Situación de La Política y de La Gestión Ambiental en Argentina

;?4= .,-$.+&$(&$(&)($,

6J ORV?FQWRV9aPJ\# 9OFI[V7O3PGNJQWJJQ OF3ULJQWNQFIJO 4NHJQWJQFUNR%$ OFJI% $ 4XJQRV3NUJV/3GJOJIR>JUURW#(&'(%)+( S%0'*Z(& HP%

'%<JINR 3PGNJQWJ%'% @`WXOR566)&*%(-

;?4= .,-$.+&$(&$(&)($,

?3> *')'&''+

@RIRVORVIJUJHMRVUJVJUYFIRV

o 3GJOJIR>JUURW?%3%

3IPNQNVWUFHNaQj UJIFHHNaQ@XHXP_Q#%&#@J !/#.-&^^$-,01&-0,, &8FZ%/#.-&^^$-,01&-0+,

AJQWFV@FOJFMXFQR-2- &@J !/#.-&^^$.+,.&)),)@FOJFMXFQR/.) &@JO%/#.-&**$.+,.&2/+)8NLXJURF3OHRUWF++/, &@J !/#.-&^^$-1),&+-/18FZ/ #.-&**$.+,/&12,2JONJQWJV2FGJOJIRSJUURW%HRP

4XJQRV 3NUJV$ 3ULJQWNQF

&.,05 .2 -.6=91:5 7;. .9:*+2.,. 2* 2.< ''%,()%'368.95 .4 2*%8/.4:14*! (814:.- 14%8/.4:14*!

86EtIJAD ''

/(01!#(G+ $% )! -,)F0(#!2 )! '%/0(G+ !*"(%+0!)

%+ A6 6G<:CI>C6 &%$%.!)

)79;B;=;636 D 5?>AB@C55;H>67<67@75:? 3=4;7>B3< 7<8767@3<;A=?5?=? A;AB7=3

bad 6A9a GD9Gt<J:O H6A6H

O%>CIGD9J88>uC

:^ H\efX_T;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^ #H;6$ XeX T`WT_\T]XeaUdX!' VgT WXUXVaèfdg\deXX _TdVa ]gdxW\VaX` _TfXd\TT_U\X`fT^%'a`Yad_X T^WXe^\`WXWXVa_bXfX`V\TeX`fdX TCTV\z` [ ^Tebda&h\`V\Te%XefTU^XV\Wabad X^Tdfa-* WX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^# C$3 ^TCTV\z` W\VfTae bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`g_U\X`fT^[ ^Tebdah\`V\Te ^Teàd_Te Va_b^X_X`fTd\TeWXW\&"[ae dXcgXd\_\X`fae_x`\_ae' :efT àd_T bdahaVz g` VT_U\a

e\Z`\Y\VTf\haX` X adWX`T_\X`fa]gdxW\VaT_U\X`fT^WXbTxe'6ex%WXeWXg`T bXdebXVf\hTdXWgVV\a`\efT%X^YXWXdT^\e_a

bTdXVXdxTXib^\VTdeXX` `gXefdT _TfXd\T _XW\T`fXX^WXe^\`WXfXzd\VaWXcgw X`fX`WX_aebad â_x`\_a [ â Va_b^X_X`fTd\a'>$XV\_ae dXWgVV\a`\efTbadcgX X^YXWXdT^\e_aXe _gV[a _vecgXg` WXe^\`WX]gdxW\Va':e g` e\efX_Tba^xf\VacgX egba`X g`T

"

,- :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

W\mfd\UgV\zfXdd\fad\TWX TeVa_bXfX`V\TeX`fdXâe :efTWae_\X_Udae' :efT W\_Xè\z` ba^xf\VTeXbdajXVfTT â T_U\X`fT^XmV^ T`faX e^ efdmfaXVamzZ\VaWXTàd_T fdTeV\X`WXTe]gd\e&m^VV>D`XefXd`fad'^T^mem>mma^gVdTba^xf\VTej TVV\a`XecgX âef\fg^TdXeWXVTmT]gd\eW\VV\z WXUXVaadW\`TdXVXeTd\T_X`fX'

' :^ YXWXdT^\e_aXeX`fXmW\WaVa_a g` e\efX_TcgX bdafTZa&dgkT` Va`]g`fT_X`fX X ZaU\XdàYXWXdT^j ^Tebdah\`V\Te' 8a_aX` faWTYXWXdTV\z`%X :efTWa VX`fdTj âe :efTWaeJGCJ@OLPCP$QYKALLOBGK?BLPV KL PR@LOBGK?BLPCKQOCPZ#jT cgX fT`fa gà85ma âe'afdae ea` zdWX`XebTdV\T^XeWX^XZTWaeWX T8aèf\fg&VmaCTV\a`T^' 9X fT^Yad_T%VgT`WaeXhg^`XdT`âe ^x_\fXeWXY\&`m5aebam^TeXeYXdmeWXVa_bXfX`V\TTfd\Ug\WTebad ^T8aèf\fg&m>DCTV\a`T^%eXK>D^Tm5amT'Yg`5T_X`fT^ WXXefXe\efX_Tj eX>^^Vgd3XX` g`T WXZdTWTV\z`_ef\fgV\a`T^%:e WXV\d%eXT^fXdT`TedX^TV\a`XeWXVaadW\`TV\z cgX%Va_a XibdXeT;d\Te * e\ U\X`àea` ^TXeX`V\TWXe\efX_T%PLKPRGJ?ECKJGPJ?%Ead"XeaeXTfd\&UgjX` ^TeW\Y\Vg^fTWXeWXgXefda e\efX_T\èf\fgV\a`T^ X` _TfXd\TWXba^xf\VTT>5U\X`fTT I? GKPRDGAGCKQCL COO[KC?\_b^X_X`fTV\z`WXXeTedX^TV\a`XeWXVaadW\`TV\z`'

Ead X^â%TAXj <X`XdT WX6_U\X`fX #A<6$ &>Xj_TdVa T^TVgT WXmXmTWXVgTdeX^Te'mXefT`fXeàd_Te eXVfad\T^XeWXbdXeg&bgXefae_>^^>_ae&XefTU^XV\zX H;6 Va` !XâU]XfaWXWXeTdda^^Td^TVaadW\`TV\z`WX Tba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^%fX`W\X`fXT^âZdaWX^WXeTdda^^5e5efX`fTU^X%X`fdXX^ZaU\Xdà `TV\a`T^% ae ZaU\Xd&àe bdah\`V\T^Xej X^WXT8\gWTWWX7gXàe 6\dXe! #Tdf'+,$'

>>';JC96B:CIDH 9:A H>HI:B6 ;:9:G6A 6B7>:CI6A

8 :efX WXe^\`WXVa_bXfX`V\Tj ^TadZT`\kTV\z`WXH;6 Tbg`&fa T'dXea^hXmg` ZdThXbdaU^X_TWX\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WX Tàd&_Tf\hT T_U\X`fT^%X` fT`fa ^Te\fgTV\z` T`fXd\adT ^TdXYad_TWX^Tya *2m- Xi[\UxTg`T ZdThXTà_T^xT3X \ddXZg^TdWXeTdda^âWX^Tba^xf\VTj ^XZ\e^TV\zT_U\X`fT^XeX` _gV[Te bdah\`V\Te ZX&

; 4;G0<# EXWda%2COCAFLM\@IGALMOLSGKAG?I#9XbT^_T%7gXàe 6\dXe *210])][]% ! #

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' ,.

! dTUTW\ebXde\z j Te\_XfdxTecgX bXd]gW\VTUTT^Va`]g`fa +'

>^^>*fDâe hTVxae ad_Tf\hae Va_a eg W\hXde\WTWj W\ebXde\z`[`bXWxT`g`T ZXef\z` T_U\X`fT^_x`\_T_X`fX Va[XdX`fXj XY\&;!;;] X` X bTxe' :e WXV\d%bdXWa_\`TUTX X]XdV\V\aT\e^TWaWXTe`gfaà_\Te a% a cgX XebXad%eg YT^fTWXX]XdV\V\a%bdahaVT`WaTXJ X^WXdXV[aT g` T_U\X`fX eTà j Xcg\^\UdTWaVTdXV\XdTWXJ>^= UTeXad_Tf\hT Vaè\efX`fX,'

ATe Te\_XfdxTe\èf\fgV\a`T^Xe Xi\efX`fXeX` ^Te]gd\eW\V&\â`XefXdd\fad\T^XedXcgXdxTWXg`T àd_T _TdVa a Uve\VT'6ex%

** âWaX fXdd\fad\a TV\a`T^% ae [TU\fT`fXeZakTdxT`WXg` _x&QNUQRWXbdafXVV\z`Va_{`'

AgXZaWXTdXYad_TWXT8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^ WX*22-%'&'' X dXVaàV\_\X`fa XibdXea WXXefXWXdXV[aeXVa`Y\d\zT ^TCTV\z` ^TbafXefTWWXXefTU^XVXdâe bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WX'O;! fXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^' AT WX^XZTV\zWXXefTbTdfXWX TVad`&;OfX`V\Tbdah\`V\T^ YgXg` bTea Yg`WT_X`fT bTdTT^VT`kTdXeXbdabze\fa WXVaèf\fgjX`fX' GXV\w`WXeWXX^Tya +))+ eXeT`&V\a`T` bad X 8a`ZdXea WX TCTV\z` g`T eXd\XWXad_Te cgXgbg`fT` T Vg_b^\d Va` X _T`WTfa Vaèf\fgV\a`T^'

H\` X_UTdZa%egUjTVXX` faWaXefXe\efX_T ^TfXè\z` X`&>>"#$â `TV\a`T^ j â bdah\`V\T^' Ca àe dXYXd\_aeT ^TW\eVge\z`W V`\Va&^XZT^%exT ^TW\_Xè\z` ba^xf\VTcgX X^^TX`fdTyT'

***' :KDAJ8>uC 9:A H>HI:B6 ;:9:G6A 6B7>:CI6A

^' \`fXdbdXfTV\a`Xe T`fXd\adXe T ^TdXYad_T

6`fXe WX T{^f\_T dXYad_TWX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^MFG`Fg` XebXVfdaWX\`fXdbdXfTV\a`XeeaUdXdXbTdfaVaèf\fg&

+ Bve T{`%cgX eXfXd_\`X VaèTZdT`WaTbTdf\dWXXi\ZX`V\TeW\ebTdXeg`TebXV\XWX!bda_aV\z` \`Wgefd\T \`hXdeT!%I6L>A%<g\Wa H'%!AT V^vgeg^TT_&

[^X`fT^X` ^T8aèf\fgV\a`T^ CTV\a`T^!%AA *22.&7&*+2*', 6_b^\Td X` GD9Gt<J:O H6A6H%6^Wa%!K\ZX`V\T [ abXdTf\h\WTWWX T

àd_T T_U\X`fT^' :^ H\efX_T ;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^!% AA WX *)(*+(+))-% Hgb^'W 9XdXV[a6_U\X`fT^'

,/ :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

V\a`T^ WX TeVa_bXfX`V\TecgX egba`xT fT_U\w` g`T Yad_T'XTALKAC@GOMLIZQGA?JCKQCCPQ?POCI?AGLKCPBCALLOBGK?AG[K.

T$J`T bae\V\z`%cgXbaWdxT_aeWXà_\`Td bdah\`V\T^\efT%emefX`xTcgX ^T_TfXd\TT_U\X`fT^à [TUxTe\WaWX^XZTWTT^Za&U\XdàYXWXdT^bad ^Tebdah\`V\Te%eT^haX` T^Zg`TeXiVXbV\a`XeXibdXeTe'Aae :efTWae _\X_Udae bdXXi\efX`fXeT *1., [TUxT`XefTU^XV\WaVa_a dXZ^TVaèf\fgV\a`T^ cgX VaèXdhTUT faWaeâe baWXdXea WX^XZTWaeXibdXeT_X`fXT ^TCTV\z` #Tdf' *)-%XC$4 X` VaèXVgX`V\T%Tebdah\`V\Te fX`xT` b^X`T Tgfaà_xTbTdTWTdeXTe\èf\fgV\a`Xe [ X dwZ\_X` _ve Va`hX`\X`fX T ege\`fXdXeXe-'

ETdTXefTbae\V\z`% ^T{`\VT bae\U\^\WTWWXVaadW\`TV\z`WX'meVm_bXfX`V\TeTgfzà_Te egbXdTWadTWX TVa_bXfX`V\Ta`Z_T`T% cgX X` VTeaeWXVa`Y^\Vfaef\X`X ^T8adfX HgbdX_TWX?gef\V\TWX TCTV\z` #T`fXd\adTdfa*)*%8C$%XefTUTX` âefdTfTWae\`fXdbdah\`V\T^XecgX bdXhXxTX^X`fa`VXe Tdfa*)0 WX^T8C.'

U$J`T \`fXdbdXfTV\z Va_b^X_X`fTd\T%WXXeX`V\TVa`VXd&fTWadT%WXeTdda^^TWTbad EXWda;dxTe /% Xib^\VTUTX dXbTdfaWXVa_bXfX`V\Te%TbadfT`Wa ^T`XVXe\WTWWXg`T ^XZ\e^TV\zVa&_{` WXTe\Zg\X`fXYad_T3

^' :^ T_U\X`fX XedXebaèTU\^\WTWad\Z\`T^ WXf\fg^TdWX^T]gd\eW\VV\z`%a eXTWXcg\X` X]XdVXTTgfad\WTWX` X X`fadà`TfgdTâ X` X X`fadà VdXTWabad X [a_UdX'

+' Aae bdaU^X_Te T_U\X`fT^XeW\h\e\U^Xe]gd\eW\VV\a`T^&_X`fX ea` Va_bXfX`V\TWXTTgfad\WTWaVT^%T ^ThXkTgfad\WTWàd_T^ WXX]XVgV\z`'

,' Ead ^T \`fXdWXbX`WX`V\TWXT_U\X`fX j ^T_ah\^\WTWWX ae YTVfadXeWXZdTWT`fXe%faWTe\fgTV\z` WXWXfXd\adabgXWX

- 86CD%<g\^^Xd_a%:LIZQGA?V ICEGPI?AG[KMOLSGKAG?I%8CBGL?J@GCKQCV ILPOCAROPLPK?QRO?ICP#6VTWX_\TWX8\X`V\TeBadT^Xe%7gXàe 6\dXe%*210 [ Ba&j 6CD%6_x^VTd%!9XdXV[aj ^XZ\e^TV\zT_U\X`fT^Xe\`YdT`TV\a`T^Xe!%3KARCKQOLBCILP0KBCP#ha^' >>%;6GC% *22*%bH' *+. [ ee'

. GD9G\<J:O H6A6H%6^Wa%!DdZT`\kTV\z` T_U\X`fT^X` g` bTxeYXWXdT^!%'26LOK?B?P5KQCOK?AGLK?ICPPL@OC8CBGL0J@GCKQC#:W\g_% BX`WakT%*22*%be' +0, [ ee'

+ <GPQCJ?PBCALJMCQCKAG?PCKCIBCOCAFL?J@GCKQ?I%5KQOLBRAAG[K?I BCOC$AFLM\@IGALMOLSGKAG?I#9XbT^_T%7gXàe 6\dXe%*21)%be' +*1 j ee'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' ,0

** `d TVa_bda_XfXd âe baWXdXeVa`VgddX`fXeWXZaU\XdàYX&I _\ X` !â Va`WgVX`fXT ^TbdaebXd\WTWWXbTxe%T^TWX^T`faj*** `XefTdWXfaWTe Tebdah\`V\Te! #Tdf'/0%\`V */%8C$ j [TVXd* >f\dàj `XVXeTd\aeg Va`Vgdea Va` ^Tbae\U^XXiV^ge\z` WXTO;XOd\WTWaVT X` VTeaWX\`Va_bTf\U\^\WTW' '

-$ 9X^ bd\`V\b\a WX aVT^\kTV\z&d`gV[TehXVXe aVT^\kT&* NaQ_zh\^& j WXVa_b^X_X`fTd\a WX\`fXdWXbX`WX`V\TdXeg^fT****** Va_bXfX`V\TâVT cgX WXh\X`XXhX`fgT^_X`fXX` Va`Vg&** `fXVa` ^TCTV\z`'

.$ Bve YdXVgX`fX_X`fX%j bad dTka`Xe WX\`fXdWXbX`WX`&**** j âVT^\kTV\z`%X^bdaU^X_TT_U\X`fT^Va`V\Xd`XT _ve WX;;;;;W]gd\eW\VV\z ba^xf\VT%X` hTd\TU^XVa_U\`TV\z` WX_g`\V\&S D^^%bdah\`V\Te j :efTWa `TV\a`T^'

+"3I J?OALMLIZQGALICE?IV I? K?QRO?ICW?BCIBCOCAFL?J@GCK$&#((?ALKPCH?K?PRJGORK?ICEGPI?AG[KALJ\K# GKPQORJCKQ?B?MLORKR I?BL CKQOCCIEL@GCOKLK?AGLK?IV I?PMOLSGKAG?P?OECKQGK?P%

X$;\`T^_X`fX%^Tbae\V\z` VX`fdT^\efTeaefX`xTcgX ^TTb^\&>` '\z` XifXè\hT"WXTV^vgeg^TWXbdaebXd\WTW#Tdf'/0%\`V' */$%DUXXRVa` ^TV^vgeg^TVa_XdV\T#Tdf'/0%\`V' *+$%XdTegY\V\X`fXb`dg XefTU^XVXdg`T dXZg^TV\zX` faWaX bTxeWXeWXX baWXdVX`&WUQO%Eae\V\z` cgX T^VT`kzVa` X bdajXVfaWX8zW\Za 6_U\X`fT^W ^TGXb{U^\VT6dZX`f\`T eg _vi\_a `\hX^WXX^TUadTV\z`0'

IdTe ^T^Xj `TV\a`T^ +-').* WXGXe\WgaeEX^\Zdaeae[gUa**** XeYgXdkaWXef\`TWaT X`VgTWdTd^TX` XefT{^f\_T bae\V\z`'

Aae TdZg_X`fae WXXefT{^f\_T Va`VXbV\z` a ea` `gXhae''! NRQRHJQT`fXVXWX`fXeh\`Vg^TWaeT `gXefda fX_T' ?aTcgx`> zbVk%VgT`WaT`T^\kT^TefXe\ecgX eX[T` WXeTdda^^TWaeaUdX*** Pgd\eW\VV\zeaUdXâe dxae \`fXdbdah\`V\T^Xe%Xib^\VTcgX ^TSR \V\z` WX VX`fdT^\e_a VgT`Waeaef\X`X ^T]gd\eW\VV\z`WX*** CTV\z` eaUdXTcgw^âe eX UTeT%X`fdX afdae TdZg_X`fae%

** ;Q%dXYXd\WTV^vgeg^TWXT`fXd\adTdfa/0% \`V' */ WX T8C'K! fg &Va`f\`{T&a Xe_ve cgX ^TWaVfd\`TWX ae baWXdXe\_&%%**\^fae WXeTdda^^TWTX` âe :efTWae J`\Wae X` Xê\Zâ bTeTWa****" X ]gXk Hfadj%fXadxTX^TUadTWTX` ^T`XVXe\WTWWXafadZTd*** aU\Xdà YXWXdT^àdfXT_Xd\VTà YTVg^fTWXebTdTYdX`TdTe

; EdXeX`fTWabad X Xi W\bgfTWaTV\a`T^DeVTd7^T`Va X` X Tya *22+'

(

,1 :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G^D

fX`WXmV\TeeXVXe\a`\efTeWXT^Zgàe :efTWae WXTcgX bTxe1' Eadm^â_\e_a% à X`VgX`fdTdTkz` WXeXdX` `gXefdTdXT^\WTWba^x&fxVTj _Xàe X` X TVfgT_a_X`fa [\efzd\Va'

+' =TV\T X YXWXdT^\e_aWXVa`VXdfTV\z`

%T$7LP QO?Q?BLPM?OAG?ICP%:efTe bae\V\a`Xe% a aUefT`fX%cgX`T` dXea^hXdg` bdaU^X_T VgjT ZdThXWTWXdTXh\WX`fX3X^\ddXZg^TdWXeTdda^âWX Tba^xf\VT"N^XZ\e^TV\z T_U\X`fT^ X`_gV[Te bdah\`V\Te ZX`XdTUTTe\_XfdxTecgX bXd]gW\VTUTT^Va`]g`fa'

ATe bdah\`V\Te j X^ZaU\Xdà `TV\a`T^ Va_X`kTda` T eXdVaèV\X`fXeWX"cgX WXUxTTUT`Wa`Td^Teba^xf\VTeT\e^TWTeX\`\V\Tdg` bdaVXeaVaèXègTWaWX\`fXZdTV\z`' :efX bdaVXeaeX^^XhzTWX^T`fXT fdThweWX!Va`hX`\ae \`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`T^Xe!W\&dXVfT_X`fXVa`VXdfTWaebad ^TebTdfXe\`fXdXeTWTea bad X e\efX&_T WXTe!^XjXe&Va`hX`\aWXTW[Xe\z`!' HXWXefTVT`%X`fdX aebd\_Xdae%X IdTfTWa8aèf\fgf\ha WX8a_\fw >`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a&`T^ WXGxa 8aâdTWaVX^XUdTWaX + WXYXUdXdaWX*200 #BX`&WakT%mgXàe 6\dXe%ATET_bT%CXgcgw`%Gxa CXZdaj ZaU\Xd&à `TV\a`T^$%X 6VgXdWa8aèf\fgf\ha WX8\`fgdz` :Va^zZ\VaWXmXT BXmaba^\fT`T H: #7gXàe 6\dXe%8Tb\fT^ ;XWXdTjZaU\Xdà `TV\a`T^$ j XÊTVfaAXZ\e^Tf\ha6_U\X`fT^ WXCgX&ha 8gja WX+2 WXTZaefa WX*22+' :`fdX ^Te^XjXe&Va`hX`\a%X`fdXafdTe%Te^XjXe TV\a`T^Xe*,'+0, eaUdXGwZ\_X` ;adXefT^%^T+)'+1- eaUdXEdXeXdhTV\zWXGXVgdea6\dX%T++'-+* WX;Tg&`T% T++'-+1 WX8aèXdhTV\z` WXHgXâe%T+-').* WXGXe\WgaeEX^\Zdaeae#69A6% K>>>&>014MMM^^>&7&*-)24MA>&6&104MA>&6&+*-4 A>>&6&.+$'

U$7LP ?ARCOBLPDCBCO?ICP?J@GCKQ?ICP%EXda WXeWXg`TbXdebXVf\hT_ve \`fXZdT^%Va_bdXè\hT WX TbdaU^X_vf\VTT_&U\X`fT^%TTeg`V\z` WXYXWXdT^\e_aWXVa`VXdfTV\zVa_a \è&fdg_X`fa bXd_T`X`fX WXTba^xf\VTT_U\X`fTêXVa`VdXfTVgT`&Waâe :efTWae bdah\`V\T^XeegeVd\UX X ,* WXTZaefa WX*22)%

1 AuE:O% ?aTcgx`%:OL@ICJ?PBCOGS?BLPMLOCI?MOLSCAF?JGCKQLBCOZLPGK$QCOMOLSGKAG?ICP%0QOG@RAGLKCPBCI1LKEOCPL0OECKQGKL#9XbT^_T%7gXàe 6\dXe%*21/%b' */+' '

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A' '' ,2

!Q^TV\gWTWWXAT G\a]T%X 6VfT 8aèf\fgf\hT WX8aèX]a ;X&WXdTWXBXW\a6_U\X`fX #8D;:B6$% Va` XâU]XfaXeX`V\T^WXXefTU^XVXdg`T adZT`\e_a bXd_T`X`fX bTdT^TVa`VXdfTV\z`[ X^TUadTV\zWXg`T ba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^VaadW\`TWTX`fdXâe:efTWae_\X_Udae #Tdf'*) WX6VfT 8aèf\fgf\hT$' :efX TVgXdWa:5 Yg`WTX` ^TeXèXyT`kTeWXEXWda;dxTej gf\^\kz Va_a _aWX&â ^Te ad_Te Vaèf\fgf\hTe WX8aèX]a ;XWXdTWX>`hXde\a`Xe# ;>$'

:^ ETVfa;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^ WX. WX]g^\a WX*22,% ege&i\bfa bad X ZaU\XdàYXWXdT^j ^Tebdah\`V\Te%bdaYg`W\kzXefXbdaVXeaT^dXVaàVXd%dXV\w X`fa`VXe%X^ZaU\Xdà YXWXdT^T^#"D;:B6 Va_a g` \èfdg_X`fa hv^\WabTdT^TVaadW\`TV\z`WX^` ba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^X` X bTxe'

:` XefTXfTbTWX TXha^gV\z` WX TdX^TV\z CTV\z`&bda&h\`V\Te X` _TfXd\T T_U\X`fT^%X^_aWXâ WXVaadW\`TV\z` eX^TUadTT bTdf\d WX Tebae\V\a`Xe WaVfd\`Td\TecgX eaefX`xT`

;Q `XVXe\WTWWXT^VT`kTdg` fdTfTWa\`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`TWXcgX_XdZ\XdTg`T ^XZ\e^TV\zVa_{`'

H\` X_UTdZa%Xe \_badfT`fX eXyT^Td%WTWTT bXdebXVf\&K! ba^xf\VTcgX \`fdaWgV\_ae X` XefXT`v^\e\e%cgX bad ^TdZae** ae ^TCTV\z` YgXdX`gX`fXT ^TdTf\Y\VTV\z` XZ\e^Tf\hTWX^6VfT 8aèf\fgf\hT WX8D;:B6' :^ ETVfa;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^`XH \_bgêTWa bad ^Tebdah\`V\Te T Y\` WX aZdTdcgX ^TTgfa&d^WTWTV\a`T^ dXVaàV\XdTXefXv_U\fa WXVa`VXdfTV\z2' HggbTdfTWa>>>dXhX^TVa` V^Td\WTWXefXbdabze\fa3 !Aae :efTWae; `TfTd\ae dXVaàVX T^8aèX]a ;XWXdTWXBXW\a6_U\X`fX

Va_a RKGKPQORJCKQLSYIGBLM?O?I? ALLOBGK?AG[KWXTba^xf\VTg_U\X`fT^ X` ^TGXb{U^\VT6dZX`f\`T!'

â >T dXYad_TWX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^

:^ Tdfa-* WX T8C dXYad_TWTXefTU^XVXg`T Va_bXfX`V\T; \ ^Tf\hTVa`VgddX`fXX`fdX TC TV\z` j ^Tebdah\`V\Te X` _TfX&**** T_U\X`fT^%EXdaXefTVa`VgddX`V\TXZ\e^Tf\hTa XeZX`wd\VT%; âXe%XefvdXZg^TWTbad ^T_\e_T 8aèf\fgV\z`% cgX Tfd\UgjXT

"$:^ Tgfad bTdf\V\bz X` ^TZw`Xe\e WXXefXbdaVXea%bad Xea eXdX^TfTeg; YXOXHOaQVa`Yad_X eXTWabfTUT` TeWXV\e\a`XeX` XêXà WX8D;:B6'

E

-) :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G^D

^TCTV\z` ^TVa_bXfX`V\TbTdTXefTU^XVXdâe bdXegbgXefae_x&`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`%j T^Tebdah\`V\Te ^Te ad_Te Va_b^X_X`&fTd\Te XVXeTd\Te'8a` dTkz`%7\WTdf8T_bae W\VX3!9XeWXT`fXeWX TdXYad_TW\_ae bad V\XdfacgX X^WXdXV[aT_U\X`fT^Xeg`vdXTWX_g`Wa ]gdxW\VaX` ^TcgX Va` _ve V^Td\WTW?BSCOQGJLPI? KCACPGB?BBCRKDCBCO?IGPJLBCALKACOQ?AG[K%6[adT%^Tàd&_T à [T X_b^XTWaXefTfXd_\àâZxT%bXdaTVgeTg`T _gj Xe&bXV\TVTfXZadxTWXVa_bXfX`V\TeVa`VgddX`fXe!*)' 6ZdXZTXefXTgfad3!AT dXYad_T[T dXVaàV\Wa%\_b^xV\fT_X`fX%cgX Vg\WTdX^T_U\X`fX XedXebaèTU\^\WTWbd\ad\fTd\TWXbaWXdcgX f\X`X]gd\eW\VV\z eaUdXw^%a cgX Xcg\hT^XT Teg_\d ^TdXZ^TWXcgX^T]gd\eW\VV\z Xe%Va_a bd\`V\b\a%âVT &bdah\`V\Tâ _g`\V\&bT^&'Ca aUefT`fX%X bXd]g\V\aT^T_U\X`fXà egX^XWXfX`XdeXâVT^_X`fX%badcgX Xe_ahXW\ka j fdTèYXd\U^X_ve T^^vWX^g&ZTdWXad\ZX`4^T\`fXdWXbX`WX`V\TWXT_U\X`fXXeX`fa`VXeg`bTdv_Xfda cgX e\dhXWXZgxTj cgX Va`haVT T^:efTWa YXWXdT^TY\]Tdae bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`!'

HXVa`Yad_T X`fa`VXe g` dXbTdfaWXVa_bXfX`V\TXebX&V\T^%Wa`WX a Uve\Va eX \`fXZdTVa` *) Va_b^X_X`fTd\a' AaebdXegbgXefae _x`\_ae à bgXWX`fX`XdVgT^cg\XdVa`fX`\Wa'Ca Vg_b^\dxT^TXi\ZX`V\TVaèf\fgV\a`T^ g`T àd_T cgX {`\&VT_X`fXfgh\XdTVa_a Tfd\UgfaeXdVa_{` T faWaeâe [TU\fT`&fXe' AT 8aèf\fgV\z` Xe V^TdTVgT`WaXebXV\Y\VTcgX eX fdTfTWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WX!bdafXVV\z`!' Ead â cgX baWdxT`WXY\`\deXVa_a TcgX^^Tead_Te cgX TWX_veWXVa`VXWXdg`TfgfX^TT_U\X`fT^g`\Yad_X a Va_{`% f\X`X` bad aU]Xfa\_ba`Xdg` _x`\_a WXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^'!' Hzâ TexeX VaddXeba`&WXdxTT ^TWXV^TdTV\z`\`\V\T^WXTV^vgeg^TVaèf\fgV\a`T^ cgXdXVaàVXT faWaeâe [TU\fT`fXeX^WXdXV[aTg` T_U\X`fXeTà%Xcg\^\UdTWa%Tbfa bTdTX^WXeTdda^âeaV\T^':^ Tdfa/p WX T^Xj+.'/0. X`VgTWdTX` XefTWXY\`\V\z`'

*) =O?Q?BLBCBCOCAFLALKPQGQRAGLK?I?OECKQGKL#f' K>%7? OCDLOJ?ALKPQG$QRAGLK?IBC *22-%:W\Td%7gXàe 6\dXe%be' ,)+ j ee'

** :^ Tgfad XebTya^Bgyak BTV[TWa%V\fTWabad @TgY\`T`%a WXà_\`T!bd\`V\b\a WX Tg`\WTW]gdxW\VTj WXTg`\Yad_\WTWWXTeVa`W\V\a`XeWXh\WTX` faWaX fXdd\fad\a!%X` !AT AXj WXGXe\WgaeEX^\ZdaeaeYdX`fXT ^TdXYad_TWX^T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^!%AA WX*)(+(*22.'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' -*

' >`fXdbdXfTV\a`XeWXebgweWXTdXYad_T

T$5KPQGQRAGLK?ICP%>`fXdXeTWae\`fXdbdXfTV\a`XeWXad\ZX`;Q f\fgV\a`T cgX eXXeUakTda eaUdXX T^VT`VXWXaebdXegbgXe&fa _x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z T_U\X`fT^#EBE6$' J`T dXbdXeX`fT&W; bad ^THXVdXfTdxTWX6_U\X`fX j 9XeTdda^âHgefX`fTU^XWXT= \V\z` #H6j9H$%WXVTdvVfXdT_b^\a%j ^TafdTbad X 8D;:B6%''' ? dXefd\Vf\hT'

ETdT TeXVdXfTdxT`TV\a`T^%gXZaWXg`T Vaèg^fTVa` XibXdmf\% X` ^T_TfXd\T%eXVa`V^gjXcgX! ''' T `gXefda ]g\V\a%XefT ad&QXXNYFWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae baWdvfX`Xdbad aU]XfaVgXe&WXQJVT_U\X`fT^XeVa`fX`\X`WadXZ^TeWXfwV`\VTe]gdxW\VTeWX`RQIR a egefT`f\ha%Va_a Te\_\e_a àd_Te WXYad_T%d\fgT^XeO!f\ bdaVXea%X\`V^ge\hXTW_\`\efdTf\hTe%X` ^T_XW\WTPX`mgmR' g^fX` dTka`TU^X_X`fXXVXeTd\TebTdTVg_b^\d Va` X aU]Xf\&

** WXTeXZgdTd%X` faWaX fXdd\fad\a%g`T bdafXVV\z`g`\Yad_X j'' Va Td\TWXT_U\X`fX!' GXebXVfaWX TeYTVg^fTWXedXZ^T_X`&f^^^^êTV\a`T^Xe%XibdXeT3!8a_a bd\`V\b\a X`fX`WX_ae cgX;Q`XHXOWFIcgX ^T8aèf\fgV\z` Te\Z`T T "^TCTV\z`" bTdTW\VfTdàd_Te WXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`m^ à

*"%*) TUTdVTTeYTVg^fTWXeàd_Tf\hTe WX8a`ZdXea `TV\a`T^%***) fT_U\w` ^TbafXefTWdXZ^T_X`fTd\TWXEaWXd:]XVgf\ha' :^

^"gWad:]XVgf\ha `TV\a`T^%X` VTeaWXXi\ef\d g`T dX_\e\z` Xi&>* >>X` ^Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae eTmV\a`TWTebad>8a`ZdXea `TV\a`T^%bgXWXWXeTdda^^TdWXfXd__TWaeTebXV&

f^^ WXW\V[Te XjXeT Y\` WXVa`YXd\dTgfaegY\V\X`V\TT ^TfgfX^T_U\V`fT^Va_{`% WXY\`\X`Wa%Va` eg]XV\z` T âe bTfda`Xe WX

>"^>^>f\VTT_U\X`fT^XefTU^XV\Wae'm` ^T^Xj%TeVa`W\V\a`Xe X'VX&**>*>>GbTdTTeXZgdTdTbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^X` faWaX fXd`fa&*** `TV\a`T^! *+'

:^ 8D;:B6 XibdXezeg bae\V\z` bad dXe'2+(+))- WX*0'* bf\X_UdXWX+))-% X` Xefae fwd_\àe3 !WXUXXmfX`5XmeX*** *** dXYXdX`V\TT ^T TV\z` XeT^8a`ZdXea WXTCTV\z`% g`\Va

* #)I>A^DH6K>CD%H\^h\TC' &:HI:76C 6AK:H%GaeT%!EaefgdT WX THXVdX&* ****W 6_U\X`fX j 9XeTdda^âHgefX`fX`fTU^XWX TCTV\z` eaUdXâe bdX&!*!** efae _x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z` T_U\X`fT^!%AA WX *)(*+(+))-% Hgb^' WX

'; * MR6_U\X`fT^'

-+ :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

baWXdVa` YTVg^fTWXe^XZ\e^Tf\hTe':` VaèXVgX`V\T%X Va`VXbfaàd_Te VaddXeba`WXT^WXXjXe%cgX bad eg `TfgdT^XkTea` W\V&fTWTebad X 8a`ZdXea WX TCTV\z`' &8a`fX`\Wa WXEdafXVV\z`6_U\X`fT^3 IaWT \`fXdbdXfTV\z cgX eX[TZT WXUXfX`XdVTdvV&fXddXefd\Vf\ha%a cgX \_b^\VT cgX eg aU]Xf\ha WXUX_T`fX`Xdg`T mX^TV\z`'W\dXVfT'j Va`VdXfTVa` ^TY\`T^\WTWWXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^ H>` WXeh\dfgTdTe Va_bXfX`V\Te dXeXdhTWTeT ^Tebdah\`V\Te%hTV\T`WaWXVa`fX`\Wa T âe Tdfe' *++ j *+-%8C'&Cad_Te Va_b^X_X`fTd\Te3ATe ^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\&_ae bgXWXèXddXZ^T_X`fTWTebad ^Tebdah\`V\Te WXVa`Yad&_\WTWT âe _XVT`\e_ae cgX ege adWX`T_\X`fae àd_Tf\haebdXhw`%X` VTea PWXRcgX wefTe*) Vaè\WXdX`XVXeTd\aT âeXYXVmaeWXeg Tb^\VTV\zXYXVf\hT'ATCTV\z`%bad eg bTdfX%f\X`X^T_\e_T YTVg^fTWX` X _TdVa WXeg ]gd\eW\VV\zj X` X v_U\faWXTeVa_bXfX`V\TeVaèf\fgV\a`T^_X`fX WX^XZTWTe!':` ^TdXe'1)(m))- *, X' 8D;:B6 ^^XZzT!Va`V^g\dcgX ^Te XjXeVa` Va`&fX_Wa T_U\X`fTêT`V\a`TWTe[TefT X bdXeX`fXThT`kT` eaUdXVammXfX`V\TedXeXd3hTWTeVaèf\fgV\a`T^_X`fX T ^Tebdah\`V\Te%Xi\ef\X`Wa^T`XVXe\WTWWX_aW\Y\VTd^Te!#Tdf'*p$'

9XUXTV^TdTdeXcgX X` ege bda`g`V\T_\X`fae _ve dXV\X`&fXe[T Xha^gV\a`TWa[TV\Tg`T bae\V\z` _ve !Va`VXdfTWadT!'

U$7? BLAQOGK?%9XeWXX^VT_ba WaVfd\`Td\a%Xi\efX g`ThXmWTWXdTZTmTWXbae\V\a`Xe *-%bXda V\fT_ae Va_a dXbdXeX`&fTfdhT%bad eg _ZX_a% ^TWX6_x^VTd BajTà3 !AT ^Xj +.'/0.Wm85mZdXe5WXU\XdTeXdg`T dXZ^TWXWXdXV[acgX Va_a ]g\V\a[\bafwf\Va eaâ bgXWXeXdWXeVd\bf\hTWXTdXT^\WTW%j bad X`WX%à bmXmXdXX_b^TkTdT^WXdXV[aT_U\X`fT^ dXeXdhTWabad ^Tebdah\`V\Te%cgX VdXT` ad_Te ]gdxW\VTe\_bgfTf\hTe WXha^g`&fTW':^â XeTex%badcgX ^TWX^XZTV\z`cgX eX[TVXT^8a`ZdXeaà Xe^TWXXefTU^XVXdg` VzW\ZaWXYa`WaVa_a â eXyT^TX Tdfa0.%\`V' *+ WXT8C%PGKLRKRJ@O?Ia RKKGSCIJZKGJL BCPAOGM$

*, 7D WX+.(,(+))-'*- ATe dTka`TU^Xe \_\fTV\a`Xe WXXefXfdTUT]a\_b\WX` g` T`v^\e\e WXfT&

^^TWa'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' -,

QGSL#cgX bad XibdXeTW\ebae\V\z` WXTdfa-*%bvdd' ,p GKDGKCWX^T8C "à bgXWXT^fXdTdTe]gd\eW\VV\a`XeaVT^Xe"!*.'

Ca baWX_ae Va_bTdf\d cgX âe EBE6 eX ^\_\fX` T Y\]Td'iV^ge\hT_X`fX g_UdT^Xe'

J`T \`fXdbdXfTV\z \`fXZdT^ a eX ^\_\fT T^Tdfa-* WX TC3 9T`\X^ HTUeTj%T^T`T^\kTd^T`gXhT W\efd\UgV\z`WXVa_&

bXfX`V\TeT_U\X`fT^XeWXd\hTWTeWXTdfa-* WX T8C% eXyT^TcgX eX dXcg\XdX\`fXZdTdeg \`fXdbdXfTV\z`Va` afdTe àd_Te'aèf\fgV\a`T^Xe dXYad_TWTe3!IT_U\w` WXUX`Vaè\WXdTdeXafdae TdfxVgâecgX [TVX` T ^TVgXef\z` YXWXdT^j cgX [T` e\Wa\`fdaWgV\Waebad ^TdXYad_T'IaWae X^âeXefTU^XVXWX_T`XdT\`hTd\TU^XX^YadfT^XV\_\X`faWXv_U\fa âVT^'6ex aVgddXX`_TfXd\TWXXefTU^XV\_\X`faeWXgf\^\WTWTV\a`T^ #Tdf'0.% \`V',)$%WX\`fXdhX`V\z` YXWXdT^#Tdf'0.%\`V' ,*$%WXdwZ\_X` Y\`T`&'\Xda#Tdf'0.% \`V' +p$%WXTgfaà_xT _g`\V\bT^ #Tdf' *+,$%WX`gXhTe bafXefTWXebdah\`V\T^Xe#Tdf'*+-%*! bTdfX$%XfV'IaWTeefTe VgXef\a`Xe%]g`fT_X`fX Va` ^TeVaè\WXdTV\a`XebTdf\Vg&

^TdXeX` _TfXd\TWXWXeTdda^âfXdd\fad\TWX\`V' *2 WXTdfa0.#"`gXhTV^vgeg^TWXbdaZdXea"$%ae Xefv` eXyT^T`Wag` V^Tdadg_Ua WXeXTWabad X Vaèf\fgjX`fX WXdXYad_T%CINRCeXPGQ\? ""$ CIA?JGKLBCI? OCARMCO?AG[KBCIDCBCO?IGPJL%:` h\dfgWWX

''& ^TWXfXd_\`TV\z WXT^VT`VXWX TebafXefTWXeTV\a`T^XeWXd\hTWTeWXTXibdXe\z` "bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae" WXUX[TVXdeXNRQT^VT`VXdXefd\Vf\ha'9X XefX_aWa eXdXebXfTdv` Te "]gd\e&W\VV\a`XeaVT^Xe"%TecgX X _\e_a Vaèf\fgjX`fX adWX`TcgX''& WXUXeXdT^fXdTWTe!*/'

E %<=?67<? 67 5?>57@B35;H>A75?>A?<;63<793<=7>B7

6_Uae bdaVXeae%X^WX ae TVgXdWaeYXWXdT^XeT_U\X`fT&H [ ^TdXYad_TWX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^ WX*22-%Va` ^T

*. BDN6CD% 6_x^VTd%!6baef\^^Te T ^TAXj <X`XdT^WX6_U\X`fX +.'/0.'#"a`]XfgdTeaUdXeg hT^\WXk!%AA<dT` 8gja% YXUdXda+))0% b' ^'

*/ H67H6N% 9T`\X^%!:^ `gXha Tdfa-* WX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^ j ^Tn^>=fd\UgV\zWXVa_bXfX`V\Te CTV\z`&bdah\`V\Te%9? >>>&+1&01,(010%WX^

*(0(*220'

-- :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

\`V^ge\z` X` X^Tdfa-*%8C% WX T`gXhT Yad_T WXW\efd\UgV\z`WXVa_bXfX`V\Te%X`VgX`fdTèg ex`fXe\eX` X^Tdfa+. WX T^Xj+.'/0.' Ead wefX TCTV\z` dTf\Y\VTXefaeTVgXdWaej XefTU^XVXX^<GPQCJ?4CBCO?I0J@GCKQ?I#\`W\VT`WacgX !X^_\e_a PCOYGKP$QORJCKQ?BLT fdThweWX8aèX]a ;XWXdTWXBXW\a6_U\X`fX#8D;:B6$!' :efT dX^TV\z X`fdXXê\efX_T j eg adZT`\kTV\z`Xe^TXeX`V\TbTdT^TVa_bdXè\z` WXYXWXdT^\e_a'T_U\X`fT^j^T{`\VT Yad_T hv^\WTj XY\VTkWXWXfXd_\`TdX^T^VT`VXWX a_x`\_a T_U\X`fT^WXVa_bXfX`V\T`TV\a`T^'

6ex%X^YXWXdT^\e_aWXVa`VXdfTV\zbaeXXg` adWX`WTWa%bXdaXeXadWX f\X`X\_b^xV\fT^TW\_Xè\z` ba^xf\VT%{`\VT cgXbgXWXdXeba`WXdcgw WXUXX`fX`WXdeXbad _x`\_a j cgw badVa_b^X_X`fTd\a'

:` VaèXVgX`V\T%T `TfgdT^XkTba^xf\VT WX bdaU^X_TT_U\X`fT^ eX b^Te_T X` ^T_\e_T ^Xj `TV\a`T^ +.'/0. eaUdXba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^ `TV\a`T^' 8aèf\fgjX X^`gXha _TdVa WX T^XZT^\WTWT_U\X`fT^X` `gXefda bTxe%bXdaWXeWXg`T bXdebXVf\&hT cgX Xefv_gj ^X]aeWXeXdYad_T^%X` fT`fa eXTdf\Vg^TT fdT&hwe WXg` adZT`\e_a WXWXdXV[aYXWXdT^%WX\`WgWTU^XXeX`V\Tba^xf\VT%VgjTe Yg`V\a`XebTeT` T eXdX^CHCQO?KPSCOP?IWXXeT^XZT^\WTW'

>K' :A 8D;:B63 >CHIGJB:CID 9:A H>HI:B6 ;:9:G6A

6B7>:CI6A

HaUdXX bTdf\Vg^TdfX_T WXT^VT`VXWXTàd_T T_U\X`&fT^%HTUeTjj 9\ ETa^TeXb^T`fXT`3!qVgv^Xe^T^x`XTW\h\ead\TX`fdX TebafXefTWXeTV\a`T^Xej bdah\`V\T^Xe5:efX \`fXddaZT`&fXVaèf\fgjX ^TbdXZg`fTV^ThXX` XefXVT_ba' Cae bTdXVXW\Yx&V\^X^ aZdaWXg`T dXebgXefThv^\WTT X^^Te\ Va` T`fXd\ad\WTWaeXVaèf\fgjX g` _x`\_a WXVaèXèa X`fdX \hX^XeWXZaU\Xd&à%:efT `XVXe\WTWae bTdXVXTgeb\V\aeTX` ^T_XW\WTX` cgXàe gU\VTWX`fdaWXg` YXWXdT^\e_aWX"Va`VXdfTV\z`!*0'

', H67H6N% 9T`\X^ 6' &9> E6DA6% BTdxT :gZX`\T% !:^ YXWXdT^\e_a[ ^TCgXhT AXj <X`XdT^WX6_U\X`fX!% 69A6% 7a^Xfx` \`Yad_Tf\ha% Tya +))+%`da' ,+%be' -0(.-'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' -.

8a_a g`T VaèXVgX`V\TWX T adZT`\kTV\z` XefTU^XV\WTbad ^TA<6% WXXeX`V\TYXWXdT^%X^Tdfa+- W\eba`XcgX !XÊa&WXd:]XVgf\ha bdaba`Wdv T ^T6eT_U^XT WX8aèX]a ;XWXdTWXBXW\a6_U\X`fX X^W\VfTWaWXdXVa_X`WTV\a`Xea WXdXea^g&V\a`Xe%eXZ{` VaddXeba`WT%WXVa`Yad_\WTWVa` X 6VfT 8aè&f\fgf\hT WXXeXadZT`\e_a YXWXdT^%bTdT^TTWXVgTWTh\ZX`V\TjTb^\VTV\z XYXVf\hTWX Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae% ^TeVa_b^X_X`fTd\Tebdah\`V\T^Xe%j ege dXZ^T_X`fTV\a`XeX` ^TeW\ef\`fTe]gd\eW\VV\a`Xe!'

6ex%Xefae Va_bda_\eae ea`% X` X^Va`fXifa WXH;6% ^TUTeX_\e_T WX T\èf\fgV\a`T^\WTWT_U\X`fT^X` `gXefda bTxe'FgXWTb^Te_TWaWXXefX_aWa g` W\eXya\èf\fgV\a`T^ bad X^VgT fX`X_ae%e\` dXT^\kTdg` ZdT` XeYgXdkaWX\`fXdbdXfTV\z`%cgX âe bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^`TV\a&`T^Xej ^Te ad_Te Va_b^X_X`fTd\Tebdah\`V\T^Xe%Va_a \èfdg&_X`fae ]gdxW\Vaead_Tf\hae WXTba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^%f\X`X` g`v_U\fa WXVa`VXdfTV\zWXY\`\Wa#X 8D;:B6$% cgX QRbgXWXaUh\TdeXe\` d\XeZaWXT^fXdTdj h\a^Td âe TVgXdWaeYXWXdT^XeT_U\X`fT^XedTf\Y\VTWaebad ^T_\e_T ^Xj +.'/0.'

K' A6 8DC9>8>uC 9: K6A>9:O j :;:8I>K>969

9: A6 CDGB6 6B7>:CI6A

>`fXdXeTTcgx WXefTVTdcgX ^T^Xj `TV\a`T^%X` eg Tdfa+-%XefTU^XVXg` bdaVXW\_\X`faWXef\`TWaT TeXZgdTdTTb^\VTV\z`WX Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^3!:^ EaWXd:]XVgf\ha bdaba`Wdv T ^T6eT_U^XTWX8aèX]a ;XWXdTWXBXW\a6_U\X`fX X^W\VfTWaWXdXVa_X`WTV\a`Xea WXdXea^gV\a`Xe%eXZ{` VaddXeba`WT%WXVa`Yad_\WTWVa` X 6VfT 8aèf\fgf\hT WXXeXadZT`\e_a YXWXdT^%M?O?I? ?BCAR?B?SGECKAG?V ?MIGA?AG[KCDCAQGS?BCI?PICVCPBCMOCPRMRCPQLPJZKGJLP#I?PALJMICJCKQ?OG?PMOLSGKAG?ICP#V PRPOCEI?JCKQ?AGLKCPCKI?PBGPQGKQ?PHROGPBGAAGLKCP %:efa bXd_\fX: efX`XdcgX ^TXeX`V\TWXH;6 Xe^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WXTàd&_T T_U\X`fT^TdZX`f\`T'

H\` ^gZTdT WgWTe%wefTXe^TVaèXVgX`V\T_ve \_badfT`fXWXXefTU^XV\_\X`faWXH;6% VgjT TVTUTWT\`fXdbdXfTV\z dX&bXdVgfX\`Xh\fTU^X_X`fXX` ^TTb^\VTV\z a XY\VTV\TWXTàd_T

-/ :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

T_U\X`fT^' :^ ^XZ\e^TWad`TV\a`T^ [\ka g`T ^XVfgdTWXdXbTmaWXTdfa-* WX T8C j XefTU^XV\zX` Yad_T XibdXeTX _XVT_e&_a WXVa`VXdfTV\zcgX ^Tàd_T Vaèf\fgV\a`T^ VaèTZdTUTX`Yad_T \_b^xV\fT' HXTWh\XdfXcgX X _T`WTfa ^XZTâ e'XTZafTX` ea_XfXd T XefX\èfdg_X`fa YXWXdT^^Teàd_Te `TV\a`T^Xe%e\à fT_U\w` ^TeVa_b^X_X`fTd\Tebdah\`V\T^Xe'

Ca eXbgXWXeae^TjTdcgX ^T Xj \_ba`X T EaWXd:]XVgf\ha`TV\a`T^ g`T Yg`V\z` XebXVxY\VT3bdaba`Xd X^W\VfTWaWXdXVa&_X`WTV\a`Xej dXea^gV\a`Xe%eXZ{` VaddXeba`WT%T^8D;:B6M?O?I? ?BCAR?B?SGECKAGA.V ?MIGA?AG[XCDCAQGS?#WX m amTT_U\X`fT^' :` VaèXVgX`V\T%T^Xj T_U\X`fTêXdTaU[ZTfa`T%Va_a faWT ad_T%!T bTdf\dWXeg X`fdTWTX` h\ZX`V\T!j eXTb^\&VTdv!Tg` T^TeVaèXVgX`V\TeWXTedX^TV\a`Xej e\fgTV\a`Xe]g&dxW\VTeXi\efX`fXe! #Tdf',p%88\h'$%bXdaXeTX`fdTWTX` h\ZX`V\Tj Tb^\VTV\z`%M?O?NRCPC??BCAR?B?V CDCAQGS?#WXbX`WXWXg`TVfaVa_b^X_X`fTd\a3 ^T\`fXdhX`V\z` WX8D;:B6'

6ex%X` X bdaVXeaWXYad_TV\z`%eT`V\z` j Tb^\VTV\zWXTàd_T T_U\X`fTêX\`VadbadTg`T Va`W\V\z`WXhT^\WXkWXbda&Yg`WTTfgdT^XkTYXWXdT^'H\ X 8zW\Za 8\h\^ XefTU^XVXcgX ^Te^X&jXe X`fdT`X` h\ZX`V\TVgT`WaX^^TeaWXfXd_\`T`%TA<6 [T m\e&bgXefacgX^T ad_T T_U\X`fT^%M?O?NRCPC??BCAR?B?V CDCAQGS?#dXcg\XdXWXTedXVa_X`WTV\a`Xea dXea^gV\a`XeWX8D;:B6'

:efT \`fXdbdXfTV\zCPALKEORCKQCVa` X hXfa cgX X EaWXd:]XVgf\ha `TV\a`T^ [\ka T ^TbT^TUdT!abXdTf\hTe! WXmTdfa,pWX T^Xj +.'/0.' 9XUXX`fX`WXdeXcgX àd_Te abXdTf\hTeea`^TecgX à bdXV\eTèXddXZ^T_X`fTWTe%`\ Xefv` Va`W\V\a`TWTebad afda TVfaàd_Tf\ha bTdTeXdTb^\VTWTej Xi\Z\U^XeT`fX ^me]gXVXe':^^Te ea` àd_Te \`Va`W\V\a`TWTedXebXVfaWXeg mb[&VTV\z`%XeWXV\dcgX bdaWgVXb^Xàe XYXVfaeWXeWX'cgX'miêfX`X` X fXifa Vaèf\fgV\a`T^%jT eXT`àd_Te WXadZT_kTV\a` a WXVa`WgVfTe*1' Ead â cgX X hXfa WXEaWXd:]XVgf\ha Va`W\V\a`zXeTabXdTf\h\WTW*2'

*1 FJ>GD<6A6K>s%=g_UXdfa &7:C:9:II>% B\ZgX^ r`ZX^& 8:C>868:A6 j 6%BTdxT WX TeC\XhXe%2COCAFLALKPQGQRAGLK?I?OECKQGKL#f' *>%GgU\`kT^&8g^&ka`\% 7gXàe 6\dXe%+))*% b' /0' S

*2 6V^TdTV\z`3^Tbae\V\z` XibgXefT YgXXibdXeTWTbad X Tgfad X` X^'Tà+))- X` X fdTUT]a!K\ZX`V\T j abXdTf\h\WTWWX Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^%:^ H\efX&_T ;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^!% AA WX*)(*+(+))-% Hgb^' 9XdXV[a6_U\X`fT^%b' -'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' *,

K>' A6 EDH>8>uC 8DCIG6G>6 9: :H6>C

?aew 6ÛXdfa:eT\`% X` eg aUdT1LJMCQCKAG?P?J@GCKQ?$ICP#dXUTfXVa` T^fgdTTVTWw_\VTXefTbae\V\z` +)' Hge TdZg_X`&fae e\`fwf\VT_X`fXea` âe e\Zg\X`fXe3

*' Ca eXbgXWXT^fXdTdX dXbTdfaVaèf\fgV\a`T^3^TCTV\z`W\VfTae bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae j ^Tebdah\`V\Te âe Va_b^X&_X`fT`' 6_UTe Va_bXfX`V\Teea` Tgfzà_Te'

+' Ca Xi\efXg`T "`gXhTf\baâZxTWXXjXeeg]XfTeT ^TTbda&UTV\z`WXg` zdZTà T]Xà T ^TCTV\z`%X 8D;:B6'

,' Ca [Tj g` bdaVXW\_\X`fbgXha3 X^â[g`W\dxTg`T WTZTeaUdXX Xebxd\fgWXTGXb{U^\VT;XWXdT6dZX`f\`T'

-' Ca [Tj g` !8a`ZdXea WX TCTV\z` T_U\X`fTÛ\e! #X^8D;:B6$'

.' :e WX_Te\TWaXifdThTZT`fXbdXfX`WXdTh\ZX`V\TWX Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae bad g` TVfaWXg` zdZTà WXd\hT&WaWXg` Va`hX`\a X`fdX TCTV\z` j ^Tebdah\`V\Te'

/' :^ 8D;:B6 `\ e\cg\XdTXefv\`fXZdTWabad ^Te^XZ\e^Tfg&dTe aVT^Xe%e\à bad WX^XZTWaeWXae:]XVgf\hae âVT^Xe'

0' :efT_ae T`fXàd_Te abXdTf\hTe%Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXe&fae _x`\_ae à bgXWXeXdWXeVaàV\WTebad Tgfad\WTWXe]gW\V\T&^Xea TW_\`\efdTf\hTe'

1' :^ 8a`ZdXea [T WXeXV[TWa^T^XVfgdTbdabgXefT3TexVa`^Te XjXe+.'/114 +.'1,* j +.'2*/'

2' C a faWTe Tebdah\`V\Te[T` dTf\Y\VTWaX 6VfT 8aèf\fgf\&hT WX8D;:B6'

!:efT \`fXdbdXfTV\zPeXdXY\XdXT ^TVa`W\V\z`WXhT^\WXkjY\VTV\TXib^\VTWTbdXVXWX`fX_X`fXReXdxTg` cgXUdT`fT_\X`fa

WXae Va`fX`\WaeUve\VaeWXTYad_TWX:efTWabXdZXyTWTbad> e XefTWag`\WXèXej TWabfTWTbad `gXefdae Vaèf\fgjX`fXe'EdXfX`WXdcgX X 8a`ZdXea WX TYXWXdTV\z`bgXWXW\VfTdXjXe` _TfXd\TWXeg Va_bXfX`V\T%bXda eg]XfT&bTdTeg abXdTf\h\&

WTW&T ^TTbdaUTV\z`bad g` zdZTà Va_bgXefa bad ZaU\XdàeâVT^Xej X YXWXdT^%\_badfTdxTTWabfTdae zdWX`XeTgfzà_ae

+) 6UX^XWaEXddaf%7gXàe 6\dXe%+))1% bH' ,)) [ ee'

-1 :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

WXg`T YTVg^fTW_gj bTdXV\WTT ^TWXg^\Y\VTV\z X_bTdX`fTWTVa` g`T Yad_T Va`YXWXdTWT!'

;\`T^_X`fX%j wefTXe^Th\e\z` _ve \_badfT`fX WX TVdxf\&VT%XibdXeT3!H\`VXdT_X`fX%ae bTdXVXWX_Te\TWaT^X]TWaWXâe _T`WTfae [\efzd\Vae WXVaèf\fgjX`fX Va_a bTdTTVXbfTWa':efa {^f\_a Xeâ cgX [T hX`\WaegVXW\X`WaX` faWaeâe VTeaeWXXjXeeXVfad\T^XecgX ^Xe\Zg\Xda` T ^TA<63 +.'/11%+.'1,*j +.'2*/' CTWTeX[T W\V[abad X 8a`ZdXea VgT`WaW\VfzXeTe_\e_Te ^XjXeeXVfad\T^XedXebXVfaT eg h\ZX`V\Tbad WXV\e\z`WX8D;:B6' :^ 8a`ZdXea XeX cgX WXV\W\zWXeXV[TdT^XVfg&

" " " $#dTbdabgXefT%VdXX_aecgX e_ X`fXdTdeXe\cg\XdT 'GXV[Tka XefT \`fXdbdXfTV\z` Va` X^ _\e_a v`\_a WX

:eT\`3 X^WXUTfXVaèfdgVf\ha' AX]aeXefaj WX\d X` WXe_XWdaWX^TYXWXdTV\z`4bad X Va`fdTd\a%_X T`\_T eg WXYXèT'H\ U\X` X^WXeTdda^âad\Z\`T^ WXXefT\`fXdbdXfTV\z++ eX[\ka VgT`Wa^Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae dXV\wVa_X`kTUT` T W\VfTdeX%^TXha^gV\z` baefXd\ad à [\ka _ve cgX YadfT^XVXd_\ ab\`\z`3^TTWXVgTWTh\ZX`V\Tj XYXVf\hTTb^\VTV\z`WX T àd_T WXUXVg_b^\d Va` X dXcg\e\fa XeX`V\TWXH;63 ^T`XVXeTd\TVa`VXd&fTV\z` X` XêXà WX8D;:B6' Aa Va`fdTd\a Xe fT`fa Va_aVaè\WXdTd\`Tb^\VTU^Xeae Tdfe' +,%+- j +. WX T^Xj +.'/0.'EXadT{`%Xehg^`XdTdX^YXWXdT^\e_a_XW\T`fXeg WXZdTWTV\z`\èf\fgV\a`T^'

8dXX_ae cgX ^TVdxf\VThXdf\WTa eaUdXbTeTX bdaU^X_T_ve ZdThXWX Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^ TdZX`f\`T3eg \_b^X_X`fT&V\z` +,' :ibdXeT_ae cgX ^TXeX`V\TWXH;6 XefTU^XV\WaX` ^TA<6 XeâZdTd T\_b^X_X`fTV\z`%bad X^âdXVgdd\dT afdae Td&Zg_X`fae dXeg^fTaV\aea' :eZd\_\d cgX Xe X^bdab\a 8a`ZdXea

+Q :H6>C%?aew6ÛXdfa%1LJMCQCKAG?P?J@GCKQ?ICP#V\f'%b' ,),'++ AT bae\V\z` XibgXefT YgXXibdXeTWTbad X^Tgfad X` X^Tya +))- X` X^

fdTUT]a!K\ZX`V\T j abXdTf\h\WTW''' !%V\f'%b' - #g` Tya T`fXe X` ^TdXh\efT4LOLBC 1RVL WXBX`WakT$' "'

+, KXd 86;;:G6II6% Cwefad%!9X ^T XYXVf\h\WTWWX WXdXV[aT_U\X`&fT^!%AA WX +**)(+))1' 8\fT ^T XibdXe\z` WX6`fa`\a 7X`]T_\`3 !WX]TdWX^TWaX^Va_b^X]a ThXefdgk]gdxW\VacgX eX _T`\Y\XefT X` W\e\_g^Td WX_T&`XdT bTfwf\VTVa_a g` hXâ cgX fTbT g aVg^fT^T WXY\V\X`fXXYXVf\h\WTWWX^WXdXV[aT_U\X`fT^!' ADG:CO:II>%G\VTdWaA'%=CLOZ?BCI BCOCAFL?J@GCKQ?I#AT AXj%7gXàe 6\dXe%+))1% b' 20'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' -2

X cgX a_\fX Vg_b^\d Va` ^TVa`W\V\z`WXhT^\WXkj XY\VTV\TWX^H;6%WT`Wabad X]X_bâ ^XjXecgX%eg_TWTeT afdTe%TVgemmg`ZdThXXefTWaWX\`Vg_b^\_\X`fa% dXhX^TX^XddadWX TVdxf\VT'Ca [Tj g` 8a`ZdXea T_U\X`fTÛ\e%X 8D;:B6 Xe%bad ^Xj jbad VaèXèa WXae :efTWae _\X_Udae cgX TWm\XdX`%g` f5XVT&`\e_a WXVaadW\`TV\z`ba^xf\VTT^cgX ^X[T H>WaVa`YX`WT Te\`Zg^TdYg`V\z` WX_aWXdTd TfXè\z` xè\fT X` X YXWm3T^\e_a_XW\T`fX TVa`VXdfTV\zWX ae \`fXdXeXeX`fdX TCTV\z` j ^Tebdah\`V\Te' ' '

:efT bae\V\z` à bdXfX`WXaUh\TdaUeXdhTV\a`XeT^_efdg&_X`fa WXe\efX_TcgX ea` Xh\WX`fXe3X 8D;:B6 à [T âZdTWaX WXeTdda^â\èf\fgV\a`T^ `XVXeTd\abTdTVg_b^\d Va` X _T`WT&fa ^XZT^'6g`cgX WXUXWXefTVTdeX^TVdXTV\zWXVa_\e\a`Xe WXVTdvVfXdbXd_T`X`fX+- j WXg` bdaVXeaWXdXadZT`\kTV\z TW_\&`\efdTf\hT egefT`f\ha +.' :` Xefa cgXdX_ae eXdV^Tdae3fT`fa ^TCTV\z` Va_a ^Tebdah\`V\Te dXg`\WTeX` X^8D;:B6 ea` âedXebaèTU^XeWXaZdTdg` Yg`V\a`T_\X`fa XY\V\X`fXWXe\efX_T'Aae WXeXcg\^\Ud\ae X` ^TedX^TV\a`XeWXVaadW\`TV\z`TYXVfT`'^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WXTàd_T T_U\X`fT^'KXT_ae ^TedXbXdVge\a&`Xe WXa Vg_b^\dVa` ^T^Xj+.'/0.'

+- Ead dXe' 8D;:B6 0/(+)), eX VdXz T8a_\e\z` 6eXeadT EXd_T`X`&fXeaUdXIdTfT_\X`fa AXZ\e^Tf\ha#86EIA$ bTdTcgX _T`fX`ZT g`T dX^TV\z`Te\WgTVa` âe TeXeadXeWX Te8a_\e\a`Xe 6_U\X`fT^Xe WX8a`ZdXea Va` XâU]Xf\ha WX[TVXdg` eXZg\_\X`fa WXfdv_\fX bTd^T_X`fTd\a WX ae bdajXVfaeT_U\X`fT^XedX^XhT`fXe%T`T^\kTdâe%\`Yad_Td T^8D;:B6 j bdaba`Xd ^TeT^&fXd`Tf\hTeWX_aW\Y\VTV\z`cgX eX Vaè\WXdXabadfg`Te' Ead dXe' *0*(+))2VdXTX` eg v_U\fa ^T8a_\e\z` ?B FLA WX;\`T`V\T_\X`fa >`fXd`TV\a`T^%TVgT^TVfgTdvVa_a TeXeadT%T`fX ^T HXVdXfTdxT:]XVgf\hT j ^T6eT_U^XT%X`fX_Te cgX [TVX` T^Y\`T`V\T_\X`fa \`fXd`TV\a`T^j ^TY\d_TWXVa`hX`\ae%cgX^XYTV\^\fXT^8aèX]a ^Tfa_T WXWXV\e\a`XeX` X^WXeTdda^âWXbdajXVfaedX^TV\a`TWaeVa` ^Tba^xf\VTT_U\X`fT^'

+. GXe' *1.(+))2% bdaVXW\_\X`fae bTdT^TeX^XVV\zWX\`fXZdT`fXebTdT^TXefdgVfgdTWX8D;:B6' HXYg`WTX` X Vg_b^\_\X`fa WXae aU]Xf\hae Xi&bdXeTWaeX` X 6VfT 8aèf\fgf\hT WX8aèX]a% cgm WX_T`WmcgX"X8D;:B6VgX`fXVa` g`T XefdgVfgdTfwV`\VTj TW_\`\efdTf\hT Tbdab\TWT%Va` dXVgdeae[g_Tàe j _TfXd\T^XeegY\V\X`fXe'

.) :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

K>>'A6H 8DCH:8J:C8>6H 9: :AJ9>G :A EGD8:HD

9: 8DC8:GI68>uC3 A6 A>B>I696 :;>868>6

:efX bdaU^X_T à Xe bdab\a WX WXdXV[aT_U\X`fT^4^TVa_b^X]\WTWWXYg`V\a`T_\X`fa WX Teàd_Te ]gdxW\VTeXeg`fX_T cgX X`fdTyTbdaYg`WTedXY^Xi\a`XeeaUdXX^WXdXV[a'@X^&eX` \`fXdbdXfT ae e\Zg\X`fXeVa`VXbfaeYg`WT_X`fT^Xe3 7? CDG$A?AG?BCIBCOCAFLcg\XdXWXV\dcgX âe [a_UdXe eXVa_badfT`X` ^TYad_T X` cgX WXTVgXdWaVa` ^Teàd_Te ]gdxW\VTeWXUX`Va_badfTdeX4a eXT%cgX ^Teàd_Te ea` dXT^_X`fXTb^\VTWTejaUXWXV\WTe'7? S?IGBCWXeg`T VgT^\WTWWXWXdXV[a4T^^T_TWTXY\VTV\T%g`T VgT^\WTWWXTVa`WgVfTdXT WXae [a_UdXe j à%Va_a bTdXVXegZXd\dâX^gea ^\`Z|xef\Va%WXWXdXV[a_\e_a'AT TY\d_TV\z`WXcgX X^WXdXV[aXeXY\VTke\Z`\Y\VTea^T_X`fXcgX ^TVa`WgVfTdXT WX ae \`W\h\WgaeeX T]gefTT ^Teàd_Te]gdxW\VTe'6ex%bgXe%hT^\WXkj XY\VTV\TeXdXY\XdXT YX`z_XàeVa_b^XfT_X`fXW\ef\`fae''' J`T àd_T XeVaè\WXdTWTVa_a hv&^\WTezâ UT]a^TVa`W\V\z`WXcgX bXdfX`XkVTT g` e\efX_T àd&_Tf\ha% T g` adWX cgX%Vaè\WXdTWaX` eg fafT^\WTW%XeXY\VTk'6ex%bgXe%TXY\VTV\TXeVa`W\V\z`WXThT^\WXk%bXdaà ^TdTkz`WXT_\e_T' >K? KLOJ? KLCPSYIGB?MLONRCCPCDGA?W/CPSYIGB?PGCILOBCK?I AR?IMCOQCKCACQGCKC#CKECKCO?I#CDGA?AG?!Q .

Ca WgWT_aeX` eaefX`XdcgX _gV[Te hXVXe Teàd_TeT_U\X`fT^Xe TV\a`T^XeVTdXVXWXXY\VTV\Te\_b^X_X`fX bad&cgX à Vg_b^X` Va` ^TVa`W\V\z` XeX`V\TWXhT^\WXkcgX Xe&fTU^XVXTA<6% afdTehXVXebad à T^VT`kTdege aU]Xf\hae' :`VaèXVgX`V\T%Xe XâdWX`T^ VgT bXdfX`XVX`%X^H;6% X^cgXdXeg^fT\`XY\VTkbad eg dXVgddX`fX\`Vg_b^\_\X`fa'

Ead X^â%VgT`Wa[TU^T_ae WX^T TWXVgTWTh\ZX`V\T jTb^\VTV\z XYXVf\hTWX Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^%T^gW\_ae T ^TebTd&f\Vg^Td\WTWXeWXadWX`T_\X`fa T_U\X`fT^' :e eaUdXXefTee\`&'Zg^Td\WTWXecgX WXUXdXT^\kTdeXX^T`v^\e\e T Y\` WXdXea^hXdX^bdaU^X_TWXeg \_b^X_X`fTV\z` j%WXXefT_T`XdT%TVdXW\fTd^Tea^\WXka à WX Tbae\V\z` YXWXdT^XibgXefT'

+/ @:AH:C% =Tè% =CLOZ?ECKCO?IBCI BCOCAFLV BCI 3PQ?BL# (-*,#b'-/'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' .*

9X^ Va`]g`fa WXad_Te T_U\X`fT^XeeT`V\a`TWTeUT]aX^QXJYRdwZ\_X` bgXWXXifdTXdeXg`T eXd\XWXVa`V^ge\a`Xe dXe&bXVfaWXYg`V\a`T_\X`fa WXmefXe\efX_T j ^TbdaU^X_vf\VmWXeg \_b^X_X`fTV\z`' 6`T^\kT_ae T^Zg`Teàd_Te j ege bTdf\Vg&^TdXee\fgTV\a`Xe3

*' :^ VTeaWX T^Xj +.'/*+ eaUdXEdXegbgXefaeBx`\_aebTdT T<Xef\z` >`fXZdTWXGXe\WgaeXedXhX^TWadTWX TeTà&_T^xTeWXe\efX_T' :efT ^Xj%T`fXd\adT ^T+.'/0.% !g`\Yad_T X`g` _\e_a dwZ\_X` ^TZXef\z` \`fXZdT WXdXe\Wgae\`Wgefd\T^Xe#e\` W\ef\`Zg\dX`fdXdXe\Wgae\`WgemT^XebX^\Zdaeam! !am dX&e\Wgae\`Wgefd\T^XeadW\`Td\aea Xcg\bTdTU^XeT Wa_\V\^\Td\ae$%ZX`XdTWaea WXd\hTWaeWXbdaVXeae\`Wgefd\T^Xe!+0' Ead egbgXe&fa%e\ U\X` Xi\efXg` ZdT` `{_Xda WXW\YXdX`V\TeVa` X dwZ\_X`T`fXd\ad%wefTeVaèf\fgjX` g`T T_b^\TV\z` WXaU]XfadXZg^TWabad ^T^Xj +-').l+1'%

HXfdTfTUTWXg` VgXdbaad_Tf\ha cgXVa` ^TWXU\WTdXZ^T&_X`fTV\z` Vaèf\fg\dxT T^XZ\e^TV\zUve\VTeaUdX T_TfXd\TX`faWaX bTxej cgX ^Tebdah\`V\Te baWdxTVa_b^X_X`fTd' >5XeWXXefTbXdebXVf\hTfXdd\fad\T^%T`TfgdT^XkTWXTàmT fdTeV\X`WXX^v_U\fa WXTb^\VTV\z`WX T^Xj +-').*% V\dVgèVd\bfTX` egXeX`V\TTW_\`\efdTf\hTT ^T]gd\eW\VV\zYXWXdT^'

:` VaèXVgX`V\T%T^Xj +-').* [TUxTcgXWTWaadZv`\VT&_X`fX WXdaZTWTbad ^T+.'/*+% Xa` ^TeXiVXbV\a`XefdTè\ ad\TecgXXibdXeTUTeg Tdfa/) GKDGKC.!6e\_\e_a% [TefT cgX'^TdXZ^T&_X`fTV\z` XefTU^XkVT^TVdXTV\zWXae W\YXdX`fXedXZ\efdaeWX&fXd_\mTWaebad ^TbdXeX`fX4eX_T`fX`Wdv` h\ZX`fXeâe TY\Xiaej dXZ\efdaeVa`fX`\WaeX` W\V[T Xj P^Xj+-').*R!' ' %

AT H6j9H ThT`kz X` X bdaV%XeaWXdXZ^T_X`fTV^D`'WX T %^Xj X`fdXâe Tyae +))+ j +)),' :efX YgXbgXefa T Vaè\WXdT&V\z` X` X^v_U\fa WX8D;:B6% X` Wa`WXWXUxTVa`VXdfTdeXX` h\dfgWWXa W\ebgXefabad X Tdfa0p WXTàd_T ^XZT^'9\V[abdaVXeaà bgWa eXdVg^_\`TWa bad \WX`f\Y\VTdeXX` XeXv_&

+0 86;;:G6I>6% Cwefad%!6bg`fXe TVXdVTWXTAXj WX<Xef\z` >`fXZdTWXGXe\Wgae>`Wgefd\T^Xej 6Vf\h\WTWXeWXHXdh\V\ae!%?6 WX+-(0 (+))+'

+1 Ead X]X_bâ%\`V^gjX âe dXe\'Wmaebd5hX`\X`fwe WX TeTVf\h\WTmXeWXeXdh\V\ae%\`VadbadT âe dXe\WgaeZTeXaeae%_fdaWgVXX^Va`VXbfa WX\hX^XeWXd\XeZae%XefTU^XVXe\efX_Te WXVaadW\`TV\z`\`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`T^%XfV'

.+ :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

U\fa ^Tabae\V\z` WXW\XV\ew\ebdah\`V\Te T ^TdXZ^T_X`fTV\z`bdam"$JXmmT%T^XZv`WaeXeXd\ae \`Va`hX`\X`fXe fwV`\VaebTdT ^TTb^\VTV\z WX^gXha dwZ\_X`'

8aèXVgX`fX_X`fX%X^8D;:B6 X^XhzT^bdXe\WX`fXWX^HX`TWaWX TCTV\z` g`T àfT WXYXV[T+0 WXW\V\X_UdXWX+m)-! _XW\T`fXmTVgT _T`\Y\XefT^TeaU]XV\a`XeT ^T^Xj j âeV`fXàe WX_aW\Y\VTV\z bdabgXefae%dXegX^faeX` ^T-)T TeT_&U^XTadW\`Td\TWXadZT`\e_a% VX^XUdTWTX`fdXâe WxTe*, j *-WXW\V\X_UdXWX+))-'

6^ dXebXVfa%TH6j9H [T X^TUadTWag` W\VfT_X]gdxW\VaeaUdXTmbXVfaeVdxf\VaeWX T^Xj +.'/*+ cgX \_b\WX` eg dXZ^T&_X`fTV\z` j aUefTVg^\kT eg \_b^X_X`fTV\z`'

:` VaèXVgX`V\T%Va`Yad_XT^Tdfa+- WXT^Xj+.'/0.% àeX W\Xda`^TeVa`W\V\a`Xe^XZT^XebTdT eg ?BCAR?B?SGECKAG?V ?MIGA?AG[KCDCAQGS?#TâUfX`Xdg` bda`g`V\T_\X`fa `XZTf\haWX8D;:B6'

+' AT ^Xj `TV\a`T^ +.'/11 #V\fTWTbad :eT\` Va_a X]X_&bâ$%cgX XefTU^XVXâe bdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae T_U\X`fT^XebTdT^TbdXmXdhTV\zWX TeTZgTe%dX{`XX` exfaWae âe h\V\ae cgXVaèb\dT` Va` eg Vg_b^\_X`fa' IwV`\VT_X`fXà XefTU^XVXàd&_Te WXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae% e\à cgX ^TeWX^XZTX` X EaWXd:]XVgf\ha `TV\a`T^%XefTU^XVXadZT`\e_ae WXZXef\z` WXTZgTVgT`Wa Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^f\X`XVa_a ^x_\fXVa_bXfX`V\T^T&V\a`T^ ^TbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^WX ae dXVgdeaeTfgdT^XeVa_abTdfXWXXVae\efX_Tj à eg ZXef\z`%cgX ^Tebdah\`V\Te eX[T`dXeXdhTWa#Tdf' *+-%8C$' Cg`VT aUfgha `\`Zg`T dXea^gV\zàdXVa_X`WTV\zWX8D;:B6 X` X eX`f\WacgX _T`WT ^TA<6'AT bdah\`V\T WXBX`WakT [T TfTVTWaTVaèf\fgV\a`T^\WTWWXXefT ad_T'

!:efT e\fgTV\z` à XeYvV\WXbdXeX`fTdeX%X` VgT`fa ^TTg&fad\WTWTV\a`T^&TbXeTdWXTh\ZX`V\T ad_Tf\hT cgXbdXeX`fT^T^mj WXeWXeg bgU^\VTV\z`&a [T bdaVgdTWaX]XdVXdTeTfd\&UgV\a`XedXZ^TWTe%à [TU\X`WaX` VaèXVgX`V\TWXeTdda^^TWa`\`Zgà WX ae TebXVfaeWXfdTeVX`WX`V\TbdXh\efae X` eg fXi&fa' Ca [T Va`Yad_TWaâe Va_\fw WXVgX`VTecgX Va`fX_b^T X^Tdfa-p% \ X` VaèXVgX`V\T[T bdaVgdTWaX_\f\d W\Vfv_X`Xeh\`&Vg^T`fXeVa_a Va`fX_b^T X^Tdfa/p%`\ [T Va`VdXfTWaTeTVV\a&

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A!% .,

`Xe_T`WTWTebad X Tdfa0p%\ [T bdaVgdTWaWXV^TdTdka`Te Vdxf\&VTeWXbdafXVV\z`XebXV\TVa_a Va`fX_b^T X Tdfa1p!+2'

,' Bve faWThxTe\ T`T^\kT_ae X Va`]g`fa WXad_Te W\VfT&WTebad ^TH6j9H cgX XefTU^XVX`^T!abXdTf\h\WTW!WXeXZgdaT_U\X`fTâU^\ZTfad\a':^ ha^g`fTd\e_a YgXdTWXe\efX_T YXWX&dT^Xeàfad\a' 6ex%X` YXUdXdaWX+))0 eXW\VfTTdXe'H6j9H*00(+))0,p% cgX X` eg Tdfa*^ TbdgXUT Teàd_Te LMCO?QGS?PbTdT^TVa`fdTfTV\z`WX ae eXZgdaebdXh\efae bad X^Tdf' ++ WX^T^Xj+.'/0.'

:efT dXea^gV\z`Xe Va_b^X_X`fTWTj _aW\Y\VTWTbad g`Va`]g`fa WXdXea^gV\a`XebaefXd\adXecgX f\X`X` Va_a aU]Xf\haVdXTdTeVa`W\V\a`XeXVXeTd\TebTdTX egdZ\_\X`fa WXg`T aYXd&fTWXXefXf\ba WXbz^\kT%T^^T`T`WaTe\`VXdf\Wg_UdXeWX^XZa&V\aTeXZgdTWadj TexZX`XdTdTeVa`W\V\a`XeVa_XdV\T^XebTdTXâYdXV\_\X`faWXXefTVaUXdfgdTj [TVXdabXdTf\hT^TaU^\ZTV\z`WXVa`fdTfTd^Te'ATeTfd\UgV\a`XeWXTebdah\`V\Te ea` Va`YgeTe':` XefXbdaVXea%g`VT ^TCTV\z` aUfgha%X` Yad_T bdXh\T`\Va`Va_\fT`fX%\`Zg`T dXVa_X`WTV\za dXea^gV\z`WX8D;:&B6 bTdTeg TWXVgTWTTb^\VTV\z`'Ead X^Va`fdTd\a%_XW\T`fX TdXe'*00(+))2 X` eg Tdfa+p%X 8D;:B6 WXV^TdTcgX !XêXZg&da WXVTgV\z` TVfgT^_X`fXXi\efX`fXà eXVaè\WXdTegY\V\X`fXbTdTZTdT`f\kTd T VaUXdfgdTWXd\XeZaT_U\X`fT^ TeaV\TWaT^g`\hXdea WXeg]XfaeT^VT`kTWae%WXU\w`WaeXVa`f\`gTd X bdaVX&ea dXZg^Tfad\acgXbdab\V\X^TZX`XdTV\zWXT_Tjad j W\hXde\&Y\VTWTaYXdfTWXZTdT`fxTeY\`T`V\XdTedXcgXd\WT!'HXZg\WT_X`fXbdab\V\T!ZX`XdTdg` v_U\fa WXVaadW\`TV\z X`fdX TH6j9H WX^TCTV\z` j ^T86EIA WX8D;:B6 T Y\` WXXefTU^XVXdVd\fX&d\aej ^\`XT_\X`fae bTdTThT`kTdX` X WXeTdda^âWXae TebXVfaebX`W\X`fXeWXdXZg^TV\z\WX`f\Y\VTWaeX` X \`Yad_X TbdaUTWabad X^TdfxVgâT`fXd\adj VaèXègTdVd\fXd\aeVa_g`Xe bTdTX^W\VfTWaWXTàd_Tf\hT âVTVa_b^X_X`fTd\T! #Tdf',p$'

-' :` dX^TV\z`Va` ^T^Xj +.'/0)% cgX XefTU^XVXae bdX&egbgXefae _x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^bTdT^TZXef\z` WX

+2 E>CID% BTgd\V\a%!8aè\WXdTV\a`Xe eaUdX^TbdXfX`W\WTad_T WXbdX&egbgXefae _x`\_ae T_U\X`fT^XeX` _TfXd\T [xWd\VT'6 bdabze\fa WX T ^Xj+.'/11!% AA WX+2(-(+)),% Hgb^%WX9XdXV[a6_U\X`fT^%b' *'

,) 7D WX*,(,(+))0%

.- :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

âe E87e% X^8D;:B6 bad dXe'2.(+))- eaUdXX bdajXVfa WXdXZ^T_X`fTV\z`WX T^Xj +.'/0)% eT`V\a`TWTX^*0(2(+)')-% \`&W\VzcgX X` â Tf\`X`fX T ^TbdabgXefTWXdXZ^T_X`fTV\z`WX Tàd_T X` XiT_X` bgXefTX` Vaè\WXdTV\zbad X EaWXd:]XVg&f\ha `TV\a`T^%dX\fXdTeg bae\V\z` WXcgX Va_bXfXT ^Tebdah\`&V\Te TdXZ^T_X`fTV\z`WXTeàd_Te WXEBE6' Ca aUefT`fX%TCTV\z` bdaVXW\zT eg dXZ^T_X`fTV\z bad WXV'*1.,(+))0,*} ATW\eVadWT`V\TX`fdX ae TVfadXeWXe\efX_T XeXh\WX`fX'

.' AT aUeXdhTV\z`#hXfa$_XW\T`fXX^WXV'*1,0(+))1 T^T^Xj +/'-*1 eaUdXEdXegbgXefaeBx`\_ae bTdT^TEdafXVV\z`WX ae <^TV\TdXej WX6_U\X`fX EXd\Z*TV\TeX egefX`fT X` ^TWXYXèTWXYXWXdT^\e_a,+ j WX T^Xj +.'/0.' :` dXT^\WTW%à[TVX_ve cgX bdaYg`W\kTd TVa`Yge\z`%e\_g^T`Wa ^TWXYXèTWXYXWXdT^\e_aVgT`Waeg bdabze\fa HX_af\hT X` \`fXdXeXeT]X&àe T ^TbdafXVV\z`WXXefaeT_U\X`fXe'6ex%X hXfa \`h\fT T âeZaUXd`TWadXe%eX`TWadXeTV\a`T^Xej W\bgfTWaeTV\a`T^XeWX^Tebdah\`V\Te VadW\^^XdT`TeT Vaèf\fg\d g` !Yada! \`fXdW\eV\b^\&`Td\a bTdT^TW\eVge\z`WX Te_XW\WTeT TWabfTdX` adWX T ^TbdafXVV\z`WX ae Z^TV\TdXej WXT_U\X`fXbXd\Z^TV\T^%VgT`WaVa`Yad_X T ^T_\e_T ^Xj +.'/0.% X^v_U\fa \èf\fgV\a`T* bTdTTUadWTdXefXbdaU^X_TXeX 8D;:B6% WXTVgXdWaVa` âe Tdfe'+, j +- WXTdXYXd\WTàd_T'

EaWdxT_aeTZdXZTdX \`Vg_b^\_\X`fa WX\`Yad_X T_U\X`&fT^T`gT^#Tdf%*1% Xj+.'/0.$% VgT`Wag`T bdah\`V\T Va_a ^TWXBX`WakT â Vg_b^XX` f\X_ba j Yad_T4^TYT^fTWXdXZ^T_X`fT&V\z` WX TAXj WXGXe\WgaeJdUTàe 9a_\V\^\Td\ae4 j ^TWXY\`\&V\z` eaUdX Te\fgTV\z` WXTAXj WXGXe\Wgae>`Wgefd\T^Xe%faWaâ VgT \_b^\VT g`T àfTU^X\`XY\VTV\TX` ^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` ,,'

,* 7D WX/(0(+))0',+ !FgX ^Tbda[\U\V\z` WXTVf\h\WTWXeWXeVd\bfTX` X dXYXd\WaTdfa/p WX^

b3aj'XVfmWX Xj%WXdXZ\d%baWdxTTYXVfTdX^WXeTdda^âXVa`z_\Va WX Tebda&"3>^^8^TH>^^%3a^gVdTWTe%\_b^\VT`Wa ^T \_bae\U\^\WTWWXWXeTdda^^TdVgT^cg\Xdf\ba WXTVf\h\WTWg aUdTX` ka`Te VadW\^^XdT`Te!':efX Vaè\WXdT`WaWXWX&VdXfa a ZgTdWTdX^TV\z`T^Zg`T Va` âe Va_bda_\eae T_U\X`fT^Xej X^Yg`&V\a`T_\X`fa WX8D;:B6'

,, 9> E6DA6% BTdxT:gZX`\T%!+)*)3 WXeTY\aeX` X 7\VX`fX`Td\a!%5KDLO$JC 0J@GCKQ?I0KR?I )'('# ;6GC% 7gXàe 6\dXe%be' /* j ee'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' ..

K>>>'JC 86B7>D EGDB>HDG>D

AT dXZ^T_X`fTV\z`WX^T ^Xj +/',,* cgX XefT5^XVm%âeEBE6 WXae UaecgXe`Tf\hae Xeg` X]X_bâWXVaadW\`TV\z jVaèXèa YXWXdT^'IT_U\w` WXVz_a X 8D;:B6 TVXbfTae dX&Z^T_X`fae WXEaWXd:]XVgf\ha `TV\a`T^' :` XYXVfa%mXWXVdXfa`TV\a`T^2*(+))2 ,- eXdXY^X]TâXibdXeTWaX` âe Vaè^WXdT`Wae3!FgX bTdT ^T X^TUadTV\zWXbdXeX`fXdXZ^T_X`fa eX [T ^^X&hTWaT VTUag` T_b^\a bdaVXeaWXbTdf^V^bTV^DN Vaèg^fT%fT`fa X`fdX^TeW\ef\`fTevdXTeegefT`f\hTe WX T HXVdXfTdx'TWX6_U\X`fX j 9XeTdda^âHgefX`fTU^XWX T?XYTfgdTWXmTU^> mfXWXB\`\efdae% Va_a X`fdX TeTgfad\WTWXeâVT^XeWXTb[VTV^Dm%^TeVgT^XebTdf\V\bTda`T fdThweWX8aèX]a ;XWXdTWXBXW>D6_U\X`fX #8D;:B6$ X` dXg`\z` WX1 WXX`XdaWX+))2 WXT

a_\e\z` WX7aecgXe CTf\hae j WXT8a_\e\z` EXd_T`X`fXWXIdTfT_\X`fa AXZ\e^Tf\haX` ^TTeT_U^XTXifdTadW\`Td\TWX8D&;:B6 VX^XUdTWTX . WXYXUdXdaWX+))2!' 3PQ?KLOJ? ALKPQG$QRVCRK? GKDICUG[KALKPCKQGBLMLPGQGSLF?AG?CIDRKAGLK?JGCKQL

BCI<40% %:efX UdXhXbTàdT_T b\`fT ^TfXè\z` WXe\efX_T YXWXdT^

X` _TfXd\TT_U\X`fT^%dXhX^T`WacgX wefX%VgT`WabdXfX`WXead&fXTdX^bdaVXeaWXVa`VXdfTV\z&jT bad X^X]Xd5\V\aXiVXe\!%aWXbafXefTWXeTV\a`T^Xea bad g`T _T^ X`fX`m^WTTgfaàm_TâVT^&%\`VgddXX` g`T WXZdTWTV\z`cgX eX_T_Y\XefT X` ^T_X&YXVf\hTTb^\VTV\z WXT^Xj T_U\X`fT^'

;B%A6H G:HEDCH67>A>969:H DE:G6I^K6H

AT;6GC% X` eg 5KDLOJC0J@GCKQ?I)''-# TbadfTm` W\TZ&`zef\Va eaUdXX^XefTWaWXVg_b^\_\X`fa WX Tàd_Tf\hT T_&U\X`fT^':` dX^TV\zVa` X fX_T cgX fdTfT_ae%XibdXeTcgX !X`^TedX^TV\a`XeVa` X^8a`ZdXea WX TCTV\z`%X^8D;:B6 mTTVdXVX`fTWa^TeVa_g`\VTV\a`Xe dX^Tf\hTeTâe bdajXVfae ^XZ\e&^Tf\haeX` ^T_TfXd\Tj [T bdabgXefa _aW\Y\VTV\a`XeT ^T'e XjXeXi\efX`fXe'Ca aUefT`fXX^â%X` h\`Vg^TV\z` T ^Te^XjXeK>ZX`fXe

,- 7D WX*/(+(+))2'

./ :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G^D

WXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae WXbdafXVV\z`T_U\X`fT^%Xi\efX` T{`fTdXTebaefXdZTWTe%j cgX [T e\Waeg_T_X`fX W\Y\Vg^faeacgXX` eg eXà eXbdabX`WTT VaèXèae Uve\VaeX`fdX^TCTV\z`%^Tebdah\`V\Te j ^T8676 X` dX^TV\z T ^T \_b^X_X`fTV\z` jdXZ^T_X`fTV\z`Va`VdXfTWXW\V[Te XjXe!,.'

:` X 5KDLOJC0J@GCKQ?I)'('# dXY\d\w`WaeXT^8D;:B6%XibdXeTcgX !bdXeX`fT`g_Xdaeae hTVxaecgX dXcg\XdX WXegTVV\a`TdbTdTcgX ^Te^XjXeT_U\X`fT^XebgXWT eXd\_b^X_X`&fTWTe'HXfdTfTWXg` VaèX]a Va` g`T _XfT Va`VdXfTWXVaad&W\`TV\z` j Va`VXdfTV\z \`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`T^XeX` _TfXd\T T_&U\X`fT^%g` X]XYg`WT_X`fT bTdTcgX ^Teàd_Te T_U\X`fT^XebgXWT fa_TdeX X` [XV[ae Va`VdXfae'Ead X]X_bâ%X^8D;:&B6 T{` à VaèXègz X` eg v_U\fa j Va` ^TTgfad\WTWTV\a`T^âe b^T`Xe WXZXef\z` WXdXe\Wgae\`Wgefd\T^Xej Wa_\V\^\Td\ae':` XefX{^f\_a VTea%X 8D;:B6 WXUXfT_U\w` Y\]Td_XfTe WXW\e_\`gV\z` X` ^TZX`XdTV\z`WXdXe\WgaeWa_wef\Vae!,/' :efX\`Yad_X Vd\f\VTTZd\T_X`fX^TYT^fTWXbTdf\V\bTV\z`X` X^8D&;:B6 WX TeadZT`\kTV\a`XeWXTeaV\XWTWV\h\^'

' 8a_bTdf\_ae XefTeVdxf\VTe%j V\fT_ae%a bad dX\fXdTWa%X^hT^\aea Vaè\WXdT`WaWX T8adfX X` X^VTea!BX`WakT! VgT`&WaTWh\XdfXX` eg eX`fX`V\TWX+) WX]g`\a WX+))/% Va` g`TXibdXe\z` _X_adTU^X%cgX !:^ dXVaàV\_\X`fa WXPQ?QRPVaè&f\fgV\a`T^ WXWXdXV[aT^ZaVXWXg` T_U\X`fX eTà%TexVa_a^TXibdXeTj fxb\VTbdXh\e\z` Tf\`X`fXT ^TaU^\ZTV\z`WXdXVa_&ba`Xd X^WTyaT_U\X`fT^%a Va`Y\ZgdT`g`T _XdT XibdXe\z` WXUmXàej WXeXTU^Xebdabze\fae bTdT^TeZX`XdTV\a`XeWXbadhX&_d%PRMCBGQ?BLPCKPRCDGA?AG?? RK?MLQCPQ?BBGPAOCAGLK?IBCILPMLBCOCPM\@IGALP#DCBCO?ICPLMOLSGKAG?ICP#e\à ^TbdXV\eTjbae\f\'!T WXV\e\z WXVaèf\fgjX`fX WX*22- WXX`g_XdTdj ]X&dTdcg\kTdVa` dT`Za egbdX_a Tg` WXdXV[abdXXi\efX`fX''' ! ,0'

,. 9> E6DA6%BTdxT:gZX`\T%!>`fdaWgVV\z`!%X` 5KDLOJC0J@GCKQ?I)''-#;6GC% 7gXàe 6\dXe%b' */'

,/ 9> E6DA6%BTdxT:gZX`\T%!+)*)3 WXeTYxae''' !%be' //-(//.',0 8adfX Hgb'%+)(/*+))/% !BX`WakT%7XTfd\k H\^h\T [ afdae h' :efTWa

CTV\a`T^ [ afdae e(WTyae[ bXd]g\V\ae#WTyaeWXd\hTWaeWX TVa`fT_\`TV\z`T_U X`fm^5X^3xa BTfT`kT G\TV[gXâ$!%Vaè\W' 0p%X` B'*./2'MA% Va_bX&fX`V\Ta`Z_T`T'

A:<>I>B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' .0

9X T[x `gXefda bdaYg`WadXV[TkaT bae\V\a`Xe WaVfm\mT&d\TecgX X`f\X`WX X^YXWXdT^\e_aT_U\X`fT^Va_a g`T dXdh_&W\VTV\zWXg` Tgfaà_\e_a T\e^TV\a`\efTX \ddXebaèTU^X':^YXWXdT^\e_aW\eVdXV\a`T^cgX ^T8adfX Tbg`fT T Va`fda^TdWXUXeXdX`fX`W\WaVa_a TcgX^X` X^cgX âe _\X_Udae WX TYXWX&dTV\z`ZgTdWTg`T TVf\fgWXZ^\ZX`fXg am\e\mmcgX bdahacgXXYXVf\hT_X`fXg`T WXZdTWTV\zà Va`fT__T8^D` X` âe dXVgd&eae T_U\X`fT^Xe\`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`T^Xe'8gT^cg\XdTeXT^TX^gVg&UdTV\z`]gdxW\Va&\èf\fgV\a`T^cgX eXbdXfX`WTX` WXYXèTWXTeTgfaà_xTe âVT^Xe%wefTef\X`X` g` ^x_\fX%j XeX dXeZgTdWaWXâeU\X`XeT_U\X`fT^Xe,1'

9X^ WXeTdda^âbdXVXWX`fXaUfX`X_ae cgX ^T\_b^X_X`fT&V\z` WXTàd_T T_U\X`fT^dXcg\XdXg` H;6 cgX eXTfT^%XefaXe%cgX X` fT`fa e\efX_T a Va`]J5fm mdWX`T%W5WXYg`Vma`Xej Va_&bXfX`V\TeWwgZTdTàd_Te ]gdxW\VTe'hT^>WTej Tb^\VTU^Xe' '

:e VaddXVfTTdXY^Xi\z WXAa_Zda X` fa_a T^YXWXdT^\e&_a VgT`WaXibdXeT3!H\Z`\Y\VTcgX bTdTe'TUXdcgw fT` YXWXdm^Xe`gXefda e\efX_T WXZaU\Xdà Xe`XVXeTà ^XXd%X` ^T8aèf\&fgV\z` CTV\a`T^%cgw Tfd\UgV\a`Xef\X`X` ^Teg`\WTWXeYXWmdT&f\hTe' EXdaVa_a ^T6dZX`f\`T à eXVTdTVfXd\kTbad X^Xef`VfaTVTfT_\X`faWXTe ad_Te bad bTdfXWXZaUXd`T`fXeC ZaU'Xd`T&Wae%TcgX T`v^\e\e fT_U\w` àe XimZX'hXd\Y\VTdVzma Yg`V>amT`X` ^TbdvVf\VTTeTgfaà_xTe bdah\`V\T^Xe':'e cgX x`WXbX`W\X`&fX_X`fX WX a cgX XefTU^XkVTTAXj HgbXàd Va` dXebXVfaTê\efX_T YXWXdT^WXZaU\Xdà%e\ ^TeTgfad\WTWXeà ^TdXebXfT`%X^YXWXdT^\e_aeXdve\_b^X_X`fX g`T cg\_XdT! ,2' '

6ex%eXTWh\XdfXcgX X \èfdg_X`fa WXXeXH>efX_T&Xm1/0&$;:B6& TWa^XVXWXg`T WXU\^\WTWcgX [T ^^XhTWaT dX^Tffh>mTdeg da^ &UT]aW\ef\`fae TdZg_X`fae&%VamZdThXe'VaèXVgX`8\THX` ^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WXTàd_T T_U>X`fT^'H*) X_UTdZa%X`âe {^f\_ae Tyae [T dXT^\kTWag` ZdT` XeYgXdkabad dmhXdf>dXe'T\`XdV\T'6^Zgàe WXege bda`g`V\T_\X`fae _ve dXV\X`fXeXh\&

WX`V\TXefXbdaVXea-)'

,1 6_b^\Td% WX Tgfad%!:^ Y\` WXYXWXdT^\m_aW\eVdXV\a`T^!%G96_U%aVfgUdX(W\V\X_UdX+))1% AXi\eCXi\e%7gXàe 6>dXe%be' 00 j HH'

,2 ADC^<GD%;w^\i Y%#!:ifdTya YXWXdT^\e_a!%AA +))1&;&*,22'-) KXddXea^gV\a`XeX`3TTT%ALDCJ?%EL@%?O%

.1 ' :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

B%JC CJ:KD E68ID ;:9:G6A 6B7>:CI6A

GX\fXdT_ae%X`fa`VXe%cgX gà WXae TebXVfaeeT^\X`fXeWX^T^Xj+.'/0. Xe[TUXddTf\Y\VTWaâe TVgXdWaeYXWXdT^XeT_U\X`&fT^Xe&6VfT8aèf\fgf\hT WX8D;:B6 j ETVfa ;XWXdT6_&U\X`fT^&%Vaèf\fgjX`Wa TexX^H;6% Va_a X]XbTdT^TTWXVgTWTh\ZX`V\Tj XYXVf\hTTb^\VTV\z WXTe^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x&`\_ae' :efT àd_T% WXXeX`V\Tba^xf\VT%_aWXdT^TfXè\z` >`&e\fT X` X e\efX_T YXWXdT^X`fdXbaWXdXeaVT^Xej baWXdVX`fdT^_XW\T`mXm` v_U\fa WXVa`VXdfTV\z`%X 8D;:B6% cgX \èfT^mVa_a X]X>èfdg_X`fT^ WXH;6'

:ebXV\T^\_badfT`V\T f\X`XX` X^WXeTY\aWXTb^\VTdTàd&_T T_U\X`fT^XÊTVfa;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^' sefX XeT`fXd\adT ^TdXYad_TWX*22-*' N YgX_af\hTWa bad ^TXeVTeTbTdf\V\bTV\z`WX TCTV\z` X` X 8D;:B64 ege bg`fae >>*j K>>dXhX^TXefTe\fgTV\z`' EXdaX` â cgX _ve àe \`fXdXeT%X` eg bg`fa ' eXyT^TVa_a aU]XfaX XefTU^XV\_\X`faWXTVgXdWae_TdVa cgX ?EGIGACKV BCKJ?VLO CDGAGCKAG?? I?MOCPCOS?AG[KBCI?J@GCKQC#fX`\X`WaVa_a dXYXdX`V\TT âe baefg^TWaeWXEdaZdT_T +* TbdaUTWaX`^T8CJB69 2+!' Aae bg`fae >>j >K _T`\Y\XefT` ^T`XVXe\&WTWWXYadfT^XVXdâe adZT`\e_ae âVT^Xej WX!Va_bTf\U\^\kTdC GKPQORJCKQ?O%X` ege ]gd\eW\VV\a`XeT^XZ\e^TV\zT_U\X`fT>m':`fa`VXe XeXh\WX`fXcgX eg bdabze\fa YgX T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WX^Tàd_T T_U\X`fT^' '

' AgXmm%Va` ^TdXYad_TWX T8aèf\fgV\z` CTV\a`T^ j ^Tbma_g^ZTV^D WX Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_x`\_ae% X` XebX&V\T^ TA<6% egdZXVa_a `XVXeTd\aTWXVgTd>aT ^TTVfgT e\fgT&V\z` \èf\fgV\a`T^' =aj ^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WXTàd_T T_U\X`&fT^dXcg\XdXWXg` dXàhTWaXeYgXdka\èf\fgV\a`T^3 PCQO?Q?BC

DLOQ?ICACO?I 194380# Vgja bTbX^\èf\fgV\a`T^ fdTeV\X`WXaad\Z\`T^_X`fX TVadWTWa'

' mme_\X_Udae ea` VaèV\X`fXeWXX^âj fdTUT]T X` XefTW\dXVV\z`%:`' ^T9XV^TdTV\zWX<gT^XZgTjV[{ WX. WX_TjaWX+))/ _T_YXefTda` XâU]Xf\ha WX!YadfT^XVXd^T\èf\fgV\a&`T^\WTWT_U\X`fT^ YXWXdT^!#bg`fa /p$' :` Gxa =a`Wa% X^,)

-* ;gX egeVd\bfa X .(0(*22,'

A:<Î^B>969 N 8DCHIGJ88>uC 9:A 9:G:8=D 6B7>:CI6A''' .2

Wa]g`\a WX+))/% bdDYg`W\kT5XefXam]Xf'\ha3!9Td m` `gXha\Z`\Y\VTWaT ^T dX^TV\z CTV^D`&bdaK>`8>Tm%Vamea[WT`WaT^"D;:B6 à ezâ Va_a VX`fda WXVaadW\`TV\z` j Va`VXd&

fTV\z` Va_a *) Xef\bg^T^TA<6% e\à TWX_veWXY\`\X`WaTebd\ad\WTWXeVa_g`Xe WXTVV\z` X` _TfmdmTT_U\X`fT^X` UTeXg TVgXdWae_x`\_ae% X VaèXèa WXba^xf\VTe%_XfTe j dXeg^fT&WaeXebXdTWae%TexVa_a fT_U\w` ^TTe\Z`TV\z` WX ae dXVgdeaeVaddXeba`W\X`fXe!-+' ' ' ' } '

:^ 8D;:B6 WXUXWX]TdWXeXdg`T _efdfgV\z` WXYg`V\a&`Td\ae `z_TWTe%bTdTZX`XdTdg`T TW_\`\efdTV\z` bXd3`3T`X`fX%TbTkWXTfX`WXdae \``g_XdTm^XeTmg`mae'WX mbDm^f>VTT_&

U\X`fT YXWXdT^%Va` ^TWXU\WTTe\efX`V\TfXV_Va&V^X`f>mmTmâe\èfdg_X`fae WXbTdf\V\bTV\z` XeX`V\T^XebTdT ^T ^XZ\f\_\WTWWXege WXV\e\a`Xe'sefT Xe^TW\dXVV\zcgX eXWXebmm`WXmXegdXe'*1.(+))2 eaUdXbdaVXW\_\X`faebTdT^TeX^XVV\zWX>`fX&ZdT`fXebTdT^TXefdgVfgdTWX8D;:B6' HXYg`WTX5 mTXmX&\WTWWXVa`fTd !Va` g`T XefdgVfgdTfwV`\VTj TW_\`\efdTf\hT

Tbdab\TWT%Va` dXVgdeae[g_Tàe j >5TfXd\T^XmemY\V\X`fXe!'''ETdTXefXbdabze\fa WXUXVg_b[d ^Tebdah_V\Te j ^TCTVâm

Va` g`T TYXVfTV\zbdXegbgXefTd\TbXd_T`X`fX bTdT'X^mDHfm5>&_\X`fa WXadZT`\e_a #Tdf'*)%\`V' VR%WX6VfT 85èf>fgf>hm$''

9XUX bdaYg`W\kTdeg bdafTZa`\e_a ba^xffma'3bTdf^m^bTdX` X fdTfT_\X`fa WX Te^XjXeWXbdXegbgXefae_>5^_DH%W>mfTdVa`VXdfTWT_X`fXTedXea^gV\a`Xea dXVa_X`WTV^D`XmWX\_&b^X_X`fTV\z` fT`fa WX ae EBE6 Va_a mX TedXebXVf^%3%Te'àd&_Te Va_b^X_X`fTd\Te%Teg_\d Va_bda_êam WXVg_b[_'^X`faâVT^%TVadWTdbdaVXW\_\X`faebTdTX fdTfT_^X`f5WXVgmem^D`Xe\`fXd]gd\eW\VV\a`T^Xe%[TVXdbTdf\V\bTdT ^T eaV\XWTW'V^h^^%Xe&fTU^XVXddX^TV\a`XeWXVaadW\`TV\z`Va` afdae adZT_e_ae X&WXdT^Xe%X^TUadTdg` bdaZdT_T WXTb^\VmV\5WX Tàd_mm*KTT_U\X`fTêg]Xfa T \`W\VTWadXeWXVg_b^\_\X`fa4 X` WXY\`\f\hT%

-+ KXdfXifa Va_b^Xfa TTT%ALDCJ?%EL@%?O% # %-, GXe' 8D;:B6 *00(+))23 Tdfa,p3 !:`Va_X`WTd T ^THXVd'Xfm`T:?XVm&

f\hT ^TX^XhTV\zT ^TTeT_U^XTWXg`T bdabgXefTbTdTX^'3adfT^XV^_^m`faba^m&f\Va \èf\fgV\a`T^ WX8D;:B6 fX`W\X`fXT ^TdXhT^\WTV\zWXT^fa_hX>%5a[&f\Va WXVa_bda_\ea YXWXdT^Va` X T_U\X`fX j X^WXeTdda^âegefX`fTU^X'

-- ;Gt6H% EXWda?'%!AT dXWX`V\zWX Tebdah\`V\Te!%AA +))-&7&*-*2'

/) :A 6B7>:CI: :C A6 6G<:CI>C6 9:A 7>8:CI:C6G>D

TVfgT^\kTdege aU]Xf\hae X` bdaVgdTWXVg_b^\d X da^ Te\Z`TWaX` ^T^Xj`TV\a`T^ +.'/0.'

8a`Yad_X T XefXWXeTdda^â%eXWT`^TeVa`W\V\a`XebTdT^TTVfgT^\kTV\z WXETVfa ;XWXdT6_U\X`fT^ Va_a \èfdg_X`faba^xf\VaV^ThXbTdTXefTU^XVXddXàhTWae_XVT`\e_ae cgX TeX&ZgdX`^T\_b^X_X`fTV\z` WXTàd_T T_U\X`fT^'AT Va`ZdgX`&V\T%Tea^\WTd\WTWj ^TVaabXdTV\z`Vaèf\fgjX` ^TeW\dXVfd\VXebTdTXefT gXhT XfTbTj bTdTâZdTdX Yg`V\a`T_\X`fa Td_z`\VaWXH;6'

IXd_\`T_ae Va` g`T V\fTWX;dxTe% ^X`TWX\èb\dTV\z`3!EdXef\Z\TdX^YXWXdT^\e_a%X` eg_T%WXbX`WXWX TedX^TV\a`XeX]X_b^TdXeX`fdX^TCTV\z` j X^^TeP^Tebdah\`V\TeR%WX T_T&WgdXkWX TedXZ\a`Xe%WXTeT^\T`kTe\`fXddXZ\a`T^Xe%WX TVa&ddXVV\zWXTe\`XdV\TeUgdaVdvf\VTe%WXTVTbTV\WTWWXTV^TeXba^xf\VT%X` âe VaèXèae bTdTba^xf\VTeWX:efTWa%WXTW\e_\&`gV\z` WXZTefa b{U^\Vaj ^TbdXYXdX`V\Tbad X^VTb\fT \`hXd&f\Waj WXVa_bda_\ea WX TeaV\XWTWVa` ^Th\WTb{U^\VT'N%WXeWXgXZa%WX]TdTfdveâe dXZx_X`XeYXgWT^XeWXV^\X`fX^\e_aj dXX^XVV\a`XeegVXe\hTe!--'

Situación de La Política y de La Gestión Ambiental en Argentina

Documents

Transcript of Situación de La Política y de La Gestión Ambiental en Argentina