8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 1/21
»Moskjoeog, pgtrogr`ghosmk y rkhbs cb jïebrk be Hg Sobrrg Mbcog;
Hgs knrgs cb hks jrgecbs jbeoks sobmprb vge g`kmpg÷gcgs cb vghkrg`okebs y
prbduo`oks qub, `ke frb`ube`og, sb rbpotbe `kmk b`ks soe sbetock g hk hgrjk cb tobmpk,
hhbjgeck g sbr `kesocbrgcks vbrcgcbs oe`ubstokegnhbs pkr tkcks. Bh prkpok Skhiobe sbskrprbecíg cb ghjuegs cb hgs ríto`gs qub rb`oníg, qub gtronuíg g hg oe`kmprbesoðe, b oe`husk
g hg fghtg cb hb`turg cb hg knrg7. Cb betrb bstks gxokmgs, bh qub pgrto`uhgrmbetb mb pgrb`b
mçs oedustk y cbs`gnbhhgck bs hg g`usg`oðe cb moskjoeog y pgtrogr`ghosmk>, bspb`oghmbetb
gh `kmpgrgrhk `ke ktrgs knrgs cbh mosmk jïebrk cb hg g`tughocgc0.
Hg hotbrgturg fgetçsto`g y cb `obe`og fo``oðe be jbebrgh, age sock curgmbetb
`roto`gcgs pkr hks fbmoeostgs `kmk @okffo4 «Ptohh, tab rkhbs tagt fbmghb `agrg`tbrs phgybc
wbrb bxtrbmbhy homotbc nkta oe s`obe`b fo`toke gec oe fgetgsy. Oe s`obe`b fo`toke, wkmbewbrb wovbs, jorhfrobecs, s`obetosts‟ cgujatbrs, kr rbwgrcs fkr abrko` cbbcs pbrfkrmbc. Oe
fgetgsy, taby wbrb jkccbssbs, wot`abs, fgorobs, kr cbvoh-wkmbe. Oe ebotabr jberb coc
fbmghb `agrg`tbrs agvb gey psy`akhkjo`gh ktabr tage tab stbrbktypbs oe wao`a taby wbrb
`gst.¹3
@ke Skhiobe, Mgroke Tommbr Nrgchby bs bspb`oghmbetb curg4 «Skhiobe coc ekt
put gey wkmbe oe aos nkkis bx`bpt tab mktabrhy bhf-qubbe Jghgcrobh gec tab gmnotokus
Ïkwye wak agc tk hbgre ekt tk wosa tk nb g abrk (takuja sab wgs jovbe abr `age`b gt
7 «Ghjueks cb hks qub hbybrke bh honrk, k gh mbeks hk rbsb÷grke, hk age be`ketrgck gnurrock,gnsurck k cbsprb`ognhb9 y yk ek tbejk pkr quï qubdgrmb, pubs pobesk `gso hk mosmk g`br`g cb sus knrgs, kcb hks topks cb honrks qub bvocbetbmbetb prbfobrbe.¹ Be bh prbfg`ok cb 7?66 g hg sbjuecg bco`oðe cb Bh Pb÷kr
cb hks Geohhks y rb`kjock pkr Paoppby be PAO\\B_, S.G.4 Bh `gmoek g hg Sobrrg Mbcog. Ngr`bhkeg4Moektgurk ><<>4><.
> @R^^_, \.4 «Hbss Ekosb gec mkrb Jrbbe4 Skhiobe‟s Ocbkhkjy fkr Bejhgec¹ be ^BOEKHCP \.y JKKCIEOJAS J.A. (bcs.)4 \rk`bbcoejs kf tab D.^.^. Skhiobe @betbegry @kefbrbe`b. Mohtke Ibyebsgec Ghtgcbeg4 Sab Skhiobe Pk`obty gec Sab Mytakpkbo` Pk`obty 7??>, 7>:. Pb rb`kjbe hgs mçs ompkrtgetbs`ríto`gs be bstb sbetock be C^KRS, M.C.@. (bc.)4 D.^.^. Skhiobe Be`y`hkpbcog. P`akhgrsaop gec @roto`gh
Gssbssmbet . Ebw _kri4 ^kuthbcjb ><70, ><>-><0. 0
Ek bs mkmbetk eo hujgr pgrg ag br ueg rbfhbxoðe be prkfuecocgc cbh tbmg pbrk, pkr bdbmphk, hgsgjg cb Jbkrjb ^.^.Mgrtoe, @ge`oðe cb Aobhk y Fubjk, rbvbhg qub hg gnuecge`og cb pbrskegdbs fbmbeoeksek tobeb pkr quï sojeofo`gr ueg vghkrg`oðe supbrokr cb hgs mudbrbs, eo hg phgsmg`oðe cb ke`bptks cb ojughcgccb jïebrk cbh sojhk QQO. Mgrtoe cbmubstrg ueg agnohocgc bxtrgkrcoegrog pgrg `grg`tbrozgr cb mgebrgcofbrbetb g ueg jrge `getocgc cb g`tgetbs cb gmnks sbxks, so nobe sus mudbrbs `kmpgrtbe sobmprb bh rgsjkcb hg bstuhto`og, hg agnohocgc cb hhbvgr hg cbsjrg`og g sus ghhbjgcks y, jbebrghmbetb, `kesbjuor hk `ketrgrok ghk qub prbtbecbe. Hg aostkrog cb @ge`oðe cb aobhk y fubjk sb sotôg be ue mueck fo`to`ok mbcobvgh,
proe`opghmbetb be ue `ketoebetb hhgmgck \keobetb pbrk tgmnoïe be ue vgstk `ketoebetb krobetgh, `kek`ock`kmk Bssks. Krojoeghmbetb phgebgcg `kmk ueg trohkjíg, g`tughmbetb sb bspbrg qub hg sbrob sbg uegabptghkjíg4 Dubjk cb trkeks ( G Jgmb kf Sarkebs, 7??6), @akqub cb rbybs ( G @hgsa kf Ioejs, 7??1),Skrmbetg cb bspgcgs ( G Ptkrm kf Pwkrcs, > vkhs. ><<<), Fbstíe cb `ubrvks ( G Fbgst fkr @rkws, ><<2) y
Cgezg cb crgjkebs ( G Cge`b wota Crgjkes, ><77) trgcs. pkr @rostoeg Mg`íg y punho`gcks pkr Jojgmbsa(><<>-><7>).
3 @OKFFO, I.4 «Sypbs kf Fbmoeost Fgetgsy gec P`obe`b Fo`toke¹ be ZBBCMGE, D.N.4 ZkmbeZkrhcwghibrs4 Ebw Combesokes kf P`obe`b Fo`toke. Hunnk`i4 Sbxgs Sb`a. Bgrta Mktabrs kr MghbMbmkrobs, Zohabhm, Hbm, gec Futurb Zkmbe 7?12, 13.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 2/21
ngtthb, tagei jkkcebss!)¹2 _ Ptompske `kesocbrg qub sus pbrskegdbs fbmbeoeks ske
«ag`iebybc…stbrbktypbs…botabr nbgutofuh gec costget, somphy costget, kr somphy
somphb¹6.
Hg g`usg`oðe pgrtb proe`opghmbetb cbh ab`ak cb qub hg mgykríg cb pbrskegdbs ske
skhtbrks k auïrfgeks b oe`husk ue pubnhk betbrk, hks bets, `ubetge qub age pbrcock g sus
mudbrbs. Hk obrtk bs qub bstb rgsjk nobe pkcríg rbspkecbr g ueg ubstoðe nokjrçfo`g, mçs
qub g ue oetbetk cbhonbrgck cb moeomozgr hg prbsbe`og fbmbeoeg be su knrg. D.^.^. Skhiobe
y su abrmgek Aohgry sb qubcgrke auïrfgeks g muy tbmprgeg bcgc y qubcgrke g `grjk cb
ue sg`brcktb, qub tbrmoeð sobeck hg fojurg mçs ompkrtgetb be su vocg:. Suvk trbs aodks y
skhk ueg aodg y hg oembesg mgykríg cb sus `khbjgs y ghumeks brge akmnrbs. Be su
gmnobetb prbckmoegnge hgs fojurgs mgs`uhoegs1 y tgmnoïe gsí be sus proe`opghbs
oefhube`ogs hotbrgrogs4 be hg ïpo`g, hg mgtbrog grtôro`g k hks honrks cb `gnghhbrígs, hgs
aostkrogs sb `betrge mçs be hg gvbeturg cb hks aïrkbs qub be su rbhg`oðe `ke hgs cgmgs.
Hbybeck hg knrg cb Skhiobe, oe`huocgs sus `grtgs?, qubcg `hgrk qub brg ue akmnrb
cb vghkrbs trgco`okeghbs, hk ugh ek quobrb cb`or qub fubrg mosðjoek, soek somphbmbetb ue
akmnrb prkcu`tk cb su tobmpk. Nbevbeutk ag`b ue mgjeífo`k rbsumbe cb hg mgeofobstg
`ketrgco``oðe betrb hgs kpoeokebs sknrb hgs mudbrbs `kesbrvgcgs be hgs `grtgs punho`gcgs,
muy oefhuocgs pkr hg bcu`g`oðe vo`tkrogeg cb hg ïpk`g, y su `kmpkrtgmobetk `ke hgs
fïmoegs `ke hgs qub tuvk rbhg`oðe4 su bspksg `ke hg qub prktgjkeozð ueg aostkrog cb gmkr
qub hb sorvoð cb oesporg`oðe hotbrgrog, su aodg \ros`ohg, sus ghumegs y, g pbsgr cb hk
bxprbsgck be hgs grtgs sknrb ek rbbr be hg gmostgc betrb akmnrbs y mudbrbs, sus gmojgs
`kmk Pomkeb c‟Grcbeeb, hg prkfbskrg Abhbe M`Mohhge Nu`iaurst, Bhgoeb Jrofotas, Ptbhhg
Mohhs, Mgry Pghu y su sb`rbtgrog Dky Aohh7<.
G mo duo`ok, hks `ríto`ks sb age ngsgck be bstgs `grtgs, rb`krcbmks qub
sbhb``okegcgs y rbtk`gcgs pkr ktrks trgs su mubrtb, pgrg ngsgr sus tbkrígs cb moskjoeog y
2 TOMMB^ N^GCHB_, M.4 «^bspkesonohotobs gec Sbmptgtokes kf Zkmbe P`obe`b Fo`tokeZrotbrs¹ be ZBBCMGE Zkmbe kp. `ot., 01.
6 C^KRS kp.`ot., :7>. Hgurg Mo`abh rb`kjb ktrgs `ríto`gs be hg mosmg híebg, be MO@ABH, H.4«\khoto`ghhy Oe`krrb`t4 Skhiobe, Zkmge gec Fbmoeosm¹ be F. ZBOE^BO@A & S. AKEBJJB^4 Skhiobe
gec Mkcbreoty. Puozg4 Zghioej Srbb \unhosabrs ><<6, 62-6:.: Hg nokjrgfíg cb Frge`os Mkrjge ag sock punho`gcg pkr FB^^ÇECBT N^R, D.M.4 Hg @kebxoðe
Bspg÷khg cb D.^.^. Skhiobe. Bh ‘tík @urrk”. Gstkrjg4 @PBC ><70.1 @G^\BESB^, A.4 D.^.^. Skhiobe. Reg Nokjrgfíg. Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><<>.
? @G^\BESB^, A.4 Sab Hbttbrs kf D.^.^. Skhiobe.R.P.G.4 Akujatke Moffhoe @kmpgey ><<<.7< NBEVBERSK, M.^.4 «Gjgoest Ptbrbktypb4 Ïkwye gec Hôtaobe gs ><ta @betury Zkmbe¹, beF. ZBOE^BO@A & S. AKEBJJB^4 Skhiobe gec Mkcbreoty. Puozg4 Zghioej Srbb \unhosabrs ><<6, 00-02.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 3/21
fghtg cb kmprbesoðe, mçs qub be gspb`tks cb sus egrrg`okebs77. _ rb`krcbmks qub hg knrg
cb Skhiobe rbquobrb ue bsfubrzk pkr pgrtb cbh hb`tkr, qub cbnb hbbr betrb híebgs k fodgrsb
be pbqub÷ks cbtghhbs qub beroqub`be y cge prkfuecocgc gh grjumbetk7>.
Guequb ek cbnbmks bspbrgr tgmpk`k vbr be bh pgcrb cb hg fgetgsíg mkcbreg ue
mohotgetb fbmoeostg, prkngnhbmbetb sbg, cb betrb hks gutkrbs cbh jïebrk, bh qub ag trgtgck
g sus abrkíegs `ke mgykr rbspbtk y `kesocbrg`oðe. @kmk sb÷ghg M`Ebw4 «Sarbb taoejs
grb `hbgr4 ab wgs fgr frkm nboej g moskjyeost, tab fbmghb `agrg`tbrs oe aos mgstbrpob`b
`khhb`tovbhy rbprbsbets ghh tagt‟s jrbgt tagt nboej g wkmge, gec hbss rbprbsbetgtoke ckbs
ekt bqugh hbss ompkrtge`b.¹70
Be Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks y Bh Pohmgrohhoke, tkcgs hgs qub gpgrb`be hk ag`be `ke
ueg jrge ompkrtge`og pgrg bh cbsgrrkhhk cb hg trgmg, `kmk vbrbmks be cbtghhb g
`ketoeug`oðe. Ghjuegs oe`husk supkebe ueg rbprbsbetg`oðe pbrfb`tg cb grqubtopks
`kesgjrgcks be hg hotbrgturg grtôro`g y `gnghhbrbs`g, guequb mu`ak mçs cbsgrrkhhgcks y
ro`ks be mgto`bs4 Grwbe `kmk hg cgmg, Jghgcrobh `kmk mgjg nbeïfo`g y Ïkwye `kmk
cke`bhhg jubrrbrg. \kr g÷gcocurg, hg getgjkeostg fbmbeoeg, mgjg cognðho`g k jojgetbs`g,
pbrskegdb rb`urrbetb cb hgs `gnghhbrígs, hg motkhkjíg hçso`g k oe husk hks `ubetks cb agcgs,
ek gpgrb`b. Skcgs hgs mudbrbs vge g bstgr sobmprb voe`uhgcgs gh ngeck cbh Nobe, `ke hg
pksonhb bx`bp`oðe cb `kesocbrgr g Bhhg-Hgrg÷g `kmk pbrskegdb y ek `kmk mkestruk73.
Po nobe obrtks ríto`ks fbmoeostgs utohozge tgmnoïe bstk kmk grjumbetk be ketrg.
@kesocbrge qub hg fghtg cb rbprbsbetg`oðe cb mghcgc fbmbeoeg sbríg ueg prubng mçs cb hg
77 \kr bdbmphk, Skhiobe gprknð hg gcgptg`oðe tbgtrgh cb \gtro`og Jrgy cb Bh Aknnot be 7?61 ckecbbe hujgr cbh rby cb hks bhfks, agy ueg rboeg. MO@ABH kp.`ot., 67.
7> Re bdbmphk cb bstg roqubzg cb mgto`bs ek rbhg`okegck `ke bh trgtgmobetk cb hks pbrskegdbsfbmbeoeks sbríg hgs rbfbrbe`ogs gh fubjk be hgs cbs`rop`okebs cb Jgecghf y sus bstgcks cb çeomk, bhbmbetk`ke bh qub tobeb ueg bspb`ogh gfoeocgc gcbmçs cbh Geohhk Egryg. Skcg su knrg bstç phgjgcg cb bstb topk cbcbtghhbs, frb`ubetbmbetb oesoeugcks mçs qub bxprbsgcks, qub quozç age pgsgck cbsgpbr`onocks g sus
cbtrg`tkrbs, pubcb qub pkr hb`turgs rçpocgs k oetbrbsgcgs.70 M`EBZ @.H.4 «Mbe grb frkm Jkeckr, Zkmbe grb frkm Hktahkrobe¹ be Sab \bkphb‟s Juocb tk
D.^.^. Skhiobe (Sab Keb^oej.ebt bcs.). @khc Pproej Agrnkr4 @khc Pproej \rbss ><<0, 772.73 @kmk nobe sb÷ghg Hgurg Mo`abh4 «Pabhkn os fbmghb fkr nokhkjo`gh rbgskes¹ be MO@ABH kp.`ot.,
6:. Hg oetbrprbtg`oðe frbucogeg cbh befrbetgmobetk betrb Pgm y Bhhg-Hgrg÷g cofí`ohmbetb pubcb sbr tkmgcgbe sbrok, be \G^S^OCJB, N.4 «Ek Pbx \hbgsb ‐ Zb³rb Aknnots4 Sab @kestru`toke kf fbmghb Pbxughoty oeSab Hkrc kf tab ^oejs¹ be JOCCOEJP, ^.4 D.^.^. Skhiobe4 Saos Fgr Hgec. Hkecke4 Vosoke & Ngrebs&Eknhb 7?13, 7?7. _ hg bxpho`g`oðe cb qub g Skhiobe hb cbsgjrgcgnge hgs grg÷gs, cgcg hg `getocgc cb bhhgsqub gpgrb`be be su knrg, pbsb g hk co`ak be hg `grtg 760 g Z.A. Gucbe (@G^\BESB^ Hbttbrs kp. ot., >7:),mb pgrb`b mçs kevoe`betb qub hg cb vbr g bstb mkestruk kmk «ge bxprbsoke kf akstohoty tk tab fbmbeoeb¹,be PSOM\PKE, @.4 D.^.^. Skhiobe. Ebw _kri4 @khumnog Reovbrsoty \rbss 7?6?, 7?. Ktrks hg `ghofo`gesomphbmbetb `kmk hg `grg kpubstg cb Jghgcrobh, hg ocbghozg`oðe `ketrg hg mkestruksocgc, be FBEZO@I,M.4 «Nrbgstphgtbs kf Pohi4 Akmbro` Zkmbe oe Sab Hkrc kf tab ^oejs¹ be Mytahkrb 17, 7??6, >0 y
CKEKVGE, H.G.4 «Sab Vghiyrob ^bbx oe D.^.^. Skhiobe‟s Sab Hkrc kf tab ^oejs4 Jghgcrobh, Pabhkn,Ïkwye, gec Grwbe¹ be @AGE@B, D. (Bc.)4 Skhiobe tab Mbcobvghost . Hkecke gec Ebw _kri4 ^kuthbcjb><<0, 77>-7>7.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 4/21
fghtg cb `kmprbesoðe cb Skhiobe cb hgs mudbrbs y su phgsmg`oðe `kmk grqubtopks
pbrfb`tks b oegh`gezgnhbs, `ksg fç`ohmbetb cbsmketgnhb `ke skhk b`agr ue vostgzk g
pbrskegdbs `kmk Mkrwbe hg mgcrb cb Suroe, hg rboeg Nbrutaobh, Brbecos…
Sgmnoïe sb ag `roto`gck hg gusbe`og cb sbxk be hg knrg, g`ag`gcg g hg supubstgoemgcurbz sbxugh cbh gutkr 72 k sb age nus`gck oetbrprbtg`okebs mçs ghhç cb hk qub hg knrg
sujobrb76. Be mo kpoeoðe, hg cbs`rop`oðe moeu`oksg cb rbhg`okebs sbxughbs bxphí`otgs, betrb
hks covbrsks pbrskegdbs qub sb quobrge bmpgrbdgr, ek gpkrtgríg egcg eo gh grjumbetk eo g
hg grg`tbrozg`oðe cb eoejuek cb bhhks. _g agy jïebrks hotbrgroks bspb`ífo`ks betrgcks be
bsks gspb`tks y be hks qub, frb`ubetbmbetb, bstçe gusbetbs rgsjks muy cbstg`gcks be
Skhiobe `kmk ske bh abrkísmk, hg gmostgc, bh ghtruosmk… y g egcob sb hb k`urrb `roto`gr g
sus gutkrbs pkr bhhk7:.
Mb `betrgrï be bh geçhosos bspb`oghmbetb be Bh Aknnot y Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks,
cgck qub ske hgs ôeo`gs ekvbhgs gmnobetgcgs be hg Sobrrg Mbcog qub punho`ð D.^.^.
Skhiobe be vocg, y pkr tgetk, qub pkcbmks bstgr sbjurks cb qub rbspkecbe pkr `kmphbtk
g hg oetbe`oðe cbh gutkr. Poe bmngrjk, cbnock g hg tktgh gusbe`og cb fïmoegs be Bh Aknnot
(mgh qub hb pbsb g \btbr Dg`iske71) y hg ompkrtge`og cb Bh Pohmgrohhoke be bh `keduetk cb
knrg, tgmnoïe oe`huorï cb mgebrg tgejbe`ogh ghjueks pbrskegdbs cb ïstb. Ek knstgetb, sb
cbnb tbebr be ubetg qub cbco`ð tkcg su vocg g su rbcg``oðe7?
, pkr hk qub bxostbe cofbrbetbsvbrsokebs, bstgng trgngdgeck be ïh `ugeck muroð y sb punho`ð cb fkrmg pðstumg pkr su
aodk @arostkpabr. Pgnbmks qub D.^.^. qubríg oe`huorhk g mkck cb gpïeco`bs cb Bh Pb÷kr
72 PSOM\PKM kp.`ot., ><76 Nrgchby vb mçs qub ueg gmostgc be hg rbhg`oðe betrb Pgm y Frkck be TOMMB^ N^GCHB_, M.4
«Mbe, Aghfhoejs gec Abrk-Zkrsaop¹ be OPGG@P, E.C. y TOMNG^CK, .G. (bcs.)4 Skhiobe gec tab roto`s.
Bssgys ke D.^.^. Skhiobe³s Sab Hkrc kf tab ^oejs. Oecogeg4 Reovbrsoty kf Ektrb Cgmb \rbss 7?:<, 10.7:
Ibebta Mg`Hbosa `kesocbrg qub hg gusbe`og cb sbxk ag`b qub sbg cofí`oh `kesocbrgr Bh Pb÷kr cbhks Geohhks ghjk mçs qub ue somphb ubetk pbrk, kmk nobe gcu`b \gtro`i @urry, bs kmphbtgmbetb rocí`uhky hk kmpgrg ke ktrgs ekvbhgs be hgs qub tgmpk`k gpgrb`b kmk Mkny Co`i. Be @R^^_ \.4 «Skhiobe gecaos `roto`s4 G `rotoqub¹ be ^kkt gec Nrge`a4 Gpprkg`abs tkwgrcs Recbrstgecej Skhiobe (AKEBJJB^ S.bc.). Turo`a4 Zghioej Srbb \unhosabrs ><<2, 17-1>.
71 Ek vky g rbfbrormb mçs g hgs gcgptg`okebs oebmgtkjrçfo`gs cgck qub su kmphbdocgc rbqubrorígue trgngdk `kmphbtk qub bspbrk gnkrcgr be bh futurk. Ôeo`gmbetb sb÷ghgr qub, g pbsgr cb prbtbecbr«`krrbjor¹ fghhks `ke rbspb`tk g hks rkhbs cb jïebrk cb Skhiobe pgrg gcgptgrhks gh sojhk QQO, g mo mkck cbvbr, `kesojub bh bfb`tk `ketrgrok. \kr bdbmphk, sotôg g ^ksotg @ktk cb tgnbrebrg, supkejk qub oetbetgeckgprkxomgrhg g hg mudbr trgngdgckrg, pbrk ek tobeb eo ueg híebg cb tbxtk y tkcgs sus oetbrvbe`okebs sb rbcu`beg skerbír `ke `grg cb tketg y bspbrgr pgsovgmbetb g qub bh dgrcoebrk mbcok nkrrg`ak sb cb`ocg g `kevbrtorhgbe ueg mudbr akebstg. _ bs mbdkr eo mbe`okegr hg oeeb`bsgrog `rbg`oðe cb Sgurobh pgrg Bh Aknnot.\rkngnhbmbetb sbg @arostkpabr Skhiobe quobe mbdkr ag cbfoeock hgs `rbg`okebs cb Dg`iske4
attp4//www.wkrhc`rue`a.`km/`uhturb-sk`obty/my-fgtabr-<0?-s-qukt-bvos`brgtbc-qukt-wkri-ske-kf-aknnot-s`ronb-d.r.r.-tkhiobe-foeghhy-spbgis-kut/aknnot-sohmgrohhoke-hkrc-kf-roejs/`0s7<>??/#.RK>swIz`yPr7? JG^SA, D.4 Skhiobe y hg jrge jubrrg. Bh krojbe cb hg Sobrrg Mbcog. Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><73.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 5/21
cb hks Geohhks pbrk qub, foeghmbetb, ek puck ag`brsb y cbs`kek`bmks hg `kefkrmg`oðe
cbfoeotovg qub aunobsb qubrock qub tuvobsb.
7.
Hgs aknnots
Cgcg hg fk`ghozg`oðe cb gmnks rbhgtks cbscb bh puetk cb vostg cb hks aknnots><,
pgrb`b gprkpogck `kmbezgr pkr bstks. Be hg `grtg >73 g G.@. Euee>7 cbdg nobe `hgrk qub
be bstg sk`obcgc gmnks `ðeyujbs tbeíge hks mosmks cbrb`aks, guequb fue`okebs brge
cofbrbetbs. @ughquobrg cb bhhks brg `kesocbrgck bh rbprbsbetgetb cbh ktrk be `gsk cb
gusbe`og, mubrtb oe`huocg. Po bh vgrðe mkríg prombrk, su hujgr hk k`upgng su bspksg,
pucobeck sbr `gnbzg k totuhgr cb ueg fgmohog eumbrksg k `hge, qub ek pgsgng gh aodk k g
ghjôe ktrk abrbcbrk mobetrgs bhhg vovobrg, g ek sbr qub rbeue`ogrg vkhuetgrogmbetb. \kr
tgetk, pkcíg k`urror be vgrogs `or`uestge`ogs qub ueg mudbr hkejbvg cb `grç`tbr fubrtb
sojuobrg sobeck «`gnbzg cb fgmohog¹ agstg tbebr eobtks pbrfb`tgmbetb gcuhtks, kmk k`urrb
`ke hg gnubhg cb Jkhhum>>.
Hg prombrg aknnot cb hg qub tbebmks ekto`ogs bs hg mgcrb cb Nohnk, Nbhhgckeg>0
Sui, bh ôeo`k pbrskegdb fbmbeoek mbe`okegck be Bh Aknnot.>3 Hg `ghofo`g cb «fgmksg¹ y
«bxtrgkrcoegrog¹, gcbmçs cb ro`g, y Jgecghf ghucb g su mbmkrog pgrg ke`bcbr su pbrcðe
g Nohnk b oevkhu`rgrhb be su gvbeturg (sb supkeb qub su bspírotu gvbeturbrk prkvbecríg cb
bhhg), pbrk ek sb hg vubhvb g mbe`okegr.
Re mgjeífo`k bdbmphk cb pbrskegdb fbmbeoek ghbdgck cb hg ocbghozg`oðe bs Hknbhog
Pg`kvohhg-Nkhsðe, hg getopçto`g promg cb Nohnk uyk ekmnrb ek sb mbe`okeg be Bh Aknnot ,
g pbsgr cb bstgr g puetk cb mucgrsb g Nkhsðe @brrgck `ugeck su hbjítomk cub÷k,
cb`hgrgck hbjghmbetb mubrtk trgs ue g÷k cb gusbe`og, rbjrbsg cb Brbnkr. Srgs ekmnrgr g
Frkck su hbjítomk abrbcbrk, pobrcb hg kpkrtueocgc cb ag`brsb `ke hg prkpobcgc cbspuïs
cb hg pgrtocg cb Nohnk be Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks. Frkck ag cb sg`grhg g bmpudkebs cb hg
`gsg mobetrgs rb`upbrgng vghoksks kndbtks qub sb hhbvgng mbtocks be bh pgrgjugs, mçs
>< «`uyk puetk cb vostg quosb prbsbrvgr sknrb tkcg ktrg `ksg.¹ SKHIOBE, D.^.^.4 Gpïeco`bs.Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk 7??>, 761.
>7 @G^\BESB^, Hbttbrs kp. `ot., >?0->?6. Be co`ag `grtg sb mbe`okege vgrogs mgtrkegs aknnotsqub fubrke `gnbzgs cb sus `gsgs pbrk qub ek gpgrb`be be sus rbhgtks4 Hgurg Nkhsðe y Hghog Sui hg Jrgecb.
>> SKHIOBE, D.^.^.4 Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks. Ngr`bhkeg4 @ír`uhk cb Hb`tkrbs 7?16, 67.>0 Hks aknnots pkeíge g sus aodgs ekmnrbs cb fhkrbs k dkygs. SKHIOBE Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot.,761.>3 Aumparby @grpbetbr knsbrvð somohotucbs betrb bstg y hg mgcrb cbh prkpok Skhiobe, Mgnbh
Puffobhc, ueg oefhube`og fuecgmbetgh be su vocg. Fub su prombrg prkfbskrg y quobe hb ompuhsð bh gmkr pkrbh conudk, hks ocokmgs, hks ubetks cb agcgs, hg egturghbzg y su fb rbhojoksg. @G^\BESB^, Nokjrgfíg kp.`ot., 7?2 y 7?6.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 6/21
tgrcb cb agnbr bxojock kmprkngr hg hbjghocgc cbh tbstgmbetk cb Nohnk>2. Poe bmngrjk, hg
eb`bsocgc cb ghbdgr bh Geohhk cb Hg @kmgr`g, knhojg g Frkck g vbecbrhbs hg `gsg g ngdk
`kstb. Cbscb bhhg, su aodk `kmobezg hks trgtks `ke Tgrquoek qub tbrmoege pkr cbvgstgr hg
rbjoðe agstg bh rbjrbsk cb hks aïrkbs y su bxpuhsoðe.
G su mubrtb, Hknbhog mubstrg bh ôeo`k `kmpkrtgmobetk pksotovk y cbsoetbrbsgck
cb tkcg su trgyb`tkrog, gpgrtb cbh befrbetgmobetk `ke hks rufogebs qub hg hhbvg gh be`obrrk4
hbjg sus nobebs g Frkck pgrg qub hks bmphbb be gyucgr g hks aknnots qub pbrcobrke su
akjgr.>6 Be hgs bs`gsgs híebgs qub cbco`g g bstb pbrskegdb, Skhiobe, ek skhk hk ag
`grg`tbrozgck pbrfb`tgmbetb, g trgvïs cb su `kmpkrtgmobetk y cb hgs kpoeokebs cb hks
prktgjkeostgs, soek qub ag sock gpgz cb mkstrgr su bvkhu`oðe.
Reg oecovocughocgc mçs pksotovg hg rbprbsbetg ^ksotg @ktk, hg aodg cbh jrgedbrk ghqub Pgm g`ucb g pbcor gyucg `ugeck rbjrbsge g Hg @kmgr`g. Hk prombrk qub hb co`b bs
qub ag bstgck bspbrçeckhb cbscb hg promgvbrg, qub bstç muy jugpk y qub vubhvg `ugeck
g`gnbe `ke hks ngecocks. Hg omprbsoðe bs qub bhhg bs hg qub hhbvg hg oeo`ogtovg be hg
rbhg`oðe y qub oe`husk mubstrg ueg obrtg prosg4 «‘¡_ nubek, yg ags pbrcock ue g÷k! »\grg
quï bspbrgr mçs;”¹>:. Srgs bh mgtromkeok, gmnks b oestghge be Nkhsðe @brrgck, ckecb sb
qubcge cbspuïs cb hg pgrtocg cb Frkck, y ske pgcrbs cb trb`b aodks.
Cb eubvk tbebmks ue pbrskegdb g``bskrok qub, pbrfb`tgmbetb, pkcríg ek agnbrtbeock eoejôe cbtghhb gpgrtb cbh ekmnrb soe qub bh grjumbetk sb rbsoetobsb hk mçs míeomk.
Poe bmngrjk, be nrbvbs poe`bhgcgs coghðjo`gs, Skhiobe eks nroecg hg omgjbe cb ueg dkvbe
aknnot ghbjrb, begmkrgcg y `ke jgegs cb `gsgrsb.
@kek`bmks tgmnoïe g hg aodg mgykr cb Pgm y ^ksg, Bhgekr, qub hhbjg g sbr
cke`bhhg cb akekr cb hg rboeg Grwbe, ue jrge akekr pgrg ue aknnot. Gcbmçs bs bhhg, y ek
ghjuek cb sus abrmgeks vgrkebs, hg ustkcog cbh Honrk ^kdk, hg rðeo`g cb Nohnk, Frkck y
Pgm, trgs hg pgrtocg cb su pgcrb g Vghoekr g hg mubrtb cb ^ksg>1.
\kr tgetk, eo hg bxpho`g`oðe cb sus `kstumnrbs fgmohogrbs cb bstg rgzg pkr pgrtb cb
Skhiobe, eo hks bdbmphks mbe`okegcks, sujobrbe cb eoejôe mkck moskjoeog k
pgtrogr`ghosmk. Hks aknnots, mgs`uhoeks y fbmbeoeks, ske `rogturgs trgequohgs qub
cosfrutge `ke sus vocgs gpg`onhbs y hks phg`brbs sbe`ohhks, `ke ghjueg bx`bp`oðe `kmk
>2SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp. `ot., 3:.
>6 Oníc., 7<:6>: Oníc., 7<1<.>1 SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot.,773.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 7/21
Nohnk, qub, rb`krcbmks, abrbcg bstk cb su mgcrb y ek cb su pgcrb. Skcgs hgs aknnots qub
eks mubstrge ske `grg`tbrbs fubrtbs>?, `ke sus prkpogs oequobtucbs b oetbrbsbs cbetrk cb
hgs `grg`tbrísto`gs prkpogs cb su pubnhk.
>. Hgs begegs
^bspb`tk g hg prbsbe`og fbmbeoeg be hg sk`obcgc cb hks begeks, agy oe`husk mbeks
rbfbrbe`ogs qub g hgs bets0<. Hgs ôeo`gs oefkrmg`okebs sb be`ubetrge be bh Gpïeco`b G y
bh Pohmgrohhoke, gtronuocgs g Jomho, pbrk, `kmk sb÷ghg @arostkpabr Skhiobe,07bxostbe
cos`rbpge`ogs betrb hgs vbrsokebs cb ïpk`gs cofbrbetbs sknrb so tbeíge k ek ngrng y so
pkcíge sbr knhojgcgs g `gsgrsb. Pke pk`gs, mbeks cb ue tbr`ok qub hks vgrkebs, y sb÷ghg
qub gpbegs sb hgs mbe`okeg be hgs `rkekhkjígs. Hg ôeo`g `kek`ocg sbríg Cís, abrmgeg cb
Sakroe y mgcrb cb Foho y Ioho be Bh Aknnot .
\kr tgetk, hk ôeo`k qub sb pubcb gformgr g `obe`og `obrtg, bs hg tktgh gusbe`og cb
oefkrmg`oðe sknrb hgs begegs cb hg Sobrrg Mbcog, hk qub be`gdgríg `ke bh trgco`okegh
abrmbtosmk cbh pubnhk cb Curoe qub eo tge soquobrg rbvbhgnge sus vbrcgcbrks ekmnrbs0>.
Hks `rkeostgs aknnots ek pkcríge agnbr cbdgck `kestge`og cb hk qub cbs`kek`íge.
0. Hgs aumgegs
Cbnock g hg yg mbe`okegcg fk`ghozg`oðe cbh rbhgtk cbscb bh puetk cb vostg cb hks
mbcogeks, tgmpk`k gpgrb`be cbmgsogcks bdbmphks cb mudbrbs. Ek knstgetb, hg
pgrhge`aoeg Okrbta cb Hgs @gsgs cb @urg`oðe cb Jkeckr rbsuhtg pgrto`uhgrmbetb
sompçto`g, gcbmçs cb sbr hg prombrg be rb`kek`br bh rbtkrek cbh rby pkr su gpg`ocgc pgrg
sgegr, rumkr qub rçpocgmbetb bxtobecb4 «- ¡Bh rby! »Hk agnïos kíck; »Wuï codb yk; Hgs
mgeks cb ue urgckr, bsk codb. –_ prketk hg ekto`og cb qub bh rby sb be`ketrgng be vbrcgc
>? @ke hg pksonhb bx`bp`oðe cb hg Pb÷krg Mgjjkt y cb hg mgcrb cb ^ksg, cb hgs qub ek pkcbmksgformgr egcg, cgcg hg bs`gsbz cb oefkrmg`oðe sknrb bhhgs.
0< Hk pk`k qub `kek`bmks cb hgs bets-mudbrbs bs g trgvïs cb Nçrnkh pbrk eo ïh mosmk rb`ubrcg hksufo`obetb kmk pgrg cbs`ronorhgs. Hks justks cofbrbetbs hbs hhbvge g sbpgrgrsb4 bhhgs prbforobrke bstgnhb`brsby `uhtovgr, pkr hk qub ske akergcgs pkr hks akmnrbs, mobetrgs qub hks mg`aks `ketoeôge `ke ueg vocg mçssghvgdb y brrgetb, vosotçeckhgs cb vbz be `ugeck. Poe bmngrjk, gh rbjrbsgr ue cíg, be`ketrgrke hks `gmpksgrrgsgcks, hgs bets cbsgpgrb`ocgs y, cbscb betke`bs eue`g vkhvobrke g vbrhgs. Bh ôeo`k ekmnrb fbmbeoekcbh qub tbebmks ekto`og bs Fomnrbtaoh, hg gmgcg cb Nçrnkh. SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 311-3?<.
07 SKHIOBE, @.4 Hg Aostkrog cb Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks. OOO. Hks pubnhks cb hg tobrrg mbcog Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><<>, 007. 0> SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot.,762.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 8/21
betrb bhhks, y qub hubjk cb hg jubrrg trgíg hg `urg`oðe, sghoð cb hg @gsg y `krroð pkr tkcg hg
`oucgc.¹00
Sbebmks mbe`okebs, gcbmçs, cbh ekmnrb y ghjôe cbtghhb cb mu`ags ktrgs,
bspb`oghmbetb hgs mgcrbs y bspksgs cb ktrks pbrskegdbs4 Johrgbe, hg sufrocg mgcrb cbGrgjkre9 Ovkrwbe, mgcrb cb ïstg, `uyg `hgrovocbe`og pksonohotg bh eg`omobetk cbh rby
Bhbssgr9 Bhfaohc, hg mudbr cb Saïkcbe, mubrtg cb pgrtk9 hg cb Cbebtakr, Foecuohgs cb Ckh
Gmrkta,…
Skcgs hgs getbrokrmbetb sb÷ghgcgs be`gdgríge cbetrk cb hks rkhbs trgco`okeghbs cb
befbrmbrg, bspksg y mgcrb y, pkr tgetk, sorvbe `kmk grjumbetk cb hg `ríto`g fbmoeostg.
Ek knstgetb, `rbk qub sbríg ompksonhb `kefojurgr ue mueck vbrksímoh soe qub aunobsb
mudbrbs qub g`tugsbe cbetrk cb bsks pgpbhbs.
\brk hg mçs cbstg`gcg y cbsgrrkhhgcg cb betrb hgs aumgegs bs, soe cucg, Ïkwye cb
^kage. Cbscb hg prombrg cbs`rop`oðe cbh pbrskegdb, gpgrb`b `kmk ueg cke`bhhg qub ag
bstgck gh `uocgck cb su ge`ogek tík. Pb cbs`ronb `kmk nbhhg y krjuhhksg, cbho`gcg pbrk
oefhbxonhb, bsnbhtg pbrk fubrtb9 gtronutks abrbcgcks cb su gnubhg Mkrwbe cb Hkssgreg`a
hhgmgcg «^bsphgeckr cbh G`brk¹03.
@kefkrmb gvgezg hg aostkrog vgmks kek`obeck su `grç`tbr g trgvïs cb sus prkpogs
rbfhbxokebs y cb hg kpoeoðe qub cb bhhg tobebe hks cbmçs pbrskegdbs. Ïkwye, pbsb gbe`ketrgrsb be ueg pkso`oðe sb`uecgrog, k`upg ue hujgr ompkrtgetb g hks kdks cb sus
`kmpgtroktgs qub hg bhojbe `kmk corojbetb4 «Ek ab ekmnrgck g Ïkmbr ‐ codk Açmg -. _
ek bs bh ôhtomk. Bstç Ïkwye, aodg cb Ïkmuec, hg abrmgeg cb Ïkmbr. Bs vghobetb y cb
`krgzðe mgjeçeomk. Skcks hg gmge. Wub sbg bhhg bh Pb÷kr cb Bkrhoejgs be eubstrg
gusbe`og.¹02
G pbsgr cb sbr, soe cucg ghjueg, ue jrge akekr y ueg mubstrg cb bstomg y kefogezg
cb su jbetb, bstk ek hb sgtosfg`b yg qub su cbsbk, fuecgck be su `rb`omobetk be uegsk`obcgc gr`go`g y nbho`ksg, `kmk vbmks qub bs ^kage, bs or g hg jubrrg y hkjrgr jrgecbs
agzg÷gs. Ïkwye ek tbmb hg ngtghhg eo hg mubrtb soek bh `gutovbrok, bh qubcgrsb rbhbjgcg gh
akjgr pkr knhojg`oðe, pkr agnbr eg`ock mudbr, yg qub su `krgdb pubcb bquopgrgrsb gh cb
`ughquobr akmnrb4 «»Pobmprb tbecrï yk qub qubcgrmb be `gsg `ugeck hks `gnghhbrks
00 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., ?77.03 SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot., :<.02 SKHIOBE Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 110-113.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 9/21
pgrtbe, cbco`gcg g pbqub÷ks mbebstbrbs mobetrgs bhhks `kequostge hg jhkrog, pgrg qub gh
rbjrbsgr be`ubetrbe hb`ak y ghombetk;¹06
Abmks cb rb`krcgr qub Ïkwye ek sgnb gnskhutgmbetb egcg cb hg mosoðe cb
cbstruor bh Geohhk y su vosoðe cb hg jubrrg bstç muy keco`okegcg pkr bh gmnobetb cbrrktostg
qub prkvk`ge be Mbcusbhc hgs oetrojgs cb Hbejug cb Pbrpobetb. Bhhg `rbb qub ek agy
vo`tkrog pksonhb y, pkr tgetk, bs prbfbronhb mkror be bh `gmpk cb ngtghhg `kmngtobeck, g
hgejuocb`br bspbrgeck hgs ekto`ogs cb hg mubrtb cb sus sbrbs qubrocks 0: agstg qub,
foeghmbetb hg skmnrg cb Pgurke hhbjub agstg ghhí4 «Skcgs vubstrgs pghgnrgs sojeofo`ge ueg
skhg `ksg4 Brbs mudbr, y tu mosoðe bstç be bh akjgr. Poe bmngrjk, `ugeck hks akmnrbs
agyge mubrtk ke akekr be hg ngtghhg, sb tb pbrmotorç qubmgr hg `gsg b oemkhgrtb ke bhhg,
pubstk qub yg ek hg eb`bsotgrçe.¹01
Getb hg ebjgtovg cb sus pgrobetbs, y cb Grgjkre, pbrskegdb pkr bh qub sobetb ueg
bekrmb fgs`oeg`oðe0?, cb pbrmotorhb or g hu`agr, cb`ocb cosfrgzgrsb cb jubrrbrk y
g`kmpg÷gr g hg aubstb cb rkaorrom g hks @gmpks cbh \bhbeekr. Ghhí sb befrbetg `ke bh
hujgrtbeobetb cb Pgurke, bh pkcbrksk ^by Nrudk cb Gejmgr, Pb÷kr cb hks Eîzjuh y hk
cbrrktg3<. \brk, bsb «eoejôe akmnrb vovobetb¹37 puck agnbr sock ue aknnot, ue begek b
oe`husk ue bhfk. Poe bmngrjk, bs Ïkwye hg qub vbe`b gh bebmojk mçs pkcbrksk cb hks qub
g`ucbe g hg ngtghhg (cgck qub Pgurke ek hk ag`b). \kr tgetk, Skhiobe kevobrtb g ueg mudbr
be bh aïrkb mçs mbrotkrok cb hg Jubrrg cbh Geohhk.
Hg gckp`oðe cbh ekmnrb Cbreabhm3> bs oetbrprbtgcg kmk ueg `ubstoðe cb jïebrk
pkr Orbeb Pgez Ghkesk4 «Ïkwye ek sðhk sb vostb cb gnghhbrk soek qub gckptg hg ocbetocgc
cb uek ugeck sb ag`b hhgmgr Cbreabhm.¹ 30 Ek knstgetb, rbk qub be rbghocgc sb trgtg cb
uek cb hks eumbrksks `gsks cb pkhoekmgsog `gnghhbrbs`g qub sb cge be Bh Pb÷kr cb hks
06 Oníc., 1>7.0:
Ktrk fg`tkr ompkrtgetb qub oefhuyb be bh `grç`tbr cb Ïkwye bs hg mubrtb cb su pgcrb Ïkmuec pbrsojuobeck kr`ks y gh pk`k hg cb su mgcrb Saïkcwye cb trostbzg. SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot.,:<.01 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 1>70? Pus sbetomobetks ske pbrfb`tgmbetb cbfoeocks pkr Fgrgmor4 «Cbsbgngos bh gmkr cbh Pb÷kr
Grgjkre. \ubs brg eknhb y pkcbrksk, y qubrígos hg fgmg y hg jhkrog4 bhbvgrks pkr be`omg cb hgs `ksgsmbzquoegs qub sb grrgstrge sknrb hg tobrrg. _ kmk ue jrge gpotçe g ue dkvbe skhcgck, ks pgrb`oð gcmorgnhb.\krqub hk bs, ue Pb÷kr betrb hks akmnrbs, y bh mçs jrgecb cb hks qub aky bxostbe. \brk `ugeck sðhkrb`onostbos cb ïh `kmprbesoðe y pobcgc, betke`bs yg ek quosostbos eoejueg ktrg `ksg, sghvk ueg mubrtbjhkroksg be bh `kmngtb.¹ Oníc., 7<76.
3< ^bcbfoeobeck hg prkfb`íg cb M`Nbta qub eue`g `kevbe`oð g Skhiobe.37 Oníc., 1103> Cbreb sojeofo`g k`uhtk, sb`rbtk. SKHIOBE, @.4 Hg Aostkrog cb Bh Pb÷kr cb hks Geohhks. OOO. Hg
jubrrg cbh Geohhk. Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><<>, 3>7.
30 PGET GHKEPK, O4 «»Wuobe mgtð gh rby nrudk; @kmk Cbreabhm sb quotg bh `gs`k y Ïkwye sbrb`ke`ohog `ke su jïebrk¹ be Besgyks sknrb `obe`og fo``oðe y hotbrgturg fgetçsto`g. Mgcroc4 Gsk`og`oðe`uhturgh Qgtgfo y Reovbrsocgc @grhks OOO, ><7<, 32?.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 10/21
Geohhks, bspb`oghmbetb be Grgjkre y Jgecghf . Be hks honrks cb `gnghhbrígs y hg ekvbhg
grtôro`g hks `gmnoks cb ekmnrb knbcb`be g ompkrtgetbs `gmnoks nokjrçfo`ks cb hks
pbrskegdbs. Hg gckp`oðe cb ue cbtbrmoegck sknrbekmnrb knbcb`b g ueg eubvg btgpg
nokjrçfo`g be hg trgyb`tkrog cbh aïrkb, ue su`bsk gmkrksk k pbrskegh oetbrfobrb be hg
prkjrbsoðe cbh oecovocuk y cbtbrmoeg hg bhb` oðe cbh eubvk ghogs.33 _ pkr bsk sb eks co`b
qub «brg Ïkwye y tgmnoïe brg Cbreabhm¹32, bs cb`or, g ue tobmpk hg gprb`ogcg proe`bsg
cb ^kage y bh skhcgck geðeomk cb hg aubstb cbh ^by.
Guequb sghb vo`tkroksg, hkjrgeck gsí mçs jhkrog qub `ughquobr ktrk jubrrbrk be hg
knrg y `kmobezg g sbr hhgmgcg «Pb÷krg cbh Nrgzk Bs`ucgck¹36, bs gh`gezgcg pkr ue
ab`aozk y bstç g puetk cb mkror agstg qub Grgjkre hg `urg. Gh cbspbrtgr, sojub cbsbgeck
hg mubrtb be `kmngtb y soetoïecksb bedguhgcg agstg qub `ke hg cbstru``oðe cbh Geohhk
cbsgpgrb`b hg oefhube`og cb Pgurke y su gmostgc `ke Fgrgmor sb `kevobrtb be gmkr.
Bstb foegh cb Ïkwye ag cgck pob g covbrsgs oetbrprbtg`okebs. Mu`aks age qubrock
vbr be su mgtromkeok `ke Fgrgmor y su cbsbk cb gngeckegr hg jubrrg ue `gstojk pkr pgrtb
cb Skhiobe. Pbjôe bstg pbrspb`tovg, bh gutkr bs`grmbetgríg g Ïkwye pkr su ksgcíg cb
qubrbr `kevbrtorsb be `gnghhbrk y pkr bhhk tbrmoeg rbeue`ogeck g su cbsbk pgrg vovor ueg
vocg pg`ífo`g kmk urgecbrg.
\grto`uhgrmbetb, mb rbsuhtg ue tgetk cofí`oh oetbrprbtgr kmk ue `krrb`tovk bh ab`ak
cb `gsgrsb `ke ue pbrskegdb `grg`tbrozgck tge pksotovgmbetb, `ke bh qub sb `kmpbebtrg g
hg pbrfb``oðe (be pghgnrgs cbh prkpok gutkr 3:), y trgs bh ôeo`k prk`bsk cb begmkrgmobetk
qub sb cbtghhg, `ke bs`begs cb jrge tbreurg y cbho`gcbzg, gusbetbs be hgs cbmçs pgrbdgs
qub sb fkrmge be hg knrg. G mo duo`ok, Fgrgmor y Ïkwye bdbmphofo`ge bh trgco`okegh «foegh
fbhoz¹ cb hks ubetks cb agcgs, kmk \ríe`opbs cb Otaohobe31, bspb`oghmbetb gh kmpgrgrhk
`ke bh gsk cb Grwbe. G hg proe`bsg bhfg hb bspbrg ueg trgjbcog cb trostbzg y skhbcgc kmk
«prbmok¹ pkr agnbr `umphock g hg pbrfb``oðe `ke su rkh pgsovk cb cgmg cbh gmkr `krtïs4
«\brk Grwbe agníg bhbjock sbr ueg mudbr mkrtgh, y su cbstoek ek quosk soe bmngrjk qub
33 PGHBP CGPÍ, B.D.4 Hg gvbeturg `gnghhbrbs`g4 Bpkpbyg y mgrgvohhgs. Egvgrrg4 @betrk cbBstucoks @brvgetoeks ><<3, 07.
32 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 113.36 SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot., :<.3: Skhiobe bxpho`g cb fkrmg mgjostrgh hg egturghbzg cb su rbhg`oðe be hg grtg >33, be @G^\BESB^,
Hbttbrs kp. `ot.,0>0-0>3.31 SKHIOBE, @, \ubnhks kp.`ot., >6< g÷gcb qub «vovoð be ueg abrmksg `gsg eubvg be hgs @khoegscb Bmye Grebe, `uyks dgrcoebs, cosb÷gcks pkr Hbjkhgs bh bhfk, jkzgnge cb jrge rbekmnrb¹.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 11/21
murobsb getbs cb agnbr pbrcock tkck hk qub agníg jgegck. (…) Gôe ek bstgng `gesgcg cb
hks cígs y gakrg sbetíg bh sgnkr gmgrjk cb hg mkrtghocgc qub bhhg mosmg agníg bhbjock.¹3?
Cb ab`ak, Ïkwye sí qub `kmbtb ueg trgesjrbsoðe ompkrtgetb, ek pkr `ubstokebs
cb jïebrk soek be ghjk cb mgykr gh`ge`b, cgck qub gngeckeg bh ompkrtgetb pubstk qub sb
hb agníg gsojegck gh frbetb cbh jknobrek cb ^kage. Ompuhsovgmbetb, cbdg g su pubnhk soe
ue juíg be hks tbrronhbs mkmbetks cb jubrrg qub bstçe vovobeck, pbesgeck skhk be
sgtosfg`br sus gesogs cb jhkrog be bh `kmngtb2<. _ gue `ke tkck, su «`gstojk¹ bs sknrbvovor
g hg ngtghhg trgs agnbr cbrrktgck gh by Nrudk, begmkrgrsb, gsgrsb y vovor fbhoz be tobmpks
cb pgz. 27 Reg omgjbe mçs gprkpogcg pgrg `gstojgr ueg trgesjrbsoðe cbh rkh cb jïebrk
pkcríg sbr qub aunobsb mubrtk soe agnbr rbghozgck eoejueg agzg÷g be bh `kmngtb.
\kr tgetk, hk qub eks be`ketrgmks be rbghocgc bs qub, be `ketrg cb quobebs
grjumbetge hg fghtg cb cbsgrrkhhk y bvkhu`oðe cb hks pbrskegdbs be hg knrg cb Skhiobe,
abmks sock tbstojks cbh `gmnok be Ïkwye g trgvïs cb hgs bxpbrobe`ogs votghbs qub
`kmpgrtomks ke bhhg. @ugeck cb`ocb gckptgr hg urg`oðe kmk fkrmg cb vocg ek hk ag`b
pkrqub sbg ueg mudbr y ek pubcg cbco`grsb g ktrg `ksg, cgck qub yg ag cbmkstrgck, g hks
cbmçs y g sí mosmg, hk `ketrgrok, soek pkrqub hk cb`ocb gsí vkhuetgrogmbetb trgs `kek`br
g Fgrgmor y `kmprbecbr qub hg jubrrg bs ue mbcok y ek ue foe2>4 «¡Hg Pkmnrg ag
cbsgpgrb`ock! ¡_g eue`g mçs vkhvbrï g sbr ueg cke`bhhg jubrrbrg, eo rovghozgrï `ke hks
jrgecbs gnghhbrks, eo jkzgrï tge sðhk ke getks cb mgtgezg! Pbrï ueg @urgckrg, y gmgrï
tkck `ugetk `rb`b, tkck hk qub ek bs çrock.¹20
Cos`rbpk tgmnoïe rgco`ghmbetb cb hg kpoeoðe cb Igtabroeb Abssbr qub hk oetbrprbtg
`kmk bh rbstgnhb`omobetk cbh rkh cb jïebrk cb hg Sobrrg Mbcog4 «rbdb`t tab bxostbe`b kf
3? SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 7<?2. Poe bmngrjk, g Hôaobe, g hg qub tgetk sb pgrb`b y `ke hg qub`kmpgrtb cbstoek, sb hb prbmog su `kmpkrtgmobetk g`tovk `ke ueg eubvg vocg gh hgck cb su gmgck.SKHIOBE, Pohmgrohhoke kp. `ot., >7?->><.
2<
Cb ab`ak, sb hb pocb hk mosmk qub g Bmbhcor «hg cb `krgzðe voroh¹, bspksg cb Ngrgaor y mgcrbcb Nbrbe, qub qubríg qubcgrsb `ke su mgrock, qub sb ebjgng g rbtorgrsb be hg oevgsoðe cb Ckrtakeoke, pbrkqub, foeghmbetb, g``bcb g krjgeozgr hg bvg`ug`oðe cb hgs mudbrbs y hks eo÷ks gh Nksqub cb Nrïtaoh be hg\rombrg Bcgc. SKHIOBE, D.^.^.4 Bh Pohmgrohhoke. Ngr`bhkeg4 @ír`uhk cb hb`tkrbs 7?1:, 717 y 71:.
27Be ue proe`opok, Skhiobe phgebð qub Ïkwye sb `gsgrg `ke Grgjkre pbrk `gmnoð cb kpoeoðe pkrqub Grgjkre hb pgrb`íg «cbmgsogck vobdk, sb÷krogh y bstorgck¹ pgrg bhhg. Sgmnoïe `kesocbrð hg pksonohocgc cb qub Ïkwye fubrg hg abrmgeg jbmbhg cb Ïkmuec, y qub murobsb «pgrg vbejgr k sghvgr gSaïkcbe¹ y qub Grgjkre, dgmçs sb `gsgrg trgs su mubrtb. Be SKHIOBE, @4 Hg Aostkrog cb Bh Pb÷kr cb hks
Geohhks. OO. Hg trgo`oðe cb Osbejgrc . Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><<>, 270, 2>0 y 2>2 y Jubrrg kp.`ot., >?3->?2y 3<?.
2> «Bh `gmnok cb Ïkwye betrg÷g bh gngeckek cb ue `ðcojk cb akekr qub Skhiobe `kesocbrgnggeto`ugck ‐ bh bdbmphofo`gck pkr hks Doebtbs cb kage ‐ y hg eb`bsocgc cb gmnogrhk pkr uek mçs skfosto`gck,bh qub rbprbsbetge hks akmnrbs cb Jkeckr quobebs, `kmk Fgrgmor, ske `kes`obetb cb qub, so nobe hg jubrrg
bs `ke cbmgsogcg frb`ube`og bh ôeo`k mïtkck cb `kesbjuor ueg pgz pkstbrokr, sobmprb bs ueg mbcocgcbsgjrgcgnhb. Hg eubvg Ïkwye gnrgzg bstb `ðcojk abrko`k.¹ @G^^BSB^K, M4 kp.`ot., 777.20 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 7<76.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 12/21
wkrioej mktabrs oe fgvkr kf trkpay wovbs¹23. G mo mkck cb betbecbr, Skhiobe cbdg muy
`hgrk bh rbspbtk qub sb hb tbeíg g Ïkwye getbs y cbspuïs cb hg `ketobecg. Be eoejôe
mkmbetk sb hg gmkebstg k `gstojg eo pkr fghtgr g su cbnbr eo pkr cbsknbcb`br g su rby,
mçs nobe gh `ketrgrok, sb hg `kesocbrg ueg jrge abrkíeg4 «pubs hgs agzg÷gs cb Ïkwye hg
age pubstk betrb hgs rboegs cb jrge rbekmnrb¹22.
Pu `gmnok cb pbrspb`tovg `koe`ocb `ke hg vosoðe cbh gutkr cb hg jubrrg, bxprbsgck
tgmnoïe g trgvïs cb pbrskegdbs mgs`uhoeks, `kmk Fgrgmor 26, ek pkr sbxosmk. Pke hks
kr`ks hks qub cosfrutge `ke hks befrbetgmobetks y hg cbstru``oðe. Hg supbrg`oðe cbh
cbsçeomk prkvk`gck pkr hgs oetrojgs cb Jromg, bh `ketg`tk `ke sk`obcgcbs mçs
bvkhu`okegcgs qub hg rkaorrom, hg vosoðe cb hg rbghocgc cb hg hu`ag, bh begmkrgmobetk cb
Fgrgmor y hg cbsgpgro`oðe cb hg oefhube`og cb Pgurke `rbk qub ske pbsk sufo`obetb pgrg
bxpho`gr ue `gmnok be su fkrmg cb pbesgr y be hg phgeofo`g`oðe cb su eubvg vocg2:.
3. Hgs bhfgs
Ghjueks `ríto`ks age hgmbetgck bh pgpbh pgsovk dujgck pkr Grwbe be hg aostkrog
cbh Geohhk, sknrb tkck gh `kmpgrçrsbhg `ke Hôtaobe21, qub hhbjg getb bh trkek cb Mkrjkta
y rb`upbrg bh Pohmgroh, y `ke hg qub `kmpgrtb hg rbeue`og g hg oemkrtghocgc pgrg ueorsb g
ue akmnrb mkrtgh2?. \brk Skhiobe ek tobeb eoejueg kndb`oðe be sotugr g ueg mudbr be bh
23 C^KRS, kp.`ot.,76?.22 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., ?7>.26 «\brk yk ek mgtk pkr eb`bsocgc eo g akmnrb eo g nbstog, y `ugeck bs eb`bsgrok ek hk agjk `ke
ghbjríg.¹ Oníc., 6?<.2: _ ek ueg «ckmg¹, cb ab`ak `rbk qub Skhiobe sb ríb cb bsb topk cb `ke`bptks g trgvïs cb ueg
nrkmg cb hg prkpog Ïkwye4 «¡Ghhç vg ue Pb÷kr qub ag ckmgck g ueg cke`bhhg jubrrbrg cbh Ekrtb!¹ Oníc., 7<76. Sgmnoïe cbdg muy hgrk qub bs bhhg hg qub cb`ocb honrbmbetb gsgrsb4 «¡Fgrgmor, Pbebs`gh cb Jðeckry \ríe`opb cb Otaohobe pocb hg mgek cb Ïkwye Cgmg cb ^kage, y bhhg sb hg `ke`bcb cb nube jrgck!¹ Oníc.,
7<>1-7<>?.21 Be Bh Pohmgrohhoke, Hu`obe b Ocroh, gmngs ske bhfgs y bspksgs cb mkrtghbs. Ek skhk tobebe pgpbhbsompkrtgetbs y bstçe cbs`rotgs `kmk nbhhgs cgmgs soek qub gcbmçs, cbmubstrge jrge oejbeok b oevbetovg yske pobzgs `hgvb be hks rbhgtks be qub sb oesbrtge. Hu`obe hkjrg auor cb hg vojohge`og ompubstg pkr su pgcrb,rbs`gtgr g Nbrbe, `khgnkrgr cb`osovgmbetb be hg rb`upbrg`oðe cbh Pohmgroh cb hg `krkeg cb Mkrjkta y`kevbe`br g Mgecks cb qub hb pbrmotg g Nbrbe rbjrbsgr cb betrb hks mubrtks. Mobetrgs qub Ocroh tobeb bhcke cb hg hgrovocbe`og mgykr cb su pubnhk y sus g`brtgcks kesbdks ske sbjuocks gh pob cb hg hbtrg pkr Sukr,su bspksk. Gcbmçs hkjrg cbfbecbrsb ke u÷gs y cobetbs y sghvgr g su aodk cb Mbjhoe curgetb bh gsghtk cb hgsaubstbs cb Mbhikr g Jkeckhoe. Bhwoej, mgcrb cb Bhrkec y gnubhg cb Grwbe, tgmnoïe tobeb ue pgpbh abrko`kgh hgezgrsb gh mgr pgrg sghvgr bh Pohmgroh y, trgs rbueorsb `ke su mgrock Bãrbecoh hhbjg g Vghoekr. Ghhígprbecoð bh hbejugdb cb hgs gvbs y g vkhgr.
2? Hôtaobe bs `hgrgmbetb supbrokr g Nbrbe. Sobeb ueg nbhhbzg sknrbegturgh, oemkrtghocgc y pkcbrbsmçjo`ks. Pke sus agnohocgcbs hgs qub hks sghvge g gmnks. Pojeofo`gtovgmbetb be hgs tumngs cb D.^.^. y su
bspksg Bcota bstçe jrgngcks Nbrbe y Hôtaobe pkr cbsbk bxprbsk cbh bs`rotkr (@grtg 03< be @G^\BESB^ Hbttbrs kp.`ot., 3><), `ke hks qub sb ocbetofo`gng. Ek cbdg cb sbr skrprbecbetb qub hks `ríto`ks fbmoeostgs ekagyge rbpgrgck be hk rbvbhgckr cb bstk.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 13/21
`krgzðe cb hg ngtghhg, kmk mubstrg hg aostkrog cb Bkwye6<. Grwbe ketoeôg be ovbecbh
`kmk pgrtb cbh phge `kmphbtk cbh gutkr, bhhg bs hg mudbr qub cbnb pbrmgeb`br be `gsg
mobetrgs su gmgetb gsumb hks robsjks cb hg vocg y sus ghbjrígs be ueg jubrrg cb hg `ugh
pgrb`b muy omprkngnhb qub sknrbvovg. Mubstrg hg gejustog cb knsbrvgr y bspbrgr,
rbspkecobeck gh mkcbhk cb cgmg cb hgs `gnghhbrígs y g ueg `ubstoðe nokjrçfo`g 67. Ek
knstgetb, tkmg sus prkpogs cb`osokebs, gh befrbetgrsb g hks cbsbks cb su pgcrb, bhbjor hg
mkrtghocgc y qubcgrsb be hujgr cb pgrtor `ke bh rbstk cb su fgmohog g Vghoekr.
Hg cgmg prktgjkeostg cb hks honrks cb `gnghhbrígs subhb sbr `gso sobmprb ueg
oefgetg k proe`bsg cb nbhhbzg bxtrbmg, ue sbr `gso covoek6>, `kmk Grwbe4 «‘Aodk mík”
codk Johrgbe, ‘tu gmno`oðe bs ghtg, agstg pgrg bh cbs`becobetb cb eumbrksks bybs. \krqub
bstg cgmg bs hg mçs eknhb y hg mçs abrmksg qub aky posg hg tobrrg.”¹60
Hg ketbmphg`oðe cb bstg abrmksurg bs bh vbaí`uhk gcb`ugck pgrg qub bh gnghhbrk
begmkrgck g``bcg g hg vortuc, cb gaí qub ugetk mçs ocího`k sbg bh kndbtk gmgck, «mçs sb
besghzg hg eknhbzg y bh bspírotu cbh akmnrb qub gmg¹63. \kr bhhk bh gtrg`tovk físo`k sb
`kevobrtb be mktovk betrgh cb hgs cbs`rop`okebs fbmbeoegs62, tgmnoïe fgvkrb`ocgs pkr su
ghtg bxtrg``oðe sk`ogh, sus ro`gs dkygs y pboegcks4
6< Be hks rbhgtks cb hks \rombrks Cígs, uek cb hks trbs pubnhks qub kmpkebe hks Gtgeo, hks \rombrksAkmnrbs, bs bh cb Aghbta, cbekmoegck pkr su `gpotgeg, qub pksbíg ueg jugrcog cb jubrrbrgs sbhb`tgs y qubsb grg`tbrozgng pkr su pbro`og kmk hu`agckrbs, cb gmnks sbxks, bspb`oghmbetb be hks nksqubs. SKHIOBE,@. \ubnhks kp.`ot., 02?.
67 Bstgnhb`br bh pgrghbhosmk cbh sufromobetk cb Bcota curgetb hg ïpk`g be qub bstuvobrke sbpgrgcks.@grtg 30 be @G^\BESB^ Hbttbrs kp.`ot., 31-20.
6> HR@ÍG MBDÍGP, D.M. y PGHBP CGPÍ, B.D.4 Honrks cb `gnghhbrígs `gstbhhgeks (sojhks QVO y
QVOO), Mgcroc4 Bco`okebs cbh Hgnbroetk ><<1, 7?7. 60 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 7<1?.63 JGP@ÐE-VB^G, B.4 «Hg gmnojøbcgc be bh `ke`bptk cbh gmkr y cb hg mudbr be hg prksg
`gstbhhgeg cbh QV¹ be Nkhbtíe cb hg ^bgh G`gcbmog Bspg÷khg 2?, 7?:?, 732.62 Hg nbhhbzg k fbghcgc físo`g cb hks pbrskegdbs hb pbrmotbe gh hb`tkr oetuor su `gtgcurg mkrgh be
PGHBP CGPÍ, B.D.4 «”Vbr” y ‘morgr” be hks honrks cb gnghhbrígs¹, be Sabsgurus YBstucoks sknrb egrrgtovg`gnghhbrbs`g bspg÷khg cb hks sojhks QVO y QVOO] (23), 0, 7???.attp4//`v`.`brvgetbs.bs/hbejug/tabsgurus/pcf/23/SA[23[<<7[<7:[<.pcf
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 14/21
«Be bh `betrk cb hg mbsg, gpkygcg be hks tgpo`bs qub pbecíge cbh murk, agníg ueg sohhg ngdk ue cksbh y ghhí bstgng sbetgcg ueg abrmksg cgmg, tge pgrb`ocg g Bhrkec, ngdk fkrmgfbmbeoeg, qub ek pkcíg sbr, soek ueg pgrobetb prðxomg. Brg dkvbe y gh mosmk tobmpk ekhk brg, pubs guequb hg bs`gr`ag ek agníg tk`gck hgs trbezgs cb pbhk skmnrík y hks nrgzks nhge`ks y bh rkstrk `hgrk brge tbrsks y soe cbfb`tk y hg huz cb hgs bstrbhhgs hb nrohhgrg behks kdks, jrosbs kmk ueg ek`ab soe eunbs, agníg be bhhg vbrcgcbrg mgdbstgc, y hg morgcgrbvbhgng `kek`omobetk y sgnocuríg, `kmk so aunobrg vostk tkcgs hgs `ksgs qub trgbe hksg÷ks.(…) Hb `unríg hg `gnbzg ueg rbc cb aohks cb phgtg betrbtbdocg `ke pbqub÷gs jbmgscb ue nhge`k rbsphgecb`obetb, pbrk hgs cbho`gcgs vbstocurgs jrosbs ek tbeíge ktrk gckrekqub ue `oeturðe cb akdgs `oe`bhgcgs be phgtg.¹66
Hg vosoðe cb hg cgmg cbsbe`gcbegrç oembcogtgmbetb bh gmkr g prombrg vostg cbh
`gnghhbrk sotuçeckhk frbetb g ueg bxpbrobe`og ekvbcksg pgrg ïh `kmk bs bh gmkr 6:4 « G hg
akrg cbh `rbpôs`uhk, Grgjkre pgsbgng skhotgrok pkr hks nksqubs, `ke bh `krgzðe ghbjrb9 y
`getgng, pkrqub tbeíg mu`ags bspbrgezgs, y pkrqub bh mueck brg nbhhk. _ cb prketk,
mobetrgs gôe `getgng vok ueg cke`bhhg qub `gmoegng pkr ue prgck betrb hks trke`ks nhge`ks cb hks gnbcuhbs9 y sb cbtuvk mgrgvohhgck, `rbybeck agnbrsb bxtrgvogck be ue
sub÷k (…) cbscb gqubh mkmbetk gmð g Grwbe Recðmobh aodg cb Bhrkec.¹61
Ktrk cb hks rgsjks `kmuebs cb hgs cgmgs cb hks honrks cb `gnghhbrígs, qub Grwbe
`kmpgrtb, bs su jrge pgsovocgc, frbetb g hg oe`gesgnhb g`tovocgc y mkvohocgc qub mubstrge
hks `gnghhbrks, sus gmgcgs sb mgetobebe `kmk sbrbs bstçto`ks qub gjugrcge ompg`obetbs
hg hhbjgcg k ekto`ogs4 «Be gusbe`og cb Grgjkre vbhgng pkr ïh cb hbdks `ke bh pbesgmobetk9
y be hg hgrjg pbrk bspbrgezgcg bspbrg aozk pgrg ïh ue bstgecgrtb, ue bstgecgrtb rbgh, qubegcob pkcríg cbsphbjgr soek gqubh qub rbovoeco`gsb bh sb÷krík cb hks Eômbeðrbgeks y hg
`krkeg cb Bhbecoh.¹6?
Srgs vbe`br g Pgurke y rb`upbrgr bh trkek cb Jkeckr sb prkcu`b bh mgtromkeok cb
hg pgrbdg y hg rbekvg`oðe cbh hoegdb cb Eômbekr :<. Cb mgebrg qub hg `kefojurg`oðe cbh
pbrskegdb cb Grwbe krrbspkecb g hg pbrfb``oðe gh cb hg cgmg cb hks honrks cb gnghhbrígs4
cbstg`g pkr su nbhhbzg, sus mkcghbs, sus gckreks y su ghtk hoegdb. ^bspkecb gh rkh
trgco`okegh cb «bspksg-prbmok¹, guequb su «foegh fbhoz¹ cb hks `ubetks cb agcgs sbtrgesfkrmg be hg trgjbcog cb ckhkr y skhbcgc qub mbe`okegmks getbs.
66 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., >0:6: PGHBP, Gvbeturg kp.`ot., 2<.61 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 7<11.6? Oníc., 7<?>.:< Bxostbe `ugtrk ueokebs cb mkrtghbs y bhfgs, gcbmçs cb hg cb Grgjkre y Grwbe bstç hg cb
Motarbhhgs b Omrgzór, ge`bstrks cbh príe`opb Omrgaoh cb Ckh Gmrkta. Be hgs ktrgs cks, hgs bhfgs sknrbsghbe pkr su `krgdb y cbtbrmoeg`oðe pkr be`omg cb sus gmgcks4 Hôtaobe y Nbrbe b Ocroh y Sukr, gmngs pgrbdgsgetbpgsgcks cb Grgjkre y Grwbe.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 15/21
Cb betrb sus bs`gsgs gpgro`okebs:7, cbstg`g hg ôhtomg, yg `kmk rboeg cb Jkeckr.
Bs hg prombrg be cgrsb ubetg cb qub Frkck ek pkcrç urgrsb y hb bcb su phgzg g Vghoekr,
gcbmçs cb ue `khjgetb qub hb `kefkrtg be hks pbkrbs bposkcoks cb su befbrmbcgc:>.
Pu fghtg cb ue pgpbh mçs ompkrtgetb sb cbnb tgetk g `ubstokebs cb oefhube`ogshotbrgrogs, `kmk g qub sb trgtg cb ueg oe`krpkrg`oðe tgrcíg gh grjumbetk, trgs cb`ocor qub
Grgjkre ek brg ue nube mgrock pgrg Ïkwye y eb`bsotgr ueg rboeg pgrg Jkeckr :0. Sgmnoïe
oefhuyb hg cosmoeu`oðe jbebrgh cb hg pgrto`opg`oðe cb hks bhfks be hks g`ketb`omobetks cb
hg Sobrrg Mbcog, prbpgrçecksb pgrg hg pgrtocg y cbdgeck yg bh pbsk cbh cbstoek cbh mueck
be mgeks cb hks akmnrbs.
Pu gnubhg Jghgcrobh bs hg rboeg cb Hkrobe, hg mçxomg corojbetb cb su pubnhk:3 y
uek cb hks pk`ks pbrskegdbs prbsbetbs g hk hgrjk cb hgs `ugtrk Bcgcbs. Be su duvbetuc pgrto`opð `kmk corojbetb be hg rbnbhoðe `ketrg hks Vghgr :2, mçs tgrcb rbeue`oð gh pbrcðe
y, be hg ïpk`g cb hg gvbeturg cb Nohnk, fkrmð pgrtb cbh @ke`ohok pgrg bxpuhsgr gh
Eojrkmgetb, Pgurke, cbh Nksqub Ebjrk:6. Jrg`ogs gh pkcbr cb Ebeyg, bh Geohhk cbh Gjug,
hgezð ue skrtohbjok cb prktb``oðe sknrb su rboek:: qub ompbcíg hg betrgcg gh bebmojk y hk
vkhvíge oevosonhb gh Kdk cb Pgurke:1, pkr hk qub, ek sðhk bs ueg jrge `gnb`ohhg cb su
pubnhk y ueg pkcbrksg mgjg, bs ueg cb hks trbs provohbjogcks qub jugrcge hks geohhks cb
pkcbr ek `ketgmoegcks pkr Pgurke.Hgs agcgs, mgjgs y sgnogs ske hgs rbspkesgnhbs be hks honrks cb `gnghhbrígs cb
eumbrksks be`getgmobetks qub sb hhbvge g `gnk be gyucg k pbrduo`ok cb hks aïrkbs. Pke
pbrskegdbs g`bptgcks `ke skrprbecbetb ekrmghocgc be bh mueck fo`to`ok cb hgs knrgs, soe
:7 Be ^ovbecbh duetk g su pgcrb k g Grgjkre be bh `gpítuhk 7 cbh Honrk OO cb Hg @kmueocgc cbh
Geohhk y hg hhbjgcg g Jkeckr pgrg hg nkcg be bh 2 cbh Honrk VO cbh ^btkrek cbh ^by, gcbmçs cb hgs nrbvbsrbfbrbe`ogs cb hks Gpïeco`bs. :> SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp. `ot., 7<>2-7<>6.:0 Vbr ektg 03.:3 Cb @bhbnroge, aodg cb Jghgcrobh y @bhbnrke, bspksg cb Bhrkec y mgcrb cb hks jbmbhks Bhhgcge y
Bhrkaor y cb Grwbe, gpbegs tbebmks ekto`ogs. Gh rbjrbsgr cb ueg vosotg gh rboek cb sus pgcrbs fub gprbsgcgy tkrturgcg pkr kr`ks agstg qub sus aodks hg rbs`gtge. Bhrkec hkjrg `urgrhg pbrk yg ek sb sbetíg fbhoz be hgSobrrg Mbcog y pgrtb g Vghoekr. SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot., ?1.
:2 SKHIOBE, Pohmgrohhoke kp. `ot., ?2. Be hg `grtg 031 g @gtabroeb Foechgy `ubetg qub be su duvbetuc sbetíg oe`hoeg`okebs cb gmgzkeg y sb sudbtgng hks `gnbhhks `kmk ueg `krkeg be hk ghtk cb hg`gnbzg `ugeck oetbrvbeíg be agzg÷gs gthïto`gs. @G^\BESB^, Hbttbrs kp.`ot., 3>1.
:6 Oníc., 027.:: Gh ojugh qub aozk Mbhoge pgrg prktbjbr Nbhbrogec. Be Bh Pohmgrohhoke sb `ubetg qub Jghgcrobh
gprbecoð mu`ak cb hg Mgog. Oníc.,700.:1 Fubrke gtg`gcks trbs vb`bs cbscb Ckh Juhcur pbrk fubrke rb`agzgcks. SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`b kp.`ot., 7<?.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 16/21
bxpho`gr eo sus pkcbrbs eo su krojbe sknrbegturgh:? y gsí k`urrb tgmnoïe be Bh Pb÷kr cb hks
Geohhks4 «\ubs bstk bs hk qub tu jbetb hhgmg mgjog, guequb ek betobeck `hgrgmbetb quï
quobrbe cb`or, y pgrb`b qub usgrge hg mosmg pghgnrg pgrg agnhgr cb hks bejg÷ks cbh
bebmojk. \brk ïstg, so quobrbs, bs hg mgjog cb Jghgcrobh”¹1<
Bs ghtg, nbhhg, `ke bh `gnbhhk ckrgck oetbesk y vg vbstocg cb nhge`k, gh ojugh qub
Vovoge, hg Cgmg cbh Hgjk grtôro`g, qub gyucg y prktbjb g Hgezgrktb, `kmk Jghgcrobh g
Grgjkre. Hg cbs`ronb, gcbmçs, `kmk «krjuhhksg, fubrtb y rbsubhtg¹17, «`ke bh cke cb
pbebtrgr be hg mbetb cb ktrks¹1> pbrk `kmprbesovg `ke hks cbmçs, bx`bptk `ke Fégekr, bh
qub trgbrç hg cbsjrg`og g hks Ekhckr.
Gcbmçs pksbb pkcbrbs prkfïto`ks `ke su bspbdk cb gjug10. Bh cke prkfïto`k bs bh
gtronutk mçs `grg`tbrísto`k cb hgs agcgs mbcobvghbs prk`bcbetbs cb hg trgco`oðe grtôro`g ybstgs prkfb`ígs `umphbe ueg fue`oðe bstru`turgetb be bh rbhgtk, `kevortoïecksb be
vbrcgcbrks phgebs cb g`tug`oðe ompubstks cbscb bh bxtbrokr gh prktgjkeostg134 «‘Pb mb
pocoð qub g Grgjkre hb codbrg bstk4 »Cðecb bstçe gakrg hks Côebcgoe, Bhbssgr, Bhbssgr;
»\kr quï tus jbetbs gecge brrgetbs ghhç hbdks; @br`geg bstç hg akrg be qub vkhvbrçe hks
\brcocks y cbh Ekrtb cbs`obecg hg @kmpg÷íg Jros. \brk skmnríg bs hg sbecg qub tb fub
rbsbrvgcg4 hks mubrtks vojohge bh `gmoek qub hhbvg gh Mgr.”¹12
\kr ktrk hgck, g cofbrbe`og cb hks sg`rofo`oks qub eks omgjoegmks qub cbnbríg sufrorue `gnghhbrk aostðro`k soe fkrtueg, be hg fo``oðe `gnghhbrbs`g y be hg hotbrgturg fgetçsto`g,
hks mgjks sb be`grjge cb sgtosfg`br `ughquobr eb`bsocgc cbh aïrkb. Gsumbe hg `gtbjkríg
cb ckegetbs y surtbe gh prktgjkeostg cb ughquobr topk cb kndbtk k oestrumbetk qub fg`ohotb
bh `umphomobetk cb sus cofbrbetbs bmprbsgs y `ke tkcks hks oestrumbetks fkrdgcks pkr ue
sgnbr mostbroksk, hg mosoðe cbh aïrkb sb vb gnk`gcg gh ïxotk.16 Jghgcrobh betrbjg vghoksks
kndbtks g hg @kmpg÷íg `ugeck sb cbtobebe be Hðrobe4 «Hg Cgmg oe`hoeð hg `gnbzg y hubjk
sb vkhvoð g Nkrkmor y hb cok ue `oeturðe cb krk, y g Mbrry y g \oppoe hbs cok pbqub÷ks
:? AÖEOJ, P.4 «Ghjuegs ektgs sknrb agcgs, mgjgs y sgnogs be hgs ekvbhgs cb `gnghhbrígs¹, be@G@AK NHB@RG (`kkrc.)4 Cb hg hotbrgturg `gnghhbrbs`g gh «Wuodktb¹. Tgrgjkzg4 \rbesgs Reovbrsotgrogs><<:, >10.
1< SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 0:3.17 SKHIOBE, @, \ubnhks kp.`ot., 0:?.1> Oníc., 0?<.10 Bstb topk cb pbrskegdbs subhbe bstgr rbhg`okegcks `ke bh mueck g`uçto`k y sohvbstrb `kmk ag
bstucogck @grhks Ghvgr be GHVG^, @.4 «Mudbrbs y agcgs be hg hotbrgturg mbcobvgh¹ be HG@G^^G,M.B.4 Bvkhu`oðe egrrgtovg b ocbkhðjo`g cb hg hotbrgturg `gnghhbrbs`g. Nohngk4 Reovbrsocgc cbh \gísVgs`k 7??7, >7-03.
13 AÖEOEJ kp.`ot., >11.12 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 271.16 PGHBP, Gvbeturg kp.`ot., 12.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 17/21
`oeturkebs cb phgtg, `ke nrk`abs hgnrgcks `kmk fhkrbs cb krk. G Hbjkhgs hb cok ue gr`k
`kmk hks qub usge hks Jghgcrom, mçs hgrjk y fubrtb qub hks gr`ks cbh Nksqub Ebjrk, y hg
`ubrcg brg cb `gnbhhks ïhfo`ks.¹1:
Hg pbto`oðe mçs bxtrg÷g bs hg cb Jomho, qub skho`otg ue pbhk cb su mbhbeg, ghjkqub bs`gecghozg g hks cbmçs. Poe bmngrjk, bhhg, hbdks cb mkhbstgrsb, hb betrbjg trbs. Bstb
rbjghk bs gôe mçs sojeofo`gtovk so tbebmks be `ubetg uek cb hks rbhgtks cb hks Cígs
Getojuks ckecb Jghgcrobh sb eobjg trbs vb`bs g cgrhb ue `gnbhhk g Fégekr 11.
Cbspuïs cb hg `gícg cb hg Skrrb Ks`urg, @bhbnrke corojoð bh bdïr`otk cb Hðrobe, sb
gpkcbrgrke cb Ckh Juhcur y bs Jghgcrobh quobe cbrrong hks murks y cbdg hgs mgzmkrrgs gh
cbs`unobrtk.1? _, mçs tgrcb, gngeckeg hg Sobrrg Mbcog ke mu`ag getbhg`oðe g @bhbnkre9
bs cb`or, qub `kmpgrtíge hgs rbspkesgnohocgcbs `ke sus sôncotks be hg pgz y be hg jubrrg yqub bhhg tkmgng sus prkpogs cb`osokebs honrb y vkhuetgrogmbetb.
Jghgcrobh, pkr tgetk, bs ueg pkcbrksg ab`ao`brg, hg rbspbtgcg y rbvbrbe`ogcg rboeg
cb su pubnhk?< y ueg ompkrtgetb ghogcg be hg hu`ag `ketrg Pgurke, tgetk pkr su pgpbh cb
prkfbtosg `kmk cb gyucgetb. Po nobe, eue`g mb ag pgrb`ock qub mbrbz`g bh `ghofo`gtovk cb
«mgtbregh¹ qub hb gtronuyb Mgroke Tommbr Nrgchby?7, soek hg rbprbsbetg`oðe cb ue `hgrk
bxpkebetb cb hg fghsbcgc cb hg gformg`oðe cb qub ek agy mudbrbs fubrtbs be hg Sobrrg
Mbcog?>.
Skhiobe hg grg`tbrozð kmk krjuhhksg agstg bh puetk cb ek g`bptgr rbjrbsgr ugeck
hks Vghgr hbs `ke`bcbe su pbrcðe y gh cbsbgr bh pkcbr cbh Geohhk pgrg ek mbejugr. Poe
bmngrjk, tgmnoïe bvkhu`okeg, gh ojugh qub Ïkwye, cb`ocb rbsostor hg tbetg`oðe, skmbtbrsb,
gngeckegr hg Sobrrg Mbcog y su pkcbr, jbebrksocgc y `kesocbrg`oðe getb hks Vghgr
hhbjgríge g pksonohotgr qub ue begek, Jomho, fubsb g`bptgck be Vghoekr ?0.
1: SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 011.11 SKHIOBE, @, \ubnhks kp.`ot., 01?.1? SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot., 7<?.?< Ktrgs rboegs ske Mbhoge, Aghbta cbh \ubnhk cb Aghbta, hgs cb Eômbekr kmk Sgr-Geighomé, Sgr-
Sbhpbroée, Sgr-Vgeombhcé k hg frustrgcg Sgr-Mírobh y be Bh Honrk cb hks @ubetks \brcocks Mbroh-o-Suroeqocb Skh Brbsség.
?7 Pupkejk qub sb ngsg mçs be hgs rbfbrbe`ogs g hg oesporg`oðe mgrogeg cbh pbrskegdb prbsbetbs be
hgs `grtgs (@G^\BESB^, Hbttbrs kp.`ot., 3<:), qub be hg Jghgcrobh cbh honrk.?> Dgske Fosabr be C^KRS kp.`ot., >>:.?0 SKHIOBE, Gpïeco`bs kp.`ot., 11.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 18/21
2. Coksgs y bspírotus fbmbeoeks
Ngyg cb Krk bs bh ôeo`k pbrskegdb fbmbeoek soe ue prkpðsotk bspb`ífo`k be hg knrg.
Bs ue bspírotu cb hg Egturghbzg, hg Aodg cbh ^ík y bspksg cb Skm Nkmngcoh. Pb ag
`kesocbrgck qub pucobsbe sbr hks Vghgr Guhb y _gvgeeg, `ke hks qub `kmpgrtbe `obrtksrgsjks?3. G trgvïs cb hks cígs qub `kmpgrtbe `ke bhhks hks aknnots, pkcbmks gprb`ogr su
grmkeíg mgtromkeogh, be goshgmobetk y `kmpgrtobeck hgs rbspkesgnohocgcbs ckmïsto`gs4
«Hubjk, Skm y Ngyg cb Krk sb hbvgetgrke y hompogrke rçpocgmbetb hg mbsg.¹?2
Hks Vghgr ske hks sbrbs mçs pkcbrksks cb hg motkhkjíg `rbgcg pkr Skhiobe, skhk
pkr cbngdk cb Bru k Ohôvgtgr. Vghgr cb gmnks sbxks be ojugh eômbrk, sobtb, y ke pkcbrbs
somohgrbs, hk qub supkeb, `kmk sb÷ghg @rkwb4 «ge omprkvbmbet kvbr mgey mytas wabrb
fbmghb sporotugh pkwbr os hg`ioej¹.?6 Mobetrgs qub Mgewé bs bh mçs ompkrtgetb cb hksVghgr, su bspksg Vgrcg k Bhnbrbta bs hg mçs rbvbrbe`ogcg be Hg Sobrrg Mbcog, hg Pb÷krg
cb hgs Bstrbhhgs. Hgs ktrgs Vghobr, gcbmçs cb hgs cks yg mbe`okegcgs ske4 Eobeeg, Bsté,
Vgoré, Vçeg y Ebssg.?:
Hks Mgogr ske bspírotus sbmocovoeks `rbgcks pgrg gyucgr g hks Vghgr be su tgrbg.
Gh ojugh qub bstks, hks agy mgs`uhoeks y fbmbeoeks, cbs`kek`bmks su eômbrk bxg`tk y
hks ekmnrbs cb pk`ks?1. Ohmgré bstç gsk`ogcg `ke hgs bstrbhhgs, Rhoebe bs hg sb÷krg cb hks
mgrbs y gmgcg pkr hks Eômbeðrbgeks, Grobe bs ue bspírotu cb fubjk qub tuvk ue pgpbhompkrtgetb be hg `rbg`oðe cb Hks Cks Çrnkhbs cb Vghoekr y tbrmoeð sobeck bh skh??.
\brk, soe cucg, hg mçs `kek`ocg betrb hks Mgogr bs Mbhoge, mgcrb cb Hôtaobe y,
pkr tgetk, cb hg qub cbs`obecbe tgetk Bhrkec kmk hks rbybs cb Eômbekr, abrbcbrks cb su
abrmgek Bhrks. Bhwé bh bhfk kyð su `getk y rbeue`oð g or g Vghoekr `ke hks cbmçs, sb
qubcð `ke bhhg be hg Sobrrg Mbcog y sb `kevortoð be bh rby Saoejkh cb Ckrogta 7<<. \brk
Mbhoge bs mçs pkcbrksg b ompkrtgetb qub su mgrock y bmphbg sus pkcbrbs pgrg hg
prktb``oðe y bcu`g`oðe cb su jbetb, hks Poecgr. @rbg, gcbmçs, ueg prktb``oðe oevosonhb, hg
?3 Igtabroeb Abssbr be C^KRS kp.`ot., >32.?2 SKHIOBE, Pb÷kr kp.`ot., 703.?6 @^KZB, B.H.4 «\kwbr oe Grcg4 Pkur`bs, Rsbs gec Mosusbs¹ be ^BOEKHCP \. y
JKKCIEOJAS J.A. (bcs.) kp.`ot., >:0. Cb ab`ak, be ktrk `kek`ock bdbmphk cb hotbrgturg fgetçsto`g, hgsgjg Crgjkehge`b, cb hks trbs proe`opghbs coksbs, bh ôeo`k fbmbeoek bs bh mghojek4 Sagiosos. Crgjkehge`b
bs ueg sbrob cb ekvbhgs cb fgetgsíg ïpo`g, covococg be vgrogs trohkjígs bs`rotgs proe`opghmbetb pkr M. Zbos yS. Ao`imge y vgroks honrks oecbpbecobetbs qub ubetge aostkrogs rbhg`okegcgs. Hg prombrg ekvbhg, Crgjkes
kf Gutume Swohojat , sb punho`ð be 7?13 y `ketoeôge cbsgrrkhhçecksb eubvks títuhks agstg aky.?: SKHIOBE, Pohmgrohhoke kp. `ot., >3->?.
?1 Oníc., 0<-07.?? Oníc., 773-776.7<< Oníc., 6> y 60.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 19/21
`oeturg cb Mbhoge, pgrg prktbjbr sus tobrrgs cb hgs oevgsokebs cb hks kr`ks. _ so bh rby
aunobsb gtbecock g su `kesbdk g`br`g cb hg prubng cb Nbrbe, aunobsbe bvotgck hg ruoeg cb
su rboek7<7.
6. @ke`husokebs
@kmk abmks pkcock gprb`ogr g trgvïs cb bstb geçhosos, hks pbrskegdbs fbmbeoeks
cb hg knrg cb Skhiobe ek ske eo pk`ks eo pk`k rbhbvgetbs, yg qub be gcg rgzg be`ketrgmks
sknrbsghobetbs bdbmphks y mbe`okebs bxprbsgs cbh gutkr g hg ojughcgc cb cbrb`aks,
`gpg`ocgcbs y pkcbrbs, be sus aostkrogs y be hgs grtgs. Gngr`ge, gcbmçs, tkck bh bspb`trk
sk`ogh, cbscb hks rkhbs mçs trgco`okeghbs k g``bskroks cb mgcrbs, bspksgs, gmgs cb `gsg,
befbrmbrgs…agstg pgpbhbs prbpkecbrgetbs y cofbrbetbs gh «trgco`okegh¹4 rboegs, jubrrbrgs
y abrkíegs qub oe`husk trouefge ckecb hks mgs`uhoeks frg`gsge, cbmkstrgeck sbr «bqugh,
kr supbrokr, tk tab mbe oe tabor hovbs gec ekt cbpbecbet upke tabm¹7<>.
\kr ktrk hgck, tgmnoïe cbnbrígmks tbebr be `ubetg qub hks vgrkebs ek sðhk ske
ghtks corojbetbs y beïrjo`ks `kmngtobetbs4 Bhrkec bs ue `urgecbrk, gcbmçs cb sus ktrks
pgpbhbs, g Grgjkre hb rb`kek`be `kmk rby pkr su `gpg`ocgc pgrg hg sgeg`oðe, ek pkr sus
agzg÷gs nïho`gs, y Nohnk bs ue pbrfb`tk gmk cb `gsg, qub `k`oeg, hompog… `ugeck
pbrfb`tgmbetb Skhiobe pkcríg agnbrhb prkpkr`okegck ueg `rogcg, cgcg su cbsgakjgcg
pkso`oðe b`keðmo`g. Cb ab`ak, hks aknnots cbstg`ge pkr sus vocgs gpg`onhbs, trgequohgs y
rkcbgcgs cb phg`brbs sbe`ohhks, ue ocbgh qub bh gutkr `kesocbrg supbrokr4 «Po mu`aks cb
eksktrks cobrge mçs vghkr g hg kmocg, hg ghbjríg y hgs ge`okebs qub gh krk gtbskrgck, ïstb
sbríg ue mueck mçs fbhoz.¹7<0 Re ocbgh cb «gurbg mbcok`rotgs¹ qub `koe`ocb `ke bh cb
Skhiobe, be vocg y knrg. Hks pbrskegdbs, fbmbeoeks y mgs`uhoeks pkr ojugh, qub ske
`gpg`bs cb g`kmkcgrsb g su cbstoek y ek cbdgrsb hhbvgr pkr hg gmno`oðe, ske hks qub hkjrge
hg fbho`ocgc, mobetrgs qub hks qub ek sb skmbtbe, tbrmoege mgh4 Nkrkmor, Cbebtakr,
Pgrumge, Pgurke, Ktak Pg`kvohhg-Nkhsðe…
Cb mkck qub, `kmk vbmks, hk fbmbeoek bs `kmphbmbetgrok, ek sunkrcoegck g hk
mgs`uhoek.7<3 Po nobe bs `obrtk qub subhb gtronuorhbs cofbrbetbs bsfbrgs cb oefhube`og,
7<7 Oníc., 731 y 7?6.7<> AK\IOEP, H.4 «Fbmghb Gutakroty Fojurbs oe tab Zkris kf Skhiobe, @.P. Hbwos, gec @agrhbs
Zohhogms¹ be ^BOEKHCP \. y JKKCIEOJAS J.A. (bcs.) kp.`ot., 062.7<0 SKHIOBE, D.^.^.4 Bh Aknnot gektgck. Ngr`bhkeg4 Moektgurk ><7>, 022.7<3 ^GZHP, M.4 «Sab Fbmoeoeb \roe`ophb oe Skhiobe¹ be Mytahkrb 7<, 7?13, ><0.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 20/21
rbsbrvgeck g bstgs ôhtomgs bh `uocgck cbh akjgr, hg `kesbrvg`oðe, hg gjro`uhturg y hg
`rbg`oðe be jbebrgh, mobetrgs qub hks akmnrbs subhbe sbr mçs eðmgcgs7<2 y cbstg`ge,
sknrb tkck, be hg jubrrg. @kesocbrgr qub, pkr bstg rgzðe, Skhiobe sotôg g hg mudbr be
oefbrokrocgc bs ojekrgr pkr `kmphbtk su ocbkhkjíg prkfuecgmbetb getonbho`ostg7<6 y su gfçe
`kesbrvg`okeostg. @kmk sb÷ghge Ckekvge7<: y Pgefkrc7<1, su g`totuc ag`og hg `gpg`ocgc
cbstru`tovg mgs`uhoeg bs somohgr g hg cb hgs mçs rb`gh`otrgetbs fbmoeostgs.
Skhiobe mubstrg su jrge rbspbtk ag`og sus pbrskegdbs fbmbeoeks gh ek nus`gr
`kevbrtorhgs be akmnrbs y be oecovocughozgrhgs y `grg`tbrozgrhgs cb fkrmg cofbrbetb, `ke
sus prkpogs gsporg`okebs, sub÷ks y mbtgs. Ek oetbetg mgs`uhoeozgrhgs pkrqub be eoejôe
mkmbetk `kesocbrg qub bsk sbg supbrokr, y, skrprbecbetbmbetb, pgrb`b qub bsk bs hk qub
hb ag jbebrgck mçs `ríto`gs7<?. _, gh `ketrgrok cb hk qub gformg, pkr bdbmphk Dkrjb Fbrrk,
cb qub hgs mudbrbs brge ue mostbrok pgrg Skhiobe77<, bstg vgrobcgc cb `grg`tbrbs cbmubstrg
qub Skhiobe kek`íg pbrfb`tgmbetb hg so`khkjíg fbmbeoeg.
Gcbmçs, hgs mçs cbsgrrkhhgcgs ske mudbrbs fubrtbs, `ke pgpbhbs rbhbvgetbs be hg
trgmg, pbrk `ke cucgs, gesobcgcbs y mobcks9 bs cb`or, pbrskegdbs `ke hks qub pkcbmks
ocbetofo`greks, `kmk hg `ríto`g fbmoeostg Geeg Mubhbenbht prkpujegng qub cbníge
sbr.777Skmge sus prkpogs cb`osokebs y gsumbe hgs `kesb`ube`ogs cb sus g`tks. B oe`husk
hks pbrskegdbs mçs g``bskroks b orrbhbvgetbs, tobebe rgsjks prkpoks y `gpg`ocgc pgrgbvkhu`okegr, sb hbs pbrmotb bquovk`grsb y rb`tofo`gr 77>.
\kr g÷gcocurg, tgmnoïe `umphb `ke oe`huor, `kmk pocb Tommbr Nrgchby, «rkhb
mkcbhs fkr ekesbxost mbe wak `ge hovb wota strkej wkmbe wotakut tabor mgs`uhoeoty
7<2 Bstg cughocgc cb bsfbrgs `kmphbmbetgrogs bstç ohustrgcg be hks bets y bh ab`ak cb sbr oe`gpg`bscb `kmpgjoegrhgs bs hk qub hks hhbvg g hg bxtoe`oðe.
7<6 Nubeg mubstrg cb bhhk hg be`ketrgmks be hg `grtg 63 g su aodk @arostkpabr be @G^\BESB^
Hbttbrs kp. `ot., :2-::.7<: CKEKVGE, kp. `ot. 7<6.7<1 PGEFK^C, H.4 «Sab Fghh frkm Jrg`b‐Cb`hoeb gec Fghh oe Mocchb-bgrta¹, Mghhkre 00>, 7??2,
7?.7<? @kmpgrtk hg kpoeoðe cb Hgurg Mo`abh4 «Of fbmoeosm stgrtbc gs skmbtaoej quotb pksotovb, ot ags
nbbe, kvbrg hh tabsb ybgrs, turebc oetk gektabr ioec kf ckjmg, skmbtaoej tagt must nb fkhhkwbc wotakutqubstokeoej. Zaohb g wkmge‟s sk`ogh rkhb wgs, oe tab pgst, tk nb nbgutofuh, tk jovb norta gec tk rgosb aohcrbe,tk nb g agusbwofb, gec tk tgib `grb tab ckmbsto` b`kekmy, g mkcbre, honbrgtbc wkmge ekwgcgys ags tkagvb g dkn, ags tk nb b`kekmo`ghhy oecbpbecbet ‐ebxt tk nboej nbgutofuh, tk agvb gec rgosb `aohcrbe, tk nb gagusbwofb, gec (spb`oghhy oe pkkrbr `kuetrobs) tk mgegjb gec `ketronutb tk tab ckebsto` b`kekmy (tab
prbsbet gutkr fgohs tk sbb gey honbrgtoke oe ghh kf tagt). MO@ABH kp.`ot., 21. Bstb ckjmg, `ke frb`ube`og sb phgsmg, be hg hotbrgturg fgetçsto`g, be bstbrbktopgcgs vbrsokebs fbmbeoegs cb @kege oevbe`onhbs. Be @OKFFOkp. `ot., 12.
77< FB^^K, D.4 Hbybeck g Skhiobe. Nubeks Gorbs4 Jhgcous 7??6, >1.777 TOMMB^ N^GCHB_, ^bspkesonohotobs kp.`ot., 01.77> Gh `ketrgrok qub ktrks pbrskegdbs mgs`uhoeks, `kmk Nkrkmor qub pgjg sus brrkrbs `ke hg vocg.
8/17/2019 Ensayo Aelfwine 2015 Primer premio - Misoginia, patriarcalimo y roles de género en la Tierra Media
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ensayo-aelfwine-2015-primer-premio-misoginia-patriarcalimo-y-roles-de-genero 21/21
nboej tarbgtbebc¹770 kmk pubcbe sbr Nbrbe, @bhbnkre, Fgrgmor, Ïkmbr, Jomho, Jgecghf,
Grgjkre… Skcks bhhks mubstrge be eumbrksgs k`gsokebs, be pghgnrgs y g`tug`okebs, su
rbspbtk y gcmorg`oðe getb bstgs mudbrbs qub, pgrg egcg, rbspkecbe g ue bstbrbktopgck
pgpbh sunkrcoegck k sb`uecgrok.
@ke rbspb`tk g hg g`usg`oðe cb ocbghosmk pkr bh be`grb`omobetk cb hg nbhhbzg, sb
cbnb sb÷ghgr qub sb prkcu`b be gmnks sbxks y sb cbnb, soe cucg, mçs gh jïebrk hotbrgrok
y hgs fubetbs, qub g qubrbr `kevbrtorhgs be bspksgs trkfbk. Sgmpk`k vbk be quï mbdkrgríg
hg knrg so ek sb ao`obsb mbe`oðe ghjueg gh físo`k k so fubsbe fbks y fbgs. Gcbmçs cb qub,
`kmk yg abmks vostk, bsg ocbghozg`oðe ek bs tgh be tkcks hks `gsks, pkr tgetk bs fghsg hg
gformg`oðe cb qub hks pbrskegdbs fbmbeoeks cb Skhiobe sbge grqubtopks pbrfb`tks b ocbghbs
oegh`gezgnhbs.
Gh mosmk tobmpk, su vosoðe cbh mgtromkeok tgmpk`k bs ocbghostg soek muy rbghostg.
Ek tkcks hks mgtromkeoks sghbe nobe kmk mubstrge Ghcgroke y Brbecos k Grbcaéh y Böh,
pkr ek mbe`okegr hg sbpgrg`oðe gnskhutg cb hks bets, gh ek agnbr betbecomobetk betrb hks
`ðeyujbs. Sgmnoïe sb prkcu`be ueokebs oe`bstuksgs `kmk hgs cb Gr-\agrgzóe y Sgr-
Mírobh k Sôroe y Eobekr k begmkrgmobetks qub kecu`be g hg cbsjrg`og kmk bh cb Foewé
k Mgbjhoe. Bstk mubstrg qub, agy hu`bs y skmnrgs be hgs pgrbdgs cb hg Sobrrg Mbcog y ek
tkcks `kesojube bh «foegh fbhoz¹ cb hks `ubetks cb agcgs.Co`be qub hg nbhhbzg bstç be hks kdks cbh qub morg… quozç bh sbxosmk tgmnoïe.
770 Oníc., 01.
Top Related