OCHOBaHpTe 3a OTBOA rIO CMI4CbJIa

wt.29, an.2 HIIK ro orHorreHr,re Ha qreH ua clAe6Hkrfl a'bcraB.

HAB J\b 159/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha \r.424, il.I up. ut.422,il.l, r.5 HnK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHn{ rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHr,re or05.06.2017 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBlrrr HOXA Ns 365/ 2017 r. rro orrr4ca Ha PC -Lllyruen, orMeHraJr e o[peAeneHnero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHuero, r4 roe BbpHan na PII - IllynreH 3a HoBo pa3rne)r(AaHe or cra4r4s ,,leficrnrafl Ha

[poKypopa cneA 3aBbplrBaHe Ha pa3cneABaHero". llpuen e, qe pafionuzrr cb.{HerpaBr4nHo B HapyrreHr4e Ha qn.382, M.7 HIIK e o4o6przn cropa3yMeHr4ero, cKoero e olpeAeJleHo HaKa3aHrIe rrpu ycnoBr{rra na qr.55, a1.1,r.2,6. ,,6" f[IC,BMeCTO Aa BbpHe AenoTo Ha llpoKypopa u Aa ce rpol{3Hece B upoLr3BoAcTBo norur. 28 HIIK.

HAB J\b 1971 2017 r., o6pa^:yBaHo rro peAa ua w.424, il.I rlp. urr.422,il.I, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHurr rrpoKypop na PE. C perxeHr{e or04.09.2017 r. c'stbr e Bb3o6Hosnr rpoLr3BoAcrBoro no HOX! Ng 3441 2016 r.rro orrvea Ha PC - fienux, u e BbpHzIn Aenoro Ha ctrrlurr cbA 3a HoBopa3rnex{AaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craA}r{ Ha cbAe6Horo 3aceAaHr{e. llpuen e, qe

paitonuvtxr cbA HenpaBl4nHo e o4o6pun cropa3yMeHr{ero B HapyueHlre Ha

vn.384, an.3 HIIK - Jrr,r[ca Ha cbrJracr4e Ha crpaHa - qacreH o6sr.rHrarer.Hltr Ns 4361 2011 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa naw.424, il.l rlp. ut.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha DraBHLrs rpoKypop Ha PF. C perueHr{e or06.12.2017 r. crtbr e Bb3o6noszr HOXA J\b 5505/ 2016 r. ro oruca na PC -Bapua, orMeHI{JI e olpeAeJleHuero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopinyMeHrrero, v IBbpHan AenoTo Ha cblqut cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnelKAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB oT cTaAprtHa pa3rropeAr{TeJrHoTo 3aceAaHr.re. llpzen e) qe c6AbT e o4o6puncropa3yMeHr{ero B HapyueHlre Ha qn.38l, a:l.'3 HIIK np. vn.382, an7 HIIK - He

ca Bb3cTaHoBeHI4 lldlrVr O6e:Ueqenn [puqr.rHeHnTe c [pecrbrrJreHr{eToLrMyulecrBeHr4 BpeArl. (TP l,{s ll 2013 r. OCFIK na BKC)

HAB Ns 231 2018 r., o6pa^:yBaHo ro peAa na'm.424, N.l "p.

wr.422,il.I, r.5 HIIK uo zcKaHe Ha ocbAeHr4r, qpe3 3arrlrlTHr.rK. C peureHlre or30.04.2018 r. cr.qrr e srgo6HoBr,rJr BHOXA J\b 185/ 20ll r. no orrr{ca na OC -Pasrpag, orMeHI4Jr e peuleHl,Iero Lr e BbpH€ur .qenoro Ha cbrrlufl. cr1 3a HoBopurrne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpzer e, qe pe[reHr4ero e rrocraHoBeHo [pr4AOtIyCHaTU CbIr{eCTBeHLI Hapy[reHH.f, Ha [poqecyalHr{Te npaBr4na - HrMaMorI4BI4 Lr rlporoKonbr or cr4e6noro 3aceAaHne He e [o.qrrrzcaH orrpe.qceAarelrfl Ha cl4e6nux cbcraB (vn.311, an2 HIIK). (Peruenze J\lt 93118.05.2015 r. na BKC ro H.A. 331 2015 r., II u.o., PerueHr4e J\b 682/ 2000 r. HaBKC no H.A. 6461 2000 r., II n.o.)

11

HAB i\b 85/ 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo ilo peAa na w.420, al.Z yp. un.422,ar.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha ocbAeHnfl. C perueuue or 30.05.2018 r. cbAr,r e

erso6Hoslan BHOXA J\|l 1661 2017 r. no onuca na OC - Trproeuxr€, orMeHr4.r

e perxeHr4ero, c Koero e norBr,pAeHa rrpr4cbAara no HOXA i\b 821 2015 r. noonuca Ha PC - Onayprar) Lr ro e lr3MeHlrJr, Karo e onpaBAaJr [oAcbAr4Mkrfl rronbpBoHaqilrrHo rroBAr4rHaroro o6nuueHr,re rro wr.235, anl HK. llpueJr e, qe

nbpBoI4HcTaHIII4OHHUqT 14 B633r'rBHlrrT CbA He Ca Ce npOr43HeCnH rIO TOBa

o6ezHeHue.

Apyru [era, srso6HoseHr4 Ha c:brrloro ocHoBaHlre: H.{B Ns 161/ 2017 r.;HAB Ns 1181 2018 r.; HIB ]\b 12312018 r.; HAB NpI47l20l8 r.; HAB J\b 352l2018 r.; HlB Ns20412018 r. HIB Ns4781 2016 r.; HIB Ns 159/2018 r.

2.3. fierre. nrso6HoBeHr,r Ha ocHoBaHuero no .rr.348, a1.1, r.3 HIIK -H€LIIOXeHOTO HaKa3aHue e

'BHO HeCnpaBeAnLIBO.

HAB J\l.l 458i 20L7 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa ua w.424, M.I np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK rro r{cKaHe Ha ocbAeHr4. C peruenr4e or 05.12.2017 r. cr4rr e

srso6Hosran BHOXA J\b 9451 2017 r. rro orrnca na OC - BapHa, Lr3MeHr.rJr e

[pr{cbAara, Karo Ha ocHoBaHurrrra no ur.55, il.l, r.1 HK e HaMairur (nuecroorrpeAenr4n) pa^:rraepa Ha Huuro)r(eHr4Te HaKa3aHLIfl lrvrrraBaHe or cno6oAa u uo6arroA Hafi-Hr{cKr,rr npeAen. llpnen e, qe cbAe6Hlrre cbcraBn Ha ABere r,rHcraHrlr{r4

HerrpaBr.rnHo ca [punoxr4nn .rr.54 HK, nuecro ur.55, il.1, r.1 HK, ocHoBaHr{e

3A KOerO e yCTaHOBeHOTO tro AenOTO I43KrrOqUTeJrHO CMeKqaBaIqO

o6cro.rreJrcrBo Lr orreHKara 3a [o-H]IcKa creneH ua o6ulecrBeHa orracHocr Ha

.[esHueTO LI JII{IIHOCTTa Ha OCb.iIeHLITe.

2.4. ,{era, er:o6Hoeenv Ha ocHoBaHue HerrpaBXJrHo rrpunoxeHue Ha

MaTepr{anHlr.rr 3aKoH Lr AolycHaTo cbrrlecTBeHo Hapy[eHkre Ha npoqecyanHHTerrpaBnna (un.348, il.1, r.1 u r.2 H[IK).

HAB Ns 231 2017 r., o6pa-:yBaHo ro peAa Ha \r.424, il.l rp. wt.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ncKaHe Ha DraBHus rpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHl{e or24.04.2017 r. c'slrrr e smo6HoBr{rr HOXA l\b 157/ 2016 r. rro oruca ua PC -,{enna, orMeHr.rJr e olpeAeJreHlrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo crropa3yMeHl{ero, rsitKaro cbAbr He e ynpaxHr,rJr rrpaBoMorrluero cll rro.rr.384, an.1 np. un.382, an.5

HIIK Aa npeAnox<lr rpoMrHa B cropa3yMeHllero v ro e o4o6pul, 6ee 4anpnnox<v wt.23, ast. 2 HK no orHorrreHr4e Ha HaKa3aHr4ero nv[raBaHe or npaBo

uo vr.37, M.I, r.7 HK.HAB i\b 96i 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa ya w.424, il.l np. un.422,

at.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha TJIaBHLII rpoKypop Ha PE. C pelxeHl{e or17.05.2017 r. ctabr e Bb3o6nosur HOXA }lb 1668/ 2016 r. ilo orll4ca na PC -[o6pnu, orMeHLrJr e olpeAeJreHzero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHl{ero, H eBbpHaJr AeJroro Ha cbrrlr4r cbA 3a HoBo pa3rJIe)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. Ilpr,rer e,qe pafioHnn.rr cbA Karo e o4o6pun c[opa3yMeHr4ero, c[opeA Koero rloorHorrreHvre Ha HaKa3aHuero JI4ruaBaHe or cno6o4a e npr{noxur .rr.54 HK, a uo

18

orHoueHLre Ha KyMynarr4BHoro HaKa3aHr4e fno6a -.{n.55, an.3 HK, e Hapyixl4n

3aKoHa. He e ynpa)KHr4n npaBoMoulr4qra cI4 no 'aL382, ar.5 HIIK Aa rlpeAnoxnrrpoMrHa 14 e AonycHaJr npoqecyanHo HapyueHrre rro cMHct'JIa Ha wt.382, an.1

HNK.HAB J\b 168/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha'il.424, ast.l up. ut.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ilo LIcKaHe Ha rnaBHllt npoKypop Ha P6. C peIxeHI,Ie or22.05.2017 r. cbAbr e erso6HoBr{Jr HOXA Ns 366/ 2016 r. rro orll4ca na PC -TTTyueH, orMeHLrJr e oflpeAeneHrrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHl,Iero, ]I roe BbpH€ur na PII - lllyrraeu 3a HoBo pa3rnelrAaHe or cra4r4fl ,,[eficrnufl, Ha

npoKypopa cneA 3aBbpruBaHe Ha pa3cneABaHero". flpuen e, qe pafrouuuxr cbA e

AorrycHaJr HapylueHl4e Ha .IJI. ,il.382, a*7 H[IK, Karo e o4o6pran

cnopa3yMeHr4ero, BHeceHo rro peAa lr'art.29 HilK, a HaKa3aHl{ero e orpeAeJleHo

npu ycnoBr4flTa rro rJr. 28 HnK - ruo6a, Ha ocHoBaHuflTa ro tlr. 78a HK, r.e.rrpuno)KeHvr ca B eAHo rrpor43BoAcTBo eAHoBpeMeHHo HopMI4 oT rIpeABI4AeHI,ITe B

H|IK aa 4zSepeHrlupaHr.rre rrpoqelypr4 rro rrl. 28 urt.29 HIIK, BMecro AenoroAa ce pa3fneAa rrplr H€Inrlquero Ha ocHoBanurfl, rlo peAa Ha rJI. 28 HIIK.

HAB Ns 184/ 2011 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa laa\r.424, il.l np. w.422,il.1, r.5 HIIK uo LIcKaHe Ha rrraBHll.r rpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHl{e or15.06.2017 r. crgbr e Bb3o6nonzn HOXA J\b 5665/ 2016 r. Iro orzca na PC -Bapna, orMeHr{Jr e onpeAeJreHr{ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHl,Iero, v e

BbpHan AenoTo Ha cbulr4q cbA 3a HoBo p€Bfne)KAaHe oT Apyr cbcraB or cTaAI4q

Ha crAe6uoro 3aceAaHr4e. llpuen e, qe nbpBoIdHcraHIIIaoHHu-qr cbA He e

yrpaxHr{n rpaBoMorrlvrflTa cLr ro 'il.382, an.5 HIIK kr e o4o6puncropzr3yMeHlrero B HapyueHLre Ha wr.382, ar.7 HIIK, 3alrloro KbM Aarara Ha

Lr3BbprrrBaHe Ha rrpecTbnneHHeTo rro eAHo oT AenaTa He e pr3TeKbn cpoKa rro

vn.30, an.l HK - 5 roAuHr,r or r43TbplsBaHe Ha HaKa3aHrrrra rro [peAlrruHrrrenpucb.I.Id.

HAB J\b 198/ 2017 r., o6pa^:yBaHo rro peAa lr'a'an.424, il.l np. ut.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{rr rpoKypop Ha PB. C perreHr{e or29.06.2017 r. c'ng'sr e nrso6HoBlrrr HOXA J\b 18/ 2017 r. rro oruca na PC -Tyrparan, orMeHrlJr e olpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHr{ero, Lr

e BbpH€rJr AenoTo Ha cbql4s, cbA 3a HoBo p€BfnelKAaHe or Apyf cbcraB 3a

oTcTpaHrBaHe Ha AorrycHaTr.rTe HapyrrreHr4r. llpuen e) qe c [peAno)KeHaTarrpoMrHa B crropa3yMeHl{eTo B qacTTa 3a lI3IIbnHr4TeJIHoTo Aef,HI4e Ha

rrpecrlnneHr{ero rro 'aL343 F{K or ,,rpvrw4nvuf' Ha ,,cbfrpr4rrnnr4il" ceycraHoBrBar HoBLI SarruuecKll IroJIo)I(eHufl LI e HapyueH 3aKoHa - wt.426 HK,rro oTHorrreHlre Ha rrepuo.qlrqHocTTa Ha rrpooarluoHHaTa MrpKa 3aAbJDKr{TeJrHa

perr,rcrparlr{s rto Hacrorrq aApec. Karo e o4o6puJr roBa clop€r3yMeHr4e, cbAbr eAonycH€ur HapyrreHr4e Hawr.382, a;r.7 HIIK

HAB J\b 4951 2016 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa rra qr.424, il.l np. wt.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro prcKaHe Ha rJraBHHlr rpoKypop Ha PE. C pe[reHrze or07.03.2017 r. cbAbr e etso6HoBurr HOXAl'',lb 948/ 2016 r. rro orrr{ca naPC -[o6pu.r Karo e orMeHlrn o[peAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clop€ByMeHrrero

t9

3a peuaBaHe Ha AenoTo B qacTTa, B Ko{To e Ha[ox(eHo rIpeABI4AeHoTo B lir.343r, Bp. r{n. 3J, wr.l, r. 7 HK Haxa3aHtre JrutuaBaHe or ilpaBo Aa yilpaBrqBaMnC. llpuel e, qe e AonycHaro HapyrrreHve Ha 3aKoHa, rrit xaro o6nnHqeMurrHe e npaBocnoco6eH Bo'4ar{, I4 HenpaBr,rJrHo e [puno]Keu v1.59, an.4 HK. Karo e

o4o6pul roBa c[opa3yMe*r4e, cbAbr e AorrycHan cbxlecrBeHo HapyrxeHtre HanpoqecyaJlHl4re npaBl4na no cMr.rcb rra llj'a'il.382, an. 7 HIIK.

HAB J\b 336/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo ro peAa na qr.424, il.l np. wr.422,il.1, r.5 HIIK rro HcKaHe Ha DraBHuq rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or02.10.2011 r. cb.{br e erso6HoBrrrr HOXA l\b 27ll 2017 r. no orrr4ca na PC -Pa:rpa4, oTMeHI,IJI e o[peAeJleHl4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHlrero, r4 e

BbpHULJI AenOTO Ha CbIrIHfl CbA 3a HOBO pa3fnexAaHe OT Apyf CbcTaB oT cTaAr4tHa cr4e6noro 3aceAaHr4e. llpuen e, qe o6ezHsei\,ru-sr e npr,rBneqeH 3aI.I3BbpIrreHo [pecrtrrJreHrre uo rrr.l83, an4 Bp. aJr.l HK, 3a Koero e BHeceHo6suHLIreJIeH aKT. Pafionnusr cbA He e B3eJr npeABvA AaHHLrre 3a rrpeAxoAHoocbx{AaHe vr 3a rcnanuourar\krflTa Ha AetHr4ero Karo rrpecrbnneHve clopeAo6szHI4relrlnr4fl, aKT Ir e o4o6prnn clopa3yMeHLre 3a r.r3BbprrreHo rrpecrb[neHr4erro vn.183, an.1 HK, c Koero e AorrycHzrJr cbrrlecrBeHo HapyrueHrre HarpoqecyanHr4re rrpaBr4na -wt.382, an.7 HIIK.

HAB Ns 2l4l 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha \r.424, N.l rlp. wr.422,il.I, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHra.f, rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr.re or29.06.2017 r. crArr e etso6HoBI,IrI r{HA Ns 53611 2016 r. ro orruca Ha PC -BapHa, orMeHlrJr e olpeAeJreHr.rero, rrocraHoBeHo rro peAa ua'il.25 rip. wt.23HK, u e BbpH€tlr Aenoro Ha cbIrII{r cbA 3a HoBo pznrne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB 3aorcrpaHqBaHe Ha Ao[ycHarr,rre Hapyruenux. flpuer e, qe pafiounurr cbA e

AorlycHan HapylxeHne Ha 3aKoHa rrpr{ olpeAensHe Ha o6rqoro HaKa3aHue vr

cblrlecrBeHo HapyueHr.re Ha npoqecyaJrHr{Te npaBlrna IIo cMr4cbrral'ira qn.13 ra Ha

\r.14 HIIK upz SopvrlrpaHe Ha BbrperuHoro cr.r y6ex4eHr,re. (r.7 or ililBC Ns

41 1965 r. u TP J\b 3/ 2009 r. Ha OCHK na BKC. TP Jt 61 2014 r. Ha OCHK Ha

BKC).HAB Ns 26U 2018 r. o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua \n.424, aLL r;p. ut.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHLrr npoKypop Ha PE. C perreHr4e or20.07.2018 r. cbAbr e srgo6HoBnrr r{HA J\b 9/ 2018 r. ro ornca Ha PC -Pasrpa4, c Koero e orMeHr,rn olpeAeJreHr4ero zapea6ulvrar\vrfl., rrocraHoBeHa Ha

ocHoBaHLre wt.87 , ar.l HK, vr e BbpH€Lrr Aenoro Ha cbrrlus cbA 3a HoBopa3rnelx.qaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpraen e, qe pafionnurr cbA e AorycHairHapyureHue Ha.rr.l3 HIIK - Aa pa3Kplre o6ercrunuara HcrLrHa ro peAavr crccpeAcrBara, rrpeABnAeHLr r HIIK, r4 HapyrueHne Ha Marepr,ranHr4.f, 3aKoH, Karo erlocraHoBIar crAe6vapeafulrkrrar\vrfl'6es Aa ca H€urlrqe ycnoBrrflTaga roBa - B

TeqeHr4e Ha 3 roAuHr'r oT r43TrrrraHe Ha cpoKa Ha HillloxeHoro HaKa3aHr4e Aa He eI{3BbpIulIn Apyro npecrbrrJreHr{e, HaK€ByeMo c JrlruraBaHe or cno6ogaLrilu c rro-TE)KKO HAKA3AHI,IE.

HAB ],{e 203/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa na'aL424, il.l r,p. ut.422,il.l, 'r.5 HilK ro HcKaHe Ha rraBHI,Iq rpoKypop Ha PE. C perreHr{e or

20

04.01.2017 r. cbAbr e etgo6HoBrrJr HOXA J\ls 1411 2017 r. rio orll4ca sa PC -Hoslr lla:ap, orMeHr4Ji e onpeAeJreHuero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHnero

r4 orrpeAeJreHl4ero no .Ir.383, al.2 Bp. qn. 306, an.l, r.3 HnK, lI e BbpHzLn

AenoTo Ha cblrlufl e:..13a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe oT Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe e

AonycHaro cbrrlecrBeHo npoqecyanHo Hapy[reHl{e, rrfi raro n pafionuvfl cb[ e

BHeCeHO Clopa3yMeHr4e 3a H3BbprueHo npecrbrrJreHHe no qn.343n, anz HK, a n

o4o6peHoro I4 BrrncaHo B nporoKona,,HaK&3aHrlero ce HaIIara 3a npecrbtlJleHl4e

no qn.3436 HK", c Koero ca HapyueHrl npaBara Ha ocbAeHut. VcraHosvrlr e kr

HapyrxeHur Ha Marepl{anHl{t 3aKoH - Ha wr.57, at.l, r.2 3tr'IH3C, rtpuorrpeAensHe Ha nbpBoHar{aJrHvrfl penfl{M u Ha.{r.58 3I{H3C c onpeAeJltHe rurna

Ha 3arBopHlrqecKoro 3aBeAeHr4e, Koero e oT KoMrIereHTHocTTa Ha

3aTBOpHLrrrecKaTa aAMrrHI4cTp aL\vfl.

HAB l\b 169/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo IIo pe.ua Ha w.420, M.I np. wr.422,ffi.\, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha TJIaBHLI{ npoKypop Ha PB. C peIxeHLIe or03.07.2017 r. cr4sr e srgo6HoBr4Jr HOXA Np l47l 2011 r. rlo oruca na PC -HosH lla:ap, orMeHuJr e olpeAeJreHrrero B qacrra 3a pe)KLIMa 3a LI3TbputBaHe

Ha HaKa3aHr4eTO rr e BbpHurn AenoTo Ha csulur cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe orApyf cbcTaB 3a oTcTpaHrrBaHe Ha AorrycHaTo HapyrueHlle IIo [pzno)I(eHLIeTo Ha

3IrIH3C. llpuen e, qe PC e AorrycHzrr HapyrxeHvre Ha Marepl{€rnHlrfl 3aKoH - Ha

wr.5'1, an|,r.3 u na ur.70, an.l 3I4H3C upu orpeAensHe Ha pe)KprMa. He e

yilpax(Hr{n npaBoMolrluflTa cvr ilo wr.382, an. 5 HnK v e o4o6puncrlopa3yMeHlleTo B HapyueHl{e Ha wt.382, att.7 HIIK.

HAB Ns 3291 2018 r. o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha \r.424, il.l np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r{cKaHe Ha rJraBHlrr rpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHr{e or08.11.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBlrrr BHTD(A lllb 21l 2018 r. rro orrr{ca Ha OC -l[yuen, orMeHrlJr e pe[reHr{ero H e BbpHaJr Aenoro Ha cbrrlufl cr4 3a HoBo

pa3rnexcAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAut Ha cr4e6noro 3ace.{aHue. Cup.aJI e

H3TIbJIHeHHeTO Ha HarIO)KeHOTO HaKa3aHkIe AO OKOHTIaTeJIHOTO TIpUIKJIIOTIBaHe Ha

Aenoro. flpuen e, qe rrbpBonHcraHrlr/roHHuflT Lr Bb33LrBHr.rrr cbA Karo He ca

crlpanu AoKa3areJrcrBa 3a Bcr{rrKn o6cro-f,TeJrcrBa or npeABr.rAeHr,rre s .rr.78a

HK, ca AonycHaJru HapyueHr{e Ha Marepr4aJrHurt 3aKoH vr Ha rrpoqecyanHurerrpaBr{na.

HAB J\b 3151 2018 r. o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa lr'a,m.42\ il.l np. ur'.422,at.l, r.5 HnK ro LrcKaHe Ha uraBHlrs rpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHrre or30.10.2018 r. crArr e nrso6HoBr4rr HOXA Np 6221 2018 r. rro onuca Ha PC-

,{o6prEu, orMeHr,lJr e olpeAeJreHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHkrero, u eBbpHan AeJroTo Ha cbulrlr cbA 3a HoBo pa3fne)KAaHe oT cTa4krfl. Ha cbAeoHoTo3aceAaHrre. llpuer e, qe pafionuuxr cbA e rrpunolKr{n 3aKoH 3a rro-JreKo

HaKa3yeMo npecTbllneHlle, KaTo He e B3en npeABLrA, qe Lr3BbprrreHoTo e B

Lr3[LrrareIrHKfr cpoK, orrpeAeneH 3a Apyfo HaKa3aHLre, HaJro)KeHo c BJI'3JIa B cLrJra

rrpr4cbla (wt.3436, arl.3 HK BMecro wr.3436, a:l..4 HK), He e ynpa)KHlrnrrpaBoMoulLrflTa cr{ ro ut.382, ar.5 HIIK ra e o,qo6pun cnopzl3yMeHrlero B

HapyrueHkre laaw.382, an.7 HIIK.

2l

Apyrz l,era, elso6HoeeHr Ha cbuloro ocHoBaHr.re: H{B Ng 2491 2017 r.;HAB I{g23112011 r.; HAB J\b 208/ 2011 r.; HB{ J{s2441 2017 r.; HIB Xb 456l2017 r.; HIB Ns 2021 2017 r.; H{B Xb 335/ 2017 r.; HIB Ng 3]21 2017 r.;HAB Ns2731 2018 r.; HIB Ns22412018 r.; H{B Ns2741 2017 r.; HIB J\b 150/2018 r.; HIB l,{b 961 2018 r.; HIB J\b 306/ 2018 r.; HIB Ns28212018 r.; HnBi\b 3431 2018 r.; HF J\b 2531 2018 r.; HlB l\b 17ll 2017 r.; HAB Ne 406/ 2017r.; HfB }lb 33112011 r.

2.5. [ela, srso6uoeeHla Ha ocHoBaHlre HenpaBr4nHo npr4noxeHr,re HaMaTepI4aJrHHq 3aKOH Lr flBHA HeC[paBeAnI,IBOCT Ha H€LIIO)KeHOTO HaKa3aHI4e.

HAB l\lb 114/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa na \r.424, il.l up. ull..422,il.I, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr,rr npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or29.05.2017 r. crg'sr e srso6HoBr4Jr BHOXA J\b 1731 2016 r. rro oruca Ha OC -Trpronurqe, orMeHI4n e pemeHlrero rz e BbpH€Ln Aenoro Ha cbqlzs. c:o1 3a HoBopa3lnexAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB 3a oTcTpaH.rrBaHe Ha AorrycHaToTo HapyrreHr,re IIonpl4noiKeHuero Ha Mutepvranlevfl 3aKoH. llpue;r e, qe Bb33r,rBHr,rrr cbA e

onpeAenun cnf{atr Karo M€rrroBa)KeH, npeKB€LrruQuqupan e AerHlrero Karorlpecr:srlneHl4e rlo ttt.2I2, an.6 HK, Ho cbBKynHara or.leHKa Ha Bcr{trKlro6cro.{reJlcrBa or rIpeABI{AeHHTe n vr.93, r.9 HK He orrpeAeJr{T cnyqafl KaroMaIIOBDKeH, a HaK€BaHI{eTO rIO Br{A KaTO CrIpaBeAnr4BO.

3. AuerarraneH cbA - Eyprac.3.1. [ena, ntso6noBeHrr Ha ocHoBaHlre HelpaBr{nHo npuno)KeHr4e Ha

Mareprl€rnHur 3aKoH (vr.348, il.1, r.1 HIIK).HAB Ns l44l 2017 r., o6pa^:yBaHo rro peAa Ha \r.420, M.2 n,p. ut.422,

M.I, r.5 Hltr( ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHr4r rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHue or13.01.2017 r. cra.rr e srso6HoBr{rr HOXA Np 3231 2016 r. rro orruca Ha PC -Hona 3aropa, oTMeHLIJI e [plrcbAara B rlacrra, B Korro e [pHno)KeH .u.68, an.lHK u e o[peAeneH rlbpBoHarr€LireH pe)s{M 3a r43TbpnrBaHero My, r4 e BbpH€rJr

Aenoro Ha cblr{rrs. obry 3a HoBo p€Brne}KAaHe rro peAa Ha .rn.306, N.l HnK.flpuen e, qe pafioHnurr cbA e AorrycHaJr HapyueHr{e Ha MarepLraJrHr4fl 3aKoH,

Karo He e upuJro)KnJr ur.68, an.l HK tro orHorrreHr{e na o6uloro safi-rex(KoHaKa3aHLIe, onpeAeJleHo no I{H[ Ns 3571 2013 r. rro orrca Ha PC - KasasnrK) acaMo IIo oTHoIUeHI{e Ha eAHO OT HaKa3aHVrflTA, BKIIOTIeHI4 B CSBKynHOCTTa.

HAB Jlb 160/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha w.420, N.2 np. un.422,il.1, r.5 HIIK uo I{cKaHe Ha 3arrlr4rHr4K Ha ocbAelr.us. C perreHlre or 14.07.2017r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr4Jr HOXA Np 2791 2016 r. rro orrrlca na PC - Koren,orMeHLrJr e o[peAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopzr3yMeHr{ero, v a BbpH€rJr

AenoTo Ha cbrrlr{fl. cbl 3a HoBo p€Bfne)KAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB oT cTaAufl. Ha

crAe6soro 3aceAaHrae. llpueJr e, qe pairon:aprflr cbA e AolycHan cbrrlecrBeHoHapyrueHl{e Ha rpoqecyarHnTe npaBuna rro un.382, an.1 F{[IK, 3arrloro e

cneABilrro Aa orKax(e Aa o4o6pu cnopzl3yMeHurero nopaAr4 H€Lrrutrl4e Ha

ocHoBaHrlfl, Aa ce rpr{no)Kr4 .ur.78a HK n rpolr3BoAcrBo rro rJraBa 28 HnK.

1)

HAB Ns 2461 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo ilo peAa na w.420, an2 vp. ull..422,al.l, r.5 HnK ro r4cKaHe Ha rraBHr4q rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHr4e or27.10.2017 r. cbAtr e elgo6HoBrrrr t{HA J\rl 1468/ 2015 r. rro ornca na PC -CrHneu, oTMeHLIJI e IIporoKoJIHoro orlpeAeneHne B qacrra, B Kotro e npllnox{eHqn.68, an.l HK sa HaKa3aHLIero, HaJroxeHo c BJr{3Jrara B cvra npr4cbAa noHOXA Ns 17371 2012 r. rro orruca Ha PC - CruseH. llpraen e, qe e AorrycHaroHapy[reHne Ha 3aKoHa, rufi xaro HaKa3aHl,rero e r43TbpnqHo.

HAB Ng 2l4l 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa na \r.420, at2 np. 'u.422,il.I, r.5 HnK ro racKaHe Ha rraBHr{q rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or04.10.2017 r. c'sabr e Bb3o6Hoeur HOXA Ng 12731 2016 r. rro ornca na PC -Clunen, oTMeHI,IJI e nprlcbAara 14 e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cbrqu.rr cbA 3a HoBo

pa3rnex(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe PC HeupaBr.rJrHo e upnno)Kral .rn.61,

an.1 HK, rrit Karo rloAcbAzMara e HaBbprxr{Jra rrbJrHoJrerlre npeAr4

rrocTaHoB flBaHe Ha nplrcb AaTa.HIB Ns 9/ 20 1 8 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha 'il.420 , an2 sp. wt.422, arrl ,

r.5 H|IK no LrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHurr. C peureHze or 21.03.2018 r. cbAbr e

nrso6Honr.u HOXI Ns 22611 2017 r. ro oilvca sa PC - Eyprac, Lr3MeH]rrr e

rlpucbAara B rlacrra, B Koqro AesHr.rero e rrpeKB€urHQuqrapaHo or rrpecrb[neHneno r{Jr.183, an4 Bp. an.l HK Karo npecrbrrJreHr.re fro un.183, an.l HK v fl e

oTMeHLIJT B rIacTTa, B KosTo e llpunoxeH Ha wt.28, an.l HK. llpnen e, qe rpLrT€tlu KB€lnuQnraqufl Ha Aerrnrlero 3a r{3BbprueHoro rrpecrbrrneHr{e He ca Hanr4rleycJroBrrrTa Ha IroBTopHocT.

HAB }lb 1151 2018 r. o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa na 'rr.424, N.l "p. 'rr.422,

N.l, r.5 HnK ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHr4rr rrpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHlre or22.08.2018 r. cr.qbr e Bb3o6Hosur BrIHA }lb 1198/ 2017 r. no onr{ca na OC -Byprac, orMeHLIJr e pemeHllero, c Koero e orMeHeHo orrpeAeJreHr{ero na PC -Eyprac 3a orIpeAeJItHe Ha eAHo o6u1o HaK€BaHLre no peAa Ha rrJr. 25, np. qr. 23HK u e BbpH€lJr Aenoro ua OC - Fyprac 3a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB.llpuen e, qe oKpb)KHntr cbA HerrpaBr4nHo e [puJro)rfl{Jr un.86, an.2 HK, Karo e

rrpLIeJI, qe caMo eAHo or TpuITe HaKa3aIJLrfl rro BJre3Jrr{ B cHJra rrpvra'b4vr cneABa Aa6r4e pI3[bJrHeHo rlpkI H€L[nqlrero Ha AaHHr4, qe rro orHorueHrae Lr Ha ApyrLrre ABeHe e Hacrb rrrara pea6uturarJvrr,.

3.2. ,{ela, stso6HoneHl,l Ha ocHoBaHr.re AorrycHaro cbrrlecrBeHoHapyrueHLre Ha rpoqecyanHzre npaBr4na (vn.348, il.1, r.2 HIIK).

HIB Ns 2841 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha'rn.424, il.l rrp. utr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHrlrr rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr{e or15.01.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBkrJr BHTIXA Ns 358/ 2017 r. rro orrr4ca na OC -Eyprac n HTIXA J\b 56951 2016 r. ro orrr{ca ua PC-Eyprac, orMeHr{rr eperxeHr,rero B rracrra, B Korro e rrorBbpAeHa rrpr4cbAara na PC, KaKTo B

HaKa3arenHo-ocbAI{TeJIHaTa qacT 3a eAHo oT npecrbrlneHkTfiTa) 3a KoeTo eIIpeAaAeHa Ha cbA, TaKa L{ B rpa)KAaHcKara qacr, n e BbpH€ur Aenoro na PC ga

HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe ct4e6nure r4HcraHr\r4vr ca

23

AOIlyCHanI4 HapylxeHl,Ie Ha npOUeCyaJrHHTe ilpaBana - aKTOBere He OTfOBaprT

Ha r43r4CKBaHVflTa 3a CbAbpXaHHe Ha MOTr4Br4Te CbfiIaCHO .1n.305, ar.3, rO.{n.107 rl ilo r{Jr. 14 HnK BbB Bpb3Ka c']bc c:b6vpaHe, aHaIrLr3 rr oueHKa Ha

IoKa3areJrcrBeHHTe r43TorrHkrrlu v ilpr4 SopuHpaue Ha BbrperxHoro evr

y6ex4enue.HAB }\b 961 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo no peAa :ua,il.424, M.l up. wr.422, a:l..I,

r.5 HIIK uo rrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHr4s. C peruenne or 08.06.2017 r. cbAbr e

erso6Hoerar HOXI Ns 4691 2016 r. rro onuca na PC - Hoea 3aropa, orMeHr.rrr e

rrpHcbAara 14 e BbpHan AenoTo Ha cbrrlr4{ cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe oT ApyfcbcraB or craAr4fl ua crAe6Horo 3aceAaHlre. llpraen e, qe PC e Hapyurran wt.94,M.l, r.6, rrp.2 HIIK BbB Bpb3Ka c r,r3rrcKBaHurflTa 3a 3a.{bn)KLrreJrHo yqacrr4e Ha

3aulr4 THr4K, KOf aTO [OACbAr4MLrflT e 3aAbp XaH.HAB l\b 611 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa lna,il.424, M.I up. wt.422,

N.l, r.5 HnK ro r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHI4t npoKypop Ha PB. C peureHl{e or11.05.2017 r. csrsr e erso6HoBr4rr HOXA Ns 14671 2016 r. no onuca na PC -Eyprac, orMeHr4Jr e olpeAeJreHrrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHI4ero, I,I e

BbpHan AeJroro 3a HoBo pa3fnex(AaHe Ha PII or craIir4fl ,,,[eitcrvut Ha

rrpoKypopa cneA 3aBbprrrBaHe Ha pa3cneABaHero". llpnen e, qe pafroHHkrflT cbA

BMecro Aa orKaxe, e o4o6pr4n c[opa3yMeHve, clopeA cbAbpx{aHl{ero Ha Koeroe orrpeAeneHo HaK€BaHHe nu[raBaHe or cno6oAa I{ e rlpunoxeH .{r.66, N.l HK.3a npecrbrrneHuero rro \r.206, aJr. 6 HK 3aKoHbr npeABI{xAa HaKa3aHI4e

Jrr{rrraBaHe or cso6oAa Ao 3 roAraHu. Hannqe ca KyMyJrarHBHo npe.qBI4AeHI4Te

rrpeAnocraBKr,r 3a pa3rnexAaHe Ha Aenoro B rrpou3BoAcrBo rro fJr. 28 HIIK. C

oAo6ptrBaHe Ha clop€ByMeHnero, Koero [porI,IBoperII4 Ha 3aKoHa, cbAbr eAonycHan HapyrxeHvre Haut.382, an.7 HIIK.

HAB J\|l 290i 2016 r. o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha ,an.424, a*l up. w.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r{cKaHe Ha ocbAelr.ur. C peurenue or 06.03.2017 r. crgrr e

srso6Honun BHOXA J\b 2801 2016 r. no oIII{ca na OC - Fyprac, orMeHI,{rI e

perueHr{ero r{ e BbpHan AenoTo Ha cblrlufl, cb4 3a HoBo p€BfnexAaHe or ApyfcbcraB or craAr4fl Ha cr4e6uoro 3aceAaHr,re. llprleJr e, qe pelueHllero HsMa

MOTr.rBLr. oXptXnnqT cbA e AeKJrapupan HecbfJracne c AoBoAI,ITe Ha 3aIrII4THLIKa,

6es Aa rr4 r43cneABa B rrbJrHora r{ Aa vM AaAe Mor}IBLIpaH orroBop n cr4e6unxaKT, c Koero e Hapyuun rpLrHrlr{[a rro .m.14 HIIK 3a HarIpIHa, Iro KofiTo e

Sopvrzpan BbrperuHoro cr4 y6ex4enze. (P 2l5l 07.03.2018 r. no u.4.1016/ 2017

r., III n.o., BKC).HAB Np 2251 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha'rn.424, il.l Yp. tt.422,

M.1, r.5 HnK no LIcKaHe Ha TJIaBHHI ilpoKypop Ha PE. C peIxeHI,Ie or03.10.2017 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBr{Jr HOXA Ns 28/ 2015 r. rlo orluca na PC -Afiroc, orMeHHJr e olpeAeJreHr{ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHlrero, v a

BbpH€ur AenoTo 3a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe Ha PII or cTa4r4fl ,,[eitcruut Ha

[poKypopa cJreA 3aBbprrrBaHe Ha pa3cJreABaHero". llpnen e, qe PC e AonycHaJr

HapyrueHtre Ha qn.38l, anL,I{3p. Bropo HIIK, Karo e oAo6pl4n cnopa3yMeHlle

rrpr4 Hanr4rrr{ero Ha 3a6paHa 3a peuaBaHe Ha Aenoro B rlpou3BoAcrBo uo rn. 29

', /1-T

HnK 3a cnyqal4Te, Kofaro e I43BbplrreHo npecrr,nneHl4e, c Koero e [puquHeHacMbpr.

HAB J\b 2301 2011 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa :aa'm.424, arr.l np. utr.422,at.l, r.5 HnK uo prcKaHe Ha rJraBHHr npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHlre or24.10.2017 r. cr'gbr e Bb3o6Hosrar HOXtr }lb 3005/ 2017 r. rro orrvoa na PC -Eyprac, orMeHI4Jr e onpeAeJleHrrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo crropa3yMeHrrero, v a

BbpHan Aenoro 3a HoBo pa3rnex{AaHe or Sa":ara Ha.qocbAe6uoro ilpotr3BoAcrBorlopaArr AonycHaro HapyueHl4e Ha 'aL382, an.7 HIIK. llpuen e, qe AerHr,rero e

I{3BbpueHo Ha 30.05.2017 r., a He KaKTo e orpa3eHo B rrocraHoBJreHr4ero 3arpl4BnuqaHe Ha o6nuuseu u n o4o6peHoro crropa3yMeHr4e - 30.05.2016 r. Toeae AoBeJro Ao HapymaBaHe Ha rlpaBoro Ha rroAcbAuMvrs. Ia pas6epe B KaKBo e

o6suHeH r4 Aa opraHlr3r,rpa 3arrlr{Tara cr{.HAB Ns21 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa naw.424, an.I np.u1.422, anl,

r.5 H|IK uo rrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHr,rr. C peruenue or 25.04.2018 r. cbAbr eerso6Hoszn BHOXA J\b 3541 2017 r. rro orrr4ca na OC - Eyprac, orMeHr{rr eBb33LIBHara rIpLIcbAa B rlacrra, B Korro e norBbpAeHa [pucbAara no HOXI ]lb6091 2016 r. uo orlnca na PC - I{apeno, 14 e BbpH€Lrr Aenoro Ha oKpbx:avtfr cril3aHoBo pa3rnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qe Bb33r,rBHriflT c:''1 HerrpaBr{nHo e

OTKII3€UI Aa yBa)KI'I AOK€BaTeJIOTBeHLI I|'CKaIIIdfl, AOBenO AO HeI43tCHtBaHe Hao6errnsHara ucrkrHa orHocHo ocHoBHLr-fl Sarcr ro 'il.102, r.l HnK v AoorpaHkIqaBaHe Ha [poqecy€ulHuTe npaBa Ha rroAcbiluv'r4fl, rro cMr{cbJra Ha.{r.348,il.3, r.1 np. il.1, r.2 HIIK.

HAB Ns 721 2018 r., o6pa.:yBaHo no peAa na'rr.424, M.l "p. 'il.422,

Nr.l, r.5 HIIK ro rrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHvs. C peurenne or 31.05.2018 r. cr4rr esrso6Honun BHOXA }lb 22Il 2017 r. rro oruca na OC - -flrvr6on z HOXA J,,lb

7 57 I 2017 r. no orvca na PC - flvr6ot, orMeHLrJr e peureHnero r4 rrpr4cbAar a v eBbpHzuI Aenoro Ha PC 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or cra1Lrr,,llpe4anaHe Ha arA vr

rIoArorBI4TeJrHI4 !.eitcrnux 3a pa3rne)K.qaHe Ha AeJroro e clAe6Ho 3aceAaHue" cKoHKperHI4 yKa3aHut. fTpuer e, qe rlbpBorrHcraHrlr4oHHuflT cr1 He e Lr3rrbJrHLrJr

3aAbnxeHr{ero cvr ro .u.15, an.3 HIIK Aa puBf,cHr{ Ha [oAcbAr4Mr.rtBb3MoxHocrra lenoro Aa ce pa3rneAa rro peAa Lr ilpkr ycnoBr4rra rro rt. 27HIII(.

HAB llb 1411 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo uo peAa Ha'rr.424, il.l np. u1.422,il.I, r.5 HnK ro LIcKaHe Ha ocbAeHrar, qpe3 3arrIHTHr4K. C perreHue or09.08.2018 r. cr4rr e nlso6HoBLrrr BHOXA Np 2721 2018 r. ro oruca Ha OC -Eyprac, orMeHI{JI e pe[reHl{ero 14 e BbpH€rJr Aenoro Ha cbrrlu fl, srr 3a HoBop€BrnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAlrr ua cr4e6Horo 3ace4anvre. llpuel e, qe e

AorlycHaro cbulecrBeHo npoqecyzrJrHo HapyneHLre ro cMncbIra lna'l.r'. 34 H[IK,3aIrIoTo pelueHllero He e [oArII{caHo oT qJreH Ha cbcTana. (PeureHze Ns 77211991 r. na BKC, I u.o., Peruenr,re Ns 521 1982 r. Ha BKC, I H.o., peureHue }lbl42l 2015 r. ua BKC, III u.o.)

Apy." Aerra, nrso6HoneHr{ Ha cbuoro ocHoBaHr.re: HIB ]llb 85/ 2017 r.:HAB Ns2021 2017 r.; HlBJ\b 1181 2017 r.; HIBltb 145/2018r.

25

3.3. /[e:ra, er:o6HoeeHz Ha ocHoBaHzero tto q1.348, ar.l, r.3 HIIK -

HaJioxeHoTo HaKa3aHHe e tBHo HecnpaBeAnuBo.

HAB J\|l 93l 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha \r.424, arr.l up. ut.422,ar.1, r.5 HIIK fro r.rcKaHe Ha 3arrlurHr.rK Ha ocbAeHus. C pelxeHl4e or 19.06.2017r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr.rrr BHOXA J\b 150/ 2016 r. Iro olrl4ca na OC - CrueeH nHOXA J\b 5251 2014 r. rro onuca na PC - Hosa 3aropa, H3MeHLIrr e perleHl4ero,

c KoeTo e rroTBbpAeHa npl4cb4aTa B qacTTa 3a HaKa3aHI4eTo JII4IrraBaHe OT

cno6o4a, Karo e HaMilrrr{Jr pa3Mepa. llpuen e, qe ABere cr4e6nu rrHcraHIIIzI,I He

aa B3eJrrr npeABr.rA rrpeKoMepHaTa rrpoAbJIlI(LITeJrHocT Ha HaKa3arenHoTo

rrpolr3BoAcrBo - o6crogreJlcrBo, Koero e or cblrlecrBeHo 3HaqeHI4e 3a

cnpaBeAnr,rBocrra Ha HaKa3aHr4ero cbrJlacHo rIpaKTI4Kara Ha EClItl florrpr4no)r(eHr{ero Ha uap.l K3ltqOC v He ca ilpl4noxl4nn KoMrleHcaropHufl

MexaHr{3bM rro vn.55, il.1, r.1 HK (P Nt 2991 12.06.2013 r. rlo HA J\b 9061 2013r., BKC, III u.o.)

HAB Jt 49l 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa Ha wr.424, arr.l up. wt.422,il.1, r.5 HIIK ro LIcKaHe Ha ocbAeH. C peruenve or 03.05.2018ergo6Hosnn BHOXA Ns 10121 2011 r. Iro oruca na OC - Eyprac,peIxeHLIeTo B rIacTTa 3a pa3Mepa Ha HaKa3aH\4qra rLIUaBaHe oT

qacrra 3a pa3Mepa Ha orpeAeneHoro Ha ocHoBaHvre qr.23 HK o6qo

f. cbAbr e

I{3MeHLIJI e

ceo6o4a, eHafi-rexro

HaKa3aHr4e, Karo fu e HaMaJrvtr\ n e rrpHJrox{r.rJr un.66, an.l HK. llpuen e, qe

HaKa3aHLIf,Ta IIpaBHnHo Ca OlpeAeneHl4 IIpI4 IIpeBec Ha OTerqaBaIqI'ITe

orroBopHocrra o6crosreJrcrBa, Ho B olpeAeneHlls I4M pa3Mep ca qBHo

HecrrpaBe ArrvrBLr, 3arrloTo ca 3aBHrrreHr{ - He ca cro6pa3eHpr c KoHKpeTHara

Texecr Ha Aefl:rrvrflTavr He orroBapflT Ha IIenI{Te no'uI.36 HK.

3.4. .{ena, elso6HoeeHu Ha ocHoBaHlre HeupaBLIJIHo rlpuno}I(eHlle Ha

MaTepr{€rJrHr4r 3aKoH r{ AorrycHaTlr cbulecTBeHu HapylxeH.vrfl, Ha npoqecy€LIIHI4Te

rrpaBuna.HAB J\b 15/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rlo peAa Ha w.424, il.l Yp. wt.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK ro ucKaHe Ha TJIaBHLIff rpoKypop Ha PE. C pelxeHl{e or21.02.20L7 r. crxsr e Bb3o6HoBlrrr HOXA J\b 2088/ 2016 r. rlo oruca na PC-

Eyprac, orMeHrlJr e olpeAeJreHuero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHl{ero, v Q

BbpHiur AeJroro Ha cbrrlLrfl cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuel e,

qe pafioHHr.rf,T cbA e o4o6pun clop€ByMeHLIe, B Koero HaKa3aHuero JII{[raBaHe

or cBo6oAa 3a rrpecrbrrJreHlre wr.296, an.1 FIK e olpeAeJreHo rlpu ycnoBnflTa Ha

v1.55, il.l, r.2 HK Ia e 3aMeHeHo c [po6arlur, Koero e rlo-TexKo or Hafi-neKoro

HaKzBaHrde rno6a, [peABr.IIeHo 3a roBa ltpecrbrlneHl4e rlo BTopara €rnrepHarl'IBa.

Karo e o4o6pun clop€ByMeHr,rero npu H€t[llquero Ha HapyIIreHI4e Ha

MareprrurJrHr,rr 3aKoH 6e: Aa rrpeAnoxl4 rIpoM{Ha, cbAbr e AonycHarl cblrlecrBeHo

HapyureHr4e HanpoqecyanHl4Te npaBl,Ina - un.382, an.5 pr an.7 HIIK.HAB Ns 2691 2016 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa na qr.424, il.l up. wr.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r{cKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrs. C perueHue or 23.02.2017 r. cl4rr e

Br,3o6HoBr4n HOXA Ng 4571 2016 r. ilo orrr4ca na PC - Kapno6ar, orMeHar e

o[peAeneHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHnero, u e BbpHan Aenoro Ha

c'brJJvrfl 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpraen e, rre pafrouHHrr cbA BHapyrreHue Ha ,il.382, an7 HIIK e o4o6pran cilopa3yMeHr{e, BHeceHo 3a

pa3rnex{AaHe B cbAa B npor{3BoAcrBo rro rJr. 29 HIIK, cnopen KoeroonpeAeneHoro HaKa3aHrIe e Jrr4rxaBaHe or cno6o4a c [puno)KeHne ua v1.66, an.1HK, npra HaJrv.uwero Ha KyMynarr4BHo npeABr4AeHr4Te [peAnocraBKr.,r no qn.78a

HK 3a oceo6oxAaBaHe or HaKa3areJrHa orroBopHocr 14 3a HarraraHe Ha

aAMr,rHrzcrparuBHo HaKa3aHrre B rrpor43BoAcrBo rro rJr. 28 HIII(.HAB J\b 105/ 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha w.424, il.I np. wt.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro HcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{.rr ilpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or05.06.2011 r. cbAbr e erso6HoBnrr HOXA Ns257l 2016 r. rro orrr{ca Ha PC-florr,ropue, orMeHI4JI e o[peAeJreHr{ero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHuero, r.r

e BbpH€UI Aenoro Ha cbIrII4t cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe oT Apyf cscraB oT craAr{tna cr4e6Horo 3aceAaHrle. llpuen e, qe PC e AorrycH€ur cbrrlecrBeHo HapyueHlreHa rrpoqecy€ulHl,Ire npaBrrna ro cMracbJra Ha 'aLl02, r.3 u wr.l4 HIIK npn

QopvrzpaHe Ha BbrpellrHoro y6ex4euue, AoBeno Ao HeBb3Mo)r(Hocr Aa ceHarIpaBI{ H3BOA Aa"JLId e [pUnO)KeH rrpaBr4JrHo MareplranHnfl 3aKOH rro oTHorueHr{eHa KBarru$zraqraara Ha AerHuero r{ 3a pa3Mepa Ha HaKa3aHrrero.

HAB Np 2261 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa rta \r.424, il.l np. wr.422,ar.l, r.5 HIIK ilo rrcKaHe Ha 3aMecrHHK Ha rJraBHr.rr rpoKypop ua PE. CpelueHl{e or 27.10.2017 r. cbA6r e erso6HoBr{Jr HOXA Ns 23631 2017 r. rroorruca na PC - Eyprac, orMeHI4Jr e olpeAeneHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6penocuopa3yMeHrreTo rlo oTHoIueHI{e Ha eAr{HLrr rroAcbAvr}.,., vt e BbpH€rJr AenoTo Hac'brr\Hfl. cbA 3a HoBo p€Brnex(AaHe B Ta3u My qacr or Apyr cbcraB. llpuen e, qepafioHnnrr cbA e HapyurIJI trJr. 382, ur. 7 HIIK, 3arrloro clopa3yMeHr.rerorrporr.rBoperrr{ Ha 3aKoHa -fipuno]KeH e .rr.66, M.l HK IIpu nzlca Ha eAHo ornpeABI4AeHI4Te ycnoBl{tr - rIoAcbAVMLrflT Aa He e ocbxAaH; HaKzBaHLrero uo6a e

onpe.{eneHo B rlpeABv4errtz'fl or 3aKoHa MLIHr{MyM, BMecro cbrJracHo v1.55, M.I,r.l v ar.2 HK - rIoA nafi-nucxvr rpeAen. HapyrueHr4fl ca AorrycHarpr vr Harpoqecy€lJlHnre npaBl{na ro cMr{cbJra Ha.rr.381, an.5 HIIK - He e lpeAnoxeHarrpoMrHa Lr Ha qn.38l, ffi.6, tr3p. Bropo HIIK HrrMa AeKJraparlulr oro6ezHseMvIs.,qe ce orKuL3Ba or cbAe6no pa":ruexAaHe Ha AeJroro no o6qzx pe4.

HAB Ns 150/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa Ha'rr.420, ast.2 np. ut.422,am.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha DraBHr{.{ upoKypop Ha PB. C perreHue or17.08.2017 r. cbAbr e nrgo6HoBr{rr HOXI Nb 5491 2017 r. rro orrca Ha PC -Byprac, orMeHLrJI e olpeAeJleHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHuero, v eBbpH€uI AenoTo Ha cbIrIH{ cbA 3a HOBO pA3fne)KAaHe OT Apyf CbcTaB OT CTaALrtHa ct4e6Horo 3ace4anvre. llpuen e, qe xnanzsraraqllrflTa Ha AerHr.rero Karo[pecrbrrneHr{e uo qn.3436, an2 HK, 6es Aa ca B3erLr npeABr4A AaHHHTe 3aHacrbrll{Jlara pea6unr4Tarlvrfl rlo lpaBo no cMr/tcbrra Ha.rn.86, il.l, r.2 HK, e

HerlpaBl{nna. Karo He e I,I3rIbJIHlrJr [poqecyalHoro ckr 3a1:r-rl:KeHr4e uo vn.382,

27

an.5 HIIK v e oAoSpr4n c[opa3yMeHue, Koero [porr4Boperrr4 Ha 3aKoHa,

pafroHnnrr cbA e AonycHarr HapyueHr4e u ua .rr.382, arr.7 HIIK.HAB i\b 107/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha'aL420, arr.2 ep. ut.422,

ar.l, r.5 HIIK ro HcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{r npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or08.06.2017 r. cr.qbr e Bb3o6uonzr HOXI J\b 3635/ 2016 r. rro orrr4ca Ha PC -Eyprac, orMeHr4n e oflpeAeJreHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHrrero, rr eBbpHan Aenoro Ha cbulr4q cbA 3a HoBo pa3rnex{AaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuer e,qe PC e AorrycHarr HapyrreHr4e Ha wt.382, an.1 HIIK Karo e o4o6purcnopa3yMeHHe, Koero rrporr4BopeqH Ha 3aKoHa: He e [pe.{cTaBeHo r{3foTBeHo H

noArrrzcaHo clopa3yMeHr,re -.rr.381, ar.5 HIIK; HrMa cbrJlacl4e Ha crpaHa B

HapyrxeHr{e Ha vn.384, an.3 HIIK; He e npeAnoxreHa rrpoMrHa B HapyrreHne Ha

\il.382, an.5 HnK.HAB i\b 308/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha'il.420, ar'.l np. un.422,

ast.l, r.5 HIIK rro LrcKaHe Ha r.lraBHru npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or05.02.2018 r. cnabr e Bb3o6Hoer,ur HOXA Ns 12771 2017 r. rro onr4ca ua PC -ClzeeH, orMeHr,rJr e olpeAeJreHLrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHuero, u eBbpHaJr AenoTo Ha cbrrlur cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe oT Apyf cbcraB oT cTaALIt

sa crAe6Horo cJreAcrBr4e. llpuen e, qe PC e AorrycHan HapyrxeHlre Ha 3aKoHa -un.49, an.2 FIK Karo e olpeAeJrrrJr rro-KparbK cpoK Ha HaK€BaHLrero JII4IuaBaHe

or rrpaBo or cpoKa Ha HaK€BaHuero JruruaBaHe or cso6o4aLr Ha [poqecy€ulHl{TerrpaBrrJra - wr.382, an.5 HIIK, Karo He e rrpeAJrox{r,rJr rrpoMrHa. C oao6prBaHe Ha

crropa3yMeHlreTo, KoeTo nporr{Bopeqr4 Ha 3aKoHa, e AolycHan csqecrBeHoHapyrueHvre Ha rrpoqecyanHure npaBl{na no qn.382, il.J HIIK.

HAB J\b 56/ 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo rlo peAa ya \r.420, il.l n,p.'tr'.422,M.l, r.5 HnK uo rrcKaHe Ha TJIaBHHI ilpoKypop Ha PE. C peIueHI,Ie or16.04.2018 r. cr.qrr e srso6HoBr.rrr HOXA Ng 2251 2017 r. rro otll4ca na PC -Hosa 3aropa, orMeHr,rJr e onpeAeJreHrlero, c Koero e o4o6peHo rlocrl4rHarorocnopa3yMeHrre, Lr e BbpH€rJr AenoTo Ha cbulus cbA 3a HoBo p€Bfnex(AaHe oT ApyfcbcraB or ara4vrfl, Ha cr4e6noro 3aceAaHLIe. llpuel e, qe e HapyureH

Marepr,rurnHr{{ 3aKoH, Karo He e [pI4JIoxeH wt.57, il.l, r.2,6. ,,6" 3WI3C npnorrpeAeJrrHe Ha rtbpBoHaqaJrnkrfr pexfl{M. Karo e o4o6pnn clopa3yMeHuero,KOeTO rrpoTr{Bopequ Ha 3aKoHa, rr He e rlpeAnoiKl4n rlpoMxna, PC e AonycH€LJI

cbrrlecrBeHo HapyueHlre Ha rrpoqecytulHuITe rpaBl4na rlo cMlrcbJra Ha wr.382,arl.5 u an.7 HIIK.

HAB Ns l24l 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo ro peAa Haqn.420, il.l Yp. wt.422,NJ, r.5 HIIK uo LIcKaHe Ha DIaBHLII rpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHl,Ie or09.07.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr{Jr HOXA },lb 380/ 2018 r. rlo orllca na PC -Eyprac, orMeHuJr e rrpr4cbAara vr e BbpH€In Aenoro Ha cbIrIHfl crA 3a HoBo

pa3rnexAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or cra4r4fl. sa crAe6Horo 3aceAaHne rropaAu

AorycHaro HapyueHr4e rro w.382, a* 7 HIIK. llpraen e, rle PC e AorIycH€LII

HapyrxeHLre Ha 3aKoHa npv vIJAr4BI,4AyaJII43AI\Afr, Ha HaKa3aHIteTO, OUpeAeJIeHO B

HapyrxeHlre Ha wr.373, al.2 HIIK ep. vn.58a HK, I4 Ha rlpoqecyzurHllre rIpaBLIna

28

- .{n.305 HflK, [opaAl4 Irpor]IBopelrre MexAy yBoAHara qacr, MornBr4re 14

Ar4 CnO3 r4Tr4BA HA npHCbAaTa.

HAB Ns Il4l 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha w.420, an.2 np. wt.422,ar.l, r.5 HnK ro ucKaHe Ha rJraBHr4r npoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr4e or28.09.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBr{rr HOXA Is 638/ 2012 r. no orruca ua PC -Elxono, orMeHI4n e npl4cbAura B r{acrra, B Koqro [oAcbrl4MvrflT e rIpI43Har 3a

Br,rHoBeH, r4 e BbpH€rn AenoTo Ha cbrrlr4r cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe oT ApyfcbcraB. llpuer e, qe PC HenpaBHJrHo e rrpnnox{ul \r.66, an.l HK, rrfi KaronpecrbrlneHl,Iero e I43BbprueHo B r43uIaTaTeIrHVfl cpoK Ha 3aMeHeHOTO HaKa3aHI{eupo6aqux c rIHIIraBaHe or cso6oAa no HHI Ng 2341 2010 r. rro onr4ca na OC--f,ira6on v e AonycH€rn cblrlecrBeHo rrpoqecy€rJrHo HapylreHr4e, Karo He e

o6crAul ocHoBaHr.rflTa3a rrpr4nolreHrlero ua v1.68, anl uwt.69, an.2 HK.HAB J\rl 1791 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Ha,ril.424, il.l up.'m.422,

a1.1, r.5 HIIK rro HcKaHe Ha 3aMecrHr{K Ha rJraBHr4.rr rpoKypop ua PE. CperrreHlle or 12.10.2018 r. crqrr e Bb3o6nosrar HOXA Ns 2021 2018 r. rroorrr4ca ua PC - Afiroc, orMeHHJr e onpeAeneHr4ero, c Koero e o4o6peuocrlopa3yMeHllero B rracrra 3a HaKa3aHr,rero Jrpr[raBaHe or rrpano. llpueJr e, qe

HelpaBl4nHo e [pvno]I(eH .rn.343r HK, rsit Karo o6snHqeNavsr He e

rrpaBocroco6eu BoAarr Ha Mnc. Karo e o4o6pun cllopiByMe:f{:yle) Koerolporl4Bopequ Ha 3aKoHa, PC e AolycHzIJI cbqecrBeHo HapyrueHr.re HarpoqecyanHl{Te IIpaBI4na IIo cMllcbna.In.382, M.J HIIK.

HAB }lb 188/ 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo ro peAa :na'ail.424, M.l rl;p. utr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro krcKaHe Ha ocrAeHzq. C perxeHLre or 12.10.2018 r. e

nrso6Honur t{HA Ns 791 2018 r. rro orruca Ha PC-Eyprac, orMeHr,rJr eorlpeAeneHl{ero, c Koero Ha ocHoBaHlre wt.4l4, a1.1, r.l HIIK e AorrycHaJrTbnKyBaHe Ha o[peAeneHlleTo, rIocTaHoBeHO IIo peAa Ha'an.25 np. vn.23 HK srlacrra 3a orlpeAeneHl{.r [bpBoHaq€LJreH pexuM. llpuen e, qe e AorrycHaroHapylxeHkre Ha 3aKoHa npu peuaBaHe Ha Bbrrpoca 3a pex[Ma u ilpuno)KeHr{eToua ut.57 , N.I, r.3 3I4H3C. Ha ocHoBaHLr e wt.4l4, il. 1, r. 1 HIIK cbAbr, rcofiroe rlocraHoBt4Jr BJI'3bJI B cLrJra clge6eH aKT, Mome Aa ce [por43Hece rro Bcr{qKn3arpyAHeHr4s. Lr cbMHeHllf,, cBbp3aHr{ c rbnKyBaHero, Ho He v Aa ce ilpor{3Hacqrro Bbrrpoc or rrpeABuAeHlrre n .{r.301 H[IK.

Apyru AeJIa, stso6uoseHr.r Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHpre: HIB J\b 178/ 2018r.(n l/ 1983 r. na llneuyMa Ha BC, TP J\b 61/ 1980 r. Ha OCHK sa BKC, p Jt941 26.02.2009 r. BKC, II n.o., P Ns l0l 18.01.2010 r. BKC, III n.o.); HAB.Ilbr92l 2018 r.; Hrc J\b 11rl 2017 r.; HAB }lb 75l 20rl r.; Hm Ns20412018 r.

4. AnelaruBeH cbA - Beluro Trpuono.4.I. [eta, slso6HoneHz Ha ocHoBaHrae HerrpaBr4nHo rrpr4no)KeHr{e Ha

Marepr,raJrHr{r 3aKoH (un.348, il.1, r.1 HIIK).HAB }lb 510/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua wr.4\0, il.l np. wr.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK ro rlcKaHe Ha rJraBHH-f, rrpoKypop Ha PE. C perueHr4e or31.01.2017 r. cbAr,r e nrso6HoBrrJl BqHn J\b 170/ 2017 r. rro orruca na OC -

Berur<o Trpuono, orMeHlrn e onpeAeneHl4ero, c Koero e rlorBbp4eHoonpereneHr.rero ua PC-fopua OprxoBr4ua B qacrra 3a pexuMa 3a :a3r:'prtqBaHe

Ha HaJroxeHoro HaKa3aHr4e Jrlr[raBaHe or ceo6o4a v e BbpHan Aenoro Ha

oKpbxHr4fl crq 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAuq Ha clAe6Horo3aceAaHr4e. llpraen e, qe pafiounraxr cbA Karo He e rIpI4JIox(I{Jr wt.57, atl,t-23I'IH3C r4 e orrpeAerrr4rr ilbpBoHarraJleH o6q pexLIM, BMecro crpor, e Hapytuun3aKOHa.

HAB l\b 21ll 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa Ha'il.424, al.l yp. wt.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro tlcKaHe Ha rJIaBHI4t npoKypop Ha PE. C perreHue or08.06.2017 r. crgrr e erso6HoBr4rr t{HA }lb 128/ 2017 r. no olrlzca na PC -flnenen, orMeHr.rJr e onpeAeJreHlrero, rrocraHoBeHo rro peAa :aa'il.25 rp. un.23

HK, u e BbpHztrr Aenoro Ha cbrqrr{ cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne}KgaHe or Apyr cbcraB.flpraen e, lle B qacrra 3a HaKa3aHVflTa rlo ABe or BJre3nLITe B er4lra npvrcr4r4pafionnum cbA HerrpaBlrnHo e npr4no)Kun MarepI4€LIIHLIt 3aKoH, Karo rr4 eBKnroqlrJr B cbBKyrrHocrra 3a orrpeAeJltHe na o6uloro HaKa3aHVe, BMecTo Aa

rrocraHoBu Ia 6r4ar u3TbpneHl4 orAenHo.

HAB J\b 4171 2018 r. o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha \r.424, il.l np. utt.422,

M.l, r.5 HilK ro I4cKaHe Ha r.lIaBHI4-fl rpoKypop Ha PE. C peIueHLIe ortI.12.2018 r. cbAbr e stso6HoBrlJr qHA J\b 52l 2018 r. rlo oruca na PC -llarlurenlr, orMeHr4Jr e o[peAeJreHr.rero, c Koero ce e rrpotl3HecbJl no vn.25 np.

\r.23 HK, u e BbpHzt[ Aenoro Ha cblrlurl cbA 3a HoBo pa3rnex(AaHe or ApyrcbcraB or cra4nfl. Ha clAe6noro 3aceAaHne. llpnen e, .re pafiouHvrflT cbA

HerrpaBr.rnHo e orrpeAenun o6ulo HaKa3aHr.re, Karo e npl{nox(ur qr.25 u .m.23

HK, npr{ H€t[prrrr/rero caMo Ha ocHoBannfl, ilo 'aL27 HK (rlIvt ocrarbKa orHer,r3Tbpn.rrHoTo HaK€BaHI,Ie ce Ilpuc'beAvlHflBaHalloxeHoTo HOBO Hana-:aHIAe).

HAB Ns 5191 2017 r. o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa Ya w.424, il.l Yp. tn.422,il.l, r.5 HIII( rro LIcKaHe Ha TJIaBHI{{ rpoKypop na PE. C pelueHl{e or20.12.2017 r. crgnr e nrso6HoBr,rrr BTIHA l,{e 3/ 2016 r. uo oruca na OC -Jlonev, orMeHr4Jr e pelueHuero, c Koero e orMeHeHo orlpeAeJleHrrero na PC-

Tereneu, [ocTaHoBeHo rlo peAa Ha w.25 np. .rn.23 HK, u e BbpHan Aenoro Ha

oKpb)KHlrfl. crl 3a HoBo pzBrne)r(AaHe or Apyr cbcraB or craAvfl, Ha crl]e6noro3aae4anvre. llpraen e, are Bb33t4BHr{rr cbA e Ao[ycHaJI HapylreHlIe Ha

MaTepI{aJrHI{r 3aKoH, KaTO e HarrpaBr{Jr u3BoA, rle He ca HaJIUIIe [peArIocTaBKLITe

3a onpeAeJuHe na o6ulo HaKa3aHHe B rlporl4Bopeque c TP Ns 6/ 2014 r. Ha

OCHK ua BKC, cropeA Koero ce B3eMa rpeABIzA c'sge6uutr aKr, c rofiro e

r{3BbprrreHa 3aMrHara Ha HaKa3aHlrero npo6awrs, c JII{ruaBaHe or cno6o4a, a ne

na crAe6nttg. aKT, c rofiro e H€LIIo)KeHo HaKa3aHuero npo6aqzr.HAB J\b 208/ 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rlo peAa Ha w.420, il.Z up. ux.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha ocbAenvrfl. C peurenlle or 2I.06.2017 r. crArr e

erso6Honun BHOXA Ne 4151 2016 r. ro orllca na OC Pyce, LI3MeHI4JI e

perxeHr.{eTo, rlpeKBanra$uqupan e AesHLIero, nplaJrox(un e 'rn.78a HK, ralo e

oceo6oAlrr noActALtMLrr or HaKa3areJIHa orfoBopHocr vr My e HaIIO}(I'IJI

aAMLrHHcrparr4BHo HaKa3aHlre uo6a. llpuen e, ve e AorlycHaro HapyrreHl4e Ha

30

3aKoHa [o orHorxeHl4e Ha KBaJluQuxaqn.ara Ha .qetHl4ero, Bb3npllera or ABereIaHcraHul4r\ u Ttplt o[peAen{He Ha HaKa3aHr4ero Jrr{[raBaHe or ceo6oAa npuycnoBuqra na.rn.55 HK u wr.66, an.l HK.

HAB Np 3441 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa Ha'm.420, al.2 np.'ut.422,ar.l, r.5 HnK no r4cKaHe Ha rJraBHr4fl rrpoKypop Ha PB. C perueHne or10.10.2017 r. c'sl'"sr e ntso6HoBl{rl BHOXI Ns l74l 2017 r. rro orrr4ca ua OC -Pyce, I,I3MeHrrJI e pe[reHnero B qacrra, B Korro e norBbpAeHa rrpllcr,Aara HapafioHuI,tx cbA 3a orlpeAeneHrrr pex{r{M 3a lr3Tbp[tBaHe Ha Hultro)KeHoroHaKa3aHr4e, v e oTMeHHn B r{acTTa, B KotTo e o[peAeneH TI.dIla Ha

3arBopHl4rrecKoro 3aBe.qeHl{e. llpuen e) r{e PC e AorrycH€ur Hapy[reHrae HaMarepr,rzilHr{r 3aKon - .rr.57 ) aJr.l, r.3 3I4H3C, a Karo ce e [por43Hecbn rroBbrlpoca 3a rvrila Ha 3arBopHl4qecKoro 3aBeAeHI4e, no xofiro e KoMrrereHTHa3arBopHnqecKara aAMr4HHcrparJvrfl, ra Ha ql.58 3I4H3C.

HAB Ns 2931 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua \r.420, M.2 rlp. ut.422,il.I, r.5 HIIK ro prcKaHe Ha rJraBHr,rr rpoKypop na PE u Ha oct4eHux. CpelxeHue or 09.10.2017 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBrrrr BHOXA l\b 388/ 2016 r. noorll4ca na OC - Jloneu, orMeHlIJI e pelxeHnero B rracrra, B Korro e rlorBbpAeHanpvrct.ILara Ha PC-Terenen 3a ilbpBoHaqaJrnLrfi pex{r{M 3a r{3TbprrrBaHe HaHaKa3aHl{ero, HaJIo)KeHo no qn.343s, an.2 HK sa HaKa3aHzero, 3a Koero enpnnox{en v1.68, a-rr.1 HK I{ B qacrra3arvrrta Ha 3arBopHr4qecKoro o6qexvrue.flpuen e, qe e oupeAeJleH B HapyureHue Ha MarepuzuHu{ 3aKoH Lr Ha .{r.583l{H3C [opaAu HecborBercrBl{e c BJr.f,3Jroro B clrJra r43MeHeHne (ueru. Lr Aon.AIl, 6p. 13 or 07.02.2017 ,.), cropeA Koero rro ro3rr Bbnpoc e KoMrrereHrHa3aTBOpHLrrrecKaTa aAMr4Hr4CTp arlld'fl .

HAB J\b 18ll 2018 r., o6pa:ynaHo rro peAa na qr.420, il.2 n,p. ut.422,M.l, r.5 HilK no rrcKaHe Ha uraBHlrr rpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHrre or04.07.2018 r. cbAbr e nrso6HoBrrrr HOXA Ns 53/ 2014 r. rro orruca na PC -Huronol, I43MeHIJI e npucbAara B qacrra, B KoflTo e HaMaJIeH cpoKa uo .u.66,al.l HK I,I B rlacrra, B Kotro Ha ocHoBaHLre,an.6T, an.3 FIK e [ocraHoBeHor{3rrbJrHeHHe Ha npo6aqzoHHa MrpKa ro utt. 42a, M.2, r.4 HK. llpuen e, qecpoKbr Ha H3nI4TaHkre e olpeAeJreH B HapyrueHlre Ha wt.66, an.2 HK, 3arrloroHaAMkIHaBa cpoKa Ha HaKa3aHLIeTo JII{[IaBaHe or cno6oAa c rroBerre or 3 ro4znrE,a cpoKbr Ha upo6aqr4oHHara MrpKa - B HapyueHr,re ua'il.42a, aJr.3, r.1 HK nooTHOTXeHUe Ha OrrpeAeneHaTa rrpoAbDKHTeJrHocT.

Apyru AeJra, nrso6HoeeHr{ Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHr.re: H,4p Ns 4761 2018 r.;Hre Ng 4921 2017 r.; Hre Ns 50/ 2018 r.

4.2. fieta, stgo6HoeeHu Ha ocHoBaHr4e AorrycHaro cbrrlecrBeHoHapyrxeHr{e Ha npoqecyanHr{re rrpaBr4na (un.348, anl, r.2 HIIK).

HAB Ns l49l 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa Ha'il.420, il.l np. wr.422,M.l, r.5 HnK rro rrcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{.rr npoKypop Ha pE. C perxeHrre or22.05.2011 r. cbAbr e ntgo6noBrzrr HOXA Ns 291 2017 r. rro oruca sa PC -9epneu 6pxr, orMeHI{Jr e o[peAeneHr.rero, c Koero e ogo6peHo clopa3yMeHlrero,

31

10.07.2018 r. crAlr e nrso6HoBr{Jr BHOXA Ns 28l 2018 r. ro oIII4ca na OC -flneeeH u HOXA Jt 1588/ 2017 r. rro onr4ca ua PC-lIneBeH, orMeHI4Jr e

perrreHr,rero r,r nprrcbAara v e BbpH€rn AeJroro Ha PC 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe orApyr cbcraB. Ilpuen e) rre Bb33rlBHLIf,T cbA e AorIycHuL[ cbIIIecrBeHo

rpoqecyanHo HapyueHr{e ro cMI,IcbJIa Ha un.348, N3, r.2 np. M.I, T.2 HIIK,rrfi raro perueHlrero HIIMa MorI4BLI, a pafioHH:aflT cb4 - Ha 'rrr.76 HIIK -

w e :a3ilparr4n Aenoro rro KoMrrereHTHocr ua OII - flreeeFl. llpuen e, LIe AenoroHenpaBnnHo e o6pa3yBaHo e PC BMecro n OC B HapyueHre Ha.{r.38 H|IK llut.42, an.2, np.2 HIIK npr4 orpeAentHe Ha rloAcbAHocrra.

HIB Ns 338/ 2017 r. o6pasyBaHo no peAa lna'il.420, an.I np. un.422,

N.l, r.5 HIIK no r4cKaHe Ha ocbAeHnfl.. C peurenr4e or 03.11.2017 r. cbAbr e

erso6Hosr.rn BHOXA i\le 901 2017 r. ro orrnca na OC - llreseH, orMeHI4JI e

perxeHr{eTo H e BbpHan Aenoro Ha cblql,If, cbA 3a HoBo pa3rnexAaHe oT ApyfcbcraB or craAr4s. Ha cl,4e6uoro 3aceAaHr4e. llpraen e, qe OC e AorIycH€LII

CbUIeCTBeHO IIpOqeCyanHO Hapy[IeHLIe, KaTO He e I'I3IIbJIHI{JI 3aAbJIx{eHI4eTo cI4

no .rr.339, a*2 HIIK Aa r{3nox{Lr Mort4Brr rro Bcr.rqKr.r BbrIpocLI, KoHTo ca orcbrrlecTBeHo 3HaqeHI4e 3a peuraBaHe Ha AeJIoTo.

HAB J\b 140/ 2018 r. o6paayBaHo rlo peAa na qn.420, il.l Yp. wt.422,a1.1, r.5 HIIK no LrcKaHe Ha ocbAeHr4r, qpe3 3arrIHTHr{Ka. C peureHlae or

KOHCTLTTy:/IpaUI e OUIeTeHOTO rOpHAr{rreCKO nr4rle Karo tracTeH o6sl4Hlarer.HAB J\b 1641 2018 r. o6pa":yBaHo ro peAa na \x.420, il.l Yp. un.422,

ffi.|,, r.5 HIIK ro r4cKaHe Ha ocbAenvrfl.. C peureuLle or 1I.07.2018 r. clAm e

Bb3o6HoBral BVHA }lb 11581 2017 r. uo ornca na OC - llreseH, orMeHlul e

perrreHr{eTo r{ e BbpHirn AenoTo Ha cblrlut cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnex(AaHe oT ApyfcbcraB or cra4vrfl Ha crAe6Horo 3aceAaHlle. llpuen e) qe pelxeHllero e

rrocTaHoBeHo rrpv cbrrlecTBeHo rrpoqecy€LllHo Hapy[reHue, rsit KaTo oKpbxHHf,T

c6A Ce e [poll3HecbJr rro AoBoAr4Te B qacTHI4t rlpoTecT Ha npoKyPoPa, Ho He LI

rro AoBoAHTe B xal6ara Ha ocbAeHl,If,.

HAB }lb 1251 2018 r., o6pa3yBaHo rlo peAa na \r.420, N.2 np- wr.422,

il.1, r.5 HIIK ro I4cKaHe Ha ocbAenvfl. C peureune or 30.05.2018 r. cl4rr e

orMeHlrrr rro peAa Ha srgo6HoBf,BaHero pelueHl,Iero rlo BHOXA ],lb 328/ 2017 r.ro orrr4ca na OC - Jlonev, c Koero e rlorBbpAeHa rpllcbAara uo HOX[tNs 2291

2016 r. no onr4ca na PC - Tpoxn B HaKa3areJrHara LI B rpaxAaHcKara it'aacr ufI,I e I43MeHLIJI, KaTo e o[paBA€tJI TIOACbA}IMATA IIO O6BUHEHI{CTO 3€t IIO-TEXKO

HaKa3yeMo rrpecTbrrJreHue r{ e HaMzllun pa3Mepa Ha lpaiKAaHcKI4{ LICK 14 Ha

Abp)KaBHara raKca. flpuen e, qe ca HapyueHl{ npoqecyanHllTe fi upana, 3alrloro

cbAe6Hr4Te aKToBe ca [ocraHoBeHll cneA orM{Ha Iro HefiHa xa-n6a Ha

rrocraHoBeHara rIpH rlbpBoro pa3rnexAaHe Ha Aenoro or PC rlpucbAa.

Heupanunuo upu BTopoTo pa3rnexAaHe Ha AenoTo cbAbr e AoIIycHanr43MeHeHue sa o6nnHeHl4eTo rlpu ycnoBr4flTa no'rr.287, il.1 HIIK, MaKap v

^aca 6ulu HaJrr,rqe ocHoBaHI4s, 14 e npI4Jro)KI4Jr 3aKoH 3a no-TexKo HaKa3yeMo

IIpeCTbIIneHLIe.

4.3. I.eta, ssso6Honeuz Ha ocHoBaHVe ro .rr.348. a,r.l" r.3 HIIKHanoxeHoTo HaKa3aHue e rBHo HecrIpaBeAnI4BO.

HAB Ns 2241 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha w.424, ar..l vp. ttr.422,aJI.l, r.5 HIIK ro I{cKaHe Ha ocbreHafl. C peureHue or 17.07.2017 r. cbAbr enrso6Hoezl BHOXA J\b 8l5l 2015 r. no onuca Ha OC - llreseFr, r.r3MeHr4rr epelxeHl4ero, c Koero e [orBT,pAeHa npr4cbAara na PC-9epBeH 6pxr B rracrra 3aHaKa3aHl4ero Ha eAI4H or noAcbArrMr4Te npr4 ycnoBr4flTa Ha .{r.54 HK u npnycnoBl4tra Ha q1.55, il.1, r.l HK e HaMiuIr4Jr (nuecro oupelenvl) Hara:aHr4erontrlraBaHe or cno6o4a B pa3Mep noA rrpeABuAeHr4_fl Mr4Hr{MyM 3anpecrbllneHllero rlo rIJI.l96, anl, r.1 FIK. llpraeJr e, qe e norBbpAeHo rBHoHeclpaBeAnLIBo HaKa3aHHe nopaArr HecboTBercrBLrero My c r{3BbprrreHoTo, co6rqecrnelc'ara orracHocr Ha AeflHkrero z Ha Aeerla, c rleJrr4Te no qr.36 HK.

HAB Np 3321 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa ua \r.424, M.l np. ut.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK uo HcKaHe Ha uaBHr4-rr ilpoKypop Ha pE. C perueHrre or14.1I.2018 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBLIrr HOXA l'(b 1554/ 2018 r. ro orrr{ca na PC -llnenen, oTMeHLIJI e olpeAeJleHr.rero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cloprryMeHr4ero 3apeluaBaHe Ha AeJIoro, I4 e BbpHiur AeJroro Ha cbrrlu{ cb.4 3a HoBo pa3fne)KAaHeor Apyr cbcraB. llpnen e) qe HaKa3aHlzero upo6aqzx e olpeAeneHo rrpuycnoBrrtra IF^a'Ir.55 HK e HapylxeHl4e Ha 3aKoHa r{ [poqecyanHr.rre rrpaBuna,3alrloro He ca B3erLI rIpeABrrA AaHHr{Te sa cr4e6noro Mr,IHano Ha o6nuu11ery1ut,IIOPAAH KOCTO HC CbOTBCTCTBA HA IICNI4TE TIO 'IJI.36 HK U E

'BHOHecrIpaBeAnLIBo. Ogo6pxnaHero Ha cropa3yMeHr,rero e B HapyueHLre uawr.382,ar 7 Hltr(.

4.4. [ela, ntgo6HoneHz Ha ocHoBaHlre HenpaBHJrHo npvnoxeHrre HaMarepu€rnHl,If 3aKoH H AonycHaro cbrrlecrBeHo HapyneHlre Ha rrpoqecy€rrrHrrrerrpaBr{Jra.

HAB J\b 1231 2017 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa na'rr.424, il.l np. wr.422,il.l, r.5 HIIK ro LrcKaHe Ha rJraBHr{r rrpoKypop Ha PE. C peureHr4e or01.06.2017 r. cbAbr e srso6HoBI{JI HOXA Ns 504/ 2016 r. rro oruca Ha PC -llneneu, orMeHuJI e o[peAeJreHllero, c Koero e o4o6peHo clopa3yMeHr4ero, H eBbpHuLn Aenoro Ha cblrlu{ cbA 3a HoBo punrne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. llpuel e,ve pafioHHvrflT cbA e o4o6pun cropa3yMeHlrero B HapyueHlre Ha st.382, an 7H[IK, rtfi xaro He e B3en [peABLrA AaHHrlTe B crrpaBKara 3a cbArrMocr 3arIpeAI4ruHI{ ocbntAanvrfl na o6suHfleMvrfl vI HaJil4queTo Ha [peArrocTaBKuTe 3alpuno)KeHraero Ha .rr.78a HK Karo ocHoBaHr,re Aenoro Aa ce pa3fneAa B

rrpor43BoAcrBo rro frr. 28 HIIK. (P-271 2003 -r,p-4ggl 2009 - II BKC ,IIBC 7l1985 r.;)

HAB Ns 2521 2018 r., o6pa":yBaHo rro peAa :e'a'il.424, il.I np. utr.422,al.I, r.5 HIIK rro rrcKaHe Ha rJraBHr4r npoKypop Ha P6. C perxeHr,re or18.09.2018 r. cbAbr e srgo6HoBLIrI HOXA J\b 306/ 2018 r. ro orruca na PC -Pyce, orMeHr.rJr e olpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e ogo6peHo clopa3yMeHnero, v aBbpHaJI Aenoro Ha cblr{Ht cbA 3a HoBo pa3rne)KAaHe or Apyr cbcraB. flpzel e,

JJ

qe pafioH:uvrfrT cr,A e oAo6pl4n cilopa3yMeHuero B HapyueHl4e Ha qn.382, an. 7

HIIK, Tbfi Karo tr3rrbJlHeHr4ero Ha orrpeAeJleHoro HaKa3aHI,Ie e ornoxeHo B

HapyrxeHr{e Ha 3aKoHa, 3auloro He ca HanI4IIe ocHoBaHl4tra rlo ull.66, an.1 HK.

HAB J\b 378/ 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo no peAa ]Ha'il.424, il.l Yp' wt'42L

ar.l, r.5 HnK rro I{cKaHe Ha DIaBHI4I llpoKypop Ha PE' C pelxeHue oT

1I.12.2018 r. crabr e Bb3o6Hoerar HOXA Ng 162712018 r. rlo oilnca na PC -fllenen, orMeHr4Jr e onpeAeJreHlrero, c Koero e o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHl4ero, I4 e

BbpH€Ln AenoTo Ha cbIIIIIfl A'bA 34 HOBO pa3lnex{AaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB nopaAl4

AouycHaro HapyueHr{e Ha .rn.382, an.7 HIIK. llpuen e, qe pafroHHl4sr cbA e

HapyIIIun 3aKoHa, KaTO e onpeAenr4n pa3Mepa Ha HaKa3aHI{eTO JITIUaBaHe OT

cso6oAa rpr4 ycnoBvrflTa Ha vn.54 HK, a ro orHolrreHrle Ha KyMyJIarrrBHo

rrpeABuAeHoro 3a rrpecrtrrJreHlrero HaKa3aHI4e uo6a e [puno)I(Izn 'rn.55, al.3

HK, roero e Bb3MoxHo caMo Koraro r4 ABere HaKa3aHu{ ce o[peAensr rlpll

ycnoBr4sra uo q1.55 HK.HAB ],{b 180/ 2017 r., o6pasyBaHo rro peAa :na'rr.420, N.2 np. wt.422,

an.l. r.5 HIIK no ucKaHe Ha ocbAeHvrfl.. C peruenlle or 2I.06.2017 r. crgtr e

Bb3o6HoBr,rn BHOXA Ns l05l 2017 r. rlo oIII4ca Ha OC - Pyce, orMeHI4JI e

peueHr4eTo r4 e BbpHan AenoTo Ha cbuILIs cbA 3a HoBo p€Bfnex{AaHe oT cTailI4fl.

ua crAe6Horo 3aceAaHue. flpnen e, rre [puerara realu0Hxar\vs. Ha Ae{HI,Iero e

He3aKoHocro6pa:na. BrsglannnflT cbA e AoIIycHiuI cblrlecrBeHo HapyueHl,Ie Ha

lpoqecyanHr4r 3aKoH, KaTo He e y[paxHHJI rIpaBoMoIrIvrflTA CI,I rO Wr.337, il.1,r.2, np. rocneAHo np. un.334,'r.3 HIII( Aa r{3MeHI,I nbpBoLIHcraHIII4oHHara

rrpucbAa LI Aa rrpuno)Kl{ 3aKoH, KofiTo e rpr6nano Aa rrpl4no)Iil'I.

HAB }lb 1441 20Ll r., o6pa-ayBaHo rlo pe.qa na wr.424, M.l np. wr.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HIIK ro I{cKaHe Ha r;IaBHLII npoKypop na PE. C perueHl4e or22.05.20IJ r. c's1rr e Bb3o6HoBr,rJr HOXA J\b 21811 2016 r. ro ornca na PC -Belnro Trpnono, oTMeHI4JI e onpeAeneHzeTo, c KoeTo e ogo6peno

crropiByMeHrreTo, LI e BbpH€Lrr AenoTo Ha cbLIIH{ cbA 3a HOBO pa3fnexAaHe oT

Apyr cbcraB or craAras Ha cb.qe6noro 3aceAaHI,Ie. flpuel e, qe pafioHHzxr cbA

Karo e o4o6pun c[opa3yMeHuero, B Koero HaKa3aHLIero e olpeAeneHo rIpLI

ycJroBurflra :na'ril.78a HK, e AorIycH€In HapyneHl{e :aa'aL382, N.l HIIK. llpuH€Lrrutrr4eTo Ha KyMyJraTr4BHo rrpeABr4AeHI{Te rIpeArIocTaBKI4 AenOTO Cne.qBa Aa ce

p€BrJreAa B rIpoH3BoAcrBo uo ruI. 28 HIIK, a He rlo rt.29 HilK.HAB Ne 148/ 2017 r., o6pa3yBaHo rlo peAa uaqil.424, il.1 Yp. wr.422,

M.l, r.5 HIIK ro LIcKaHe Ha HTaBHI{-f, llpoKypop Ha PB. C pelxeHue or27.04.2017 r. csil'rr e srso6HoBlrrr HOXA J\b 86/ 2017 r. IIo oruca na PC -fopna Opxxonnqa, LI3MeHLIJI e olpeAeneHl4ero, c KoeTo e o4o6peno

crrop€ByMeHlleTo B qacTTa, B KOrTo e onpeAeneH pex{LlMa 3a I43Tbpru{BaHe Ha

HaKa3aHHeTo JrI4IrIaBaHe or cso6oAa B HapylreHvre Ha ut. 57, il.1, r.2 u r.33I4H3C, V ro e oTMeHHJI B rIacTTa, B KotTo e onpeAeneH TI{na Ha

3arBopHr{rrecKoro 3aBeAeHlre. flpuen e, qe PC e AonycHzIJI HapylxeHlre Ha iIJr.

58, an.l 3I4H3C, Karo ce e ilpor{3HecbJr BMecro 3arBopHl,IqecKara

34

aIMI'IHI4crparil4A. He e I43[IT,JIHI4n [poqecyaJrHnTe cv 3a1bnxeH14-s no .ir.382.ar.5 HIIK u e o4o6pl4n cnopa3yMeHnero B HapyueHr4e Ha r{rr. 382, a1.7 HIIK.

HAB l\b 3451 2018 r., o6pasyBaHo no peAa Ha,il.424, at.I np. ul,.422,M.l, r.5 HllK rro HcKaHe Ha rJraBHr4r rrpoKypop Ha pE. C peureHne or21.11.2018 r. cbAbr e er:o6FloBr4rr HOXA Ns 4221 2017 r. rro onuca ua pC -Cnuulor, orMeHI4JI e onpeAeneHzero, c Koero e ogo6peHo crropa3yMeHuer o, pr eBbpH€trI Aenoro Ha rlpoKypopa. llpueJr e, rle He[paBr4JrHo e npr4noxeH .{r.343rHK np. utt.37 , il.1, r.7 HK, rrfi raro o6enH-f,eNar4flT He e rrpaBocloco6en BoAaqua MIIC. Karo e o4o6pun cnopa3yMeHr{ero, Koero rrporuBoperru Ha 3aKoHa,cbAbr e AonycH€LII CbIrIeCrBeHO HapyneHr4e Ha npoqecyanHr{Te rrpaBr4na IIocl,lucbna'rr.3 82, an. 7 HIIK.

HAB 4691 2018 r., o6pa3yBaHo rro peAa :r'a\r.424, ar^.l np. u1.422, at.r,r.5 H|IK ilo I{cKaHe Ha rJIaBHnq rpoKypop Ha PE. C perxeHr.re or 20.02.2019 r.cbAbr e erso6HoBI4JI HOXA Ns 2441 2018 r. rro ouuca na PC - Cnzulon,orMeHI'IJI e olpeAeJleHl,Iero, c Koero e o4o6peHo c[opa3yMeHLrero 3a peruaBaHeHa Aenoro, 14 e BbpHaJr Aenoro Ha cbulHs cbA 3a HoBo pa3fnexAaHe or ApyfcbcraB. llpnen e, qe PC e AonycHan HapyrueHr.re Ha 3aKoHa, Karo He erlpeAno)Klan IIpoMf,Ha u He e rrpr4noxr{n qn.343r HK 3a rr3BbprrreHororlpecrbnneHlle no '{r.3436 FIK Aa nr4rnvr IroAcbAlrMufl or rrpaBo Aa y[paB rrflBaMIIC, 3alrloro e rlpaBocloco6eH BoAarr. O4o6pxeaHero Ha cropa3yMeHlrero e BHapyIIIeHVe Ha [poqecyanHLlTe [paBLIna rro cMIICbJIa Ha .In.382, an'5 u an.]HNK.

Apy." Aelra, nrso6HoneHll Ha cbrrloro ocHoBaHr4e: FIp Ns 191/ 2017 r.;HAB J\b 31ll 2011 r.; HIB J\b 455/ 2011 r.; HIB Ns7412018 r.; H,D Ns 361/2018 r.; Hre Ns 4281 2018 r.; HlB Ns l47l 2017 r.; HlB J\b 3t9l 2018 r.;HP }lb 3201 2018 r.; HAB J\b 405/ 2018 r.

4.5. [eta, stso6HoseHll Ha ocHoBaHrie HerrpaBlrnHo npr4noxeHrre HaMarepLIuuIHI{t 3aKoH vr flBIla HecrrpaBeAnl{Bocr Ha HalroxeHoro HaKa3aHr,re.

HAB Ns 2641 2018 r., o6pa:yBaHo rro peAa Lra,rn.420, at.2 np. ut.422,M.l, r.5 HIIK ro LIcKaHe Ha 3anlrrrHr4K Ha ocbAerrus. C perxeHrre or 16.11.2018r. cbAbr e sr:o6HoBHJr BHOXA J\b 138/ 2018 r. rro onvca na OC - Jloneu,I,rcMeHIIJI e pe[reHuero B rlacrra 3a KBalluQnrcaquxra Ha AesHuero, Karo fo erlpeKBanl4QIaqupan ro r{JI.149, alr.l HK r{ ro onpaBAir[ ro nbpBoHaq€urHoroo6nnHenve; B rracrra 3a HaK€BaHLIero JrrlrrraBaHe or cso6oAa, Karo ro HaM€urrrJI,orMeHI{JI B qacrra, B Kotro e npuno)Ken v1.68, an.l HK u [pr{noxuttut.69, anTHK, Karo ocso6oAzr ocbAeHl4r H3rrrno or H3TbprrrBaHe Ha HaKa3aHLrero.flpuel, qe e AorlycHaro HapyrueHr{e Ha MarepraaJrHr4r 3aKoH rrpurnanzQzqupaHe Ha AeflHr4ero H rrpu [pr4noxeHr{ero Ha v1.68, an.l HK, a 11o

orHolrreH6e Ha pa3Mepa Ha HaKa3aHr4eTO - rre He ca B3eTr4 rIpeABLrA BCnrrKLrulr4uBu Ay anra:'Lrp aulpr n H qH o c rra r{ A erH r4 e ro o6 crosren c rB a.

35

Ha .rn.55, an.l, T.2, 6. ,,6" HK, e B HapyueHl4e Ha 3aKoHa v

HecnpaBeAJII4BO, 3aIIIOTO e IIO-Te)KKO OT anTepHaTuBHo IIpeABI4AeHOTO

HaKa3aHI4e rno6a 3a u3BbpIIIeHoTo rIpecTbIIneHI4e. Karo e

4.6. [ela, Bb3o6HoBeHr4 Ha ocHoBaHr4e HenpaBunHo npi'Inox(eHHe Ha

MaTepnaJrHt4s 3aKOH, qBHa HecrrpaBeAn[BocT Ha HanoxeHoTo HaKa3aHI4e I{

H apyIUeHVe HA rlpoqecyarHr{Te rlpaBl4na.

HAB J\b 154/ 2011 f., o6pa3yBaHo no peAa Hasn.424, arl.1 8p.qn.422,

aJr.l, r.5 HIIK rlo r'IcKaHe Ha rqaBHufl. rpoKypop Ha PE. C pelueHl4e or

22.06.2017 r. cbAbr e Bb3o6HoBlrrr HOXA J\|l 60/ 2017 r. ro orlnca Ha PC -llleeeu, orMeHr4n e onpeAeJreHr4ero, c Koero e oAo6peHo cllopa3yMeHl'Iero, I'I e

BbpHan AenoTo Ha c6uII,I{ CbA 3a HOBO pa3fne}KAaHe oT Apyf cbcTaB oT cTaAI4q

Ha cbAe6Horo npor43BoAcrBo. flpHen e, qe HaKa3aHuero, Koero pafroHHr4f-T c1".(

e H€uroxuJr - 11po6apfl, a':,,c cborBerHl4Te IIpo6aIII4oHHlI MepKI4 rlpu ycnoBnflTaE {BHO

B 3AKOHA

oAo6pI4n

crropa3yMeHl,Ie, KOeTO npOTI.IBOpeqU Ha 3aKOHa, e AonycHan cbIIIecTBeHO

HapyrreHr4e HailpoqecyanHl{re rlpaBl4na - qn.382, an-7 HIIK.HAB }ts 4Srl 2018 f. o6pa3yBaHo ro peAa Ha v.n.424, il.I Bp. qil.422,

il.l, r.5 HIIK rro I4cKaHe Ha ocb4eH. C peruenue or 0I.02.2019 r. clAlr e

Bb3o6HoBun HOXA J\e 80/ 2018 r. IIo oruIca Ha PC-Tpoau, Ia3MeHLIJI e

rrpr{cbAaTa vr e HaM€Lrrr4Jr pa3Mepa Ha HiLlo)KeHoTo HaKa3aHI4e JIHIIIaBaHe OT

cBo6oAa. llpuen e, qe B Ta3r,r ft qacr e [ocraHoBeHa B HapyueHue Ha 3aKoHa,

Karo He e cbo6pa":eHa cbc 3a6pa*arra 3a refonnatio in pejus, 3alrloro e Bropa

cne.rl orM.rrHa rro )Kan6a Ha rroAcbAl,IMara Ha nocraHoBeHara rrpu tlbpBoro

pa3rJrexAaHe Ha AenoTo u cneA BHactHe Ha HoB o6nnHureJleH aKT c o6BuHeHI4e

3a cbrrloTo rlpecrbrlJleHl4e.

II. Koncraraurr.,{ouycnarn HapyuIeHl4x, KoHcTaTupaHYr oT AC-flnonAus:

HecboTBeTcTBHe Ha OrrpeAeneHlrfl pe)KI4M 34 I{3TbprItBaHe Ha HaK€BaHLIeTO

Jrr{rrraBaHe or cBo6oAa c aKryurJrHara peAaKllvrfl. Ha 3I4H3C; orpeAensHe Ha rutra

Ha 3aTBOpHLTqeCKOTO 3aBeAeHI,re BMecTo KOMIIeTeHTHaTa [a fo orIpeAeJILI

3aTBopHrrqecKa aAMlrHr{cTpa\r4fl.; He e HiL[o)KeHo aAMLIHLICTpaTI4BHO HaKa3aHIAe

fJlo6a, fipLr laankrrllaero Ha Bcr4rrKI{ KyMynaruBHo npe,qBLIAeHlr npeAilocraBKl{ uo

.rr.78a HK; npunox(eH ql.78a HK ro orHoIueHLIe Ha oupeAeneHoro Ha

ocHoBaHr{e un.63, an.l, r.3 F{K narasanvre; o[peAeneHLI ABe npo6aIII4oHHI'I

MepKI,r, BMeCTO CaMO eAHa, 3a lI3rrI{TaTeJIHHfl CpOK; OIIpeAeneH I43rII'ITaTeneH

cpoK, KofiTo HaAMLTHaBa cpoKa Ha HaKa3aHuero JILI[IaBaHe or cBo6oAa c rloBerle

or rprr roAr4Hr{; ocBo6oxAaBaHe or HaKa3arenHa orroBopHocr c HaIIaraHe Ha

aAMLTHHCTpaTT{BHO HaKa3aHI'Ie IIO OTHOIIIeHI4e Ha IIbJIHOJIeTHO JII4IIe,

ynorpe6uno HapKorvq;z; He e [pLrJro)KeH sait-lnarorputrH]It 3a AeeIIa 3aKoH;

HaJroXeHo HaKa3aHue iIrIUraBaHe or rlpaBo Ha o6eI'1HseN4, KofiTo He e

rrpaBocrroco6eu BoAarr Ha MIIC; Ha3HarIeH cnyxe6eH 3aIrIrIrHI4K nopaAl{

36

HetBtBaHe Ha ynbnHoMouleHl4t no yBax{I4TeJIHt4 rrpurvHvr, 6es cr,uacr4e HarIoAcbAI4MLlfl; B'b33r4BHI{f,T CbA He e rocoqnJr ocHoBaHr4flTA 3a OTKa3 Ia npr4eMe

AoBoAI4Te B xan6a vIrr4 B nporecr - perxeHr4ero HrMa Morr,rBr{; orKa3 3aI'I3MeHeHI4e Ha o6saHeHuero ilpv ycraHoBeHr4 Ha cl4e6uoro cnencrBr{eocHoBaHI4t 3a cbu]ecrBeHo I43MeHeHHe Ha o6croqreJlcrBeHara r{acr Hao6enHenzero; [opaAu lrurca Ha AoKa3areJrcrBa 3a cr4e6Horo MrdHaJro Hao6snHser\4r4q e o4o6peHo crropa3yMeHrie 3a npecrbnneHr4e, 3a KoeroOOBI,IH'EMI4qT C I4MA[ BJI.f,3JIA B QKIJJA NPHCbAA; PCIIABAHC HA ACNOTO OT

He3aKOHeH CbCTaB rropaAr,l IlaJrurlsr4e Ha ocHoBaHr4r 3a orBoA; Hapy[reHaza6panara 3a reformatio in pejus rpr4 orMeHeHa npr4cbAa rro xan6a HafIoAcbALIMVfl; rrpkrcbAa rlo orHorrreHkre Ha nr4rle c pa3rl{r{no SavuJrHo HMe orToBa Ha JII4IIero, cpeqy Koero e nO4eHo HaKa3arenHoro npolr3BoAcrBo;npvnoxeHa pa3nrrrrHa or aKryanHara peAaKrlufl npu cuoro46a no HrD([; cpa3rrope)KAaHe, BMecro cbc ct4e6eu aKT, cbAbr ce e [por.r3Hecbn rrorna-rrzSura\LrflTa Ha AesHuero; He e r43rrbJrHeHo 3aAbmKeHr4ero 3a orIeHKa Ha

BcLITIKI,I vrHAvtBvtAyaJILI3upaIqu rLrr{Hoc'rta u AetHrlero o6croqreJlcrBa, AoBeno

AO flBHA HeC[paBeAnI{BOCT Ha HaJTOXeHOTO HaKa3aHUe rro pa3Mep; rBHa

HecrIpaBeAnI4BocT Ha HanoxeHoTo HaKzBaHI4e nO AenO, KOeTO He e pa3fneAaHo rr

perrreHo B pa3yMeH cpoK; He e npeAnoxeHa [poM.f,Ha B crrop€ByMeHzero;

ogo6peno e c[opa3yMeHne, Koero nporuBoperrr4 Ha 3aKoHa; r43n6JrHeHr,rero Ha

HaKa3aHLIeTo JII{[IaBaHe or cso6oAa e orJloxeHo, 6ea Aa ca Harlr4rle Bcr{qKLr

rIpeABuAeHI{ B 3aKoHa rlpeAllocraBKrz; rcnanvr$zrarluflTa Ha Ae.rrHrrero Bcrlopa3yMeHl4ero e pa3nuqHa or r€Br4 rro o6nusenuero; HtrMa rrporr3HacrHe 3a

HaKa3aHHeTO JIHIUaBaHe OT IIpaBo, KOTaTO e IIpeABLtAeHo.

,{onycHaru HapyrxeHr4s, KoHcrarvpaHu or AC BapHa: orJro)KeHo

I43nbJIHeHLIeTo Ha HaKa3aHI4eTO [pLI H€UIHqIIeTO Ha AaHHI{, qe TIOACbAZMI,I'T He epea6uturrlpaH no rlpaBo; o[peAeneno o6qo HaKa3aHLre, Karo He ca BKJrrolreHu B

cbBKynHocTTa BcI4qKI{ HaKa3aHVfl; HeCbOTBeTCTBT{e Ha OrrpeAeJreHuf pexfl{M 3a

LI3TbpIItBaHe Ha HaKa3aHnero nlaluaBaHe or cso6oAa c aKTyaJrnara peAaKrllrs Ha

3I,IH3C; olpeAentHe Ha rr4rra Ha 3arBopHr.rqecKoro 3aBeAeHr4e, BMecro3arBopHr4rrecKara aAMlrHr.rcrparlufl; rnanusnxa\vsra Ha AeflHr4ero He e

necro6pa:eHa c AaHHI4Te 3a Hacrbnuta pea6unurrar\krfl: cpoKbr Ha HaKa3aHlrero

JII4IrraBaHe OT npaBo rIO-KpaTbK OT CpOKa Ha HaKa3aHVeTO nVUraBaHe OT

cno6o,qa; MecroI43rIbJIHeHpIero Ha rrpHHyAr{TeJrHara MeAr.rrIr{HcKa MrpKapa3nLItIHo OT IIpeABI4AeHOTO B 3aKOHa; HanO)KeHo aAMLIHI4OTpaTI,IBHO HaKa3aHr.re

rIpH ycnoBl{flTa Ha 'il.78a HK, 6es Aa ca HaJr[rIe BclrrrKtr rrpeABr{AeHra

npeAnocraBKr{; He e rrpeAnoxeHa npoM.f,Ha B c[opa3yMeHuero; o4o6peuo e

37

cnopa3yMeHlle, KOeTO [pOTI4BOpeqI{ Ha 3aKOHa; HaJiOXeHa eAHa BMeCTO ABeTe

3aA:bJr)rgrrerHg rIpo6aUHoHHH MepKI4; OC He e yrpaxHl{Jl npaBoMolr{uero Aa

r,r3MeHr4 npI4cT,AaTa B qacTTa 3a KBaJIUSrzxaqraflTA HA AetHpIeTO; B OIIpeAeJIeHoTO

o6qo HaKa3aHI4e ca BKIIoqeHu HaKa3aH1g'fl', HaMHpaIq14 ce B oTHoIUeHHe Ha

perIrrAI4B; HaKa3aHI4eTo e H€UIolI(eHo npu ycnoBnflTa flo 'In.54 HK, Ho rIoA

npeABr,rAeHI4t 3a npecTbnJIeHI,leTO MIIHIIMyM; HapyueHl4e Ha IIpaBOTO Ha

noAcbAr4M4fr ila AaBa hnt Aa oTKax(e [a AaBa o6qcHeul4q IIo oSnuueuraero;

perxeHl4eTo He OTfOBOpq Ha I43LICKBaHI/.flTA 3a CbAbpxaHI'Ie; AenoTo e

pa3fJreAaHo oT He3aKoHeH cbcTaB IIopaAI{ Ig.aIII4IsI,e Ha ocHoBaH.Ide 3a oTBOA;

oAo6peHo cropa3yMeHr4e or cbAa B rrpol,I3BoAcrBo tro qil.29 HIIK, BMecro orKa3

lr Bpbu{aHe Ha Aenoro 3a o6pa3yBaHe Ha npol43BoAcrBo rlo ur. 28 HIIK npra

]HaJrvr-qzre Ha BcLrrrKH rrpeArrocraBKlr IIo qJI.78a HK; o4o6peHo cnopa3yMeHl4e 3a

pelraBaHe Ha Aenoro B cbAe6Horo [poll3BoAcrBo rrpl,r Jrlr[ca Ha cbrJlaavre Ha

crpaHa; oAo6peHo crropa3yMeHr,re [pr{ AaHHI4, qe He ca Bb3craHoBeHH IIJII{

o6egue.reHr4 npr4rrr4HeHr.rre c IrpecrbrlneHuero uMyIrIecrBeHI'I BpeAI{;

rrpoToKonbT He e [o.qlvcaH oT rrpeAceAaTeJlt Ha cbcTaBa; HqMa IIpoI43HaCtHe OT

ABeTe r4HcTaHrlr4r4 fro rrbpBoHaq€L[HoTo o6enHeHl4e; IIpu peluaBaHe Ha AenoTO

c:bc c[op€t3yMeHr{e HqMa rrpor43HacrHe no qn.23, ffi.2 HK sa HaKa3aHl{ero

JrHrrraBaHe oT npaBo; KyMynaTLrBHo rIpeABI4AeHI{Te 3a H3BbpIUeHOTO

rrpecrbrrJreHr{e HaKa3aHr.r{ ca olpeAeJIeHLI npu pa3nvrrrHr ycnoBHfl (luuraeaue or

cBo6oAa .In.54 HK; uo6a .Ir.55 K); npeAno)KeHa rlpoMtHa B

cnopa3yMeHlre, c Ko{To e ycTaHoBeHo HoBo $arcruuecKo [oJIox(eHLIe; H€LIIO)KeHO

HaKa3aHUe JrLr[raBaHe oT rrpaBo Ha o6BLrHreM, KofiTo He e npaBoc[oco6eH Bo.{aq

Ha MfIC; oAo6peHo cuopa3yMeHr4e 3a rrpecrbfrJreHl{e, pa3nl{qHo or roBa, 3a

Koero o6suHqeN,rvsr e [pkrBneqeH Aa orroBapt LI e BHeceH oOBLIHI,ITeIeH aKT;

orrpeAeneHo o6qo HaKa3aHLre, Karo He ca BKrroqeHLI B cbBKytlHocrra BcI{qKu

l;iaKa3antrfi; cbAe6Ha pea6unr4Tar\vrfl. rrpeAu I,I3TLIqaHe Ha rIpeABr4 ennfl. cpoK;

HaKa3aHzero, o[peAeneHo n o4o6peHoro cnopa3yMenue, e 3a IIpecrbrIJIeHLIe,

pa3nr.rqHo oT BrrncaHoTo BbB BHeceHoTo 3a oAo6pflBane; IIocTaHoBeHI{ cbAe6Hn

aKToBe rro HIXA, 6el Aa ca cl';6paHvr AoKa3arencrBa 3a o6crotreJlcrBara Iro

.rr.78a HK; [pr4 orrpeAenrHe Ha o6uloro HaK€BaHHe cbBKyrlHocrra e

QoprvrupaHa HerIpaBHJIHo.

,{onycHarra Hapy[IeHI{t, KoHcraTIlpaHV oT AC - Eyprac: [pllnox{eH

un.68, an.l HK caruo 3a eAHo or HaKa3aHvrflTa B cbBKy[Hocrra, BMecro Iro

orHorrreHne Ha o[pe.{eneHoro o6ulo HaK€BaHI4e; oAo6peHo clopa3yMeHue B

lpor/r3BoAcrBo uo 'aL29 H[IK, BMecro orKa3 vr BpbIrIaHe Ha AeJIoro 3a

o6pasynane Ha rrpor,r3BoAcrBo rro rJI. 28 HIIK upu HaJrvqr4e Ha BcI{IIKI4

38

rlpeAnocraBKlr [o qn.78a HK; npl4no]I(eH.rn.68, an.l HK no orHo[reHr4e Ha

HaKa3aHHe, Koero Beqe e I,I3TbpnqHo; npunoxeH q1.67, a*l HK rio orHorrreHr,re

Ha rIoAcbAHM, HaBbprxAJI [bJrHOJreTrre ilpeAlr nocTaHoBrBaHe Ha npr4cb4aTa;

AorrycHara pea6r4nvra\r4fr rlo [paBo, 6ea Aa e Hacrbfrr4Jra pea6uttuTarlr4r no

IpyfH trpvcbnv; HapylxeHo [paBoro Ha 3axIHTa rro orHorrreHr4e Ha 3aAbpxaH, 3a

r<ofiro e npeABI4AeHo 3aAbJIx{HTeJrHo yqacrue Ha 3arrlkrrHnK; o4o6peHoCnOpa3yMeHLIe c o[peAeJleHo aAMLIHIIcTpaTI{BHo HaKa3aHIIe rto .{r.78a HK; He

ca rlocoqeHl4 ocHoBaHvIflTa 3a oTKtBa Aa Ce npr4eMaT 3a ocHoBaTeJrHH AOBOAHTe B

xal6ara; HapylxaBaHe Ha sa6paHara 3a peuaBaHe Ha Aenoro cbc cnopa3yMeHue

3a cnyqanTe, Koraro e u3Bbp[IeHo npecTbnneHtre, c KoeTo e npuqLrHeHa cMbpr;perrreHr,rero He e noArrr4caHo or rIJreH Ha crge6uun cbcraB; qBHa

HecrrpaBeAnl4Bocr Ha HaIIo)KeHOTO HaKa3aHHe rIO AenO, KOerO He e p€BfneAaHo H

perxeHo B pa3yMeH cpoK; HapyrxaBaHe Ha npaBoro HaKa3aHr4ero Aa 6t4eo[IpeAeneHo B cboTBeTcTBI4e C yCTaHOBeHr4Te r4H4ldBLrAyanzl3lapau\r4

o6crosreJlcrBa, Te)Kecrra Ha H3BbprreHoro 14 rlenr.rre uo .{r.36 HK; ilptraJITepHarI,IBHo rIpeABHAeHIl HaKa3anvrfl e rrpr4nox(en .{r.55 HK, nrraecro Aa 6rleollpeAeneHo no-JIeKoTo tlo BI4A; He e rrpeAnox(eHa npoMrrHa B crropiByMeHHeTo;o4o6peno e cnopa3yMeHl{e, Koero rrporr{Bopequ Ha 3aKoHa; orJro)r(eHoLI3rIbJrHeHI4ero Ha HaKa3aHLIero rro orHorrreHxe Ha ocbx(AaH Lr Hepea6utmrupauo6szuseNa; o4o6peHo cropa3yMeHkre rrprr nkrrrca Ha AeKnapa\prfl na o6suHflovrprfl3a orKa3 or crAe6so pa3rne)KAaHe Ha Aenoro no o6qr4s. pe1; HrrMa cbrJracne Ha

crpaHa upl{ clopa3yMeHI4e 3a perxaBaHe Ha AeJroro n clAe6uoro rrpor{3BorcrBo;cpoKbr Ha HaKa3aHI4erO JrlrlraBaHe or lpaBo no-KparbK or cpoKa Ha

HaKa3aHnero JrkIIIraBaHe or cno6oAa; HecborBercrBr4e Ha olpeAeneHr.rf, pexLrM3a I,I3Tbpn.sBaHe Ha HaKzBaHHero JrlrruaBaHe or cso6oAa c aKTy€urHara peAaKrl[rflHa 3I4H3C; [pornBopeqI4e MexAy yBoAHa rracr, Morr4BLr rr Aurcno3vrrvB Ha

rrpkrc'brura; rplrnoxeH wt.66, an.l HK 3a fipecrt[neHrre, Lr3BbprrreHo B

I43tlzrarelruufl. cpoK Ha 3aMeHeHoro HaK€BaHr4e upo6aqnr c JrzruaBaHe orcno6oAa; H€uIo)KeHo HaKa3aHve JrurxaBaHe or rrpaBo na o6nuHxeu, rofiTo He enpaBocnoco6eH BoAaq Ha MIIC; olpeAenrHe Ha pe)Kr{M Ha r43TbprurBaHe HaHaKa3aHr4ero rro pela Ha rbnKyBaHe Ha BJre3JILrfl B Cy'Ira Cr4e6en arr.

,{ouycnaru HapyrrreHur, KoHcrarr{paqu or AC Berurco Trpnono:HecborBercrBue Ha o[peAeneHr,rr pexr4M 3a Lr3TbprrsBaHe Ha HaKa3aHr{eroJII4IrIaBaHe or cno6oAa c aKry€LJIHara peAaKrlr4fl Ha 3I4H3C; orpeAeneno o61loHaKa3aHHe BMeCTO rlpn HAnurlue caMo Ha ocHoBaHLre KbM OCTaTbKa OT

HeI'I3Tbp[-[HOTO HaKa3aHLIe Aa Ce npr4cbe4r4Hvr H€L[oxeHoTo HoBo HaK€BaHHe;

H€LlO)r{eHO HaK€BaHr4e rrpu ycnoBr{qra Ha .rr.55 il \r.66 HK. BMeCTO

39

aAMUHr4CTparrrBHO HaKa3aHr{e fnoSa; oilpeAenflHe Ha THIIa Ha 3aTBOpHHqeCKOTO

3aBeAeHHe BMeCTO 3aTBOpHr4r{eCKaTa aAMHHr4CTparlUq; KBaII4oI4KA]-Jjr1^sTa Ha

AerHrreTo HecT,o6pa3eHa c AaHHLITe 3a HaCTbIIHna peA6]j1ln]|1lTa\VIA;

tr3rrrrrareJrHr{rr cpoK HanMHHaBa c roBerre oT 3 foAIrHI4 HaKa3aHHeTO JIHIXaBaHe

oT cBo6oAa; rrpoAbn)Kr{TeJrHocTTa Ha npo6arll4oHHaTa Mf,pKa pa3nl4qHa oT

npeABHAeHaTa B 3aKOHa; HapyIxeHI4 npaBl,InaTa 3a onpeAensHe Ha

noAcbAHocTTa; KoHcTr4TyvpaH KaTo rracTeH O6BI4HI4TeJI OIIIeTeHOTO IOpIAAHTIeCKO

nuqe; He ca rocorreHr4 ocHoBaHr4sTa 3a oTKa3 Aa ce nplleMaT 3a ocHoBaTeJIHI,I

AOBOAT,TTe B )Kan6aTa; HapyueHa e 3a6paHaTa 3a LI3MeHeHI4e Ha O6BI'IHeHI4erO 3a

no-Tex{Ko HaKa3yeMo rrpecTbrrJreHr4e vr 3a HaJrafaHe Ha [o-Te]KKo HaKa3aHI{e [pLI

BTOpOTO pa3rnexAaHe Ha AeJroTo, KoraTo IIpIrcbAaTa npl4 IIbpBoTo pa3fJIe)KAaHe

e oTMeHeHa no x{an6a Ha IIoAcbAl/rMI4fl; O[peAensHe Ha BI/.I.a I4 pa3MepA Ha

HaKa3aHr{eTo B HapyrueHkre Ha r43rrcKBaHVflTA 3a CbOTBeTCTBI'Ie C TeXeCTTa Ha

r{3BbplueHoTo, rIeJII4Te Ha HaKa3aHI4eTO, o6qecTBeHaTa OIIaCHOOT Ha AetHI'IeTo I'I

Aeerla; oAo6peHo cnopa3yMeHr{e B rrporl3BoAcrBo \o qn.29 HIIK, BMecro orKa3

r.r BpbrrlaHe Ha Aenoro 3a o6pa3yBaHe Ha rIpoLI3BoAcrBo rlo rJI. 28 HIIK upu

HAJILIqI4C HA BCI4IIKI.I NPEATIOCTABKH TIO '{I.78A HK; I{3NbJIHEHI'IETO HA

HaKa3aHuero e oTJro)KeHo rrpu nnllca Ha HtKofl or rIpeABuAeHI4Te rIpeAnocTaBKH;

KyMynaTr{BHo rrpeAB}rAeHLrTe IJaKA3aIJVI[. 3a I43BSpIIIeHOTO IIpeCTsnneHI4e ca

orpe.qeneHr4 rrpr4 pa3nuqHu ycnoBlrq (.u.54 ra qn.55 K); Bb33LIBHHsr cbA He e

yrrpa)KHun rrpaBoMorrlvflTa cv ila rlpunoxfl4 3aKoH, lcofiro e rp.a6nano Aa

flpunoxcra; H€lJro)KeHo HaKa3aHpre Jr]r[raBaHe or rlpaBo na o6s[Hxeu, rofito He e

rrpaBocnoco6eH BoAarr na MIIC; He e Hano)KeHo HaKa3aHHe JrLI[IaBaHe or rlpaBo

Ha rroAcbAUM, rofiro e [paBocuoco6eH BoAar{ ua MIIC; rtpu zulrepHarl4BHo

rrpeABrrAeHrr HaKa3a:a:zfl npI,rnox(en qn.55 HK, nuecro Aa 6tae otrpeAeneHo rlo-

JIEKOTO TIO BLI/I.

llpnvnHIl 3a AorIycH arrTe HapyIxeHLI{ :

- cr[]grflTa-AoKnaAqlrK He r{3BbprrrBa eaAr[6o.reHa rIpeABapI{TeJIHa

rrpoBep Ka rlo Bbrlpo cvr e ) npeABI{Ae rru s qr.24 8 HIIK ;

- Herro3HaBaHe Ha aKTyErJrHaTa pe,qaKrll{t Ha npI4nox(LIMHt 3aKOH;

crAe6na npaKTHKa rro [p[no)KI4MLITe

na BKC na HK vr Ha rIpaKrI,IKara Ha

- SopuaneH IIoAXoA npu o4o6prnaHe Ha IIpeAnoXeHLIre clropa3yMeHl4fl';

- HEIO3HABAHE HA TIOCTOflHH.UTA

3aKOHH, Ha rSnKyBaTeJIHkITe peureHl4t

ECrIq.

40

lII. Brs ocHoBa Ha KoHcrararlur{Te Ha ocHoBaHrre .rr.58, a,r.2 3cBI,IBCC AaBa crreAHHTe

TIPETIOPbKII:

1. flpe4ceAarenr4re ua AC - llroeAran, AC - Bapua, AC - Eyprac u AC -Belurco Trpuono B eAHoMecerreH cpoK or Bnlr3aHe B cvna Ha aKTa

pe3ynTarHTe or rlpoBepKaTa Aa cb3AaAaT opfaHr{3aur4r 3a 3arro3HaBaHe

npeAceAareJII.ITe Ha oKpb)KHure cbAr.rnprrqa or cborBerHr4-f, cr4e6eu pafiou.2. llpegceAarenr4Te Ha oKpb)KHure cbAr4nr,rilIa:

-cro6pa:Ho rrpaBoMorrrrrrra cu ro vr.86, il.1, r.7 3CB Aa cBrrKar o6ruucro6panut, Ha KoIzTo Aa 3a[o3Harr c:''4trvrre or crAe6uux pafioH c pe3ynrarr4Te

or rrpoBepKara Ha ITBCC, Aa n4 aHankrcr4par u o6csgtr;- Ia I{3rIpaTtT llpelluc oT aKTa 3a pe3ynTaTr{Te oT rrpoBepKaTa Ha

pbKoBoAI4TeJILITe Ha pafionHl4Te LI oKpbx(Hr4re npoKyparypr4 or cborBerHr4tcrAe6es pafron;

- Aa ynpalxHrr rrpaBoMonlvrflTa cu ro vn.86, il.1, r.6 3CB - Aa Lr3Bbprrar

II4TIHO UnU Ia Bb3JIO)KaT HA Cb.I'Vrfl OT CbOTBeTHVTfl OKpb)KeH CbA rrpoBepKa Ha

opraHl43ar\vrflra u 4efinocrra Ha c1Dl.uvrre or pafionHr,rre cbAr{nr4rrla [pe3 2019 r.BbB Bpb3Ka c KoHcrarupaHr4re B aKTa Ha I4BCC HapyrxeHLrr;

Koncrarallpllare or ABere rrpoBepKkr ga 6'sgar cbrrocraBeHr.r, aHaJrkr3vrpaHu

u o6c'sgeHr4 Ha o6ulu cs6panur^ Ha c:o4krvrre B cbAe6rtus pafioH. .{a ce [pLreMar

MepKLI:a UO4O6ptBaHe 4efiUOCrra r{M rrpfi pa3fnex(AaHe r{ perxaBaHe Ha AenaTa.

3a pe3ynrarure or rlpoBepKara, 3a rrpraerrrre MepKLr vr cpoKoBe 3a

r,r3rrbJrHeHr,re Aa 6r4ar yBeAoMeHr4 rrr,rcMeHo ITIBCC u npeAceAareJrr4re Ha

arreJraTr4BHLrTe cbAr4nrrIla B eAHoMeceqeH cpoK.

- Aa yrpaxm.{r npaBoMorrluflTa cv no un.86, il.l, r.9 3CB Aa

opraHr{3rapar rroBr4rrraBaHe rnannQxrarlkrrra Ha cr4Lrurre

crAe6es pafiou, Karo npeABr.rArr rroAxoA.rrqv Sopvru 3a

3a

HA

OT CbOTBCTHH'

IIOCTLI|AHE HA

eQercrunnocr;

3. B erHoMecerreH cpoK or 3ano3HaBaHe c aKTa rrpeAceAareJrr{Te Ha

pafioHuure cr4vrnvrqa, cbrJracHo rrpaBoMoulLrflTa no .ur.80, a*1, r.3 3CB, 4acBLIKar o6ulo cl6pauue, Ha Koero Aa ananvrcvrpar u o6o6ufsr [paKTlrKara Ha

cbAa rlo AeJIara, perreHu ct,e crropa3yMeHr.re ro peAa Ha rJr. 29 HIIK r4 rro

Aelrura, pa3rneAaHll no peAa Ha rJr. 28 HIIK ,,Ocno6oxAaBaHe or HaKa3areJrHa

orroBopHocr c H€LIIaraHe Ha aAMuHr.rcrparr{BHo HaKa3aHLre" no .rr.78a HK. Iace upI4eMaT MepKH 3a rlpeoAoJrrBaHe Ha nporzBopeqr4sTa B rrpaKTr{Kara Ha

41

c.bilLrvTe,3a Koe'ro [a 61bl|e yBeAoMeHH rrllcMeHo I4BCC n rpeAceAaTennTe Ha

cboTBeTH u Te oKpT'xHpr c'b4}lnr4u\4.

Ha ocHosaHr4e vl. 58, an. 3 3CB nperLIO or aKra 3a pe3ynrarnre or[poBepKaTa Ia ce n3npaTL Ha aAMr4HI4CTpaTI4BHI4Te pbKOBOAI4Tenvr sa AC -llnoe4He, AC - Bapua, AC - Byprac n AC - Beluxo Tlpnoeo.

BtspaxeHuq Mofar Aa ce HarrpaBrr sJ - AHeBeH cpoK or BpbrlBaHero My

rrPeA |JIaBHH{ I{HCneKTOp.

Cne.q BJrr,r3aHe B cvra Ha aKTa rlpenuc Aa ce I43npaTI,I Ha eJIeKTpoHeH

Hocr4reJr Ha [peAceAaTenq Ha Btpxoeunr Kac#II4oHeH cbA 14 Ha

np eAce.qaTencTBalrl ut c's gvtitcKaTa Kone rl4t ua B uc ur ua ff r4e6 e H cbBeT.

mv krflI,IH

d)

si;)?*it*t ,*"//

.ly.JJ-/

42

· Ha ocnoBaHue r{r. 58 or 3arcoHa 3a cr1e6uara BJracr r4 r-oAr4rrrHara ilporpaMa Ha I4BCC za 2019...

Documents

Transcript of · Ha ocnoBaHue r{r. 58 or 3arcoHa 3a cr1e6uara BJracr r4 r-oAr4rrrHara ilporpaMa Ha I4BCC za 2019...